-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Next-gen Racing Graphics Face-off | (Next-gen means current-gen)
- Thread starter Gestault
- Start date
So go buy GT6 that have a true dynamic TOD and a true dynamic weather, not the scrioted event of forza.
0:39
reminds me something)))
Jamesways
Member
Goddammit Russia!
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Admeister wants it to be true lol
TheAdmiester
Member
.
You're also conveniently ignoring that I made the first callback to the "that's Forza" thing on that page in the first place...
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
GT wins in reflections too?
TheAdmiester
Member
It's thelastword, don't bother questioning anything.
For us to be able to tell if GTS looks a generation ahead or not in the rally stages we need something to compare to. How's the rally looking in Forza 7?
MilkyJoe
Member
FH3 has your back there.
In 60 fps on Xbox One? That's news to me.
I downloaded Digital Foundry's 4k files (Patreon member) HDR files for GT Sport and Forza 7, put them on a USB, and watched them on my B6 OLED.
To me GT Sport has the better implementation of HDR, but Polyphony has always had better lighting than Forza anyway, imo. Both looked good, but Sport definitely had the edge. I've also played Sport by way of the demo, while I'm waiting on Xbox One X to hit next month for Forza.
How does the HDR implementation on Horizon 3 compare to Forza 7?
To me GT Sport has the better implementation of HDR, but Polyphony has always had better lighting than Forza anyway, imo. Both looked good, but Sport definitely had the edge. I've also played Sport by way of the demo, while I'm waiting on Xbox One X to hit next month for Forza.
How does the HDR implementation on Horizon 3 compare to Forza 7?
ethomaz
Banned
Yes and no...
In static picture the higher resolution reflections in F7 looks better but in motion the 60fps reflections of GTS looks better.
Choose your side.
Both made big compromises in reflections.
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
Is there only Forza on the market?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HltAPD1AW4
it is on PC.
I choose neither one.
I think the most amazing part is your ability to raise your bias on a consistent basis. The fact you mention 60fps relays and not how Forza out performs gts says it all.
Self_Destructive
Member
I did buy GT6. :|
TheAdmiester
Member
That's why list wars are dumb. It's very easy to be selective about what you compare on and make one look way more lacking than the other.
MilkyJoe
Member
Had better retire Driveclub then?
When have I brought that up in this thread?
MilkyJoe
Member
In general.
You must have an example where I have brought it up comparing it favourably to a 60 fps racer, otherwise why use it as a rebuttal to save face for you doing that?
Then again you are one of if not the only poster in here to stubbornly insist that Forza 7's lighting is more realistic than GT Sport's, so I'm not surprised that you failed to see my post as the bait it was. I knew you could not resist bringing up FH3.
Yautja_Warrior
Member
GT Sport VR footage with foggy weather while racing 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otYyKOqPPV8&t=5m5s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otYyKOqPPV8&t=5m5s
GT Sport VR footage with foggy weather while racing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=otYyKOqPPV8&t=5m5s
That haze looks gorgeous. I'd LIVE in time attack.
MilkyJoe
Member
Sure you did, sausage.
TBiddy
Member
In order to tell if FM7 is a generation ahead of GTS when it comes to weather, we need something to compare to. How's the weather looking in GTS?
Ahh.. I completely forgot. Sorry about that.
Can we please stop with the stupid shitposting?
First and foremost, I would like to take back what I said about GTS. After reviewing the comparison of GT6 and GTS plus other racers, it's clear the amount of time and energy was used to craft this racer. It's undeniably the better looking racer and the shortcuts used were the best choices to maintain it's vision.
And for the people comparing a PC to console well, how much for both?
And for the people comparing a PC to console well, how much for both?
dr guildo
Member
Project Cars | XB1, gameplay
Too good, this game is really underestimate... It's a shame.
you forgot to mention that GTS has a bigger penis also.
But does it run at 60fps?
Haha, that's gold.
But I think it is moree of a Split situation with 8 personas from both sides arguing with each other.
Is this a parody account? The username makes me think so...
I'm too drunk for thus shit lmoa
ResidentDante
Member
Biased fanboy post of the whole generation. Lmao.
