Support NeoGAF

[Mikey Jr.]

I understand why people are speculating on a PC version of GTA V. There is precedent for R* releasing a PC version 6-12 months later, plus some retailers (like Amazon Germany) already list the PC version.

I have no idea why people speculate on an 'inevitable' next gen version, though. As far as I know, there is no indication that there will be one. No retailer listings, no industry buzz - and most important no precedent at all. San Andreas was put out at the very end of last gen and never was ported to current gen. So, why GAF, why are you so sure?

Well, 2 reasons.

1. It is releasing 2 months before the next gen, which you covered already, but....

2. The jump to current gen was much more substantial than from now to next gen, probably making it more difficult to up-port a PS2 game to the PS3.

3. Look at all the cross-gen titles. Almost every AAA next-gen game has an equivalent coming out on current gen. Not saying its easy, but making a next gen versions using the assets from current gen is probably easier.

Not saying it will happen, but I also don't see it out of the realm of possibility.

 

[maneil99]

Wishful thinking. Not gonna happen. R* won't get any significant money porting to the new consoles. Thy can sell their game to +120 millions of people on old machines.

Explain a pc release then

 

[MCN]

I don't think they've done it since the Dreamcast, have they?

 

[AustinFelix]

My friend knows someone working on the game engine said to me when te delay hit that it was practically finished... Seems a long delay for polish. But they probs delayed so the online portion was ready closer to launch. Next gen version will come with PC Release

 

[Big_Al]

I'm thinking it will come to PC and next gen for a few reasons. I'm pretty confident it will be announced for PC 5 - 6 months after the console release, it's standard Rockstar procedure to capture us double dippers and release it a bit later.

For next gen I'm thinking it will happen because of GTA Online and I don't think they'd bother porting over GTA Online without porting GTA 5. From interviews on CVG they obviously see GTA Online as a very big thing which will evolve over time with content additions etc and I think it just makes sense to provide an option on PS4/Xbox One.

I could be wrong but I am pretty certain we'll see a PC version at least.

 

[x3sphere]

It seems obvious to me. If it's coming to PC then a nextgen console port wouldn't take much in the way of resources at all. Same architecture. This isn't the case with previous transitions, porting GTA III, Vice City or San Andreas to the PS3 would have taken a great deal of effort.

Also Rockstar probably wants to get GTA Online up and running on the new consoles. As people get rid of their old PS3/360 boxes it makes sense that some of them would rebuy. My PS3 is on its last leg and probably won't even survive another year.

 

[Bricky]

A mixture of:
Financially, it makes a lot of sense; it's the most expensive game ever made - and porting it would boost sales significantly

Would it? It's not like the audiences of the next-gen consoles, no matter how well those consoles sell relatively, will be all that big by the end of next year and most people will already have played the PS3/360 version at that point in time (most mainstream buyers won't double dip). Add to that the fact that you have to release it at a more budget-y pricepoint (the game will be quite old at that point) and still need to invest manpower and money in porting such a big game and it's not unlikely we won't see a next-gen version anytime soon.

And even if you don't agree with the above; it's not like Red Dead Redemption wouldn't have sold on a PC too, but Rockstar chose not to port it anyway. That fact is what makes me doubt whether they'll even bother to port GTA V or not the most.

E: They'll port GTA Online to next-gen consoles for sure though, but that is a different story.

 

[smr00]

Because GTA Online.

Yup.

They clearly put A LOT of work into it and want it to be a thing and for it to be a thing it needs to be on platforms where people are going to play it. Besides, we all know a PC version will come and porting that to next-gen systems will be easy as pie.

It seems obvious to me. If it's coming to PC then a nextgen console port wouldn't take much in the way of resources at all. Same architecture.

Also Rockstar probably wants to get GTA Online up and running on the new consoles. As people get rid of their old PS3/360 boxes it makes sense that some of them would rebuy. My PS3 is on its last leg and probably won't even survive another year.

