• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Worst substitute actors in a licensed game

Kind of Off Topic, but in that Spider-Man movie tie in game back in the GC days, they actually got Tobey Maguire to voice Spidey.

Funny thing is, he sounded awful. Like all the other guys who voiced Spidey sounded better.
 
BONESAW is REEEAAAAADY

j6jRPY6.jpg
 
Lost: Via Domus was irritating as some characters were played by the TV show cast but some weren't.
What I came here to post. Literally the only reason I never played it was that the "sound-alikes" were just terrible.

And weren't the only cast members they got like Sun and Claire?
 
I never understood why they didn't use Jim Cummings who was his official 2nd voice, even finishing Be Prepared for Jeremy after he had to stop due to his smoking IIRC.

And Jim did do the whole performance in Simba's Adventure on PS1, even redubbing all of his lines in the movie clips.

The casting is really baffling considering how many characters Cummings did for KH anyway. I think he and Corey Burton may have been having some kind of competition!

Kingdom hearts in general. Count Frollo, Clayton, Scar, Genie and Jafar. Raised on Disney films and couldn't enjoy the game when I heard them speak. They were good with others like Aladdin and Hades.

As people have said, I was pleasantly surprised how many original VAs they have gotten back over the years for KH*. I'm still surprised Gilbert Gottfried keeps coming back for Iago. I wonder who will replace Leonard Nimoy? Burton voicing Ansem, Yen Sid and Xehanort might be one too many.

*Hilariously, Steve Burton is the only one who seems to have stuck over the years out of FF KH1 cast. I'd give a kidney for Mandy Moore to come back as Aerith. I'm curious if she'll come back to voice Rapunzel for KH3. pleasevoiceAerithinFFVII:Rpleasepleaseplease I still can't believe how awful Mena Suvari was as Aerith in KHII. Wow.
 
Kind of Off Topic, but in that Spider-Man movie tie in game back in the GC days, they actually got Tobey Maguire to voice Spidey.

Funny thing is, he sounded awful. Like all the other guys who voiced Spidey sounded better.

Josh Keaton was actually supposed to voice spiderman in the game but once they got Tobey to come back they just replaced all his lines and used them for the goblin campaign.
 
What's amazing about this is just how absolutely half-assed it is. Like they got the idea right before they did the shoot and grabbed whatever clothes were in the one guy's car. Everything is a vague approximation.

I love how the colors of Marty's jacket are right, but in the wrong places. And how they're doing the watch pose without looking at their watches.
 
Josh Keaton was actually supposed to voice spiderman in the game but once they got Tobey to come back they just replaced all his lines and used them for the goblin campaign.

Huh, so him getting replaced in Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes wasn't the first time that occurred.
 
Donkey Kong in the games sounds NOTHING like he did in the TV show.

I guess Nintendo didn't want to pony up the cash to get the true and holy DK experience on video game consoles.

Says a lot about the NX too imo.
 
I don't know what happened with the Kick-Ass 2 game, but I'm willing to believe it was released as a way for organized crime to launder money. Just listen to how bad the main character sounds.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCaVk_4_9lY

Just...wow.
from the beginning of that clip hit girl sounded terrible too

also lmao at one of her lines:

"...when i was your age my kill list..."

...isn't hit girl younger than kick-ass? who wrote this shit?
 
Brian Bloom did the UMvC3 lines as well as the Vanilla MvC3 lines. There was no voice actor change.

Wait, what? then how the fuck did he fuck up so badly? He totally phoned in the UMVC3 lines.

Which is super baffling because other characters also had new lines or retakes (Like She-hulk changing the intonation on saying "This is bad!" in her lvl3) and only Cap sounds off.
 
from the beginning of that clip hit girl sounded terrible too

also lmao at one of her lines:

"...when i was your age my kill list..."

...isn't hit girl younger than kick-ass? who wrote this shit?

Takes palce in an alt. reality where hitgirl is actually 27 years old, explains the grown ass voice too.
 
I love how the colors of Marty's jacket are right, but in the wrong places. And how they're doing the watch pose without looking at their watches.

I'm also a huge fan of how they substiute Doc's eyeshield with some chintsy red sunglasses. What is going on with Doc's socks??
 
Drake Bell's Spider-Man in MvC3 sounds so bad compared to the 90s voice guy from the older games.
That was Josh Keaton (Spectacular Spider-Man), not Drake Bell. Keaton was amazing, mind you.

Wait, what? then how the fuck did he fuck up so badly? He totally phoned in the UMVC3 lines.

Which is super baffling because other characters also had new lines or retakes (Like She-hulk changing the intonation on saying "This is bad!" in her lvl3) and only Cap sounds off.
He grew into the role thanks to EMH since his Vanilla MvC3 recording. You can tell by how Bloom sounds closer to his EMH performance than before in UMvC3.
 
While this isn't 100% percent related to the topic, I do enjoy posting these and they do have some relevance to the current discussion.

It's Josh Keaton reading/acting Spider-man memes.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PX8MOSAkLsI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5V2jUTAJuAw
Josh Keaton is to Spider-Man like Kevin Conroy is to Batman, or like Mark Hamill is to The Joker. These videos prove it.

Insomniac fucked up big-time in not getting Josh Keaton to do Spidey for the PS4 game (all due respect to Yuri Lowenthal).
 
What's amazing about this is just how absolutely half-assed it is. Like they got the idea right before they did the shoot and grabbed whatever clothes were in the one guy's car. Everything is a vague approximation.
I doubt it was meant for the general public. It looks like an ad for some industry publication. They probably just threw in a couple of guys that worked there for fun.
 
Josh Keaton is to Spider-Man like Kevin Conroy is to Batman, or like Mark Hamill is to The Joker. These videos prove it.

Insomniac fucked up big-time in not getting Josh Keaton to do Spidey for the PS4 game (all due respect to Yuri Lowenthal).
Yeah, I like Yuri but dammit, Keaton is amazing.
 
Sisko and O'Brien were pretty bad in Deep Space Nine: The Fallen.

Made worse because they were the only 2 characters that weren't the original actors.

And even worse cause Sisko was one of the playable ones.
 
Should've been Snake's voice in MGS3 and PW.
Kind of Off Topic, but in that Spider-Man movie tie in game back in the GC days, they actually got Tobey Maguire to voice Spidey.

Funny thing is, he sounded awful. Like all the other guys who voiced Spidey sounded better.

Much of the time Tobey with the mask on/stunt double he was doing ADR for sounded bored if not out right drowsy doing his lines anyway.
 
Top Bottom