• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

"Guitar Hero Live" Announced

Majine

Banned
Well, good on them for trying something different rather than just bringing it back. Mildly more interested in this than RB4 as a result.
 

DOWN

Banned
AqOIa01.jpg
Oh my god is this just uncomfortable white people who work there?
 

co1onel

Member
So if I'm understanding this right, the notes will come down in 3 different columns and each note will either be black or white to indicate which row of buttons you press on the guitar? This sounds really bad.
 
Everybody was booing activision for trying to bring back GH at the same time harmonix was doing rock band and you know what, I am one of them. However, there's no stopping activision. They want a piece of everybody's pie.

This "first person" guitar thing is the best possible news because now rock band can do it's own thing (which we all want) and guitar hero can be whatever the hell this is trying to be.
 

ViciousDS

Banned
Everybody was booing activision for trying to bring back GH at the same time harmonix was doing rock band and you know what, I am one of them. However, there's no stopping activision. They want a piece of everybody's pie.

This "first person" guitar thing is the best possible news because now rock band can do it's own thing (which we all want) and guitar hero can be whatever the hell this is trying to be.

This almost seems like an excuse for Activision to kill the studio if it bombs. Alah EA style lol.

As long as rock band stays to the standard roots....it already wins in my book. I don't want to have to think while rocking out. Its a party game for crying out loud. People play it drunk.
 
This almost seems like an excuse for Activision to kill the studio if it bombs. Alah EA style lol.

As long as rock band stays to the standard roots....it already wins in my book. I don't want to have to think while rocking out. Its a party game for crying out loud. People play it drunk.

more of the same 6/10 - IGN
 

MCN

Banned
As long as rock band stays to the standard roots....it already wins in my book. I don't want to have to think while rocking out. Its a party game for crying out loud. People play it drunk.

You already have god knows how many games with that style, and more songs than you can shake a stick at. At least Activision are trying something new for a change instead of retreading the same old path that led to the genre losing popularity in the first place.
 
I'm guessing this will be similar to Rocksmith, but with one row for thick string notes and the other for thin string notes? Either 6x2 or 3x2 for notecharts. Hopefully the upcoming media will make this look more enjoyable than it sounds.

Black and white notes, maybe it will be like Beatmania.

Will there be iron sights and auto aim ?

And can you knife the notes for extra killstreaks?
 

ViciousDS

Banned
You already have god knows how many games with that style, and more songs than you can shake a stick at. At least Activision are trying something new for a change instead of retreading the same old path that led to the genre losing popularity in the first place.

With there history in the music genre they really could have made the ultimate teaching tool and just blow away rocksmith. But going different doesn't always mean better. I just want a current gen rock band. Along with my 2k songs.

This new guitar hero also throws out all past songs so they also can just resell it to you again (recharted) and make even more money by dlc.

Hopefully they have a legacy mode or something in the game.
 

FyreWulff

Member
One of my guesses for RB4 was they might go to two rows of frets in order to get closer to chord shapes. Interesting that GH is now doing that


Something different though. Will wait to see how it actually works in gameplay.

edit: the idea in that case is you would get bonus points for using the correct row of the fret but could keep combo if you at least hit the right color
 

killercow

Member
The word "live"... Why do I have the feeling that it will be hugely MP focused?

I don't think so. I just see it as a way to showcase their new perspective, putting you in front of the audience hence being immersed more. Something akin (while of course limited) to a live concert.
 

clockpunk

Member
I always did prefer the cartoonet OTT feel, story, and stages of the GH series. So long as I can use my old 360 guitar controller, I'm curious to see more! ^_^
 

FyreWulff

Member
I always did prefer the cartoonet OTT feel, story, and stages of the GH series. So long as I can use my old 360 guitar controller, I'm curious to see more! ^_^

if the two rows of frets thing is true, you're not going to be able to unless they have a 5-note fallback mode.
 

cyba89

Member
so I clearly say sounds and you argue that we havent seen it

It's just jumping to conclusions to declare it teribble two minutes after you heard about the game from a leak, with barely any real info.

Why not give them the benefit of doubt and let them try something new? (Or at least wait til the official announcement to dump on it)
We aready know we will get RB4 and we don't need two franchises doing the exact same thing like a couple of years ago.
 

Shiggy

Member
This almost seems like an excuse for Activision to kill the studio if it bombs. Alah EA style lol.

When DJ Hero 2 bombed, they gave them to Nintendo for a while to develop the infamous Sing Party. And if Nintendo doesn't want them, the studio can always work on Call of Duty. With GH: Live they gain experience with games from a first person perspective.
 

ViciousDS

Banned
When DJ Hero 2 bombed, they gave them to Nintendo for a while to develop the infamous Sing Party. And if Nintendo doesn't want them, the studio can always work on Call of Duty. With GH: Live they gain experience with games from a first person perspective.


hahaha thats so bad. queue drumroll on that one.
 

Salsa

Member
It's just jumping to conclusions to declare it teribble two minutes after you heard about the game from a leak, with barely any real info.

Why not give them the benefit of doubt and let them try something new? (Or at least wait til the official announcement to dump on it)
We aready know we will get RB4 and we don't need two franchises doing the exact same thing like a couple of years ago.


im saying that in my opinion whats being said sounds terrible

like, literally its there in the post. I never called the game terrible not talked about it in any way beyond my interpretation of the idea that comes to mind when thinking of first person guitar hero with less colored frets by dj hero people
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
Really need to see how they changed the note highway.

I expect that this means new hardware for their game anyway.
 
Freestyle games? All right I'm in. DJ Hero 1 and 2 were probably my favorite music rhythm games last gen.

Guitar Hero and Rock Band coming back head to head? I love it, it's like 2008 never ended.
 

Ok, but how exactly does that constitute as 'diarrhoea'? Those two bits of information, how is that enough information to say the game is 'diarrhoea'?

This game could be a total pile of crap when it releases, but I don't get how those tiny snippets of contextless info are enough to condemn it already,
 
Top Bottom