Mine was like that and i tried my hardest to make it survive till after i beat GTA but sadly it just died on me on the 2nd of this month so i had to go out and buy a new one. Which i would of done anyways because PS4 lacks proper BC and i am not just going to throw away thousands of dollars worth of games.

 

[Salex]

Is PC not an option for you?

You're assuming that he even has a PC that can outperform the PS4 (or..the Xbone ). I wonder how many people with PCs that play games have better hardware than next gen consoles. I'm assuming it's less than 2 million.

 

[Sn4ke_911]

Wishful thinking. Not gonna happen. R* won't get any significant money porting to the new consoles. Thy can sell their game to +120 millions of people on old machines.

GTA Online dude.

 

[Gospel]

Wishful thinking from forum members that proudly declare their intent to buy all kinds of shit day one. There's no surprise they want the next best thing playable on their new, 500 dolla next best thing playing machine.

 

[Skeff]

Next gen consoles can receive ports from PC pretty easily.

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-how-the-crew-was-ported-to-playstation-4

the core engineering effort in moving The Crew across to PlayStation 4 was accomplished in six months with a team of just two to three people working on it.

Now consider how many people would double dip... Looks like a very nice balance between cost and revenue.

Lack of backward compatibility also a large factor.

 

[Appollowexx]

I'm not sure that people are sure we'll get a next gen GTA V. I think there's just a lot of wishful thinking going on.

I personally think it's unlikely but with all these recent HD collections, not out of the relm of possibility, say a year down the line.

 

[enzo_gt]

"It looks pretty, it has to be on next gen too!" is about the start and the end of the argument. Perhaps thinking because a PC version is likely, a next gen version must be too because of similar architecture.

 

[IdreamofHIME]

I can't think of a reason why it's not coming to PS4/XBONE.

The only reason it's being released now is because it's already monthS behind schedule and those investors will not be prepared to wait months more for all versions to be released together and thus there's no way they're gonna talk about next gen versions when they want maximum impact on launch day of PS3/360.

 

[Mikeside]

Wishful thinking. Not gonna happen. R* won't get any significant money porting to the new consoles. Thy can sell their game to +120 millions of people on old machines.

They're already going to sell the game to people on current gen. That absolutely isn't the issue. The question is; is it worth a porting job (a small one if they're already porting to PC, which I reckon they probably are) to sell next gen copies? It'll cost nowhere near the same as developing a new game so sales don't have to be THAT high.

Remember, there's people who will be picking up a console for the first time next gen, people who skipped PS3/360 who might buy X1/PS4, there are people who are happy to double-dip and I'm pretty sure there are people who aren't bothering with GTA V on current gen because they're waiting for the shiny new toys to come out at this point.

Give it a year (or whatever), put GTA V out on PS4/X1 and I bet they'll rake in some sales, especially if year 1 for those consoles is anything like Wii U's year 1 for barren releases (which it nowhere near will be, but you get my point)

 

[StevieP]

For starters all of the ads have been made with the PC version

 

[Racer1977]

Next-gen uses PC architecture, the moment a PC version is officially acknowledged, we know next-gen is coming too.

R* will ride this out until GTAV's launch window (and bulk of sales) is done with, then the Ultimate Edition will be announced for next-gen systems (including PC).

 

[Phineous_2]

People will absolutely double dip on this, unless it sucks (which seems unlikely).

Lest we forget they released GTA IV, then the expansions as DLC, then the expansions on a stand alone disc, THEN the complete edition. Pretty sure every iteration sold well (they also did the same for RDR). I personally owned all of these (disc releases), and I'm not a HUGE fan of GTA IV.

It seems NOT releasing it on next gen consoles would be leaving money on the table. I'd think it would be a guaranteed best seller on all platforms.

 

[nowheretorun]

Because GTA Online.

.

 

[Red Chocobo]

Rockstar are perfectionists. I think they would prefer their first next-gen GTA to be a proper one built just for next-gen.

It's the same reason PD say they are going to just make GT7, rather than port GT6 to PS4.

