-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Xbox 360 vs. PS3 Face-Off: Round 16
- Thread starter squicken
- Start date
Kill Your Masters
Member
I totally agree, just look at what kind of stupid posts it brings up.My Arms Your Hearse said:
My Arms Your Hearse said:
It's quite amazing that it took this article to convince people that the PS3 version of ME is a "whole step down" from the 360 one when the consenses for the weeks it's been out, is that they're the same save for slightly more jaggies.
Despite the near-identical demos and positive reactions for both versions in the official thread.
Despite the near-identical demos and positive reactions for both versions in the official thread.
shadowsdarknes
Member
Ariexv said:A shame all evidence points to that if KZ2 was done on the 360 it would be superior to the Ps3 version.
Don't hurt me
Quite the opposite actually.
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
You have to understand that reading these threads and then seeing a game like KZ2 (which pretty much destroys anything on consoles) is an easy way to say, so what? If the games play the same enjoy life.Hellraizer said:
Mr.Potato Head
Banned
Ariexv said:A shame all evidence points to that if KZ2 was done on the 360 it would be superior to the Ps3 version.
Don't hurt me
Time for me to split... im not gonna get caught up in this derailed thread like a sucker :lol
Well despite the fact that it was a completely joke response to his idiotic post.... every Multi-platform game has been better on 360 so it stands to reason that if KZ2 was MP it would be better on 360 =Pshadowsdarknes said:
Before the mass posts w/ SSs of Uncharted and KZ2 and angry Ps3 bots show up to tear my head off.....IT'S A JOKE
Kill Your Masters
Member
Yeah, apparently it wasn't for him.LiquidMetal14 said:
Also, I'm curious how the Killzone 2 official thread title will sound like since apparently the game first destroys everything, then takes a dump on the leftovers.
I'm sorry, but I probably had to read about a 1000 times today how killzone 2 shits on and destroys everything
You like to push your like, dont you?
SonOfABeep
Banned
dallow_bg said:
I haven't seen a single thing of the PS3 version since I only own a 360 now and I played through the game on 360. I just thought the pictures they took were quite remarkable.
So I remarked.
I dunno about the validity of those screenshots, but the differences are certainly striking, wouldn't you agree?
Whoa, at the first comparison shot. At least they could've waited until the everything has been properly loaded. Anyway, here are my comparison shots. I think the 360 version looks a bit better due to some AA. As for which version has better lighting, I thought both looked pretty good.
PS3
XBOX 360
PS3
XBOX 360
PS3
XBOX 360
PS3
XBOX 360
HomerSimpson-Man
Member
Heh, yeah, those Eurogamer pics are bit misleading.
AgentOtaku
Member
alr1ghtstart said:
exactly ...how the hell do you screengrab something where the textures haven't even loaded in yet and call that a comparison?
CHRP718 said:
/thread over
#1, I didn't realize killzone was a multiplatform title, and thus your post was relevant.
#2, After listening to 1up yours, that clip seems a little less impressive from their descriptions. Namely the destructible environments aren't dynamically destructible, meaning you'll see that same effect no matter what (if I heard 1up yours correctly that is).
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
Hhahahaha understand your point. Now off ot the can to relieve myselfHellraizer said:Yeah, apparently it wasn't for him.
Also, I'm curious how the Killzone 2 official thread title will sound like since apparently the game first destroys everything, then takes a dump on the leftovers.I'm sorry, but I probably had to read about a 1000 times today how killzone 2 shits on and destroys everything
You like to push your like, dont you?
no thank to you
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
Fans of a game, yes. Sorry if me saying it craps on almot any game hurt you. Besides the thread is not about KZ2. If you weren't this upset you wouldn't needlessly curse.Becky said:
fizzelopeguss
Banned
dallow_bg said:
Keep in mind that Bishiuk's trolling.
I'm sporting a Ratchet and Clank avatar because I like Ratchet and clank..... also atleast read posts before responding because I WAS OBVIOUSLY JOKING. My god KZ2 fanboys are worse then Uncharted fanboys, how they pop up in any and all 360 vs Ps3 threads is almost as hilarious as the ones trying to claim KZ2 beats even Crysis in graphics.BeeDog said:
No it's dynamic in the sense that the stuff that *can* come off will fall off independently of each other when shot at / exploding. But it's only happening where the devs put it to be destroyed, not everywhere (much like Gears 2, only more often and better looking).fanduck said:
SolidSnakex
Member
drohne said:
It seems like they both suffer from pretty much the same issue (no v-lock). The only reason they went with UE3 in the first place was due to the Frostbite engine being behind and they didn't want to have to wait to really get moving on ME. So moving to Frostbite for the sequel makes sense.
Blimblim said:
So, if that grenade was placed differently, the pieces would fly off in a different direction? That's kind of what I think of as dynamic. Anything else just reminds me of breaking the glass and blowing up the computers in Goldeneye back in the day (it was fun to do, but not that impressive of an effect).
Ariexv said:
Yeah, obviously joking considering your last 3916912769217692 posts on this forum are clearly never putting the PS3 in any good light whatsoever. And nice going there, you clearly put 1 and 1 together when you implied I'm a KZ2 and/or Uncharted fanboy, did I even mention those games here?
Once again, :lol . You clearly have an agenda.
rollingstart
Banned
wtf is up with those Mirror's Edge comparison shots? the PS3 game doesn't look like that at all. The 360 game does look better because of less aliasing, but no way does it look like that. Do they compare review builds or something?
The spoiler tag wasn't enough for you? Or how about the second post that says twice that i was joking? Also the KZ2/Uncharted comment was more towards the other posters then yourself but w/e. As for never putting the Ps3 in any good light....BeeDog said:
Ratchet and Clank=fucking awesome
Valkyrie Chronicles=Fucking Awesome
Naruto Ultimate Ninja Storm=Fucking Awesome
First comparison shot shows a UE3 loading problem on the PS3, nothing to do with the platform (maybe slower BD drive?) that's for sure. But the second one certainly shows a discrepancy in term of lighting. I'll really have to record my own footage of both demos to see if I get the same result, it blows my mind that I didn't notice this myself.Linkzg said:
Sorry, musta missed where I said I was 100% unbiased completely neutral.... was just pointing out that there is some things I like about the Ps3 as well, really though the argument was that I wasn't joking... when I clearly was and said as much in my posts. Heck I don't even own either system(I own a Wii and a PC lol).mintylurb said:
DCharlie
And even i am moderately surprised
MYYHearse was just predicting the future of the thread, it inevitably ends with how great KZ2 is and how much better looking than Crysis it is.
I don't think he was invoking the KZ2 - but i see at least 3 posters actually high fiving and "/thread"íng :lol
i guess now the defense protocol involves :
+ secret game
+ god of war
+ how bad Gears 2 looks
Sony fans, be sure to tell as many as your friends as you can before black friday please.
but yeah, these threads are becoming pointless, i'm also not sure why Eurogamer bother. This is round 16, i think everyone gets the message that there are minor differences in the X360's favour. The only real message is the differences are getting more and more tiny.
So just lock it up - only one post required in the thread - the score, and then we can all stop dancing the same dance each week.
I don't think he was invoking the KZ2 - but i see at least 3 posters actually high fiving and "/thread"íng :lol
i guess now the defense protocol involves :
+ secret game
+ god of war
+ how bad Gears 2 looks
Sony fans, be sure to tell as many as your friends as you can before black friday please.
but yeah, these threads are becoming pointless, i'm also not sure why Eurogamer bother. This is round 16, i think everyone gets the message that there are minor differences in the X360's favour. The only real message is the differences are getting more and more tiny.
So just lock it up - only one post required in the thread - the score, and then we can all stop dancing the same dance each week.
KeioSquad2
Member
seat said:
But it's far from worded like that: to quote Eurogamer " once again the 360 version of such and such shows how magnificently beautiful a game can be with 2% less jagies then the absolutely ugly unplayable PS3 version, which should just end it's stinking life right now."
or
"The ps3 version of such and such is actually competent but lets move on to this next game that absolutely sucks on ps3 and shows how incompetent the ps3 really is."
Psychotext
Member
Is comparing the demos really a good idea here? Surely one of you must have access to the full game on both platforms just like EG does?
I know Gamersyde has been known to dabble in the world of comparison images.
I know Gamersyde has been known to dabble in the world of comparison images.
my god looking over the past couple years....DCharlie said:
2006-Gears 1 comes out destroys everything graphically: Didn't really see any constant pic posting
2007-Uncharted is king of graphics:50%+ of all threads on Neogaf contain pics of Uncharted
2008-Gears 2 and Banjo dominate the graphics this time around:Again You don't see people going around posting Gears 2/Banjo screenshots in every thread do you?
2009-KZ2 comes out:We've been getting constant screenshots of this for several months now.....
Do Ps3 fans really need to try and prove that their $600 was well spent this badly? Or do you all actually still believe Sonys utter bullshit about 4D/1080p/60FPS from before the Ps3 released?
Luckily I still have the footage I recorded from both demos, so it was quick to get 2 comparison shots:sajj316 said:
PS3: http://images.gamersyde.com/misc/mecomp/me1_ps3.png
360: http://images.gamersyde.com/misc/mecomp/me1_360.png
PS3: http://images.gamersyde.com/misc/mecomp/me2_ps3.png
360: http://images.gamersyde.com/misc/mecomp/me2_360.png
Let's just say that our relationship with EA might not be as good as Eurogamer's, and leave it at that :/Psychotext said:Is comparing the demos really a good idea here? Surely one of you must have access to the full game on both platforms just like EG does?
I know Gamersyde has been known to dabble in the world of comparison images.
Psychotext
Member
As much as I hate to say it... there's something in what you're saying there.Ariexv said:2006-Gears 1 comes out destroys everything graphically
2007-Uncharted is king of graphics:50%+ of all threads on Neogaf contain pics of Uncharted
2008-Gears 2 and Banjo dominate the graphics this time around:Again You don't see people going around posting Gears 2/Banjo screenshots in every thread do you?
2009-KZ2 comes out:We've been getting constant screenshots of this for several months now.....
d'oh!Blimblim said:
Strange ... does this look different to you? Should I look at Eurogamer.NET screens or ... Eurogamer.pt screens?
http://www.eurogamer.pt/tv_video.php?playlist_id=16772
or this ...
http://www.eurogamer.pt/gallery.php?game_id=7935&article_id=277762#anchor
http://www.eurogamer.pt/tv_video.php?playlist_id=16772
or this ...
http://www.eurogamer.pt/gallery.php?game_id=7935&article_id=277762#anchor