• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

*UNMARKED SPOILERS ALL BOOKS* Game of Thrones |OT| - Season 4 - Sundays on HBO

Status
Not open for further replies.

Valhelm

contribute something
I'm still not sure Varys has any actual loyalty to Targaryens or Blackfyres. I think he's way more interested in the whole idea of creating a perfect king that he sort of detailed to Kevan in their final scene. Making his king a Targaryen is just the simplest way of giving him legitimacy in the eyes of the people. I don't think he really cares about it outside of that. What matters to Varys about Aegon isn't his blood, but that he was raised exactly how Varys wanted him to be raised.

Why does Varys want a strong, perfect king, though?
 

Speevy

Banned
Bran can get older on the show as long as it's believable that several years have passed since the first season, which it is.
 

Kerned

Banned
http://cdn.winteriscoming.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/thechildren2.jpg


Is there some special reason
Jojen
isn't in this pic, or is he just out of frame?

1755399246_paste_xlarge.jpeg
 

Iksenpets

Banned
http://cdn.winteriscoming.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/thechildren2.jpg


Is there some special reason
Jojen
isn't in this pic, or is he just out of frame?

Meera's probably looking back at him because he's sickly and has fallen behind.

Why does Varys want a strong, perfect king, though?

His whole "for the realm" thing just taken to its extreme. He watched Aerys throw the whole kingdom into turmoil only to be replaced by a blustering fool like Robert and decided he needed to upend the whole system, so he hatched a long term plan to do it. It's a crazy plan from a guy who's become way too convinced that he knows what's best, but it makes sense.

I just feel like making Varys, one of the few real free agents in the story who's really pursuing his own goals into someone who actually has strong loyalty to one side or another really undermines that character.
 

dubq

Member
Bran can get older on the show as long as it's believable that several years have passed since the first season, which it is.

Except Sansa was still 14 (the same age she was in the pilot) on her wedding day with Tyrion.. The showrunners really should've ignored even mentioning ages past the initial few episodes. It would've made the aging of the younger actors less jarring if we weren't constantly reminded of it.


http://cdn.winteriscoming.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/thechildren2.jpg


Is there some special reason
Jojen
isn't in this pic, or is he just out of frame?

Watch the trailer and you'll see where he is. :p
 
He looks waaaay to old know. It's been partially disguised by the face he never stands up but puberty really hit his actor like a slegehammer.

All of the children have aged across the show, it just implies that more time has passed than in the books. It's not a problem right now.
 

dubq

Member
All of the children have aged across the show, it just implies that more time has passed than in the books. It's not a problem right now.

Not really. Sansa tells Cersei that she is 14 in the pilot. Tyrion asks Sansa how old she is on their wedding night and she says 14. Not that much time has passed.

Not right now but if Bran ever ends up leaving that tree he'll have to be recast.

Doubtful.
 
Not right now but if Bran ever ends up leaving that tree he'll have to be recast.

Those magic tree nutrients will just have aged him.

Not really. Sansa tells Cersei that she is 14 in the pilot. Tyrion asks Sansa how old she is on their wedding night and she says 14. Not that much time has passed.
Well that's stupid of them to have mentioned that. Who would believe Sansa is still 14 anyway?
 

Valhelm

contribute something
She must not have realized that Book Tyrion was incredibly excited by the idea of sex with a thirteen-year-old virgin.
 
Well, even at the beginning of season 3, Jaime remarks to Brienne that he's been wearing the same boots for "almost a year" or something to that effect.

Haha, oh dear. That sounds like the timeline is a bit messed up if Sansa's 14 from the pilot until her wedding with Tyrion as well, then.

I'm just ignoring the show's sense of time. I don't like very condensed tv narratives unless a lot of effort is made to represent that, like 24 or something where it's part of the point. This show's been going for over 3 years so that's how long has passed as far as I'm concerned...
 

dubq

Member
Haha, oh dear. That sounds like the timeline is a bit messed up if Sansa's 14 from the pilot until her wedding with Tyrion as well, then.

I'm just ignoring the show's sense of time. I don't like very condensed tv narratives unless a lot of effort is made to represent that, like 24 or something where it's part of the point. This show's been going for over 3 years so that's how long has passed as far as I'm concerned...

Same here, I just try not to think about it! :)
 

Speevy

Banned
No one who watches the show believes that the war of the five kings lasted less than a year.

Robb Stark even remarks about how more than a year ago, his men had a purpose, but now they're just a band of bickering children.
 
A

A More Normal Bird

Unconfirmed Member
Not really. Sansa tells Cersei that she is 14 in the pilot. Tyrion asks Sansa how old she is on their wedding night and she says 14. Not that much time has passed.
She says she's 13 in the first episode, so her marriage to Tyrion could be anywhere from less than a year after to almost 2.
 

