Support NeoGAF

[Byakuya769]

Uncharted

... my man!!!!!

 

[VALKYRAY]

i've beaten uncharted and MGS4 once. how come i don't feel these two are epic enough to be game of the gen?

 

[Hcoregamer00]

Valkyria Chronicles, no doubt.

Ace Attorney 3 is a pretty distant second.

 

[Keikoku]

i've beaten uncharted and MGS4 once. how come i don't feel these two are epic enough to be game of the gen?

Because it's true. Uncharted was great but not so awesome. MGS4 is the worst of the series and ruined it for me.

Seems well deserved for SMG though (haven't played the game yet, I need a Wii )

 

[jett]

A lot of people butthurt over Uncharted praise.

Yep.

 

[Talon]

Am I the first to mention super mario galaxy? Come on what is wrong with you gaf...

Didn't read the thread, eh?

 

[BigO]

Super Mario Galaxy

 

[Gbeav]

where does it take the cake?

To the store, to see the other cakes.

 

[Flyguy]

The most funnest GOTG so far has been Crackdown.
The most bestest GOTG so far has been Bioshock.

 

[lupinko]

I love Valkyria and THRILLZONE2 and all that jazz, but, RYU GA MOTHERFUCKING GOTOKU 3!!!

 

[vicissitudes]

Am I the first to mention super mario galaxy? Come on what is wrong with you gaf...

Yeah on this page maybe...

 

[blindrocket]

Uncharted, easily.

 

[Nakazato]

Mgs 4

 

[Kyleripman]

Afrika (Hakuna Matata).
Felt like the game was made just for me.

 

[Takeda Kenshi]

Super Mario Galaxy.

 

[BulletSmoke]

Mario Galaxy/GTA4 in terms of technical achievements

Brain Age, Wii Sports, Wii Fit redefined gaming this gen

 

[dazzgc]

Uh..you know, Sonyfans, you guys do have stuff like LBP and MGS4 now. No reason to continue pretending to like Uncharted.

LOL

 

[MikeE21286]

It was the first game I remember that made me feel that the new gen had REALLY arrived.

Gears? That gave me that "new gen" feeling personally.....

 

[user friendly]

Uncharted, hands down. Never have I replayed a single game more than this one. Crushing is pure brilliance at it's best.

 

[Poohblaster]

Bioshock

 

[Defcon]

On consoles: Uncharted
PC: King's Bounty

 

[Jaffaboy]

Dead Space

 

[Flavius]

So which is the title peeps are jerking off the most without having ever played it?

Gotta' be Super Mario Galaxy, right?

 

[rexor0717]

Uncharted

So many choices, but it's simply the best.

 

[HK-47]

Galaxy

 

[Yoboman]

Yeah I'm gonna pick Uncharted. I'm replaying it now, it's such a fun and well rounded package. Greatly paced, amazing graphics and gameplay is responsive and fun. It's ageing really well too

 

[Scottlarock]

Saint's row 2

 

[Groovester]

LittleBigPlanet

Every time I pop in that disc, I start to smile and have an instant blast.

 

[DeathbyVolcano]

So which is the title peeps are jerking off the most without having ever played it?

Gotta' be Super Mario Galaxy, right?

Can't be Metal Gear Solid, obviously, going by your avatar.

Seriously what? Mario Galaxy was nigh perfect.

 

[Shaheed79]

Left 4 Evil Galaxy 5: Fallout of the Patriots

 

[grap3fruitman]

Rockband 2

 

[cooljeanius]

Brawl. I liked Galaxy, but I have fonder memories of Brawl, mostly because of all the multiplayer matches my copy saw.

 

[TEH-CJ]

killzone 2 at 25?

wut

 

[mittelos]

RE5

 

[Synless]

killzone 2 at 25?

wut

Killzone is #3 on my list, in it's full order it's Uncharted, MGS4, Killzone 2, RE5, Brawl, and somewhere down the list is Galaxy.

 

[Cartman86]

So which is the title peeps are jerking off the most without having ever played it?

Gotta' be Super Mario Galaxy, right?

I didn't love Galaxy nearly as much as a lot of people, but I seriously doubt anyone voted for it not having played it.

 

[GrotesqueBeauty]

So which is the title peeps are jerking off the most without having ever played it?

Gotta' be Super Mario Galaxy, right?

Lol, trying to undermine the frontrunner because you're butt hurt. God forbid GAF actually agrees on something for once because the game is just that good.

 

[Gully State]

So which is the title peeps are jerking off the most without having ever played it?

Gotta' be Super Mario Galaxy, right?

It's more likely that it's MGS4 since most people can't afford a PS3.

 

[Flavius]

I'm guessing most peeps who think I'm whining in favor of MGS3 are the 15 and under crowd, since if you knew who the fuck was in the pic and the name of the game he's actually holding in the pic, you'd realize I'm far from a KojiPro fanboy (though I've enjoyed some MGS games in the past).

I wasn't saying Galaxy's a bad game. I happen to think it's pretty brilliant. But I also know how much some of the kiddies here want to be part of the gang and will say just about anything to be a part of the geek in-crowd, that's all.

If you really believe that everyone replying here has played the game they voted for, then check yo sneaks. The NB doesn't really stand for New Balance as much as it does Naive Bastard.

 

[Crumpet Trumpet]

Elite Beat Agents

 

[Haly]

I wasn't saying Galaxy's a bad game. I happen to think it's pretty brilliant. But I also know how much some of the kiddies here want to be part of the gang and will say just about anything to be a part of the geek in-crowd, that's all.

Highly doubtful considering GAFers are willing to argue over anything if it means scoring a point against the "other side".

There is no geek "in-crowd", there is only console war.

Anyway I'll put in a vote for Mother 3, and if that's not allowed then The World Ends With You.

 

[DeathbyVolcano]

I'm guessing most peeps who think I'm whining in favor of MGS3 are the 15 and under crowd, since if you knew who the fuck was in the pic and the name of the game he's actually holding in the pic, you'd realize I'm far from a KojiPro fanboy (though I've enjoyed some MGS games in the past).

I wasn't saying Galaxy's a bad game. I happen to think it's pretty brilliant. But I also know how much some of the kiddies here want to be part of the gang and will say just about anything to be a part of the geek in-crowd, that's all.

If you really believe that everyone replying here has played the game they voted for, then check yo sneaks. The NB doesn't really stand for New Balance as much as it does Naive Bastard.

Wow this post is just ridiculous.

 

[Robot Without A Cause]

Looks like Mario Galaxy is winning, I haven't played it but I guess I have to vote for it otherwise GAF won't accept me as a cool guy.

Spoiler

I already voted, don't count this post

 

[Flavius]

Ricockulous, even. But don't let me get in way of the voting. Merely posing a question and offering up my thoughts.

 

[RedRedSuit]

This concept of voting for a game you haven't played is pretty bizarre. How much of a fanboy would someone have to be to vote for an old game that they haven't yet made themselves play? And this theory about people just voting for X to be part of the cool kidz is even more bizarre.

Seriously....

 

[pizzaguysrevenge]

I'm guessing most peeps who think I'm whining in favor of MGS3 are the 15 and under crowd, since if you knew who the fuck was in the pic and the name of the game he's actually holding in the pic, you'd realize I'm far from a KojiPro fanboy (though I've enjoyed some MGS games in the past).

I wasn't saying Galaxy's a bad game. I happen to think it's pretty brilliant. But I also know how much some of the kiddies here want to be part of the gang and will say just about anything to be a part of the geek in-crowd, that's all.

If you really believe that everyone replying here has played the game they voted for, then check yo sneaks. The NB doesn't really stand for New Balance as much as it does Naive Bastard.

Not knowing the name of some random ass developer = being under 15. Gotcha!

 

[Flavius]

:lol

This should be entertaining...

I've chummed the nerd-waters, teeth are being bared.

No offense, I would also never, ever label this place "cool" nor myself, for what it's worth.

EDIT: And the 15 and under comment wasn't a put-down...I'd say the long-haired rocker dude pictured was pretty well known back in the day, but not so much now.

 

[iam220]

Street Fighter 4. Bar none. Maybe crysis on the PC side of things.

 

[Pojo]

Elite Beat Agents

That counts?

It is an incredible game, for sure. Best handheld game I've ever played, aside from maybe Metroid Fusion.

 

[andymcc]

I'm guessing most peeps who think I'm whining in favor of MGS3 are the 15 and under crowd, since if you knew who the fuck was in the pic and the name of the game he's actually holding in the pic, you'd realize I'm far from a KojiPro fanboy (though I've enjoyed some MGS games in the past).

I wasn't saying Galaxy's a bad game. I happen to think it's pretty brilliant. But I also know how much some of the kiddies here want to be part of the gang and will say just about anything to be a part of the geek in-crowd, that's all.

If you really believe that everyone replying here has played the game they voted for, then check yo sneaks. The NB doesn't really stand for New Balance as much as it does Naive Bastard.

what an amazing post. you've bested this thread.