Support NeoGAF

[Garcia el Gringo]

I agree with him. I had 2 shitty Xbox one controllers. Squeaked, got loose at the seams, and the analogs got clunky and grindy. My lunar white so far solved the squeak and loose part, but now my left analog makes a spring noise when I move it.

I've had a similar experience with the redesigned Xbox One controllers, specifically the Lunar Whites. I went through a comical amount of exchanges. I've barely had any issue with Microsoft controllers before this One redesign.

I want to see a meticulous review of the Elite that gauge a sample of controllers for how consistent good build quality is (uniform inputs, even seams/body). I'd replace the Lunar White I settled on with the Elite eventually if someone scrupulous gives the shipment their approval. Reviews that focus on reporting known features or bring up the tired battery argument aren't terribly helpful to me.

 

[BleedOrange]

The price is obnoxious. There is no justification for that.

I disagree.

 

[Troy]

Wat?

Every single Xbox controller I've owned since 2001 still functions fine.

That's across 15 controllers. 1 OG Xbox controller, 4 OG S controllers, 6 360 controllers (2 PC), and 3 X1 controllers. I've never heard of them having QC problems.

Come again?

And every single Xbox 360 controller I owned either had a dpad that wouldn't register directions correctly and/or developed analog drift on the left stick. The Xbox One controller has even more egregious problems with the sticks.

They redesigned the original dpad on the 360 controller for a reason - it sucked. And it broke easily. Hell, it was so shitty that many of them came broken or faulty right out of the box.

 

[Head.spawn]

The price is obnoxious. There is no justification for that.

Wait until you hold the controller.

Pick one up for a minute, feel the comfort and quality. Flip it around, check out the features, toggle the hair trigger, swap the d-pad, notice the steel analogs, notice the perfect weighted feel of the controller, change out the analogs, get a feel for the buttons... Now put it down really fast and pick up a PS4 controller. Quickly throw it at a wall.. You'll understand.

It feels so right. Do I wish it was cheaper? I wish it was free. But there is an actual quality material upgrade here. The cosmetic appeal, while relevant, takes a back seat here and that is a rarity.

 

[Gowans]

 

[C-Sword]

Someone needs to test it out with Killer Instinct

 

[Ryne]

The only problem I had with a xbox controller is that the stick started drifting north on my midnight forces xbox one controller.

They have held up for me at least, I have owned quite a few xbox controllers.

 

[SwolBro]

http://m.uk.ign.com/articles/2015/1...re they saying it should have came with some?

 

[Head.spawn]

I bought her a necklace with my babies birthstone on it for her around the same time in August. It was at least 3x the price of this controller.

I've heard zero complaints.

 

[Iorv3th]

Elite controller for Win10/PC gaming +1, sorry Steam controller.

I thought about that, but it only will 'beat' the steam controller in games that require gamepad support for people that enjoy the sticks over the touchpad. The reason being that you can only rebind that back grip buttons to the gamepad buttons. You can't do mouse/keyboard emulation. So you aren't getting extra buttons, you are just hitting the ones already on the controller with a different finger.

Would still like to own one, but it is more limited than what the steam controller can do.

 

[Poker Face]

Need to know warranty details. I have had the worst luck with controllers this generation.

 

[Iorv3th]

This is the question I have now. Eneloop or Eneloop Pro?

Pro are more for cameras, they have longer battery life but less charges to them. It's up to you, but you will not be able to recharge the pro's as many times as the regulars.

 

[kodecraft]

I thought about that, but it only will 'beat' the steam controller in games that require gamepad support for people that enjoy the sticks over the touchpad. The reason being that you can only rebind that back grip buttons to the gamepad buttons. You can't do mouse/keyboard emulation. So you aren't getting extra buttons, you are just hitting the ones already on the controller with a different finger.

Would still like to own one, but it is more limited than what the steam controller can do.

So how deep does the companion app the Elite comes with go? I know it lets you remap buttons and I think analog sensitivity. So could it be updated to let you control the mouse on Win 10?

 

[diablos991]

I thought about that, but it only will 'beat' the steam controller in games that require gamepad support for people that enjoy the sticks over the touchpad. The reason being that you can only rebind that back grip buttons to the gamepad buttons. You can't do mouse/keyboard emulation. So you aren't getting extra buttons, you are just hitting the ones already on the controller with a different finger.

Would still like to own one, but it is more limited than what the steam controller can do.

False. I believe it was mentioned in an MS video that these could be bound to whatever you want. They are additional buttons on PC.

 

[Troy]

Give me a choice by throwing one of them in with the controller for free, and letting me buy the other if I prefer it. Having both as additional purchase options is stupid. The point is I shouldn't have to spend additional money for a rechargeable controller, especially if it costs $150...

The point is they give you batteries with every single controller and then treat you like a big boy and let you decide what to do with it going further. Infinitely better than giving me a battery with a 6 hour lifespan that forces me to either buy a brand new controller I dont want just to be able to continue to game or force me to buy a long ass USB charging cable and tether myself to my console just to play. I'll take choice.

 

[SwolBro]

has anyone discovered if the remap button feature allows you to leave some slots blank?

 

[The Albatross]

I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ENELOOP OWNER

ENELOOPS RULE

Welcome to BatteryGaf

 

[JayWood2010]

I just wish i could find somewhere to buy it and get it within the first week.

 

[Syrus]

Lol love it

 

[crpav]

Too bad they don't see it like this. They see it as the expensive jewelry is a need while a system, game, controller or anything else a man wants is a waste of money and junk....

 

[Steverulez]

The price is obnoxious. There is no justification for that.

Its a controller aimed at a very different market to the regular one, that group is prepared to pay a premium for a better controller, its not intended to be the sort of controller you buy 2/3/4 of them to go with your system and play local co-op with

Scuf (who they are partnered with on it) charge similar/larger amounts for their controllers too https://eu.scufgaming.com/store/

Considering how it appears to be selling it seems the price they picked is fine.

 

[the_don_patch]

Just ordered mine on Bestbuy! Looks like it should get here Wednesday!

 

[KevinG]

I had to use the "this is my Christmas present" with my wife, combined with "avoid doing too much Black Friday splurging."

 

[KevinG]

I just wish i could find somewhere to buy it and get it within the first week.

GameStop.com (if you're in the U.S.) with $15.99 overnight shipping. It should arrive on Tuesday.

 

[malfcn]

Major did an unboxing and shared a secret. Double tap the bind button to turn off and on the paddles. Sorry, no screen shots.

 

[diablos991]

From the Amazon questions:

I heard this elite controller emits pheromones that send out subconscious scent signals to illicit sexual responses from females. Is this true?

and the top response:

I was one of the lucky few to receive an alpha release of the Xbox One Elite controller last month. Immediately upon signing for it I tore the box open. I then received a knock on the door and it was my neighbor's wife. Vanessa and I have never gotten along, but this time she was all smiles. She said, "I just got off of my Playboy shoot and I just want to say that I'm sorry for being such a b#@$h to you over the past couple of years, but I need you now." I was obligated to make "the love" to her.
So the answer is an astounding "YES"!

The pheromones are worth the $150 alone!

 

[Vire]

How long do eneloops typically last for curiosity sake?

 

[Jarrod38]

Still 50/50 on if I should buy it or not.

 

[chekhonte]

Damn I was under the impression that this controller came with a wireless usb adapter for PC. I don't know how I got that idea in my head but I'm sad that it doesn't.

 

[chekhonte]

How long do eneloops typically last for curiosity sake?

6 to 7 hours from my experience.

 

[The Albatross]

How long do eneloops typically last for curiosity sake?

I'd say a solid ~50 hours of play time on two eneloops before I toss them in the charger (Amazon and reddit reviews claim 60 hours, but I'd say if you have a game w/ a lot of rumble, it'll be less). I don't play as much these days, so maybe once a month I swap the batteries in the controller for the batteries in the charger. The charging cradle is next to my recliner so it's more convenient for me to swap the pair in there. I always have 4 in the charger and 2 in the controller. I also use eneloops for my wireless keyboard/mouse and remote controls, so I have a few boxes.

6 to 7 hours from my experience.

Wait... 6 - 7 hours... Wut? Even the base eneloops should get 30 hours, and the higher capacity ones... 2500mah or whatever, should be in the 40 - 50 range.

*edit*

NeoGaf battery review thread reports ~40 hours generally with the base eneloops.

 

[Troy]

6 to 7 hours from my experience.

15-20 hours for me. You might have chinese knock-offs.

 

[diablos991]

6 to 7 hours from my experience.

You have bad eneloops or some cheap knockoffs.
I advise you to buy replacements from an authorized source.

 

[SamastahSukhino]

15-20 hours for me. You might have chinese knock-offs.

