-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Yes or No: Is a Dreamcast worth it for just Shenmue?
- Thread starter falconxcrunner09
- Start date
Upsidedown Fuji
Member
Exactly. This is hard to say for me as I'm a huge Sega fan, but modern Sega is a shell of its former self that is very risk adverse. I'm not sure where this instant expectation for Sega to make a logical decision came from. Sure ShenmueIII happening is a miracle, but this miracle is only backed by Sega in name only, because Yu Suzuki has such good ties with the company.
80 is a little pricey for a Dreamcast and Shenmue after it was worth barely anything before the announcement. I wouldn't have paid more than 25 for a Dreamcast and another 10 max for the game but supply and demand happens. It's a great game and stands visually but it is a 15 year old game on a controller many people do not like. I would suggest you get a vga cable or box for it to play it in its best image quality possible.
The Dreamcast is really the best way to play it unless you're fine with glitchy emulators that requires a decent PC and for you to manually rip the game and bios. 80 bucks still isn't that much and if you're not convinced you could always sell it off as I'm sure the v value of the system and game is going to stay high for a while.
Shenmue is an experience all gamers should be required to have. They don't need to love it, just understand how groundbreaking and deep it was for its time. This is not a game for those who just want to finish it. It is a game that is best played slowly.
Yes
This, it's not worth it for just one game but dreamcast back library is goat tier for Peanuts
ajim
Member
That was the one! Thanks for that.That's the post.
Does not sound like something unsolvable. That's what layers are for. Sounds more like Sega just didn't bother with the hassle because their other ports bombed.
Even Sega can't be blind to the fact that a simple port could make some good money here.
Right? :-(
And yeah... Sega gonna Sega...
Crayon
Member
If you are interested in experience a landmark game design for educational purposes, yes. In the context of it's time Shenmue is a stunning piece of history.
But just to get ready for shenmue 3 no way. Shenmue had glaring flaws even back them and nowadays some of the design is outright hilarious from a playability standpoint.
So for fun education: yes. For pure entertainment: No.
But just to get ready for shenmue 3 no way. Shenmue had glaring flaws even back them and nowadays some of the design is outright hilarious from a playability standpoint.
So for fun education: yes. For pure entertainment: No.
Lee Chaolan
Member
Nah, if you get a dreamcast you need to get some of the great fighters for it. Alpha 3, Soul Calibur, Mark of the Wolves, MvC2, Power Stones and Rival Schools Project Justice.
If you don't like fights, there's some good shumps and quality RPGs too.
If you don't like fights, there's some good shumps and quality RPGs too.
thewhitehawk
Member
I love the game but I wouldn't say it has aged very well. It has a lot of detail and and immense quantity of little things that make it a charming experience, but as a game it is mechanically outdated, perhaps to a very bad level compared to games today.
Considering how expensive the game and the console would be, I think I'd say the most affordable and pleasant way to afford it would be, if you have an xbox 360, try to get Shenmue 2 and watch the movie that tells the story of shenmue 1.
Considering how expensive the game and the console would be, I think I'd say the most affordable and pleasant way to afford it would be, if you have an xbox 360, try to get Shenmue 2 and watch the movie that tells the story of shenmue 1.
Drilbit777
Member
At least with GTA 3 you can get it on PS3 through the PS2 classics while thats not the case with Shemune
$80 seems steep. Does anywhere else have it for cheaper? I remember buying my Dreamcast for $20 shortly after it was discontinued and that included 4 controllers, 2 VMUs, and a few games. Ended up picking up Shenmue for somewhere around $10 if memory serves.
It's a cool game, but be warned that it's very much a product of its time. This was before QTEs were in every action game and the voice work/dialog can be very... endearing at times.
It's a cool game, but be warned that it's very much a product of its time. This was before QTEs were in every action game and the voice work/dialog can be very... endearing at times.
It wouldn't. Shenmue is still the only game like that.
