• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Better Call Saul S3 |OT| Gus Who's Back - Mondays 10/9c on AMC

Amazing cinematography once again. Especially loved when Chuck was talking to his lawyer in the darkened room, with the sun shining directly on him like some kind of "holier than thou" being. Perfect.

What I didn't like though was the Andrea and Brock cameo...Brock must have only been like 6 years old in Breaking Bad so he probably wouldn't even be born in the canon of this show, and if he was he'd be a baby.

I didn't think that was them, but I did wonder.

Also, how firm is the timeline that this is 6 years before BB? Because at the rate time is passing, it could be just a year or two. Would explain Katie's age as well.
 

Veelk

Banned
You've misread either me or the quote from the interview.

What I'm saying, and what I think Vince is saying:

Chuck's Delusion: I'm a dutiful brother and lawyer, and I will hurt Jimmy to help him in the end.
Chuck's Reality: I'm a resentful brother and lawyer, and I will destroy Jimmy for presuming to invade my domain.
Well, I reread the quote, and I don't get that at all.

Vince is saying that if Chuck were more honest with himself, he'd admit that he's doing this to hurt Jimmy. And that's basically what I said as well. He is doing this to hurt Jimmy. But he's also doing this because he believes it's the right path to take. That Jimmy will be better for having to work within the law. What I'm saying is:

Chuck's Delusion: I have no unnecessarily negative feelings to Jimmy and do everything out of a moral duty and brotherly love.
Chuck's Reality: I have many negative feelings toward Jimmy, including resentment and bitterness, and I try to do what I honestly believe is right, while unaware that my negative feelings skew and poison my perception of what that is.
 

hobozero

Member
So does the sun not bother Chuck anymore? When he was talking to Jimmy on the curb, he seemed fine.

Was never the sun that bothered him, rather the EM radiation from power lines, etc. (also, its completely psychosomatic).

I think if you look back at previous seasons, Chuck's symptoms are lessened whenever he feels he is in a position of power or authority over his brother, and worse when his brother is doing anything that might affect Chuck's reputation.

Symptoms less:
- taking away Mesa Verde
- keeping Jimmy off the Sand Piper case
- being outside waiting on cops

Symptoms Worse:
- stealing neighbors paper and finding out about Jimmy's billboard stunt

etc. I think it goes along with Chuck's obsession with Jimmy as the source of his ailment. His irrational blaming of Jimmy, his inferiority to Jimmy socially 9people like Jimmy more) and so on.
 
No! If you've read the thread and reviews, most fans of the show love the slow pace. I love trying to figure out what Mike is up to before it's shown to us. Better Call Saul is a perfect example of showing and not telling. I hope the show runners don't listen to those saying the show needs to move at a faster pace.
I have no problems with the slow pace of the show, but on the other hand I do expect it to ramp up significantly at some point in the not so distant future.
 

Veelk

Banned
Was never the sun that bothered him, rather the EM radiation from power lines, etc. (also, its completely psychosomatic).

I think if you look back at previous seasons, Chuck's symptoms are lessened whenever he feels he is in a position of power or authority over his brother, and worse when his brother is doing anything that might affect Chuck's reputation.

Symptoms less:
- taking away Mesa Verde
- keeping Jimmy off the Sand Piper case
- being outside waiting on cops

Symptoms Worse:
- stealing neighbors paper and finding out about Jimmy's billboard stunt

etc. I think it goes along with Chuck's obsession with Jimmy as the source of his ailment. His irrational blaming of Jimmy, his inferiority to Jimmy socially 9people like Jimmy more) and so on.

Not just Jimmy, but also the ability to do his job. His single strongest instance of aversion to his allergy is when he and Jimmy were closely working together on the Sandpiper case and he just casually walks outside to Jimmy's car without even noticing what he's doing.

I think it's more that he gains strength from being a lawyer, and since he views it as his lawyerly duty to stop Jimmy from wreaking havok, he gets fulfilled from taking him down whenever he feels he's done something wrong.
 
