• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

COMICS! |OT| August 2016. That's Rare Groove. Volume is Crucial.

GAMEPROFF

Banned
Blown away how good ANAD Amazing is. And the look into the future is promising.

Next up are the female Spider-Books.

Feels good to be able to catch up.
 

TheFlow

Banned
Snotgirl #2


Honestly one of my favorite reads of the month.
Cute Girl is so fucking awesome, and slays me

I didn't think a book about fashion bloggers would be both interesting, and hilarious at the same time.

also the ending once again fucks with my mind
WTF! so who is texting snotgirl, is cool girl really dead, that cop is a boss
 

Hagi

Member
I hope it works. Lol.

I wouldn't be against this to be honest but that said I just started reading ANAD X-men and it's not bad. The Ghosts of Cyclops thing is dumb but I've come to terms with how shitty the direction they've gone with Scott is post Bendis.
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
Blown away how good ANAD Amazing is. And the look into the future is promising.

It's one I decided not to continue with when I jumped back into MU last week. It wasn't alone though.

I also stopped reading Invincible Iron Man, Nova, Spidey 2099, and Spider-Gwen.
 
It's one I decided not to continue with when I jumped back into MU last week. It wasn't alone though.

I also stopped reading Invincible Iron Man, Nova, Spidey 2099, and Spider-Gwen.

I bounced off of amazing and invincible iron too, I'm kind of interested if he's felt this way through out (nothing wrong with that of course) or if he feels it's jumped up at all.
 

TheFlow

Banned
Superman #4
this was some good shit, but I was hoping Jon would rekt.

Superman #5

Bruh! Batman showing everyone he is still the best
He got a batcave on the fucking Moon!

One of the best things about this issue was
Lois in the hellbat, and an inside view of the suit

the art is great in both issues

5/5 can't believe we got one more issue before this arc ends
 
New Doc Shaner art:
1yp2e.jpg
Looks like it connects to his Jon piece.
 
Bah, stuck in Skardu because my flight back to mainland Pakistan got delayed due to the weather.

And I'm pretty much out of comics to read that I have downloaded offline.

Feels bad.
 

Farside

Unconfirmed Member
Generation Zero #1 was awesome. I can't believe it's a Valiant book.

My local shop (which is my avatar pic BTW) only got one copy and I passed. I'll see if they can reorder it from Diamond. Knew I should have grabbed it.

8/31 List!
Black Panther trade
Saga #37
Avatarex #2
 
Bah, stuck in Skardu because my flight back to mainland Pakistan got delayed due to the weather.

And I'm pretty much out of comics to read that I have downloaded offline.

Feels bad.

Google LL3 on the Huffington post man, by josh dysart. 35 page short graphic novel, hosted for free on that website, really great, I wrote a thing about it last week so still have it on the mind haha should keep you occupied for awhile! (No need to download it, it's just there on the page)
 

TheFlow

Banned
Batman #4

I know a bunch of yah had issues with this one, but I liked it. Gotham is no batman or superman.

4/5

Batman #5

solid issue that kinda left me confused as it tried to explain Gotham's power and such.
so I guess Gotham girl and Duke get married in the far future?

4/5

2 more weeks before the conclusion.
 

Zombine

Banned
Snotgirl #2


Honestly one of my favorite reads of the month.
Cute Girl is so fucking awesome, and slays me

I didn't think a book about fashion bloggers would be both interesting, and hilarious at the same time.

also the ending once again fucks with my mind
WTF! so who is texting snotgirl, is cool girl really dead, that cop is a boss

I find a lot of the dialogue to suffer from Waid-itis. An old ass dude trying to emulate culture he doesn't really understand based on what he's seen, so it comes off as kind of stiff and unnatural, but I am still compelled by a majority of the elements in this book (including the art).

I think there is
more to this cool girl thing than we think. A part of me thinks she isn't dead and doesn't really exist, but is instead a manifestation of her "coolness" dying. She's more or less coming to terms with growing up and becoming irrelevant.

But we will see what happens.
 

GAMEPROFF

Banned
What issues of asm have you been reading/catching up on today?

It's one I decided not to continue with when I jumped back into MU last week. It wasn't alone though.

I also stopped reading Invincible Iron Man, Nova, Spidey 2099, and Spider-Gwen.


I have read booth Trades up to Issue 11.
I think it was quiete fun and even grew after the first arc IMO, which felt a little bit overstuffed with all that setup.

Compared to the books post Spider-Island its an insane hike in quality, even the dialogues arent that awful quippy as before.
 

jon bones

hot hot hanuman-on-man action
It's one I decided not to continue with when I jumped back into MU last week. It wasn't alone though.

I also stopped reading Invincible Iron Man, Nova, Spidey 2099, and Spider-Gwen.

I bounced off of amazing and invincible iron too, I'm kind of interested if he's felt this way through out (nothing wrong with that of course) or if he feels it's jumped up at all.

i treat IIM as a Riri prequel so i'm still in
 
Google LL3 on the Huffington post man, by josh dysart. 35 page short graphic novel, hosted for free on that website, really great, I wrote a thing about it last week so still have it on the mind haha should keep you occupied for awhile! (No need to download it, it's just there on the page)

Thanks! Let's hope it loads on this Internet lol.
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
I have read booth Trades up to Issue 11.
I think it was quiete fun and even grew after the first arc IMO, which felt a little bit overstuffed with all that setup.