A open world story oriented game, with bad voice acting, QTEs, collectibles, fetch quests, and an overarching story to cause you to buy the next installment? Ya, modern gaming has nothing on that.
family_guy
Member
If you have a 360 and can find a disc, it's backwards compatible.
John Bender
Banned
Dreamcast ist worth it, because it's the Dreamcast.
Shenmue? Nah. Better wait a bit.
Seems like there is a Remaster or port coming for the PS4.
Just wait a little bit more.
Shenmue? Nah. Better wait a bit.
Seems like there is a Remaster or port coming for the PS4.
Just wait a little bit more.
Yea it's kindof wrong to say the game has aged poorly. Most of its flaws were just as big back then, even when compared to its contemporaries, but it did some things that were pretty impressive as well so it was easier to look past the issues.
Ya I personally don't like it, but I give it respect for doing a lot of new things back then. The trouble is a lot of those new things are very common in AAA gaming today, even hated things like QTEs. So it can't really prop itself up with that anymore.
I was just giving an equivalent scenario. A lot of people would have seen GTAIII again recently what with the mobile releases and will have seen how it's aged. Shenmue is the same.
Bought into the Shenmue hype on release and didn't enjoy it at all. Most of the other classic Dreamcast games I enjoyed got superior ports like Rez, Skies of Arcadia, Crazy Taxi, Jet Set Radio, Ecco Defender of the Future, etc.
The only reasons I still keep my Dreamcast around are Border Down and Outtrigger.
The only reasons I still keep my Dreamcast around are Border Down and Outtrigger.
Shift Breaker
Member
That's the post.
Does not sound like something unsolvable. That's what layers are for. Sounds more like Sega just didn't bother with the hassle because their other ports bombed.
Even Sega can't be blind to the fact that a simple port could make some good money here.
Right? :-(
I'm still very sad about the SoA port not being a thing. Can we petition for that
UltraGunner
Banned
Yes, Along with every other game that got released for it.
Seriously, the Dreamcast is probably one of the top 5 best consoles ever.
Seriously, the Dreamcast is probably one of the top 5 best consoles ever.
openrob
Member
Yes, and their are many other great gems you will find (although, as you said you may have played them all).
But heck sure you could easily resell it.
Fox Mulder
Member
Sega is the same company that gave chuchu rocket a hd version, but mobile only. No online multiplayer version for xbla, psn, or steam.
They suck.
and people gotta stop acting like all of its great games have been ported elsewhere.
unless they own dope Naomi collections I guess.
No, I played through the whole thing just fine all the way back in 2005.
Tizoc
Member
It's also the same company that let V. Chronicles release on Steam.
They rock.
Tell me about it, I mean how else is one gonna play Cannon Spike/Gun Spike? Not to mention the BEST ver. of Capcom vs. SNK 2!
I'm not even a Shenmue guy and this is the right answer.
If you're only getting the dreamcast for shenmue then do you value a dreamcast game at $80? Or would you be a tad salty with yourself if/when the 1+2 remaster comes out?
Dreamcast is a neat console though, and everyone *has* the play the sonic adventure games sometime. they just have to. Also stuff like jet set radio is supposed to be good too@
ienjoyrawfish
Member
Saying Shenmue has aged badly makes absolutely no sense. In order for something to have aged badly it must have been superseded by something that has followed. Yet there is absolutely nothing even remotely like Shenmue on the market now.
Today's AAA open world games bear only a very superficial resemblance at best.
Today's AAA open world games bear only a very superficial resemblance at best.
eso76
Member
How much is a Dreamcast these days anyway ?
They are worth experiencing for sure, although you had to be there they still have their own charme and uniqueness and are surprisingly refreshing.
Impressive, for a 14 years old games.
Shenmue I and II weren't following any game design guideline, and as a result they were unlike any other game before them and are still unlike any game that came after them.
Mind you, they have aged terribly in terms of controls though, which represents a huge barrier.
They are worth experiencing for sure, although you had to be there they still have their own charme and uniqueness and are surprisingly refreshing.
Impressive, for a 14 years old games.