A-V-B

Member
Has anyone been reading the westeros forums?

Apparently a guy named Foody has seen the episode because he works for a media company or something. He's said some... really crazy stuff, but the descriptions have been pretty detailed.

He claims
in the battle with Brienne and the Hound, Arya kills Podrick. Also Tysha is completely left out of the episode, undoing years of buildup, and Tyrion kills Shae with his bare hands instead of the Chekov's gun golden chains.

And you don't see Stannis or anyone else from his side. Just his army charging in, and that's it.

REALLY hope this stuff isn't true. If it is, GoT goes from decent adaptation to Hollywood-level rewrites of "lol boring book material"
 
It would certainly cement the show as no longer even trying to follow the books anymore.

I think that's where they're going anyways. There's no way GRRM will be able to write the next few books in time, and they're not going to stop and wait. Might as well cut their losses and start building their own story. Maybe we can get a remake that fully follows the books in a few decades :/
 

A-V-B

Member
I think that's where they're going anyways. There's no way GRRM will be able to write the next few books in time, and they're not going to stop and wait. Might as well cut their losses and start building their own story. Maybe we can get a remake that fully follows the books in a few decades :/

Well, they adapted the Red Wedding. That's what they really wanted to do, right? Everything after that is... hey, the show's popular, let's keeping making episodes.
 

RatskyWatsky

Hunky Nostradamus
I think that's where they're going anyways. There's no way GRRM will be able to write the next few books in time, and they're not going to stop and wait. Might as well cut their losses and start building their own story. Maybe we can get a remake that fully follows the books in a few decades :/

Exactly.
 

A-V-B

Member
It's just, y'know, the reason this show's so popular in the first place is because Martin was and is such a great writer. The structure was all up to him, and the characters and what they decided to do and where it took them. Very consistent, made a lot of sense, made for fantastic drama.

If they go into full-on "thanks for everything GURM, it's our now" fan fiction mode, they're basically... they don't know the characters as well as Martin does to handle them without his guidance, and even if they did, they probably don't care that much about making these people act "truthfully." The technique they use for the show certainly seems less refined. As the seasons go by, things will make less and less sense, and characters will be doing weird things and they'll keep falling in that direction, and then suddenly it's not that great story anymore that got people hooked. Instead it's just an entity that has to exist because it's a huge television show and you have to keep doing things required by that structure. They'll create lesser material by a considerable margin.

I mean, I guess the audience is in for the long haul now, but you hope that long haul is worth the time watching it and won't cause the numbers to drop, and people to look back in the future and say, "that really fell apart in those last few years."
 
I mean, I guess the audience is in for the long haul now, but you hope that long haul is worth the time watching it and won't cause the numbers to drop, and people to look back in the future and say, "that really fell apart in those last few years."

You mean like all the book readers?
 
Martin certainly's had his snags, but I don't yet believe his story's entered an unstoppable slip into decay. It's just had to wind around a bit

No me either, but you have to admit we are in part just reading because we assume he is going somewhere with it all. Also Arya might do something cool.

In my eyes, this coming episode is the absolute peak of the series. Martin might well bring it all together, but I think I'll still struggle to care as much as I did during these events with these characters.

As such I'm pretty relaxed about where the TV show goes.
 
Has anyone been reading the westeros forums?

Apparently a guy named Foody has seen the episode because he works for a media company or something. He's said some... really crazy stuff, but the descriptions have been pretty detailed.

He claims
in the battle with Brienne and the Hound, Arya kills Podrick. Also Tysha is completely left out of the episode, undoing years of buildup, and Tyrion kills Shae with his bare hands instead of the Chekov's gun golden chains.

And you don't see Stannis or anyone else from his side. Just his army charging in, and that's it.

REALLY hope this stuff isn't true. If it is, GoT goes from decent adaptation to Hollywood-level rewrites of "lol boring book material"

Looks like a troll.
 
Has anyone been reading the westeros forums?

Apparently a guy named Foody has seen the episode because he works for a media company or something. He's said some... really crazy stuff, but the descriptions have been pretty detailed.

He claims
in the battle with Brienne and the Hound, Arya kills Podrick. Also Tysha is completely left out of the episode, undoing years of buildup, and Tyrion kills Shae with his bare hands instead of the Chekov's gun golden chains.

And you don't see Stannis or anyone else from his side. Just his army charging in, and that's it.

REALLY hope this stuff isn't true. If it is, GoT goes from decent adaptation to Hollywood-level rewrites of "lol boring book material"
What the fuck is this bullshit
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom