This can be from a pool of games confirmed for the show or LIKELY to be at the show. All platforms, currrent or next gen, console, PC, or portable.
My list:
1) Too Human
2) Mass Effect
3) Bioshock
4) Halo 3
5) Metal Gear Solid 4
6) Ratchet and Clank 4
7) Lair
8) Animal Crossing Revolution
9) Super Smash Brothers Revolution
10) Super Mario Revolution
NEO-GAF TOP TEN (as of post #161)
1. Metal Gear Solid 4 - 71
2. Super Mario Revolution - 47
3. Zelda: Twilight Princess - 43
4. Resident Evil 5 - 41
5. Metroid Prime 3 - 40
6. Halo 3 - 38
7. Too Human - 36
8. Red Steel - 29
9. Mass Effect - 28
10. Super Smash Bros. Revolution - 23
AND MORE...
11. (TIE) Zelda: Phantom Hourglass - 22
11. (TIE) Devil May Cry 4 - 22
13. Gears of War - 20
14. Bioshock - 19
15. Final Fantasy XIII (PS3 or PS2) - 18
16. Warhawk - 16
17. Lair - 15
18. (TIE) Heavenly Sword - 14
18. (TIE) Blue Dragon - 14
20. (TIE) Killzone PS3 - 10
20. (TIE) Tekken PS3 - 10
20. (TIE) Motorstorm - 10
23. (TIE) Alan Wake - 9
23. (TIE) New Super Mario Bros. - 9
23. (TIE) Spore - 9
26. (TIE) Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles (Rev) - 8
26. (TIE) God of War 2 - 8
26. (TIE) New Miyamoto IP (Rev) - 8
26. (TIE) Project Assassin - 8
26. (TIE) Silent Hill V - 8
31. (TIE) Final Fantasy III (DS) - 7
31. (TIE) Gran Turismo PS3 - 7
33. (TIE) Lost Odyssey - 6
33. (TIE) Pokémon Diamond/Pearl - 6
33. (TIE) Virtua Fighter V (console vers.) - 6
36. (TIE) Crackdown - 5
36. (TIE) Fable 2 - 5
36. (TIE) Final Fantasy VIIre - 5
36. (TIE) Ratchet & Clank 4 - 5
36. (TIE) Rayman 4 - 5
36. (TIE) Resistance: Fall of Man - 5
36. (TIE) Starcraft II - 5
36. (TIE) Yakuza - 5
THE COMPLETE LIST IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER -
Ace Combat X (PSP) - 1
After Burner Climax - 2
Alan Wake - 9
Animal Crossing (Rev) - 1
Armored Core 4 - 1
ASH (DS) - 2
Balloon Fight Revolution - 1
Banjo-Threeie - 2
Baten Kaitos II - 1
Bioshock - 18
Blade Storm - 1
Blue Dragon - 14
Bob Ross Painting - 1
Brothers in Arms 3 - 4
Camelot RPG - 1
Capcom Puzzle Collection (PSP) - 1
Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin - 4
Cellfactor - 1
Children of Mana - 1
Cooking Revolution - 1
Crackdown - 5
Cry On - 2
Crysis - 2
Culdcept Saga - 1
Darkness, The (360/PS3) - 3
Dark Sector - 2
Dawn of War Expansion - 1
Dead or Alive: XVB2 - 3
Dead Rising - 1
Devil May Cry 4 - 22
Devil May Cry PSP - 1
Diablo III - 1
Donkey Kong Revolution - 1
Dragon Age - 3
Duke Nukem Forever (keep the hope alive) - 3
Ensemble RTS - 1
Every Extend Extra (PSP) - 2
Eyedentify - 2
Fable 2 - 5
Fallout 2 - 1
F.E.A.R. 360 - 2
Final Fantasy III (DS) - 7
Final Fantasy V (GBA) - 1
Final Fantasy VI (GBA) - 1
Final Fantasy VIIre - 5
Final Fantasy VII: CC - 4
Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronices (DS) - 2
Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles (Rev) - 8
Final Fantasy XII (PS2) - 1
