Supermanisdead
Member
I'm so glad all these Persona fans can come together to hate that loser Ken Amada.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Japanese Persona fans rank their favorite characters in the series.
- Thread starter Snakeyes
- Start date
Supermanisdead
Member
Seth and Samael <3
Jawmuncher
Member
Okay,
a) what the goddamn hell is Kanji doing at 12!?
b) what's so cool about the Persona 4 main character? I don't get it. He's not... anything.c) there's only one character in the whole list that isn't from P3 or P4. :|besides JYB when he yells out persona names
I haven't played P2 yet.
But going into P1 even knowing it was nothing like P3 or P4, I gotta say i hated all of it.
Characters included.
cj_iwakura
Member
zerokoolpsx
Member
I couldn't get into P1 either. Maybe I'll try again later. It's just so different.
But....but....Koro is one of my favorite characters
In fact, my top three characters are listed consecutively, and much lower on the list than I think they should be. But alas, opinions right?
Well yes taking into account what i wrote you're correct.
Kinda liked Black frost the most out of all of the different versions.
They did.
1) Izanagi
2) Thanatos
3) Alice
4) Jack Frost
5) Ninja Disco Frog
6) Yoshitsume
7) Konohana Sakuya
8) Orpheus
9) Mara
10) Sukuna-Hikona
Heh. I'm not surprised.
I have no shame admitting that's part of it, but I genuinely like his character and I'm glad they were bold with the direction they went with.
idlethreats
Member
Came to see how high Mitsuru placed, leaving deeply disappointed.
I love Kanji, even in Japanese. His character is fantastic. I just loved how Troy translated Kanji into a more "american" style of punk while not getting stereotypical.
Jawmuncher
Member
I don't recall hating Ken all that much when I played P3.
I even used him to beat the game.
But that Dog, I hated him.
While that is true I tried to play that shit on psp and I can't do it anymore. Believe me I tried but the combat is slow and the encounter rate is way to high, the story can't save it for me because I already know it from playing it long time ago.
buddha0991
Member
Does Tamaki Uchida count as a Persona User/Devil Summoner? 90% of this topic will Who? this and I don't blame em hah
This list isn't about all SMT games its about SMT persona as in the only 4 games that are called persona. It has nothing to do with who can summon demons or games like DDS.
Why are you trying to mess with these people dawg
.buddha0991
Member
She's in Persona 1 and 2 though, but I did mainly just mention her as a joke
Also in Persona's direct predecessor SMT If...
Hours Left
Member
Why is Yosuke so high and Kanji, Mitsuru, Akihiko & Dojima so low? (And no Metis?) :/
Also P3 FeMC > P3 MC all day, every day.
I'm glad Theodore made the list (especially considering Margaret didn't even make it), I hope we see more of him.
Atlus USA should do a similar poll, I think the results would be quite interesting.
Also P3 FeMC > P3 MC all day, every day.
I'm glad Theodore made the list (especially considering Margaret didn't even make it), I hope we see more of him.
Atlus USA should do a similar poll, I think the results would be quite interesting.
buddha0991
Member
Popular fan opinion is that Margaret is nowhere near as amusing as Elizabeth and Theodore so that makes sense.
Also, Metis is one if the main focuses of a quite unliked chapter of Persona 3 in fan opinion, so it also makes sense she's not here.
Unknown Soldier
Member
Rise is way too low.
1) There is a spell to reduce the encounter rate, and since the game is easier on PSP you won't suffer from the loss of fights.
2) The BS is actually faster than P3-4 thanks to the ability to skip animations + set up attacks automatically.
3) The story shouldn't lose value because you are replaying it, when i replayed IS the second time i actually loved the story even more because of the huge ammount of details/foreshadowing you won't notice the first time. (there are even references to EP plot in the initial dungeon!)
lol
WrenchNinja
Member
He's a completely normal dude who tends to screw up a lot but manages to keep the team moving forward during the case. I find him amusing, he reminds me of a friend I had in High School. Also he's the best party member in the game, does great magic and physical damage and has masukukaja and dekaja to boot.
He's the Tim Drake to my Batman. Doesn't challenge me for stupid reasons like Jason Todd...I mean Junpei.
He's an archetypal obedient sidekick.
zerokoolpsx
Member
As a party member, he's pretty versatile. Good physical attacks, buffs and debuffs, good magic attacks and limited healing. In P4G, they gave him even better healing spells. He's good all around in almost any role. Brosuke
TheBaronOfNA
Banned
He is an jerkass with everyone and people say that is a Bro cause he does what friends are expected to do.
Also, he needs a huge.
Tim Drake will be insulted and he will tell you that is Damian... and Damian will get insulted too and will affirm is Drake [REPEATTOINFINITUM]
buddha0991
Member
I really find it interesting just how split down the middle peoples reactions to yosuke are.
TheBaronOfNA
Banned
He is more a Sasuke than a Tim Drake.
WrenchNinja
Member
Well all three are yaoi bait.
TheBaronOfNA
Banned
Can't argue against that.
Laughing Banana
Weeping Pickle
Bleh.
P3 protagonist > P4 protagonist.
P3 protagonist > P4 protagonist.
Professor Beef
Banned
I'd put Yukiko above Chie, but I can't disagree with that list at all.
I'd say that Yukiko has the weakest personality of all of the P4 cast. I always find it surprising when people say how much they like her.