• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

When a homeless person comes up to you

Status
Not open for further replies.
I once bought a guy a bunch of groceries, he said he didn't want money, just needed food, and we were close to a supermarket.

Usually I decline.


a friend of mine once bought a homeless person a sandwich and handed it to him.. he took the sandwich and shouted "i want money you fucking cunt" and threw it right back at her lol
 
I have never had that outside of a guy asking if I had some change to spare for to make a phone call. Gave him like a dollar in change and he called some rehab center.
 
clearly homeless in need? sure I give them some money. It never happens though, its always menacing looking people that get on your face while asking for it

99 percent of the time they dont ask nicely, so its a situation of "if I give him a couple coins will he not try to mug me or will I actually encourage him to mug me?"
 
clearly homeless in need? sure I give them some money. It never happens though, its always menacing looking people that get on your face while asking for it

99 percent of the time they dont ask nicely, so its a situation of "if I give him a couple coins will he not try to mug me or will I actually encourage him to mug me?"

Where do you live?
 
I tell them they don't work hard enough, and that I would be willing to go to their local shelter and teach them the value of a paycheck instead of a foodstamp.
 
Where do you live?

Montevideo, Uruguay. I live near very rough neighborhoods so you're gonna run into that situation past 11pm or so if you leave the house. Its a bummer. Never got mugged myself, but tons of friends have, its just the way they approach you I guess..
 
Montevideo, Uruguay. I live near very rough neighborhoods so you're gonna run into that situation past 11pm or so if you leave the house. Its a bummer. Never got mugged myself, but tons of friends have, its just the way they approach you I guess..

Damn that sucks.
 
I walk with my earbuds and act like I don't hear them. The worst is when you get a homeless guy on your train car that loudly spouts a sob story and makes the ride incredibly awkward for everyone until he gets off. I'm a very liberal person, but I usually can't stand homeless people. I'm a pretty big hypocrite like that.
 
I give them money.
Not sure what they're going to do with it, but I'm pretty sure they're -

a. need it more than me.
b. not going to be better off if I don't give them any money.

But generally, I mostly try to treat and talk to them like the real human beings that they are, those people miss normal human interaction and its lack really hurt their mental state (which in many cases is not that great to begin with).
 
I live and work in San Francisco, there are a lot of them here and while I see a few of the same people now and again I'm asked for money by new faces every single day. It's an epidemic and I'm sick of my city and my country not taking it more seriously. But at the same time, I do not believe giving each one a dollar every time I see one is a cure for anything. I have no idea what they are spending that dollar on and it probably is not good.

It's unlikely to be food. Why? Because I have lived here long enough to know where all of the free kitchens are. They are numerous and every meal of the day can be had for free at multiple locations within the city, particularly downtown. I know they know this, and if they play dumb, I am happy to inform them anyway.

When I am asked for money, I decline, usually with a head shake. If they are aggressive and follow me I point them in the direction of the nearest shelter and/or soup kitchen. I never give out money. A few times I broke down, only to be asked by the same people over and over for years afterwards. I understand, they have no money, no job, no place to live. Except that they could. There are shelters, there are organizations that give out free toiletries and medical care and everything a person needs. USE the services.

Giving money panhandlers is not a solution to any problem and is likely supporting nasty habits you don't want to know about. If you want to be helpful, the best you can do is donate your time or money to a free kitchen, shelter, food bank, what-have-you. These services work hard to help those in need, those that work within the system. Those people sleeping on the streets instead of shelters are choosing not to work within the system (usually due to alcohol problems, but there are a variety of reasons)

And the panhandling is not even the worst. You should see what they do to the public transit system. It's a disgrace. I often have to leave trains due to the smell of some people that slip onboard past security.

BTW, speaking of wi-fi hotspots, I stayed in a hotel (in a not so great part of town) while our place was undergoing some maintenance. I was shocked and a little upset that the WiFi network of the hotel was named BurnTheHomelessToTheGround. Not even shitting. I know my attitude towards the homeless may sound cold, but all I want is to see money well spent on help, not towards drugs or alcohol. However when I see things like what this hotel was doing I see my attitude is not so extreme afterall.

Closing out a longer post than I thought, I just want to point out that being homeless and being a street person are not the same thing. The former have all my sympathy and support, having experienced it in my own family. The later can fend for themselves if they can't put some effort into cleaning up their act. I would like to see those who are too mentally ill to do so put into institutions, it's far more humane than letting them run the streets and sleep in the cold.

I agree with everything you said above, more people in this thread should read this post.

I live in Seattle and it's the same thing here, sad part is most people do not know this and thus think they're being kind or helpful (I mean in regards to the homeless person the money is being given to, it's still a very nice thing to do for a person) when in reality the majority of the time you're just being taken for your money. Hell I imagine part of the reason it's so bad in this country is due to that exact mindset.

But as Zulithe points out above, especially in major cities, the homeless have access to a good amount of food and shelter that is provided to them and a lot of the time the money you give them is spent on alcohol/drugs.
 
I usually just lay my head low and walk away.

I hate seeing homeless people, but I don't carry cash on me either to help them out.
 
I don't usually carry money on me and some people get angry like I am lying to them.


When people ask for food or something like that I will buy them something.
 
I give them a look, say "sorry, no" and move on.
I don't want totally ignore them, but I stopped giving money because they don't want to change their situation.
 