Final Fantasy XIII (PS3 or PS2) - 18
Fire Emblem (Rev) - 1
Forza 2 - 2
Gears of War - 20
Getaway, The (PS3) - 1
God Hand - 1
God of War 2 - 7
Golf Revolution - 1
Gothic 3 - 2
Gran Turismo PS3 - 7
Gran Turismo PSP - 1
GTA: Next - 4
Guitar Hero 2 - 1
Gumshoe Revolution - 1
Half-Life 3 - 1
Halo 3 - 38
Heavenly Sword - 14
Hellgate: London - 2
HL (PSP) - 3
Hot Shots Golf (PS3) - 1
Huxley - 2
Ice Climbers Revolution - 1
Id Game - 1
Jade Empire 2 - 1
Kid Icarus DS - 1
Kid Icarus Revolution - 1
Killer Instinct 3 - 1
Killzone PS3 - 9
Kojima/Suda51 Title - 4
Lair - 15
LA Noire - 3
Loco Roco - 2
Lost Odyssey - 6
Lost Planet - 2
Mach Rider Revolution - 1
Madden NFL 2007 - 1
Mario Paint (DS or Rev) - 2
Mass Effect - 28
Medal of Honor: Airborne - 3
Medieval: Total War - 1
Megaman ZX - 1
Metal Gear Solid 4 - 71
Metal Gear Solid PSP - 4
Metroid Dread (DS) - 2
Metroid Prime 3 - 40
M&M: Dark Messiah - 3
Mother 1+2 (English) - 2
Mother 3 (English) - 2
Motorstorm - 10
Naughty Dog Untitled PS3 - 4
NBA Live 2007 - 1
Neverwinter Nights 2 - 1
New Miyamoto IP (Rev) - 8
New Super Mario Bros. - 9
Ninja Gaiden 2 - 4
Nintey Nine Nights - 1
Okami - 3
Persona 3 - 1
Phantasy Star Universe - 3
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney DS 2 - 2
Pikmin 3 - 3
Pikmin DS - 1
Pilotwings Revolution - 2
Pokémon Diamond/Pearl - 6
Powerstone Collection (PSP) - 1
Prey 360 - 1
Project Assassin - 8
Quake Wars - 3
Rainbow Six: Vegas - 3
Ratchet & Clank 4 - 5
Rayman 4 - 5
Red Steel - 29
Resident Evil 5 - 41
Resistance: Fall of Man - 5
Return to Castle Wolfenstein 2 - 2
Rogue Galaxy - 1
Sadness - 1
Samurai Warriors 2 - 1
Shadowrun 360 - 11
ShenMue 3 - 1
Silent Hill V - 8
Silent Hill: Original Sin (PSP) - 3
Smackdown vs Raw 2007 - 1
SMT: Devil Summoner - 1
SOCOM PS3 - 1
Sonic Revolution - 1
Sonic Rush 2 - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog (PS3/360) - 4
Space Adventure Cobra (PS2) - 1
Splinter Cell: Double Agent - 2
Spore - 9
SquareEnix 360 MMORPG - 1
STALKER - 1
Starcraft II - 5
Star Wars (New Game) - 1
Stranglehold - 1
Super Mario Revolution - 47
Super Smash Bros. Rev - 22
Supreme Commander - 2
Tales of Rebirth - 1
Tales of the Abyss - 2
Tekken PS3 - 10
Tengai Makyou (series) - 1
Time Crisis 4 (PS2 or PS3) - 1
Titan Quest - 2
Tomb Raider 10th Anniversary - 1
Tomb Raider Legends 2 - 1
Too Human - 36
Trauma Center Revolution - 1
Twisted Metal (PSP or PS3) - 1
Ultimate Ghosts 'n Goblins - 1
Unreal Tournament 2007 - 1
Valkyrie Profile: Silmeria - 3
Vanguard - 1
Virtua Fighter V (console vers.) - 6
Viva Piñata - 4
Warhawk - 16
Wario Thief - 1
Wasteland Remake - 1
Waverace Revolution - 2
Winning Eleven NEXT-GEN - 2
Wipeout PS3 - 2
World in Conflict - 1
World of Starcraft - 2
World of Warcraft: Burning Crusade - 3
World of Warcraft (360) - 1
Yakuza - 5
Zelda: Phantom Hourglass - 22
Zelda: Twilight Princess - 43
Zone of Enders 3 - 4
Mod Note - Hope you don't mind, Speevy.
My list:
1) Too Human
2) Mass Effect
3) Bioshock
4) Halo 3
5) Metal Gear Solid 4
6) Ratchet and Clank 4
7) Lair
8) Animal Crossing Revolution
9) Super Smash Brothers Revolution
10) Super Mario Revolution
NEO-GAF TOP TEN (as of post #161)
1. Metal Gear Solid 4 - 71
2. Super Mario Revolution - 47
3. Zelda: Twilight Princess - 43
4. Resident Evil 5 - 41
5. Metroid Prime 3 - 40
6. Halo 3 - 38
7. Too Human - 36
8. Red Steel - 29
9. Mass Effect - 28
10. Super Smash Bros. Revolution - 23
AND MORE...
11. (TIE) Zelda: Phantom Hourglass - 22
11. (TIE) Devil May Cry 4 - 22
13. Gears of War - 20
14. Bioshock - 19
15. Final Fantasy XIII (PS3 or PS2) - 18
16. Warhawk - 16
17. Lair - 15
18. (TIE) Heavenly Sword - 14
18. (TIE) Blue Dragon - 14
20. (TIE) Killzone PS3 - 10
20. (TIE) Tekken PS3 - 10
20. (TIE) Motorstorm - 10
23. (TIE) Alan Wake - 9
23. (TIE) New Super Mario Bros. - 9
23. (TIE) Spore - 9
26. (TIE) Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles (Rev) - 8
26. (TIE) God of War 2 - 8
26. (TIE) New Miyamoto IP (Rev) - 8
26. (TIE) Project Assassin - 8
26. (TIE) Silent Hill V - 8
31. (TIE) Final Fantasy III (DS) - 7
31. (TIE) Gran Turismo PS3 - 7
33. (TIE) Lost Odyssey - 6
33. (TIE) Pokémon Diamond/Pearl - 6
33. (TIE) Virtua Fighter V (console vers.) - 6
36. (TIE) Crackdown - 5
36. (TIE) Fable 2 - 5
36. (TIE) Final Fantasy VIIre - 5
36. (TIE) Ratchet & Clank 4 - 5
36. (TIE) Rayman 4 - 5
36. (TIE) Resistance: Fall of Man - 5
36. (TIE) Starcraft II - 5
36. (TIE) Yakuza - 5
THE COMPLETE LIST IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER -
Ace Combat X (PSP) - 1
After Burner Climax - 2
Alan Wake - 9
Animal Crossing (Rev) - 1
Armored Core 4 - 1
ASH (DS) - 2
Balloon Fight Revolution - 1
Banjo-Threeie - 2
Baten Kaitos II - 1
Bioshock - 18
Blade Storm - 1
Blue Dragon - 14
Bob Ross Painting - 1
Brothers in Arms 3 - 4
Camelot RPG - 1
Capcom Puzzle Collection (PSP) - 1
Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin - 4
Cellfactor - 1
Children of Mana - 1
Cooking Revolution - 1
Crackdown - 5
Cry On - 2
Crysis - 2
Culdcept Saga - 1
Darkness, The (360/PS3) - 3
Dark Sector - 2
Dawn of War Expansion - 1
Dead or Alive: XVB2 - 3
Dead Rising - 1
Devil May Cry 4 - 22
Devil May Cry PSP - 1
Diablo III - 1
Donkey Kong Revolution - 1
Dragon Age - 3
Duke Nukem Forever (keep the hope alive) - 3
Ensemble RTS - 1
Every Extend Extra (PSP) - 2
Eyedentify - 2
Fable 2 - 5
Fallout 2 - 1
F.E.A.R. 360 - 2
Final Fantasy III (DS) - 7
Final Fantasy V (GBA) - 1
Final Fantasy VI (GBA) - 1
Final Fantasy VIIre - 5
Final Fantasy VII: CC - 4
Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronices (DS) - 2
Final Fantasy: Crystal Chronicles (Rev) - 8
Final Fantasy XII (PS2) - 1
Final Fantasy XIII (PS3 or PS2) - 18
Fire Emblem (Rev) - 1
Forza 2 - 2
Gears of War - 20