 

[Dysun]

Because it would print money, and holding off the announcement ensures maximum double dipping

 

[ThePowerofX]

Understand that Rockstar can reasonably expect many enthusiastic gamers to purchase the same title twice: once on the existing console base, which is huge, and again on next-gen systems (with improved draw distance, sharper graphics, additional content, etc).

Promoting a PS4/X1 version too soon will detract from sales on PS3/360. These guys aren't stupid. It's in Rockstar's best interest to kill any expectation of a next-gen version at this time.

 

[Whitechocolatekrispies]

I would really like a PS4 version. My Xbox 360 died two years ago and I haven't had a single reason to buy a new one ... until GTAV came along ... please put it on PS4 ... plleeeeeease.


It can't be that hard to port from PC to Next-Gen ...

In fact has anyone addressed the relative easy of porting PC games to PS4/Xbone? Both x86 ... lots of memory ...?

Is there a thread on this, I would like to read it.

 

[Skeff]

For starters all of the ads have been made with the PC version

PS3

http://www.videogamer.com/ps3/gta5/...otage_from_ps3_version_rockstar_confirms.html

I would really like a PS4 version. My Xbox 360 died two years ago and I haven't had a single reason to buy a new one ... until GTAV came along ... please put it on PS4 ... plleeeeeease.


It can't be that hard to port from PC to Next-Gen ...

In fact has anyone addressed the relative easy of porting PC games to PS4/Xbone? Both x86 ... lots of memory ...?

Is there a thread on this, I would like to read it.

this is an article about PC->PS4 ports:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-how-the-crew-was-ported-to-playstation-4

 

[AOC83]

Because it makes sense.

If there will be a PC version (and that´s very likely) it´s going to be extremely easy and cheap to port for a game that´s easily going to sell another 2-3 million copies minimum on both next gen consoles combined. It´s free money and a early presence on the new systems which is pretty important.

 

[10101]

Because it would print money, and holding off the announcement ensures maximum double dipping

This is very true.

To the people here who think the install base will be too low...by that logic no 3rd party would release anything until the sold numbers were 10m or whatever surely? EA wouldn't bother with FIFA/Madden, Acti with COD etc, etc. If there is an easy conversion path or you can reuse shit from the older gen version (which is what they usually do with the early ones) then why not? Also remember that while there are less units out there, there are also less games to buy/less competition.

 

[Afrodium]

People are greatly overestimating how many people would buy a $60 game twice.

Why does GTA Online need to have GTA V? I expect they'll work out all the kinks with the current gen version, and then re-make it for next gen as a free-to-play download.

 

[rjcc]

There's no doubt it's going to happen.

They will make a PC version, and the next gen consoles are close enough to pcs that it would be ridiculous for a port not to happen.

now, the question of when is more up in the air than I think people are suggesting, but it's going to happen.

 

[PureGone]

Because people like money and Rockstar would make shit tons of money from double dippers and get tons of new customers

 

[Not Spaceghost]

I don't think it will happen.

If it does happen it will release around when the PC version is released but I am not holding my breath.

 

[Devilinthiscity]

The pc version and because of, well, money. I doubt it will be out anytime soon. Maybe a year after the current gen release.

 

[Bsigg12]

Because Rockstar likes money and rereleasing next spring to summer as a GOTY edition exclusive to next gen is am easy way to get double dippers. Also GTA online is a huge factor where your character should be able to transfer across versions if all the data is saved server side.

 

[Deleted member 22576]

Assuming there is add on content there will most likely be a second disc release anyway. It's the norm for BIG games to get released twice these days anyway.. Only this time next year there will be new consoles.

 

[KAL2006]

Pretty simple

There will be a PC version
Next Gen systems are basically PC architecture

Personally I'm gonna hold out for next gen version, if it doesn't happen I'll but GTA5 GotY Edition for PS3.

 

[pizza dog]

1) This is NeoGAF where we want to BELIEVE
2) Bully: Scholarship Edition

 

[GrumpyOutlander]

I don't know if there will be a next gen version. I kinda doubt it, but I do believe that they will bring GTA Online to next gen at some point.

 

[Skeff]

People are greatly overestimating how many people would buy a $60 game twice.

Why does GTA Online need to have GTA V? I expect they'll work out all the kinks with the current gen version, and then re-make it for next gen as a free-to-play download.

Who says they would buy it twice? who says it will be $60?

Doesn't buy GTA because next gen is 2 months away and won't have console hooked up enough to finish it. Buys next gen.

Console recently broken, buy a new console at the end of the gen or wait? $200 PS3 or X360 is a lot to play GTA when you could be buying a PS4 or XB1 soon.

People who don't like buying DLC piece by piece and waiting for the GOTY edition like this one:

http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0045U01OG/?tag=neogaf0e-20

A next gen version of GTA5 would sell millions. Less than PS360 versions, but still more than a lot of games.

 

[Patrickv27]

Because people will double dip.

No doubt. This is the main reason.

 

[IllumiNate]

Because they are planning DLC for the next year or more for GTAV. I will bet someone a game that GTAV will come to next gen consoles within 1.5 years

 

[Tenck]

I don't think there's much money to grab in a userbase of 5-10 million, especially when you're re releasing an, at that point, 1-2 year old game.

Kinda odd how digital sales of games on PC is what's making some companies a bunch of money, but you say otherwise.

I wonder who's to believe here. You or the industry.

 

[TheShampion]

I think there is actually quite a bit of precedence.

For one, Bully was ported to the 360 and PC, and the last GTA from the previous generation (San Andreas) was made available on both 360 and PS3.

The question isn't "will they," the question is when.

 

[Midou]

GTA Online will most certainly get ported to next-gen to survive as people move onto the next consoles. GTA V is probably not guaranteed though. Seems like a smart move to throw like a GTA V GOTY edition on next-gen consoles with some technical improvements and whatever DLC was released in like end of 2014 or something. By then they should also have a slightly more significant install base.

 

[Valnen]

Is PC not an option for you?

With how badly 4 was optimized Rockstar would have to pay me to get 5 day one on PC. But hey, if my money isn't good enough for Rockstar, more power to em. They'll do fine without me and my money.

 

[TheExecutive]

There won't be a next gen version. If there is it will be a remake years down the road. It's not really R* style to re release though. Bully is an exception.

 

[Sn4ke_911]

With how badly 4 was optimized Rockstar would have to pay me to get 5 day one on PC.

RDR was fine.

Spoiler

I will never forgive you R*.

 

[MormaPope]

With how badly 4 was optimized Rockstar would have to pay me to get 5 day one on PC.

I'm glad you ignored how well done the Max Payne 3 PC port was,

 

[ShinMaruku]

I know you guys go on and on about "It's the same as pc architecture" except pc don't have a shared memory bank no is the xbone's tech the same as the PS4 there are difference maybe not PS3 level difference but it's not the same ports are not as easy as you think. Easier than the old way yes but think about how crazy the old way is.

And really it's not a good spend for 2k to spend (I know it's rockstar but it's all the same company. It's like people trying to separate Blizzard from Activision)

Now we'll have a next gen GTA. That will be worth it. But this? Come on this generation has gone on too long as a result you lose out on GTA V on next gen. It's the price to be paid.

 

[TheExecutive]

I think there is actually quite a bit of precedence.

For one, Bully was ported to the 360 and PC, and the last GTA from the previous generation (San Andreas) was made available on both 360 and PS3.

The question isn't "will they," the question is when.

I guess when you think about it there could very well be a port but by then who will care about it? Everyone will be talking about GTA6 and what R* is able to do with 8gb of GDDR5

 

[Man]

Free money. I am personally waiting for GTA5 and Diablo 3 PS4.

I have only so much spare time so I try to fill what I have with the absolute best in gaming.
After finishing TLoU (half remaining) and Journey I'm exclusively next-gen.