I give them a look, say "sorry, no" and move on.
I don't want totally ignore them, but I stopped giving money because they don't want to change their situation.
You don't have to give anything to anyone, but I can tell you for a fact that the vast majority of homeless people want desperately to change their situation, they just don't really know how to go about that.
 
I don't carry cash anymore, but I always make eye contact and respond verbally. I used to just ignore them but it made me become disgusted with myself that I could act like that so I changed.

I've spent the last 8 years in SF and Portland, so it's been a part of my daily life for a long time.
 
They're all over the place in the central parts of Seattle. In the fourteen years I've been here, I've gradually learned to ignore them. Otherwise, they remember you and don't leave you alone. It saddens me that this is necessary but there's plenty of services for them in the city if they need food and shelter.
 
I tend to make up a sob story about how I need a few bucks to cover gas or to get something to eat.


Totally confuses the shit out of them.
 
and asks for money. What do you do?

Do you give a few bucks? Do you politely refuse? Or do you become angry?


I really wonder what's appropriate today.

Depends on location. If you so much as acknowledge a homeless person in San Francisco, you'll soon have several following you for blocks like you're the pied piper. Sounds brutal but when you live there and deal with it every day, there aren't many options. Same goes for Berkeley, especially if they're addicts camped on curbs with a kennel's worth of pit bulls. Otherwise I might give if I happen to have any cash on me.
 
You could tell them that you're also homeless, not sure what they would say.
As for your clean clothes, you could tell them you got them from an Op Shop.
 
You could tell them that you're also homeless, not sure what they would say.
As for your clean clothes, you could tell them you got them from an Op Shop.

If you're going that way, crib from a fool I knew in San Francisco. The homeless paper there is called Real Change, so he'd respond to every approach with "Real change comes from within." Guy was gross.
 
I used to ignore them, but since I've stopped carrying cash I tell them "Sorry, don't carry cash." I think it probably makes me seem less asshole-y.
 
If I have cash to spare, I give him/her a few bucks. If I don't, I politely say I can't help them. It's a non-issue, and I don't feel guilty when I have cash on me, but can't afford to give a few bucks away.
 
Normally, just say "I'm sorry, I don't have any cash", even if it is a lie.

On some rare cases, I do give them some spare cash, but that's the exception, not the rule.
 
Ill give only if they look like

mulholland_drive_bum.jpg
 
I really don't actually carry cash, and tell them as much. I find that a lot of them ask for smokes if they catch me lighting up though (ZOMG LYNCH THE SMOKER!), and I'm more than happy to give them the half-pack I usually have on me - I usually have a couple of packs in the car anyway.
 
I give them my fucking belt
You mean bootstraps.

Anyway, I worked at a gas station that had a lot of homeless around the area. They would hang out on the corner with signs and what not, then come in the gas station and buy booze and lottery tickets. So that's where all that money you give them goes. A lot of them would have some fat stacks after a day of pan handling.
 
I try to ignore them, or just say sorry and continue on.

It's not really fair, but my tolerance for the homeless decreased a ton after I was held up in London by either a homeless person or someone pretending to be homeless. I can't trust their intentions, so I keep my distance and don't assume any level of harmlessness.
 
What's weird is that I can't remember the last time I gave a homeless change, but I have given every one who asked a cigarette.
 
if I actually have cash on me, I'll give a few bucks. if I don't, I'll let them know I don't, and apologize.

Though usually, homeless people ask me for a cig and a light before they ask for money, and I'm happy to oblige. Hell, I even light it for them.

One of the most interesting conversations I ever had was with a homeless man in downtown Osaka. He told me about his world travels, and what he saw. God knows if he ever actually did any of that, but he was a fantastic storyteller. I was happy to sit with him and talk for the 10 minutes my friends were off getting something from the convenience store.
 
Would you people believe that in my country this problem is so widespread that many people actually consider being a beggar is actually a legitimate job to do? And that many beggars actually own large houses with cars and swimming pools back at their hometown? And that they refuse to get a decent job even if its being offered to them due to their being too comfortable with their chosen "profession"?

Things are crazy here.
 
Just say no most of the time. I have had a few awkward encounters when they wash my windshield at red lights and I give them whatever change I have.

I also had someone try to wash my shoes while I was walking in downtown Chicago. That was odd.
 
nobody should be without a home in the western world. so tragic. :(

Would you people believe that in my country this problem is so widespread that many people actually consider being a beggar is actually a legitimate job to do? And that many beggars actually own large houses with cars and swimming pools back at their hometown? And that they refuse to get a decent job even if its being offered to them due to their being too comfortable with their chosen "profession"?

Things are crazy here.

i believe it. in some states you have to get a pan handler's license to legally beg for money. i considered doing it for a living in 2007 when i lost my job and scholarship.
 
I ignore. I feel bad for them but what they're doing is basically extortion. Same with those asshole people who perform on the train and then want money.
 
I dont give shit, here in Puerto Rico homeless or "tecatos" as we call them ask for money, cigarettes every minute. And theyre diferrent everytime. Hell if they see you misplaced a pack of cig, theyll steal them. Ive seen homeless ppl stabbed in the neck for the latter.

Ive worked in places where Ive seen them steal bags off people full of groceries of people just so they can sell it for a cheap buck to get high. Things here are really bad If youve never been here go look up #drugs in documentary by National Geographic
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom