I can't speak on the PS4 youtube app since I don't have one, but damn the Xbox One and Wii U Youtube apps are inexcusable. They freeze up constantly (especially the Wii U version which if you try to close the app when it freezes your whole console gets frozen), the connection is always shit, and the Xbox version constantly shows in the lowest resolution for me. Why can the Wii U Youtube app show videos in HD but the Xbox One version can't? I guess its a fair trade off since the Wii U youtube app routinely just says fuck it and stop playing the video with no warning. You would think they would have some sort of "select your video quality" option but no there is none. They are barebone apps that barely function and you would think by 2016, in the fourth year of the Wii U's life and the third year of the Xbox One's life that they would get the Youtube app to function like the desktop and mobile counterparts.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Why is the console Youtube Apps so garbage?
- Thread starter bman94
- Start date
RedAssedApe
Banned
Ps4 seems fine to me. They are barebones because you can just use your mobile to navigate and search. No real reason to try and optimize it since doing that is always going to be a better experience than trying to navigate using ur remote or controller.
Movalpolos
Banned
Youtube, incidentally, runs better for me on consoles with that app than on a PC web browser.
CuckFupertino
Banned
The Xbox One app works great for me. If you're not getting HD resolutions it's due to your network. Are you connecting wirelessly or Ethernet? Have you disabled QoS on your router? The weak link isn't the app itself in this scenario.
I can't comment on the Wii U app as I haven't used it in years (the app, not Wii U).
I can't comment on the Wii U app as I haven't used it in years (the app, not Wii U).
Live Free or Die
Banned
PS4 app is amazing.
James Scott
Banned
The mobile apps are also garbage.
Right now in the subscriptions page the "p" doesn't completely disappear when you scroll down so there's a white line that shouldn't be there on the top of the screen. It also saves your spot...sometimes.
I've also wanted background play for a long time and they managed to do that...just to hold it hostage behind YouTube red
Right now in the subscriptions page the "p" doesn't completely disappear when you scroll down so there's a white line that shouldn't be there on the top of the screen. It also saves your spot...sometimes.
I've also wanted background play for a long time and they managed to do that...just to hold it hostage behind YouTube red
psynergylover
Member
the Vita verion was the greatest one!
*pours out a 40 for the youtube vita app*
*pours out a 40 for the youtube vita app*
Crimsonclaw111
Member
PS4 one supports 60fps. It's also the only YT app that isn't garbage on these systems.
I'm using my University's internet. The Wii U YouTube app gets HD all the time and I have no problems getting HD on my laptop. All connections are wireless. The Xbox One YouTube app has never been HD for me.
Pokemaniac
Member
The truly damning bit about the Wii U app is that you get a far superior experience just going to youtube.com in the web browser.
Rather amusingly, the website has started putting up a banner when you do this trying to convince you to go back to the app.
Rather amusingly, the website has started putting up a banner when you do this trying to convince you to go back to the app.
Yep, using the Wii U web browser is the best way to go.
It's weird though, I used to be able to watch videos in HD, but lately I only get SD playback for some reason. I wonder if there's a fix for this.
NOLA_Gaffer
Banned
I've never had problems with the Wii U Youtube app.
Pokemaniac
Member
From my experience, you should be getting HD where available, but I don't know if connection speed impacts that at all.
Though, it does have the stupid non-MSE limitations* of only offering 360p and 720p for resolutions.
*
Thanks Google for looking out for me by removing options when I'm not using a browser with a bleeding edge feature set /s
I call shenanigans. The PC version of the app doesn't even do 60 fps or else I'd be using it all the time. Always have to keep a tab open to use regular youtube for 60 fps vids.
I'm sick of trying to skip to the middle of a video and youtube freaks out like "whyyyy would you doooooo that," and completely stops working.
dragonzdogma
Member
False, it depends on the video and isp speed.
KanameYuuki
Member
Ps4 Youtube's app is only 720p right?
Crimsonclaw111
Member
I watch 60fps videos of Smash and CSGO all the time on the PS4.
PS4 and xbox apps are the same as far as I can tell. I haven't tried it on wiiu.
I use it on xbox regularly and never had a problem. I wish it was a bit snappier to navigate but otherwise its been solid. I don't use it on ps4 simply because the consoles wifi is garbage so I end up with quality drops or buffering.
even on my pc youtube has issues simply because it fails to stick with the html5 player and tries to use the flash version. It sucks because flash runs like garbage for some reason.
I use it on xbox regularly and never had a problem. I wish it was a bit snappier to navigate but otherwise its been solid. I don't use it on ps4 simply because the consoles wifi is garbage so I end up with quality drops or buffering.
even on my pc youtube has issues simply because it fails to stick with the html5 player and tries to use the flash version. It sucks because flash runs like garbage for some reason.
super-famicom
Member
PS4 app is nice. i can sync up my iPhone with it and add videos to a queue easily.
It depends on your connection but from what I know it supports 1080p/60fps. Not sure how to check on mine since it only says HD.
Spyder_Monkey
Banned
It's fine on my PS4. Hell it can even play at 60fps which is something my Chromecast can't do.
DidntKnowJack
Member
Playback on the PS4 app is great, just wish you could filter your searches. Otherwise, its actually pretty damn good.
Spyder_Monkey
Banned
I didn't even notice this but it's true, PS4 supports 60 fps.
ThoseDeafMutes
Member
My only real complaint with the XBO app is it could be a little more responsive and it doesn't cope with suspend/resume well.
MrBenchmark
Member
They all work pretty similar. To be honest my favorite YouTube app is the one on my Apple TV. I never have issues much with any they all look the same and feel the same except the Apple TV one. And it is my favorite it's so fast.
NOLA_Gaffer
Banned
That's definitely true. The Youtube app on my Samsung TV just sputters out about five minutes into any video.
CamHostage
Member
All of the apps on all of the home console and DVD players are abysmal and regularly out of date, and I don't understand it. I get stuttering on Funimation, I get failure to synch start/stop on Hulu, I get whatever the hell Youtube thinks I'm okay with on Youtube... It baffles me, these apps should not be this complicated, so much of it is server-side functions and HTML5-based application framework and yet the experience from console to console is subpar, different, and out of date compared to the mobile apps. (It depends on the service, but the web experience is rarely the inferior method.)
It'd be one thing if these were free services, but I pay for Hulu and would be willing to rent movies on Youtube (I know that nobody does, but it's to the point that their bitrate and speed is challenged by few video providers once you're in the 1080/4K range.) App quality was a nagging concern when the first Smart TVs launched and the first console apps, and for some reason, it has gotten no better despite the hardware coming closer than in the past.
I still run an HDMI out of my PC and futz around with a media remote because even though it's far from perfect, it's worth getting things exactly according to expectations whereas these apps constantly remind me of their failure points.
It'd be one thing if these were free services, but I pay for Hulu and would be willing to rent movies on Youtube (I know that nobody does, but it's to the point that their bitrate and speed is challenged by few video providers once you're in the 1080/4K range.) App quality was a nagging concern when the first Smart TVs launched and the first console apps, and for some reason, it has gotten no better despite the hardware coming closer than in the past.
I still run an HDMI out of my PC and futz around with a media remote because even though it's far from perfect, it's worth getting things exactly according to expectations whereas these apps constantly remind me of their failure points.