Shenmue I and II weren't following any game design guideline, and as a result they were unlike any other game before them and are still unlike any game that came after them.
Mind you, they have aged terribly in terms of controls though, which represents a huge barrier.
OP, lots of "no" replies in here but I'm going to buck the trend and say yes. Honestly, I don't know that the first two games will get HD ports when you consider Sega's attitude these days. They seem to have their focus elsewhere.
Shenmue has terrible, terrible voice acting, but there's some charm in that game that holds up. Do you like exploring towns? Are you one of those people who talks to everyone in a village/town just to see what they say? Do you like doing random stuff like playing mini-games or watching your main character drink a soda? Its weird to point those things out but I feel they are important things to appreciate if you're looking at playing this game. There's a lot to it, really. Martial arts, investigating the events in the story, getting to know the characters, etc. Its a game with a lot to offer if you're willing to really give it your full attention. Its one of those games that works best if you can play for an hour or more every night/day. Once it has you, you'll just keep coming back until you're done.
There's also the historical aspect of the purchase. You're getting the game that nearly put Sega out of business, but also the game that broke serious ground in many ways!
I say go for it and don't look back. Its a very unique game with no other game quite like it (Yakuza is not Shenmue, unless you ask people who must not have played Shenmue) and if you really don't like it, you can always sell it. Shenmue is trending right now, lots of people are curious about it. Hell, go ahead and do a Let's Play on YouTube or stream from Twitch if you want. People are interested and curious. Go play and have fun! Its a unique gem that may show its age in some ways, but still holds up in many others.
Shenmue has terrible, terrible voice acting, but there's some charm in that game that holds up. Do you like exploring towns? Are you one of those people who talks to everyone in a village/town just to see what they say? Do you like doing random stuff like playing mini-games or watching your main character drink a soda? Its weird to point those things out but I feel they are important things to appreciate if you're looking at playing this game. There's a lot to it, really. Martial arts, investigating the events in the story, getting to know the characters, etc. Its a game with a lot to offer if you're willing to really give it your full attention. Its one of those games that works best if you can play for an hour or more every night/day. Once it has you, you'll just keep coming back until you're done.
There's also the historical aspect of the purchase. You're getting the game that nearly put Sega out of business, but also the game that broke serious ground in many ways!
I say go for it and don't look back. Its a very unique game with no other game quite like it (Yakuza is not Shenmue, unless you ask people who must not have played Shenmue) and if you really don't like it, you can always sell it. Shenmue is trending right now, lots of people are curious about it. Hell, go ahead and do a Let's Play on YouTube or stream from Twitch if you want. People are interested and curious. Go play and have fun! Its a unique gem that may show its age in some ways, but still holds up in many others.
Yes it is.
Shenmue is such a singular experience. The indefinable value of the game, to me at least, exceeds the cost of acquiring the console.
The Dreamcast has a lot of other delights too though, some of which are not particularly expensive even today. It is such a unique system that I actually use it a lot more than some of my more popular older game systems, because it simply satisfies gaming needs that the current consoles don't.
Shenmue is such a singular experience. The indefinable value of the game, to me at least, exceeds the cost of acquiring the console.
The Dreamcast has a lot of other delights too though, some of which are not particularly expensive even today. It is such a unique system that I actually use it a lot more than some of my more popular older game systems, because it simply satisfies gaming needs that the current consoles don't.
sixteen-bit
Member
Make it a Hello Kitty Dreamcast.
Dream Cat
Crimsonclaw111
Member
Not for Shenmue alone, no. But the Dreamcast has tons of good shit for cheap to keep you entertained alone as well.
Nostalgic Nightmare
Member
Man so many people getting caught up in the hype for this game, resellers must be laughing all the way to the bank. The game is not worth the asking price currently, simple as that. Honestly I'd rather play a Yakuza game.
All that being said there are a bunch of great games on the DC, especially arcade ports.
All that being said there are a bunch of great games on the DC, especially arcade ports.
breakYODAy
Member
Yes.