• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Flash S3 |OT| It was me, Barry.

So -

The Legends broke
time
Supergirl broke
the atmosphere
Barry broke the Speed Force
How is Oliver going to break the world tomorrow night?
Someone going through a some sort of portal
Legends of Tomorrow -
the Legends thriwn into a Time Portal
Supergirl -
Mon'El sucked into a Space/Time Portal
The Flash - Barry walking into a Speedforce Portal
 
HR dying got me crying. Weird cuz I didn't really care if Iris lived or died, but HR is the best. Cool to have Harry back for a while.

I was down with the using the power of friendship plot. It fits The Flash as a show. But then Savitar just didn't want to go along with it? Okay?

Jay is always great.

Not sure what they're doing with Caitlin but it's frustrating.

Hopefully Tom Felton is back next year, I'm still confused as to his status on the show.

I immediately checked outlets to see if there was a 'Grant Gustin exits The Flash' article, and there wasn't. So this whole sacrificing himself to the speed force thing was probably pointless. They won't time skip more than six months. Doing Wally as the new Flash is a great plot that they will 100% drop after the first episode just like Flashpoint. Either go full force with these iconic plots or don't even do them.



I mean it's nowhere near as bad as I thought it could be, but just like the rest of the year it was a bunch of half baked ideas sort of coming together off the charm of the cast. I probably would've preferred they just stuck to the whole Barry is good and friendship part.

I hope they don't have Wally as the Flash for more then 2 episodes max, I'm sorry, but his actor is not good enough to carry the show, Grant Gustin is a far better actor.
 
J

JeremyEtcetera

Unconfirmed Member
Even if it is just one episode, at least I will get to see a cool episode and intro of Wally West proclaiming that he is The Flash.

Also that Savitar suit looked way better in black and red.

I hope they don't have Wally as the Flash for more then 2 episodes max, I'm sorry, but his actor is not good enough to carry the show, Grant Gustin is a far better actor.

Is it the actor's fault though? He hasn't even had a good chance to prove himself as a good main actor considering they keep putting him in each episode, with barely meaningful dialogue, for less than 10-15 minutes.
 

Kaizer

Banned
If the show was really pulling no punches, they shouldn't reintroduce Barry into the plot until the Fall/Winter finale/midseason break. Give us a good half season of Wally & crew trying to handle things without Barry around.
 

Htown

STOP SHITTING ON MY MOTHER'S HEADSTONE
So, are we assuming Barry is coming back immediately, or is DC still doing their dumbass "can't have the hero in the movies and on TV at the same time" shit like they did with Suicide Squad?
 

ZeroX03

Banned
AV Club: B+
This is by no means a perfect finale: the plotting is clunky and often nonsensical. On an emotional level, it works, however, and the episode as a whole appears to be explicitly designed to correct for the mistakes that have been made with Barry's character over the past season and a half or so. He consciously rejects the darkness, he accepts responsibility for his selfish actions, and he pays the price.

For comparison, Supergirl got a B and Legends with an A-.

Arrow aiming for that A.
 

Pics_nao

Member
That was meh. Pretty shit season. Hoping S4 turns it around and won't be a repeat of Arrow.

Speaking of Arrow, why isn't it tomorrow yet? God that finale is gonna be so rad
 
Is it the actor's fault though? He hasn't even had a good chance to prove himself as a good main actor considering they keep putting him in each episode, with barely meaningful dialogue, for less than 10-15 minutes.

It may not be on him, I dunno, I haven't seen anything that would tell me otherwise though. Maybe you are right and if they actually write some decent stuff for him he will be able to pull it off.

Grant Gustin couldn't play a convincing villain, that didn't stop them

I thought he did an okay job with what was given to him. This whole season was sloppy though, I don't think we can gauge much from it.
 
J

JeremyEtcetera

Unconfirmed Member
Grant Gustin couldn't play a convincing villain, that didn't stop them

It felt like a watching a voice actor who played a villain before but just now decided to do screen acting, and thus his voice was on point but his emotions and movements weren't.

It may not be on him, I dunno, I haven't seen anything that would tell me otherwise though. Maybe you are right and if they actually write some decent stuff for him he will be able to pull it off.

I think once they put him in the driver's seat and give him more meaning(and more meaningful dialogue) he'll step it up. I felt the same way you did when it came to Sarah Lance's actor in Legends, but she stepped up and the show's been better for it.

I just pray that they find or have writer who can live up to Wally's jokes/puns. That will make or break his character. He should be way more of a jokester than Barry, especially after a supposed time skip.
 

Bluemongoose

Neo Member
HR dying got me crying. Weird cuz I didn't really care if Iris lived or died, but HR is the best. Cool to have Harry back for a while.

I was down with the using the power of friendship plot. It fits The Flash as a show. But then Savitar just didn't want to go along with it? Okay?

Jay is always great.

Not sure what they're doing with Caitlin but it's frustrating.

Hopefully Tom Felton is back next year, I'm still confused as to his status on the show.

I immediately checked outlets to see if there was a 'Grant Gustin exits The Flash' article, and there wasn't. So this whole sacrificing himself to the speed force thing was probably pointless. They won't time skip more than six months. Doing Wally as the new Flash is a great plot that they will 100% drop after the first episode just like Flashpoint. Either go full force with these iconic plots or don't even do them.



I mean it's nowhere near as bad as I thought it could be, but just like the rest of the year it was a bunch of half baked ideas sort of coming together off the charm of the cast. I probably would've preferred they just stuck to the whole Barry is good and friendship part.

Yes, it looked like Barry was reaching him (himself?) but for some reason he just says "Screw it"? And I've missed some episodes so I don't really know why SPECIFICALLY Savitar became evil. And why is his face scarred!? He can heal.
I really stopped watching regularly when the musical episode came up. I'll watch it, but I just got the feeling that they wasted an episode just because they wanted to do the Broadway musical thing.
And what is Tom Felton's character's role in this? He does nothing but advance Caitlyn's plotpoints. He doesn't stand out on his own as an original , fleshed out character. Felton is collecting an easy check imo.
 

jrush64

Banned
Yeah that was a great finale. Flash always has good ones. Pretty sad ending too, in fact pretty sad episode all around. Dang. HR..... Barry.... ;(
 

jwk94

Member
Well that was a mess.
And the Speedforce prison shouldn't even exist because it didn't exist when Savitar existed.
We had a lot of the season building up to Wally having to save Iris only for Barry to have to only for Barry to fight evil Barry, and the the Speedforce takes Barry away leaving Wally to ascend as the hero, WHICH THE SHOW COMPLETELY FUCKING DROPPED EARLIER IN THE SEASON
I forgot about Wally trying to save Iris. Man, that would've been the perfect lead-in to this.

The article was by Iris West-Allen so they still get married at some point. The writers wouldn't leave a plot hole like that, right? Right?

Barry also said she'll always be Iris West-Allen, though. So, she probably adopts the name even without the formal wedding.
 
Just caught up. Finale was ok. Even with the some of the more bone-head moments it had, I enjoyed the Supergirl finale more. Felt like it had a good message and wrapped up with a better vibe to it. Maybe because this season sort of hand waved the end of last season away so quickly, I don't expect the status quo to be all that effected at the start of next season.
 

jobrro

Member
I really enjoyed the finale except for the last few minutes. I wish they could have just left it with a happy ending for once, he's going to be back next season anyway.

Fight scene with all hands on deck was great.

Sad about HR but they would have made reason up to get a new Wells for season 4 anyway so it's better him than Iris. Also somehow Julienne survived! Also like that Kaitlyn is not longer Killer Frost and not quite back to OG Kaitlyn. I am sure she will come back to Team Flash early next season though, bit of a boys club and even more so without her.
 

Sacul64GC

Banned
Ok so did they just take Barry Allen out of The flash because of the upcoming JLA movie like they did with the Suicide Squad and Deadshot in Arrow when that movie came out?
 

VeeP

Member
There is no way they'd spend the majority of next season without Barry.

A couple episodes, maybe.

Honestly. Flashpoint lasted one episode and we thought it would last a lot longer.

So Barry being going more than one episode? Doubt it. He'll be back within the first episode.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Ok, so when they bring Earth 2 Harrison to talk to the lady scientist, both me and my wife did audible head-smacks. She just lost her boyfriend and the first thing they think of is bringing in his exact duplicate .. struck me as real odd.

Also, Black Flash got KO'ed with just that little effort ? fuuuuuuck ... that ..
 

Blunoise

Member
Ok so did they just take Barry Allen out of The flash because of the upcoming JLA movie like they did with the Suicide Squad and Deadshot in Arrow when that movie came out?
NO! And ppl stop bring this up, dead shot and Amanda Waller were side characters, not the main character of their own show. D.C. Is not going to fire there main star
 

Mariolee

Member
God that was really mediocre. Hamfisted emotional unearned drama wrapped in character arcs with unsatisfactory conclusions amd arbitrary consequences. They keep going so...
flashy... with the results of these people's choices but the script doesn't really allow them to react like actual people enough. Like, Iris just shot Barry, a Barry that used to love her, and killed him. And by the end of the episode she's just laughing, with them even acknowledging "Eh maybe the emotional trauma will hit me later".

I realized thats my issue with this season overall. Unlike in Season 1, for the most part these characters don't act or react like real people so I'm not as invested as I can't relate to their 2-dimensional character motivations. Only to the testament of the actors can I even bear to watch this. I'll be back next season, and I hope the writers' ability to convey actual humanity in their scripts comes back as well.
 

Otnopolit

Member
God that was really mediocre. Hamfisted emotional unearned drama wrapped in character arcs with unsatisfactory conclusions amd arbitrary consequences. They keep going so...
flashy... with the results of these people's choices but the script doesn't really allow them to react like actual people enough. Like, Iris just shot Barry, a Barry that used to love her, and killed him. And by the end of the episode she's just laughing, with them even acknowledging "Eh maybe the emotional trauma will hit me later".