- another Kim montages! catchy music and visual style reminds me of Hot Fuzz.
- the opening scene is a flash forward to some point during Breaking Bad, but before the end of S4. Those worn out shoes are the same ones we see Mike throws onto the wire. We know that Gus will take over operations in New Mexico for the cartel since Hector gets confined to a wheelchair prior to BB.
- that foreshadowing from Jimmy.
- the doctor is the same one from Breaking Bad who saved Gus and Mike in the mobile tent after poisoning the Cartel.
- we finally get to see Mike fire his rifle.
- obligatory FUCK CHUCK

Holy shit!
 

Niraj

I shot people I like more for less.
I do have to wonder *why* Ernie goes to bat for Jimmy. Does he have full knowledge of the way Chuck screwed Jimmy over? Or has Jimmy just charmed him? I have been assuming the former.

In the season 2 finale, Jimmy asks him why he lied about calling him to the copy store, and Ernesto says something close to, "I didn't want to say anything, but the way he's been talking about you lately...it's like he's really out to get you. And I don't know, you're my friend." So it's a mixture of affection for Jimmy and being unsettled by Chuck's seemingly unhealthy obsession with Jimmy. We don't know specifically what he had heard, but it's probably not hard to hazard a guess or two.
 
In the season 2 finale, Jimmy asks him why he lied about calling him to the copy store, and Ernesto says something close to, "I didn't want to say anything, but the way he's been talking about you lately...it's like he's really out to get you. And I don't know, you're my friend." So it's a mixture of affection for Jimmy and being unsettled by Chuck's seemingly unhealthy obsession with Jimmy. We don't know specifically what he had heard, but it's probably not hard to hazard a guess or two.

So, Chuck's own obsession led to his failure to nail Jimmy. Nice touch.
 

jose 5171

Neo Member
Well, I reread the quote, and I don't get that at all.

Vince is saying that if Chuck were more honest with himself, he'd admit that he's doing this to hurt Jimmy. And that's basically what I said as well. He is doing this to hurt Jimmy. But he's also doing this because he believes it's the right path to take. That Jimmy will be better for having to work within the law. What I'm saying is:

Chuck's Delusion: I have no unnecessarily negative feelings to Jimmy and do everything out of a moral duty and brotherly love.
Chuck's Reality: I have many negative feelings toward Jimmy, including resentment and bitterness, and I try to do what I honestly believe is right, while unaware that my negative feelings skew and poison my perception of what that is.

I don't understand why you make such a big deal about Chuck believing that he's doing the right thing. When considering the most reprehensible people in history, it doesn't matter whether they thought they were doing the right thing or not, it doesn't change anything, and no one cares.
 

HardRojo

Member
- another Kim montages! catchy music and visual style reminds me of Hot Fuzz.
- the opening scene is a flash forward to some point during Breaking Bad, but before the end of S4. Those worn out shoes are the same ones we see Mike throws onto the wire. We know that Gus will take over operations in New Mexico for the cartel since Hector gets confined to a wheelchair prior to BB.
- that foreshadowing from Jimmy.
- the doctor is the same one from Breaking Bad who saved Gus and Mike in the mobile tent after poisoning the Cartel.
- we finally get to see Mike fire his rifle.
- obligatory FUCK CHUCK
This fucking show. It makes me sad that it takes someone pointing things out for me to pick up on some callbacks and references :( They do a great job at those.
 

Apoc29

Member
Did they waste their one F-bomb for the season on a simple "I fucked up"? Gilligan's usually good at making it count. Well, maybe they wrote the season without a use for it and just threw it in this episode to get it out there.
 
Am I crazy for feeling like people are applying some double standards when they condemn Chuck but are basically okay with Jimmy betraying his trust by breaking into his house and messing with the files (and thus, his head)? Chuck definitely harbors lots of resentment towards Jimmy, but the way he's seen Jimmy grow up, all the way back to him being the only one who knew Jimmy was stealing from their father, it's understandable. All his life, he's seen Jimmy charm everyone, while he sees his true colors. And he's right about Jimmy not being an honest lawyer too. So keeping him out of HHM, I get that. I disagree that he's the villain of the piece. He's against the protagonist, and audiences are trained to root for the protagonist (look no further than the Walter White fandom for proof of how far that goes. Unless you kill puppies and babies, people will root for you.), but Jimmy has done far more fucked up things than Chuck imo. Jimmy never thinks about who his actions might hurt. He's an egocentric sleazeball.
 

SpaceWolf

Banned
"I caught my second wife screwing my step dad, it's a cruel world, grow up!"
Saul Goodman, Breaking Bad.