TheAdmiester
Member
I think the funniest part is that he can't even give Forza the marks for IQ without a "but". It's just not possible for him to straight up compliment Forza.
Wow, Gestault's gif from my clip is pretty legendary at this point. Have the full video to mull over, lots of angles to pick apart in the replay!
As to which game I think looks better, I was seriously impressed by DF's HDR vid of GTS, but it's true Forza 7 can look gorgeous at times too. Not sure how anyone can claim "generational leaps" on either side with a straight face. Thread sure is hysterical though, keep it up chaps!
As to which game I think looks better, I was seriously impressed by DF's HDR vid of GTS, but it's true Forza 7 can look gorgeous at times too. Not sure how anyone can claim "generational leaps" on either side with a straight face. Thread sure is hysterical though, keep it up chaps!
ResidentDante
Member
Hahaha yeah. Its like looking at a election vote in dictator state where one single leader gets 101% votes.
Yautja_Warrior
Member
Christocolus
Member
thelastword
Banned
I think you're trying too hard here Admiester, but at the same time, only proving what's really superior in your mind or through concensus or your own eyes....In essence, you want Forza to be compared to GTS because it's better looking and much more accomplished graphically....
Instead of givng us your true take on things through semantics, it will serve you well if you just come clean and admit to it...Yet, even if you don't, I think that might be the clearest picture you've painted on these deliberations...
Well, here's the thing....GT reflections run at 60fps, so does it's mirrors, so for a 60fps game I think that is remarkably more impressive.....It's just like Halo 5's background animations running at halfrate of the in-game refresh, that will be immediately recognizable than say lower polygon models in the distance....I think if you're making a high fps game, it's better to keep everything at a high rate for fluidity.....
In any case, it's already been shown that F7 has some shortcomings with it's reflection resolution in certain scenes, and how does it hold when there are many cars on screen or in dark tunnels when there would be more light sources...well should.... in Forza's case?
Well I didn't mention weather just yet, because weather is coming to GTS and we can't know which is best yet.....On the flip, I don't think VR or better pit crews are coming to Forza 7 on the XBONEX....and surely, these features have already been debated in this thread...FYi, Forza does have pitting, it's just that it's not as detailed or require as many resources as GTS...
Well, I'm not familiar with that particular aspect of things, but if you are privy to the sizes of each.....feel free to weigh in on your experiences there....
And here, I give you case candidate #2 , dispelling any talk of worse trackside detail to any other racer in 2017....In a few days, we will have more trackside pics of more locations as well....
TheAdmiester
Member
I have literally never read a more ironic post in my life. Nice job.
potatohead
Member
Is this Forza? Looks kind of flat.
That mirror is absolutely hilarious, I was wondering what car it was before.
Yautja_Warrior
Member
Yeah it's a crazy rear view camera in that car.
l2ounD
Member
c'est magnifique
Geezus, I don't know what I expected but please try to be civil.
This is supposed to be a graphics face off thread. Might help to read the rules in the OP. State the game and photo mode/gameplay at the least - platform would be good too where that isn't obvious, and beta/demo/release would help.
It has been good to see the best and the worst that the games have to offer. Every game will have trade-offs. No problem showing the ugly bits and everyone has their own opinion of what looks good and what doesnt, so I'm not right and you're not right (or conversely I'm right and you're right).
If you're going to stake a claim then at least put some thought into your posts. Why do you think your image of game X has some gfx feature that looks better/worse than game Y?
I'll have a go in the coming week doing some specific comparisons.
This is supposed to be a graphics face off thread. Might help to read the rules in the OP. State the game and photo mode/gameplay at the least - platform would be good too where that isn't obvious, and beta/demo/release would help.
It has been good to see the best and the worst that the games have to offer. Every game will have trade-offs. No problem showing the ugly bits and everyone has their own opinion of what looks good and what doesnt, so I'm not right and you're not right (or conversely I'm right and you're right).
If you're going to stake a claim then at least put some thought into your posts. Why do you think your image of game X has some gfx feature that looks better/worse than game Y?
I'll have a go in the coming week doing some specific comparisons.