I realized thats my issue with this season overall. Unlike in Season 1, for the most part these characters don't act or react like real people so I'm not as invested as I can't relate to their 2-dimensional character motivations. Only to the testament of the actors can I even bear to watch this. I'll be back next season, and I hope the writers' ability to convey actual humanity in their scripts comes back as well.

One of the lead writers is leaving, so your wish may be granted.
 

Sacul64GC

Banned
NO! And ppl stop bring this up, dead shot and Amanda Waller were side characters, not the main character of their own show. D.C. Is not going to fire there main star

When I heard someone bring this up they said he would be gone until after the Christmas break. He told me this last week that they would lock Barry in the speed force. I'm furious and just want some word from DC or the show runners saying this is not the case. DC already showed they don't care about the actor by casting someone else. If they are concerned about something as small as a side character wouldn't they treat a major face the same way?
 
The show is desperately chasing the opportunity they wasted in the ending of season 2. Barry should had gone back to reveal he was the time remnant who saved everyone with his sacrifice.
 

LotusHD

Banned
As expected, I was not satisfied. Well, at least Iris is still alive. Won't lie, didn't feel a damn thing for H.R. dying, and it's not like I even hate him. (I do prefer the other Wells though...) Meh, not much more to say really about this episode or this season, it just wasn't very good. May have been if the pacing was a lot better, but oh well. The wait for Season 4 begins.... (No speedster villain this time right? Please tell me this is true...)

Imagine if we get several episodes of Wally as the Flash

Bruh we couldn't even get several episodes of Flashpoint, which is something that could've been truly and easily interesting as fuck to explore. I'm still salty about that.
 

ZeroX03

Banned
why didnt barry's fathers look alike run back into the speed force? that just seemed odd to me how he stood there and did nothing

Because Barry was taking responsibility for his mess. It's not Jay's fault all of this happened, he shouldn't have to suffer.
 

jb1234

Member
It wasn't as bad as I feared it would be, mostly because despite some clunky dialogue, the emotional scenes landed. Still, HR's death left me cold because the character never grew on me and Savitar's fate made me shrug (and made the team out to be a bunch of idiots). The real strength of the episode is Barry FINALLY taking responsibility for his shit choices. Even if it gets reversed at the beginning of next season (and it will be), it's nice that the show recognized its lead had to pay a price. Hopefully, he'll return in a much better frame of mind and less broody.

It's just becoming increasingly clear to me that with these showrunners, the show will never get back to its season 1 greatness. That's a shame.

(Neely's cue for the last five minutes was nice. Just makes me wish the show had the budget for an orchestra.)
 
It was about damn time for Barry to accept that this was all of his doing. He took all his L's and decided to own up to them. That's better than what most GAFfers are willing to do :p
 

inm8num2

Member
"Savitar took the speed force bazooka."

That line perfectly encapsulates why I haven't enjoyed most of the season. It just became too loony for me - Gorilla City was probably the tipping point. The one thing that might have saved S3 for me was more King Shark.

After tomorrow's Arrow finale I'll bid the CWverse adieu. It's been fun.
 

Kronotech

Member
I feel like we've seen this cliffhanger before and that the beginning of next season will be "I think I found a way to get Barry out of the speed force prison" and they'll do it by the end of Ep1.

Overall, low-tier finale. Felt more like a mid-season episode.
 

Magwik

Banned
I forgot about Wally trying to save Iris. Man, that would've been the perfect lead-in to this.
That's because halfway through the season they threw it out the window. It writes itself: Wally not only has to surpass Barry Allen, but also has to defeat him.
 

LotusHD

Banned
"Savitar took the speed force bazooka."

That line perfectly encapsulates why I haven't enjoyed most of the season. It just became too loony for me - Gorilla City was probably the tipping point. The one thing that might have saved S3 for me was more King Shark.

After tomorrow's Arrow finale I'll bid the CWverse adieu. It's been fun.

Heh
 
"Savitar took the speed force bazooka."

That line perfectly encapsulates why I haven't enjoyed most of the season. It just became too loony for me - Gorilla City was probably the tipping point. The one thing that might have saved S3 for me was more King Shark.

After tomorrow's Arrow finale I'll bid the CWverse adieu. It's been fun.

Isn't King Shark just as loony as a city run by gorillas?
 

Sanjay

Member
Any one else think that killer frost killing zombie black flash was hella overpowered move.

That thing got rid of eobard thane and flash couldn't even get rid of him. But Killer frost ez.
 
I liked the finale.

Also I'm a bit more optimistic that we might get an extended run with no Barry (and by extended I mean like until mid-season at best). They caught a lot of shit for hanging on to Flashpoint for all of one episode, and I don't think they'll make that mistake again.

At the very least, I don't think Barry will be back before episode 2 or 3.
 
Top Bottom