Compared to the books post Spider-Island its an insane hike in quality, even the dialogues arent that awful quippy as before.

Luckily I haven't read anything that came before. Sounds miserable.

i treat IIM as a Riri prequel so i'm still in

Yeah I won't be reading her version either.
 
I find a lot of the dialogue to suffer from Waid-itis. An old ass dude trying to emulate culture he doesn't really understand based on what he's seen, so it comes off as kind of stiff and unnatural, but I am still compelled by a majority of the elements in this book (including the art).

I... don't agree at all. O'Malley is pretty active on Tumblr/Twitter so it's not like this is all something he has no experience with. He's throwing in common acronyms used by fashion bloggers like OOTD which would leave most people scratching their head. The comments on the instagram stuff or text messages conversations all come across as pretty genuine too. That IS how a lot of fashion bloggers talk online.

You could definitely say Batgirl comes across as awkward in this regard, but this one's pretty damn accurate.
 

Hagi

Member
i treat IIM as a Riri prequel so i'm still in

I'm sceptical whether Bendis will be able to make the book interesting with her but I'll probably check it out all the same. I liked the first few issues of IIM but I steadily lost interest when Marquez left, a shame really.
 

Zombine

Banned
That IS how a lot of fashion bloggers talk online.

I'm sure that vapid fashion bloggers exist in real life, I've just never heard a 20-something girl talk like this(Coming from a 20-something year old dude who hangs out with 20-something year old girls). It reads like a man writing what he thinks women talk about IRL than how women actually speak. He's channeling Heathers/Clueless more than a female writer would approach the material.

So yeah, talking online...sure I guess.
 
I'm sure that vapid fashion bloggers exist in real life, I've just never heard a 20-something girl talk like this(Coming from a 20-something year old dude who hangs out with 20-something year old girls). It reads like a man writing what he thinks women talk about IRL than how women actually speak. He's channeling Heathers/Clueless more than a female writer would approach the material.

So yeah, talking online...sure I guess.

Did you like Scott Pilgrim? I mean, this

I find a lot of the dialogue to suffer from Waid-itis. An old ass dude trying to emulate culture he doesn't really understand based on what he's seen, so it comes off as kind of stiff and unnatural, but I am still compelled by a majority of the elements in this book (including the art).

was one of the problems I had with his previous books too.
 
I'm just done with Bendis in general. He's been put on the list.

Haha I feel like I've said this so many times since daredevil and alias, which are genuinely fantastic runs, but I'm going to give him another chance with jessica jones and honestly, probably iron doom too, even though that one I'm more skeptical with. Jessica jones with Gaydos is exactly his wheelhouse and what he excels at. I love him with Maleev too, although as mentioned, I can see myself being burned. I liked his original new avengers run well enough up to, and have a particular soft spot for secret invasion. I just think it's a really neat idea, but have been quite cold with him since.

If he really can't make it work with jessica a jones then, ouch.
 

Hagi

Member
I really liked his run on Uncanny and that only ended last year. I don't really have a list of writers I wont touch, I don't expect to like everything someone writes. He has enough good will from me that he can write duds for the rest of his career and I'll be fine.
 
I really liked his run on Uncanny and that only ended last year. I don't really have a list of writers I wont touch, I don't expect to like everything someone writes. He has enough good will from me that he can write duds for the rest of his career and I'll be fine.

Haha I guess I'm fussier than you man. I have a fairly defined list of writers in my head that I just know there's no point in me reading, I'll need be satisfied. I really can't just read something because it has a character I like, I need an engaging writing style, I need one that's not full of exposition, I need character development more than plot as a general rule of thumb, but i also need to come away with something after a trade wait.

Pacing, I think I'm more forgiving of something slow paced in other mediums if its building character as it goes, like I'd say breaking bad was quote slow paced at times but the characters were so good, the main plot could be abandoned if it liked. With comics, price to issue ratio in trades has gotten alot tighter with the big two so it ends up playing a big factor. I can't spend £12 on a 4-5 issue trade and wait another 6 months with nothing having happened haha. Not when there's so many books I want.

Specifically of bendis' uncanny run, I think if I'd have waited til it was all done, and grabbed the whole thing , uncanny and all new, I'd have enjoyed it more, but as it was it kind of annoyed me and I ended dup dropping off after about 2,3 volumes of each.
 
Isn't Snotgirl/Lottie in her late 20s? Like 27? I forgot but the book makes it clear they are close to being grown adults. Same for her "friends".
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
I really liked his run on Uncanny and that only ended last year. I don't really have a list of writers I wont touch, I don't expect to like everything someone writes. He has enough good will from me that he can write duds for the rest of his career and I'll be fine.

I do and it includes artists too.
 
I'm sure that vapid fashion bloggers exist in real life, I've just never heard a 20-something girl talk like this(Coming from a 20-something year old dude who hangs out with 20-something year old girls). It reads like a man writing what he thinks women talk about IRL than how women actually speak. He's channeling Heathers/Clueless more than a female writer would approach the material.

So yeah, talking online...sure I guess.

I can only speak for myself, but I've heard plenty of women (ranging from coworkers to my own family) in their mid-to-late 20s use phrases like the ones used here. I don't think it's out of touch at all.
 

Boogiepop

Member
Went in for the GSC exclusive version, eh?

Yup! I also have bought way too many Links, it's like some sort of weak spot for me. Already have the Skyward Sword figma and the Majora's Mask and Wind Waker nendoroids. And then there's the amiibo I have... At least I THINK I'll be able to pass on the Twilight Princess one, since I'm kind of eh on that design.

Also, like 7-8 chapters into 52 now, and I'm really enjoying it! I had heard that it did multiple story lines, but I was expecting it to be the sort of thing where it alternated plot lines each issue. But instead it's just a ton of bite-sized bits each time around, which is creating a really interesting pacing, but certainly not one I dislike. Bonus points to the fact that it's both providing a followup to Renee's storyline from Gotham Central and a solid Booster Gold story, both of which are things I really wanted.
 
I really like this quote from Kirby:

"I taught myself how to draw, and I soon found out it was what I really wanted to do. I didn’t think I was going to create any great masterpieces like Rembrandt or Gauguin. I thought comics was a common form of art and strictly American in my estimation because America was the home of the common man, and show me the common man that can’t do a comic. So comics is an American form of art that anyone can do with a pencil and paper."
 

Owzers

Member
I really like this quote from Kirby:

"I taught myself how to draw, and I soon found out it was what I really wanted to do. I didn’t think I was going to create any great masterpieces like Rembrandt or Gauguin. I thought comics was a common form of art and strictly American in my estimation because America was the home of the common man, and show me the common man that can’t do a comic. So comics is an American form of art that anyone can do with a pencil and paper."

This does not sound like American exceptionalism.
 

dan2026

Member
Wasn't Kirby at one point drawing (and probably writing) four or five books a month?

The guy was a comic making machine.

Edeit: Perhaps thats an overestimation. But still.
 

frye

Member
I really like this quote from Kirby:

"I taught myself how to draw, and I soon found out it was what I really wanted to do. I didn’t think I was going to create any great masterpieces like Rembrandt or Gauguin. I thought comics was a common form of art and strictly American in my estimation because America was the home of the common man, and show me the common man that can’t do a comic. So comics is an American form of art that anyone can do with a pencil and paper."

THE KING
 
Chuck Dixon's Robin is sick. Tim Drake's my boy. KGBeast is terrifying. And I did not know Helena Bertenelli was a teacher for her profession. I always thought she was Huntress full time, living off of her family's fortune
I hope it works. Lol.
Well it's not. At least for awhile. Thanks Mark Waid.
 
Still slowly making my way through Walt Simonson's Thor run, really good stuff. Balder might be my new favorite character. People say they like the initial run with Surtur, but I think it's gotten even more interesting. At the point with frog thor.

Was looking at picking up some current Marvel Trades. Is Aaron's current run on Thor good?
 

tim1138

Member
Wasn't Kirby at one point drawing (and probably writing) four or five books a month?

The guy was a comic making machine.

Edeit: Perhaps thats an overestimation. But still.

He was insanely prolific

Yes, but I think his pace gets exaggerated a bit for two reasons. One was that Jack worked very hard. During the late sixties and seventies, he did around fifteen pages per week of finished pencils (and, usually, script) and before that, he was even more prolific, occasionally managing 5-6 pages a day. Now, that is very fast — someone like Curt Swan might do two a day — but Kirby's output was a function not just of drawing speed but of endurance and a willingness to sit at the drawing board 10-16 hours a day. Some artists simply couldn't put in hours like that. And the other thing that perhaps made Jack appear faster than he was was that he did almost no planning. This is why you see very few Kirby rough sketches around. If they called Jack and said, "We need a cover," he would just sit down and start drawing a cover. Some of his best work was done with that kind of instant improvisation. But, yes, he was fast.

And I love the bolded bit about not planning anything out
 

jon bones

hot hot hanuman-on-man action
Jack Kirby's cosmic work is timeless... makes me want a Celestial tattoo.

Still slowly making my way through Walt Simonson's Thor run, really good stuff. Balder might be my new favorite character. People say they like the initial run with Surtur, but I think it's gotten even more interesting. At the point with frog thor.

Was looking at picking up some current Marvel Trades. Is Aaron's current run on Thor good?

Yes, get Aaron's Thor HC (contains issues 1-11 or 12) and bask in it's glory.

I need to pick up an old Thor run and read it. Need me some classic Asgard.
 
mjqbsje.gif



@Schweinehund: Havent you bought the Odinson Series in OHCs? Female Thor is getting one in the next couple of months, too.

so far I have Aaron's Odinson Run (1 HC, 2 TP's), Straczynski's (4 tp's I think), Siege + Prelude to siege. I'll check Femthor's when hers comes out, probably with some rebirth trades.
 
Top Bottom