-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Your favorite controllers of all time.
- Thread starter FireBeaver
- Start date
ComradeZero
Member
Sega Saturn
GurgleBot20
Member
I'm surprised that plenty of people are listing the Dreamcast controller. All they had to do with it is add an actual stick to the Saturn Analog pad, but instead they removed two buttons, downgraded what was the best D-Pad, and put the cord at the bottom. The thing also feels too light and cheap.
I'd go with either the Dual Shock 4 or the JP Saturn controller.
I'd go with either the Dual Shock 4 or the JP Saturn controller.
ShadowSoldier89
Member
every other controller other than the dualshocks have the left analog in the wrong spot. The triggers on the DS3 were fantastic for use as flickable buttons and not triggers. Triggers in general suck at being triggers (hence all the trigger stop mods for xbox controllers). Also the dpads on the dualshocks are by far the best, especially for fighting games.
Also the pre DS4 dualshocks are best left resting on the fingers and not gripped, which is the best part about them.
I'd say the XB1 controller but I'm on my fourth one now and all of them had different defects so fuck that shit.
First had a faulty right bumper. Would only register if you pressed it a certain way and even then it was spotty at best.
Second randomly disconnected during wireless sessions no matter if I used the battery pack or standard AA batteries.
Third (a freaking elite controller no less) had a way too sensitive left stick. If you play 2D platformers with the stick like me (it's more comfortable for me due to a condition with my left hand) you will probably do small little flicks with the stick and due to the aforementioned sensitivity issue, you will face in the opposite direction when the stick snaps back to its default position. Try playing something like Cuphead or Hollow Knight like that without wanting to throw the controller across the room.
No, fiddling around with the stick settings in the controller app did not help.
Fourth (white S revision) has an A button that won't register approximately 1 out of 10 times.
Controller QA has gone to shit this gen. Currently looking into a Switch Pro controller but that's still a bit too pricey for me at 65€. Should honestly just use one of my 360 controllers but I can't find my wireless receiver and fuck throwing out 20€ for another one.
First had a faulty right bumper. Would only register if you pressed it a certain way and even then it was spotty at best.
Second randomly disconnected during wireless sessions no matter if I used the battery pack or standard AA batteries.
Third (a freaking elite controller no less) had a way too sensitive left stick. If you play 2D platformers with the stick like me (it's more comfortable for me due to a condition with my left hand) you will probably do small little flicks with the stick and due to the aforementioned sensitivity issue, you will face in the opposite direction when the stick snaps back to its default position. Try playing something like Cuphead or Hollow Knight like that without wanting to throw the controller across the room.
No, fiddling around with the stick settings in the controller app did not help.
Fourth (white S revision) has an A button that won't register approximately 1 out of 10 times.
Controller QA has gone to shit this gen. Currently looking into a Switch Pro controller but that's still a bit too pricey for me at 65€. Should honestly just use one of my 360 controllers but I can't find my wireless receiver and fuck throwing out 20€ for another one.
I love the 360 controller outside of the D-pad. It just feels right.
Dualshock 4 is very good as well. I just wish the rubber tips didn't wear out so easily, otherwise it's excellent.
I have a lot of nostalgia towards the SNES controller though playing on a SNES Classic has made me realize that part of that might have been rose-tinted glasses. It's fine but not great.
Dualshock 4 is very good as well. I just wish the rubber tips didn't wear out so easily, otherwise it's excellent.
I have a lot of nostalgia towards the SNES controller though playing on a SNES Classic has made me realize that part of that might have been rose-tinted glasses. It's fine but not great.
Tackleberry
Member
The Xbox one controller would win for me if it weren't for one cash grabbing design flaw..
The fact that it takes batteries, or requires you to buy a recharging battery pack. Come on now MS, it's 2017.
The fact that it takes batteries, or requires you to buy a recharging battery pack. Come on now MS, it's 2017.
Interfectum
Gold Member
SNES and Switch Pro controller.
The Switch Pro feels like it just melts in your hands. Love it.
omgwtfbentime
Member
Really liking split joycons, feels like you have every control option you’d want and feels like an uncompromised split controller setup. Would like a joycon “XL” option (wish the pro controller woulda been that instead, but get why it’s not).
In terms of ergonomics, I love the Xbox one controller. Wish theyÂ’d just make a slightly smaller sega dpad and use that as their dpad solution instead of the clicky dpad but the comfort level and weight feels perfect. No idea how people actually prefer the DS4
In terms of ergonomics, I love the Xbox one controller. Wish theyÂ’d just make a slightly smaller sega dpad and use that as their dpad solution instead of the clicky dpad but the comfort level and weight feels perfect. No idea how people actually prefer the DS4
The Saturn Model 2 pad
The Xbox One and PS4 controller are equal for me
My least favorite, from what i have played, is a tie between the N64 and Dreamcast controller. I played the N64 a lot when i was younger and i hated everything about it. I got a dreamcast last year, and i play it often. Its terrible for fighting games, which i play often. I like the way the Dreamcast controller feels, but the analog stick and d-pad kill it for me.
The Xbox One and PS4 controller are equal for me
My least favorite, from what i have played, is a tie between the N64 and Dreamcast controller. I played the N64 a lot when i was younger and i hated everything about it. I got a dreamcast last year, and i play it often. Its terrible for fighting games, which i play often. I like the way the Dreamcast controller feels, but the analog stick and d-pad kill it for me.
That one was mentioned already. It looks interesting though!
Shifty1897
Member
Some of y'all don't know about this but wireless controllers before the Wavebird were 3rd party pieces of garbage. Nintendo coming out with a first party controller that registered every input with practically no input lag and ran for 20 hours on a single set of batteries felt like witchcraft. It took 2 to 3 years and a new console generation before Sony and Microsoft were able to catch up. It completely changed the way people played video games.
TheAggroCraig
Member
The Wavebird, no question (except for the awful D-Pad)
360 controller is up there too.
360 controller is up there too.
Transistor
Banned
The Logitech Cordless Action controllers for PS2 and Xbox were way ahead of their time. Wireless, comfortable, long lasting battery life. God I miss them.
Gai Murakumo
Member
Xbox 360 controller minus the d-pad(it sucked) than the Xbox One controller. Never tried the elite controller though it would probably be up there with those two.
Yes. The first week or so of me trying to situate or flick the cord around and over blankets only to realize I was flailing for no reason. The freedom to just set and move the controller without worry of being tethered. Goddamn.
Some of y'all don't know about this but wireless controllers before the Wavebird were 3rd party pieces of garbage. Nintendo coming out with a first party controller that registered every input with practically no input lag and ran for 20 hours on a single set of batteries felt like witchcraft. It took 2 to 3 years and a new console generation before Sony and Microsoft were able to catch up. It completely changed the way people played video games.
Spiritwalker
Member
DualShock 4, Switch Pro Controller and XB1 in that order. The 360 was really good for its time too, but it has been surpassed by current gen controllers.
Vita remains the king of d-pads though.
Vita remains the king of d-pads though.
I really don't agree on the LS position. The DPad is where it is on the Dualshock because before analogue sticks were invented, the DPad was the most common source of left hand input for games (or, the only source). It was therefore placed in the most comfortable position for your thumb to reach it, and the place where your thumb naturally rests when you hold that controller. It's also roughly the position your thumb is if you just leave your hand in a neutral position when you're not holding anything.
Now that the thumbstick is the primary, most common source of input, it makes more sense to have it where your thumb naturally rests on the controller and put the dpad elsewhere.
On the right hand you can put it in whichever position you like as the face buttons are used pretty much interchangeably with the right thumbstick.
Also if you use thumbsticks like I do and operate them with your thumb joint rather than the tip of the thumb itself your thumbs bump into each other too much
Chinbo37
Member
I never for the life of me could understnad this complaint. For me that is what makes it a great controller. I hate electronics that dont allow you to swap out the battery. Battery life always fades after time and then you are stuck.
Why not just buy eneloops?
PhilipDoesMatter
Member
Xbox Elite Controller is state-of-the-art thing.
GoneRestorff
Member
1. Xbox 360 - the best.
2.Gamecube
3 Nintendo 64 - really liked it.
The rest - really don't like any iteration of the sony controller. The least likeable thing with both ps2 and ps4.
2.Gamecube
3 Nintendo 64 - really liked it.
The rest - really don't like any iteration of the sony controller. The least likeable thing with both ps2 and ps4.
+1
This gen the closest to this is the Steam Controller because of gyro and touchpads, which I like very much too.
So if I had to pick today, my vote goes to the Steam Controller.
KainXVIII
Member
This, using DS4 for PC all the time!
Count of Monte Sawed-Off
un33dab@dpu$$y
The 360 controller might be my favorite overall, and from what I've played of the xbox one, it's pretty much the same, so that too. I like the the PS4 dual shock, definitely an improvement over the previous generations. Playing the SNES mini reminds me how much I really liked that controller. I just got a switch and so far I'm not really feeling the standard controller, but maybe I'll get used to it.
The worst controller ever for me was the Dreamcast. That's the only controller to ever hurt my hands.
The worst controller ever for me was the Dreamcast. That's the only controller to ever hurt my hands.
ShadowSoldier89
Member
How I use a dpad and thumbstick differ to the point where a analog stick in the lower position is nearly equivalent to the higher position with preferring the lower slightly. However the dpad being in the lower position fucking blows.I really don't agree on the LS position. The DPad is where it is on the Dualshock because before analogue sticks were invented, the DPad was the most common source of left hand input for games (or, the only source). It was therefore placed in the most comfortable position for your thumb to reach it, and the place where your thumb naturally rests when you hold that controller. It's also roughly the position your thumb is if you just leave your hand in a neutral position when you're not holding anything.
Now that the thumbstick is the primary, most common source of input, it makes more sense to have it where your thumb naturally rests on the controller and put the dpad elsewhere.
On the right hand you can put it in whichever position you like as the face buttons are used pretty much interchangeably with the right thumbstick.
Also if you use thumbsticks like I do and operate them with your thumb joint rather than the tip of the thumb itself your thumbs bump into each other too much
I use the tip of my thumb for analogs (which is why the right joycon is the worst thing ever....)
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
The 360 pad is GOAT. Dualshock 4 is not far behind but Sony really needs to change the left analog stick position.
Rellik
Member
It's not up there. It shits on them.
I'm voting the joycon for sheer versatility.
Split mode is an incredibly comfortable way to play
Grip mode is serviceable as a traditional setup
Built in gyro for aiming in traditional games, Wii style motion play and can also replicate pointer control
Best in class haptic feedback, NFC, and a thus far unused but intriguing IR camera create new ways to play
20 hours battery life in a tiny package
AND can be used as two individual controllers?!
Split mode is an incredibly comfortable way to play
Grip mode is serviceable as a traditional setup
Built in gyro for aiming in traditional games, Wii style motion play and can also replicate pointer control
Best in class haptic feedback, NFC, and a thus far unused but intriguing IR camera create new ways to play
20 hours battery life in a tiny package
AND can be used as two individual controllers?!
Similar threads
- Poll