• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Which series should next receive the 'Mania' treatment?

ASaiyan

Banned
This Destructoid article that just appeared in my feed is interesting - not just because it is a somewhat-well-written article by Jonathan Holmes (which is rarer than gold), but also because it is an interesting topic for discussion with current relevance.

As we all know, SEGA recently moved forward in its quest to Make Sonic Great Again by cutting itself entirely out of the design process - and it went pretty damn well. The game was lovingly crafted by fan creators with a serious passion for and understanding of the series, people heaped praises on it for bringing back the classic tight Sonic gameplay of yore, and SEGA made some good money and a lot of good PR for pretty cheap (only paying for a handful of devs and some old-school 2D graphics). Everybody won.

With such a simple but brilliant idea proving such a resounding success, the question becomes: who should try this next? What series could use a cheap refresh in the hands of someone else? What long-dead franchise should be revived by a fan? We have certainly seen some variations of this in the recent past. MercuryStream is currently working on an enhanced remake of Metroid II that only came to be from their love of the series and direct request to Nintendo. The Serious Sam devs made their IP freely available to indies for a time (albeit with mixed results). Super Mario Maker even took this concept one step further by essentially having players make the game themselves - and, to its credit, I had far more fun with 2D Mario again than I ever thought I would.

So, what would you like to see? Here's my wish:
51897-Castlevania_-_Symphony_of_the_Night_(E)-7.jpg

Yo, Konami. I know you're here. I see you've been toying with the idea of actually making games again recently. You wanna do one better, and collect the money on a game without actually making it? Assemble a team of fans/third-party devs to make a new Metroidvania-style game in the Castlevania series. You can even reuse the sprites from the PS1/GBA games, I don't care. If it's good I will pay $20 for that easily.

That, or have Ninty just give F-Zero to the FAST Racing devs.
 

Danneee

Member
Road Rash!
Streets of Rage!
Desert Strike!


Um, Mutant League Sports!

Those all deserve new updated games in their respective series that keep the classic 16bit gameplay and graphics. None of them have really been surpassed by similar games either.



it has to be called Castlemania for the sake of the pun.

Love it!
 

F0rneus

Tears in the rain
Mega Man already has MM9 and 10 but it still needs another 8-bit game. Otherwise IGAvania needs to return. On 3DS with 2D sprites.
 

duckroll

Member
So, what would you like to see? Here's my wish:
51897-Castlevania_-_Symphony_of_the_Night_(E)-7.jpg

Yo, Konami. I know you're here. I see you've been toying with the idea of actually making games again recently. You wanna do one better, and collect the money on a game without actually making it? Assemble a team of fans/third-party devs to make a new Metroidvania-style game in the Castlevania series. You can even reuse the sprites from the PS1/GBA games, I don't care. If it's good I will pay $20 for that easily.

This would be like if Sonic Mania was a faithful sequel to Sonic Adventure instead. Smh.
 

SkylineRKR

Member
Contra, Castlevania and Megaman are probably the most popular picks.

Megaman has gotten 9 and 10 which were 8-bit, but I'd rather see another MMX1 style game. For CV I would drop the Metroidvania approach, just go with Rondo or IV and expand on it a little.
 
They need to do a modern take on the AKI N64-style wrestling games. Get the licenses and do current rosters. With no cartridge limits they could incorporate better quality music and intros. Sell it for $20 as a downloadable title and call it Wrestle Mania.
 

Orb

Member
Id say Silent Hill, but a good chunk of the fanbase that only played 2 just love shitting on the imo cooler religious horror elements of the majority of the rest of the series, and id rather people like that not get full control lol.

While Ive never liked Megaman, a super polished new 2D one would be really fuckin rad
 
So basically what classic 8/16 bit game needs a new entry with the classic 8/16 bit style?

I'm just gonna say Actiraiser, because no one else is gonna say it.
 

ReaperXL7

Member
From Sega I would want Golden Ax.

If I could pick another publisher I'd wish for Contra, I'd kill for one more great 2D Contra game.
 

Renna Hazel

Member
Streets of Rage. There is already a fanmade game that is better than the originals. They should put that on consoles.
 
I'd agree with Castlevania, OP, but Simon's Quest specifically. That game could really use a fan-remake/spiritual sequel/"Mania treatment".
 

Huggy

Member
Aren't there SoR 1 buildings in the background of Sonic Mania?
Isn't Mania the hardest difficulty in SoR 2?
Am I just seeing things I want to see?
 

kogasu

Member
Castlevania!! Yusss! But give some love to Classicvania as well. Have some of that in there too not just Igavanias which, mind you, I guess would still be cool if it was just that regardless!
 
Something with Batman-style wall jumping. Ninja Gaiden, I don't care.

Hell, just do a straight up proper 16-bit sequel to Batman, only up the insanity to 11.
 

NotLiquid

Member
"Mania" treatment feels like kind of a misnomer for what's being asked. Sonic Mania was just such a given because fans have had decade-long histories of putting out incredible Sonic fan games that mirror classics or come with a plethora of unique spins and ideas. It was easy to say something like "Christian Whitehead should make a Sonic game" because both him and Stealth were experts on the engines of the 2D classics and I think the circumstance in which Mania came together has to do with more than just "lets make a classic-styled revival". Those have existed way before Sonic Mania came around, some of them ended up being great and others... not so great. It'll be a long time before a game ever hits the same kind of jackpot of right talent at the right time that can compare to Sonic Mania. I'm not sure how many fan gaming communities are as dedicated to the pixel perfect science of their games as the Sonic one, and in the case of a company like Capcom who are chock-full of properties people want back, they don't need fan talent for it - they either have or partner with talent already that is more than capable of putting out a well designed classic.

But as far as retro revivals go I would love to see a new Mega Man X game or linear Castlevania. I was always a bigger fan of games like IV and Rondo over Symphony of the Night.
 

PSqueak

Banned
I'd be down for a new Mario game done in the style and level design sensibilities from either World or SMB3.

But i mean, nothing, NOTHING will ever recieve the same praise as Sonic Mania because you wont find a series that was so fucked up over the last 2 decades as Sonic was.
 

RedSwirl

Junior Member
I would broaden this question and ask: In which old franchise would you like to see a new entry, even if it had the same graphics and production value as the old ones? Would you play a new full Breath of Fire even if it had the same graphics as Breath of Fire IV?

Mega Man X
Thief
Quake singleplayer? Id paying some Quake modders to do an official campaign would be neat and MachineGames did release its own full episode last year.
Silent Hill as an "officialy sanctioned" UE4 fan game could be interesting if written well.
 

I Wanna Be The Guy

U-S-A! U-S-A! U-S-A!
Tomb Raider.

I'm serious. Give me my PS1 graphics, grid system and tank controls, baby. Classic style Tomb Raider. People will hate it but it doesn't matter because I'll love it.
 
Top Bottom