Yeah 6-7 hrs seems way off. Maybe he got bootleg batteries. I play with my loops for weeks.

 

[chekhonte]

You have bad eneloops or some cheap knockoffs.
I advise you to buy replacements from an authorized source.

Hmmm, I got them at costco and they said made in japan on the box but maybe.

 

[lighthouse777]

MLG Approves Xbox Elite Controller For All Tournaments
Recently, MLG have approved the Xbox Elite Controller for all their tournaments. The Xbox Elite Wireless Controller is approved for use by Major League Gaming for all competitive gaming activities and tournaments,” said Adam Apicella, Executive Vice President at MLG. “The customization options are great, showcasing the desired functionality required for pro level competition.”

http://rectifygaming.com/mlg-approves-xbox-elite-controller-for-all-tournaments/

 

[The Flash]

MLG Approves Xbox Elite Controller For All Tournaments
Recently, MLG have approved the Xbox Elite Controller for all their tournaments. The Xbox Elite Wireless Controller is approved for use by Major League Gaming for all competitive gaming activities and tournaments,” said Adam Apicella, Executive Vice President at MLG. “The customization options are great, showcasing the desired functionality required for pro level competition.”

http://rectifygaming.com/mlg-approves-xbox-elite-controller-for-all-tournaments/

BRB. Photoshopping MLG and Dewritos onto the controller.

 

[Corpekata]

Too bad they don't see it like this. They see it as the expensive jewelry is a need while a system, game, controller or anything else a man wants is a waste of money and junk....

Project any harder and you'll need to open a movie theater.

 

[lighthouse777]

BRB. Photoshopping MLG and Dewritos onto the controller.

doritos is now sony its now monster energy

 

[Justinh]

MLG Approves Xbox Elite Controller For All Tournaments
Recently, MLG have approved the Xbox Elite Controller for all their tournaments. The Xbox Elite Wireless Controller is approved for use by Major League Gaming for all competitive gaming activities and tournaments,” said Adam Apicella, Executive Vice President at MLG. “The customization options are great, showcasing the desired functionality required for pro level competition.”

http://rectifygaming.com/mlg-approves-xbox-elite-controller-for-all-tournaments/

oooh, I hadn't seen this before. In the next/previous post section.
First Xbox One Elite Controller accessories announced
Eh...it's kinda cool, I guess. oh, they just got it from Major Nelson's blog.

 

[barneystuta83]

Any independent video impressions from YouTube reviewers? Would love an actual hands on from someone who has used a Scuff controller and compare.

 

[The Flash]

doritos is now sony its now monster energy

That's ok. I'm at work anyways.

 

[JayWood2010]

GameStop.com (if you're in the U.S.) with $15.99 overnight shipping. It should arrive on Tuesday.

Will it actually be sent out though? Or will it be delayed since they stopped taking reservation in store?

 

[lighthouse777]

That's ok. I'm at work anyways.

come on, monster is so much better than mountain dew and doritos right!!

 

[Alebrije]

If Ms just had bundled this controller instead of the useless Kinetic at launch things would be different.

I hope they bundle a proc controller with xbone plus a game in the future.

 

[PanicFreak]

How long do eneloops typically last for curiosity sake?

I don't have as much time to game as I used to but I typically go about three weeks between changes.

 

[WonkyPanda]

Yes, I will most likely get one of these

 

[ElNino]

How long do eneloops typically last for curiosity sake?

6 to 7 hours from my experience.

Wait... 6 - 7 hours... Wut? Even the base eneloops should get 30 hours, and the higher capacity ones... 2500mah or whatever, should be in the 40 - 50 range.

*edit*

NeoGaf battery review thread reports ~40 hours generally with the base eneloops.

I get around 40 hours for mine as well.

 

[Charcoal]

Wait until you hold the controller.

Pick one up for a minute, feel the comfort and quality. Flip it around, check out the features, toggle the hair trigger, swap the d-pad, notice the steel analogs, notice the perfect weighted feel of the controller, change out the analogs, get a feel for the buttons... Now put it down really fast and pick up a PS4 controller. Quickly throw it at a wall.. You'll understand.

It feels so right. Do I wish it was cheaper? I wish it was free. But there is an actual quality material upgrade here. The cosmetic appeal, while relevant, takes a back seat here and that is a rarity.

lol hey there Mr. Spencer

 

[Head.spawn]

lol hey there Mr. Spencer

I bet you'll notice all the same shit when you touch the controller.

Zero hyperbole in that post.