• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The retail apocalypse has officially descended on America

Status
Not open for further replies.
So why is Amazon planning to open b&m stores again?

I can see the Amazon stores being ike the Argos stores in the UK. Basically, the store floor is just a showroom for selected items and they have a catalogue for the whole range. You fill in a small form with the code numbers of the products you want to buy and go to pay for them at the register. You are given a ticket number and told to wait at the collection desk which is at the front of a warehouse and they pick the item you brought.

I guess all Amazon will do is add a delivery option to that as well as store pickup.
 
I wonder what happens to suburbia?

More restuarants since those don't compete with Amazon.

We really need to invest more in public parks.

Suburbia is already a wasteland.

I drive on one of the busiest non highways in my state every day, half the buildings have been empty for years despite constant eyes/potential customers.
 

jstripes

Banned
I can see the Amazon stores being ike the Argos stores in the UK. Basically, the store floor is just a showroom for selected items and they have a catalogue for the whole range. You fill in a small form with the code numbers of the products you want to buy and go to pay for them at the register. You are given a ticket number and told to wait at the collection desk which is at the front of a warehouse and they pick the item you brought.

I guess all Amazon will do is add a delivery option to that as well as store pickup.

We had that concept in Canada. The store was called Consumers Distributing. It died with the '80s. Good riddance.
 

kirblar

Member
Wtf, that looks like any mall today in Canada.
Canada's a lot more urbanized than the US because of the cold weather. Malls in urban areas are still doing fine, lots are still open and thriving, it's the smaller ones on the outskirts that are in trouble.
 
Yeah have you seen Gamestop earnings? Plus they announced 150 store closings, didn't see it in the OP - http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2017/03/24/gamestop-video-game-stores/99573598/

Regarding the digitization of consumer media, I'd expect Barnes & Nobles to go belly up before Gamestop. And after googling it I found that B&N once owned Gamestop stock aha, those were their glory days - https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB109690743684435414

I think if anything kills B&N it will be the massive square footage they have to pay for each month. Physical books still have appeal - far more than games do, I would argue, and they're the only place around to buy them locally.
 

tmarg

Member
Some of the malls that have closed in Southern California in the past few years are incredibly sad. The ones barely still open are weird marketplaces that I wouldn't want to spend more than a few minutes in.

Beyond the loss of income for stores and the options for shoppers, I'm most sad about the lack of a place for young people to gather and be social. The end of gathering places will only push more kids into the digital meeting space, which is a poor replacement.

Retail has never been a good place for young people to gather, and it hasn't been a popular one in a long time. By the time I graduated from highschool in 2002, "hanging out at the mall" was already becoming passe.
 
Being in malls used to be awesome growing up in a small town because you got to see a selection of things that weren't available most days of the week. Now I can just order something online with more of a selection and have it come to me for cheaper.

I also associate Christmas time with going to the mall to see Santa and the general christmas bustling.
 
Surprised to find that I had a dead mall in my backyard. The Sears, Walmart, Kohls and various outdoor strip mall buildings used to be one giant mall wad that closed, demolished and renovated in 2008. Second enclosed mall in Michigan. Weird.

It's all thriving now except for the Sears. I was wondering why Sears looked so old and dingy.
 

Paracelsus

Member
The trouble with evolving industries is that people assume the jobs won't change, they'll just apply in some awkward way to the new industry, and use that as a proof for why the world as they know it is going down the shitter.

In 1962 before super markets opened where you picked your own products off of a shelf, I'd imagine someone would protest "but what will the grocery boys do who take your bags to your car, follow you around the store???" And yet, here we are today and society persists. And now we're protesting that stop and shop Peapod or Amazon Local or what have you is automating or replacing the person who bags your groceries or scans an item. 65 years ago, the person protesting taking your own groceries off the shelf couldn't consider the idea of someone scanning a barcode.

Times change, jobs adapt.

Yes, but they can only adapt for so long. Moving from a farm to a factory/plant or a construction site is merely arguing semantics: you were a worker and you still are.

Also, in 1960 we were 3 billion individuals with quite a few industry shifts left, now we are 7.5 and there is not a single major shift left hiring in the millions like construction and factories.
 

Yeah, as someone who almost exclusively shopped at BestBuy for games/electronics for the past few years (I've recently let my GCU expire tho), I can tell you they're doing a lot better now than they were a decade ago.
They adapted, got aggressive with things like on-the-spot price matching (IE you don't have to walk to Customer Service like in say, Target) and they're still relatively everywhere.
Honestly, they're still a legit store and my BestBuy CC has treated my family and I, VERY well
 

matt05891

Member
I think if anything kills B&N it will be the massive square footage they have to pay for each month. Physical books still have appeal - far more than games do, I would argue, and they're the only place around to buy them locally.
Highly agree. To me physical games lost value the moment I realized I had to install it. Plus with all the DRM coming into play there is no point to have it physical if they decide to shut off the servers anyway (with some games right now) you lose it just as much as the dude with a digital copy. So in saying that the only time I ever entered a gamestop in the past 4-5 years was to pick up an Xbox One and a 3DS.

However I still enjoy book stores. Even if all you do is grab a coffee inside and read a book in there it's relaxing. My girlfriend and I do this when we spend a weekend in the nearby city. I think we would see a belly up from gamestop before B&N personally based on the amount of people I see in the gamestops when passing by versus B&N.
 

Kerensky

Banned
Those unaffected won't care because they saved money buying online. They might start caring though when their future kids have nowhere to work.

Interesting way of seeing this, like an inversed keynesianism, A lot of people however have taken to a leaner lifestyle out of necessity rather than malice.

Infinite Economical growth and infinite hyperconsumerism is simply not an attainable ideal, and the recent american generations should count their blessings that their economic shrinkage has never gone as bad as, say the beginning of the last century.

Personally i work and maintain my possessions until they break, and then i repair them or make them do something else. I also buy a lot of things second-hand if i can, allows me to create a nice disaster fund.
 

Lkr

Member
Retail is alright sometimes but mainly blows. Amazon delivered my switch preorder a day late despite having a preorder from the second they went up. Meanwhile I was able to get in line at target 2 hours before the store opened and purchased one. Not gonna lie it sucked (I'm not British, I don't have patience to stand around in a line) but at least I got it.
Winner: target

I ran out of protein powder and ordered more on Amazon Friday afternoon. It arrived in the mail yesterday.
Winner : Amazon

You can't beat the convenience. Although Best Buy has done a good job at adapting since the recession. I went in there to play with some demo units before making a decision on some Sony Bluetooth headphones they had. In the past I would check a store model and order on Amazon on my phone before even leaving the store. Now Best Buy will match literally any reputable online retailer if you show it to them. Any cashier can do it. Another thing I preferred about Amazon was that I could return it and get a full refund. These are headphones and I'm very picky. Best Buy allows 15 day refund for literally any reason and no restocking fees.


Anyway I live in Florida, I think our malls will be alright unless Trump completely kills foreign tourism
 

Bubba T

Member
Minnesotans love to shop in person. It's in our DNA. Our many large malls in the Twin Cities are doing pretty well. It's mid-small level malls, downtown shopping, and stand alone big box retailers that are suffering around here.

We have the Mall of America where occupancy has always been near 100%, foot traffic has always been stellar, and 20% of visitors are NOT from Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, the Dakotas, Illinois, Ohio, or Canada. Originally it was feared it would kill neighboring malls, but...

Every other large Mall also does well including one not too far from MOA (Southdale Mall) which is a large and has many of the same stores. Somehow it even does extremely well.

Mall of America is a destination. It has what most malls don't: Two hotels, an amusement park, an underwater park, and go karts. It also has been adding more restaurants. It's been adapting to changing consumer tastes for years now by adding these attractions and it's helped keep it relevant.