If taken at face value, I've got a feeling this line is going to prove troublesome for the writers later down the line.
 
"I caught my second wife screwing my step dad, it's a cruel world, grow up!"
Saul Goodman, Breaking Bad.

If taken at face value, I've got a feeling this line is going to prove troublesome for the writers later down the line.

Unless they just ignore it, or treat it as Saul using poetic license
 

Corpekata

Banned
I'd imagine the show isn't going to last long enough for him to get married twice and will likely leave that sort of thing as something that happens between BCS and BB. At least I'd imagine the show ends when Jimmy goes full Saul and from what we can tell in BB he's been kind of a long time staple of the area.

Especially when you add in the age of MckEan and Odenkirk. They'd have to get the world's hottest octogenarion for that story.
 
That would be a very strange (and weirdly specific!) use of poetic license.

Saul was already crooked; uttering a falsehood to make a point wouldn't exactly be that out of character.

Certainly seems far more likely than having him get married and divorced twice within the next few years
 

Grizzlyjin

Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
I could see that as Saul being folksy. Although, isn't Jimmy in his late 30s/early 40s, at least? Be surprised if he doesn't have at least 1 marriage under his belt from his younger days.
 

Alpende

Member
I really liked the episode. Seeing Mike's plan unfold was great, really digging the fact that they're giving Mike plenty of screen time. Cool to see Tyreese too.
 

Mr. Tibbs

Member
Chuck, Kim, and Jimmy are my three favorite characters on TV. I was initially bummed out last season when the latter two hooked up, as I loved the ambiguity of their relationship, but any show that describes love as "the fallacy of sunk costs" is aces in my book.

There have been some wonderful moments as these two flawed brothers are blinded by their frustrations with each other, but still bound by some mixture of duty to family and brotherly love. They seem to each know each other better than they know themselves.

I also really appreciate the long stretches without dialogue.
 

Vagabundo

Member
Chuck is a great villain for this show. Subtle, smart and flawed. The Mike plot gives the show a bit of menace and action. Great balance. Loving it.
 

UrbanRats

Member
Chuck is a great villain for this show. Subtle, smart and flawed. The Mike plot gives the show a bit of menace and action. Great balance. Loving it.
I am loving jimmy's plotline, but i cant say im enthralled by Mike's.
We already know where both characters will end up, but Jimmy seems to have much more metamorphosis coming his way, both as a character and as surroundings/people around him.

Mike is basically already the guy he'll be in BB, minus the hitman part, but he basically went there already, trying to kill Hector.
 

SpaceWolf

Banned
I'm enjoying the Mike stuff and love Mike as a character, but his storyline is becoming more and more divergent from Jimmy's, to the point now where the two characters have nothing to do with each other..which is a problem for a show which is supposed to revolve around Jimmy as a character.
 

mxgt

Banned
I think one of my favourite parts of this season so far is seeing how different Francesca is in this compared to BB.
 

Piichan

Banned
One of my favorite parts of this show is how seemingly mundane events are made enthralling due to great editing and cool music. Like this episode's visit of Kim to the gym to take a shower, or Mike taking apart the car in the first ep of this season.
 

Cmerrill

You don't need to be empathetic towards me.
Decent episode, but they really need to chill out on the montage scenes. It's not clever and it's way over done.
 

jonno394

Member
"I caught my second wife screwing my step dad, it's a cruel world, grow up!"
Saul Goodman, Breaking Bad.

If taken at face value, I've got a feeling this line is going to prove troublesome for the writers later down the line.

I read it more as Jimmy created a backstory for his "Saul" Persona.
 
One of my favorite parts of this show is how seemingly mundane events are made enthralling due to great editing and cool music. Like this episode's visit of Kim to the gym to take a shower, or Mike taking apart the car in the first ep of this season.

Yeah, it's incredibly stylish and they use a great soundtrack. I love the way it's way it's filmed and edited too.
 
I am loving jimmy's plotline, but i cant say im enthralled by Mike's.
We already know where both characters will end up, but Jimmy seems to have much more metamorphosis coming his way, both as a character and as surroundings/people around him.

Mike is basically already the guy he'll be in BB, minus the hitman part, but he basically went there already, trying to kill Hector.

Totally agreed with this. I generally find Mike's portion to be a bore--this episode possibly excepted. I'm muuuuch more interested in Jimmy's story
 

riotous

Banned
I'm enjoying the Mike stuff and love Mike as a character, but his storyline is becoming more and more divergent from Jimmy's, to the point now where the two characters have nothing to do with each other..which is a problem for a show which is supposed to revolve around Jimmy as a character.

I'm sure they'll re-diverge; Saul knows Mike works for Gus during the Breaking Bad era, so some sort of business with Mike and Jimmy goes down at some point.
 
I'm sure they'll re-diverge; Saul knows Mike works for Gus during the Breaking Bad era, so some sort of business with Mike and Jimmy goes down at some point.
I was listening to the Sepinwall/Grubb podcast where they discussed the last two episodes, and they brought this up. They noted that at by the time we roll around to BB, Mike is still working with Jimmy/Saul, which is a little odd if he gets a consistent, presumably well-paying gig with Gus. Gus is a little more aligned with how Mike wants to work (professional, secretive), so there must be a reason why Mike and Jimmy remain in contact and continue to work together given their differences. Jimmy bails Mike out of a very dire situation at some point? Mike actually likes Jimmy on some level?
 
"I caught my second wife screwing my step dad, it's a cruel world, grow up!"
Saul Goodman, Breaking Bad.

If taken at face value, I've got a feeling this line is going to prove troublesome for the writers later down the line.

Yeah... I think Viktor-- er, Jimmy-- er, Saul making shit up sometimes is probably not out of the question.
 

duckroll

Member
I was listening to the Sepinwall/Grubb podcast where they discussed the last two episodes, and they brought this up. They noted that at by the time we roll around to BB, Mike is still working with Jimmy/Saul, which is a little odd if he gets a consistent, presumably well-paying gig with Gus. Gus is a little more aligned with how Mike wants to work (professional, secretive), so there must be a reason why Mike and Jimmy remain in contact and continue to work together given their differences. Jimmy bails Mike out of a very dire situation at some point? Mike actually likes Jimmy on some level?

Does anyone other than Chuck ever interact with Jimmy and not end up liking him. The dude has like max charisma stat or something. Lol. I mean, the simple answer would just be that Jimmy is a resourceful guy who, when freed from the constrains of "legit" legal work, becomes useful for people doing criminal stuff. Why wouldn't Mike keep in contact with him? Also, having a liaison to connect people who isn't in Gus' pocket could be very useful for Mike too. Given how he doesn't completely trust anyone.
 
Also, how firm is the timeline that this is 6 years before BB? Because at the rate time is passing, it could be just a year or two. Would explain Katie's age as well.
I remember it being late 2001 or early 2002 at the beginning of the show, and though it's not always easy to tell how much time is passing it doesn't seem like time has been passing faster on the show than reality for sure.
 

riotous

Banned
I was listening to the Sepinwall/Grubb podcast where they discussed the last two episodes, and they brought this up. They noted that at by the time we roll around to BB, Mike is still working with Jimmy/Saul, which is a little odd if he gets a consistent, presumably well-paying gig with Gus. Gus is a little more aligned with how Mike wants to work (professional, secretive), so there must be a reason why Mike and Jimmy remain in contact and continue to work together given their differences. Jimmy bails Mike out of a very dire situation at some point? Mike actually likes Jimmy on some level?

Yeah it will be interesting where they go with it; the "prequel that was never meant to exist" concept makes this show kind of unique. Especially since Mike was never a planned character in the first place.

They did just show that Mike is still willing to use Jimmy; even though Jimmy sucked at what he was asked to do, I'm not sure Mike even knows that since he can't see what happened inside the restaurant. Then you have the scene of Jimmy basically begging Mike to work with him again. What's interesting is that Gus probably would recognize Jimmy as the jack-ass who was so terrible at surveilance.

My outside chance theory I mentioned the other day is that Ernesto is involved; Ernesto being the lawyer version of Gale, recipient of a Gus scholarship and being groomed to be useful to Gus's operation (and possibly related to Gus off course.) If Gus were to ask Ernesto if he knows any lawyers that would be good for them to use, perhaps for one of Gus's employees who gets in trouble, I could see Ernesto recommending Jimmy.
 
Top Bottom