Getaway, The (PS3) - 1
God Hand - 1
God of War 2 - 7
Golf Revolution - 1
Gothic 3 - 2
Gran Turismo PS3 - 7
Gran Turismo PSP - 1
GTA: Next - 4
Guitar Hero 2 - 1
Gumshoe Revolution - 1
Half-Life 3 - 1
Halo 3 - 38
Heavenly Sword - 14
Hellgate: London - 2
HL (PSP) - 3
Hot Shots Golf (PS3) - 1
Huxley - 2
Ice Climbers Revolution - 1
Id Game - 1
Jade Empire 2 - 1
Kid Icarus DS - 1
Kid Icarus Revolution - 1
Killer Instinct 3 - 1
Killzone PS3 - 9
Kojima/Suda51 Title - 4
Lair - 15
LA Noire - 3
Loco Roco - 2
Lost Odyssey - 6
Lost Planet - 2
Mach Rider Revolution - 1
Madden NFL 2007 - 1
Mario Paint (DS or Rev) - 2
Mass Effect - 28
Medal of Honor: Airborne - 3
Medieval: Total War - 1
Megaman ZX - 1
Metal Gear Solid 4 - 71
Metal Gear Solid PSP - 4
Metroid Dread (DS) - 2
Metroid Prime 3 - 40
M&M: Dark Messiah - 3
Mother 1+2 (English) - 2
Mother 3 (English) - 2
Motorstorm - 10
Naughty Dog Untitled PS3 - 4
NBA Live 2007 - 1
Neverwinter Nights 2 - 1
New Miyamoto IP (Rev) - 8
New Super Mario Bros. - 9
Ninja Gaiden 2 - 4
Nintey Nine Nights - 1
Okami - 3
Persona 3 - 1
Phantasy Star Universe - 3
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney DS 2 - 2
Pikmin 3 - 3
Pikmin DS - 1
Pilotwings Revolution - 2
Pokémon Diamond/Pearl - 6
Powerstone Collection (PSP) - 1
Prey 360 - 1
Project Assassin - 8
Quake Wars - 3
Rainbow Six: Vegas - 3
Ratchet & Clank 4 - 5
Rayman 4 - 5
Red Steel - 29
Resident Evil 5 - 41
Resistance: Fall of Man - 5
Return to Castle Wolfenstein 2 - 2
Rogue Galaxy - 1
Sadness - 1
Samurai Warriors 2 - 1
Shadowrun 360 - 11
ShenMue 3 - 1
Silent Hill V - 8
Silent Hill: Original Sin (PSP) - 3
Smackdown vs Raw 2007 - 1
SMT: Devil Summoner - 1
SOCOM PS3 - 1
Sonic Revolution - 1
Sonic Rush 2 - 2
Sonic the Hedgehog (PS3/360) - 4
Space Adventure Cobra (PS2) - 1
Splinter Cell: Double Agent - 2
Spore - 9
SquareEnix 360 MMORPG - 1
STALKER - 1
Starcraft II - 5
Star Wars (New Game) - 1
Stranglehold - 1
Super Mario Revolution - 47
Super Smash Bros. Rev - 22
Supreme Commander - 2
Tales of Rebirth - 1
Tales of the Abyss - 2
Tekken PS3 - 10
Tengai Makyou (series) - 1
Time Crisis 4 (PS2 or PS3) - 1
Titan Quest - 2
Tomb Raider 10th Anniversary - 1
Tomb Raider Legends 2 - 1
Too Human - 36
Trauma Center Revolution - 1
Twisted Metal (PSP or PS3) - 1
Ultimate Ghosts 'n Goblins - 1
Unreal Tournament 2007 - 1
Valkyrie Profile: Silmeria - 3
Vanguard - 1
Virtua Fighter V (console vers.) - 6
Viva Piñata - 4
Warhawk - 16
Wario Thief - 1
Wasteland Remake - 1
Waverace Revolution - 2
Winning Eleven NEXT-GEN - 2
Wipeout PS3 - 2
World in Conflict - 1
World of Starcraft - 2
World of Warcraft: Burning Crusade - 3
World of Warcraft (360) - 1
Yakuza - 5
Zelda: Phantom Hourglass - 22
Zelda: Twilight Princess - 43
Zone of Enders 3 - 4
Mod Note - Hope you don't mind, Speevy.