The other major malls in the area (Southdale, Rosedale, Maplewood) have also been adapting by adding more restaurants and other attractions and less retail shopping. Even the old Brookdale (Shingle Creek Crossing now) has been adapting by adding more than just retail to attact people. It's a changing trend, but it seems that's what you have to do to stay relevant these days.
 

Quonny

Member
Outdoor malls are becoming a big thing now. It seems there's always one popping up within an hour of me in any direction.
 

Xdrive05

Member
Kmart still exists!? Wow.

These companies should've welcomed their Amazon overlords while they still had a chance to get some leniency.
 

Timedog

good credit (by proxy)
Too bad, I only shop at Walgreens and rite aid and CVS if they're all 3 on the same block, so I can compare prices on each item. Might have to find a different system.
 

Xdrive05

Member
strip malls arranged to look like a town square

here's one in our area

https://goo.gl/maps/9wVp8XDMSuT2

there's a couple more and they're literally ctrl c ctrl v of each other in layout

We have one of those in a suburb of Indianapolis. They set it up to look like a little city, with it's own grid of roads and traffic signals, etc. It's kind of an oddly realized Phillip K. Dick dystopian view of the future of consumerism.

I don't see this as a winning strategy for survival against​ convenience technology.
 

fallout

Member
Finally a center for my lifestyle.
himZD0M.gif
 
Maybe it's me, but I love retail stores. Not to shop, unless there is something I like but it gave people of my generation a reason to just go out. Mallrat culture if you will.

Last year we lost our Hastings, it went from a bookshop/movie/game rental store to a niche hobbyist/nerd culture/music/book place. Our town is smallish, and that was basically our last bookstore. It was one of those places where you can go "See? Our town isn't just for dumb trailer trash and country yuppies!"
 

slit

Member
Yes I guess I am. Short term gain.

People are doing what makes the most sense for them. To expect otherwise is silly. Consumer spending isn't a charity event used to prop up industry that can't handle the competition. When manufacturing like steel making and other heavy industry started massively leaving the U.S. in the 70's/80's for cheaper manufacturers overseas and threw countless people out of work you didn't see many people doing much to stop it but the country somehow survived.
 

bionic77

Member
More jobs lost for people without degrees or education.

Our governments should be doing something to help these people out. Instead we are turning to fascist assholes who are just going to use brown people and immigration as scapegoats.

I am sure this will all end well...
 

Magwik

Banned
More jobs lost for people without degrees or education.

Our governments should be doing something to help these people out. Instead we are turning to fascist assholes who are just going to use brown people and immigration as scapegoats.

I am sure this will all end well...
There's a good chance a lot of them have a degree or an education.
 

stilgar

Member
Some elevator music composers are gonna feel the heat.


Lucky for them, the great elevator crisis is not yet upon us.
 

GhaleonEB

Member
strip malls arranged to look like a town square

here's one in our area

https://goo.gl/maps/9wVp8XDMSuT2

there's a couple more and they're literally ctrl c ctrl v of each other in layout

We have one of those in a suburb of Indianapolis. They set it up to look like a little city, with it's own grid of roads and traffic signals, etc. It's kind of an oddly realized Phillip K. Dick dystopian view of the future of consumerism.

I don't see this as a winning strategy for survival against​ convenience technology.

We have a few of those as well (in the towns just outside of Portland). Around here they're mostly niche or boutique shops catering to upper incomes, dotted with popular restaurants like Chipotle. Upper middle income people shop there, lower incomes come for a burrito and to go look in stores they can't afford. It actually seems like a sustainable business model depending on location and economy. The shops don't cater to things their target audience will order online.
 

Finn

Member
We had that concept in Canada. The store was called Consumers Distributing. It died with the '80s. Good riddance.
We also had that concept in the US in the 80s and 90s called Service Merchandise. Watching the stuff you ordered come out on a conveyor belt was super exciting as a kid.

On topic? How do people order shoes and clothes online? I mean, I do it occasionally but I prefer to try things on before I buy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom