-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
IAmRandom31
Banned
Oh boy lol
Watching the PS4 multiplayer footage is nice though. Not near as WOW inducing as Killzone, but still not bad
Think about who the poster is.
Wow i thought it would be a much bigger difference considering how hyped up the performance advantage the PS4 has.
Really questioning whether its worth it yet getting a next gen console when the graphics for multiplats are so average compared to the PC. Might just have to wait till next year for some decent exclusives to come out.
Really questioning whether its worth it yet getting a next gen console when the graphics for multiplats are so average compared to the PC. Might just have to wait till next year for some decent exclusives to come out.
Mutanthands
Member
God, what a cluster fuck of a generation. I shouldn't have to default to PC for multiplats day zero. And yet, here we are.
If you were so inclined, you could buy a GTX 760 and sit it out for a few years. I should. But, alas, I can't.
Damn that obsessive-compulsive console collecting trait of mine.
If you were so inclined, you could buy a GTX 760 and sit it out for a few years. I should. But, alas, I can't.
Damn that obsessive-compulsive console collecting trait of mine.
la flama blanca
Banned
I know plenty of people who don't have their TV's properly calibrated...I can only imagine what kind of image that xbox one version of BF4 would produce.
Stillmatic
Member
So is it the Xbox that's doing the sharpening and crushing blacks, or was that DICE? I hope it's the latter. :/
statham
Member
yep. At certain scenes I think somehow the XB1 looks better.I know PS4 is more powerful, but if this is it, ehh.
I know, that's why I posted it. The gun on the Xbox side looks like absolute trash.
Aquamarine
Member
I hope this doesn't become a standard for all Xbox One games...so many people are getting misleaded here.
No ones getting upset. But using actual objective facts, the ps4 version is better.
Subjective opinions are of course fine. Bare in mind that we were told there would be no differences in framerate or resolution only a few weeks ago.
Surface of Me
I'm not an NPC. And neither are we.
Not just you, the resolution difference is the biggest difference which is lost on Youtube. Framerate is variable on both platforms and both usually drop about the same amount at the same time, with X1 dropping 5 frames more sometimes about. X1 had the framerate edge in one scene, though.
I'm not trolling, at all. Look at how washed out it looks. It's like there is a sheen of white over the image. The texture detail is shit in comparison to the Xbone, at least from this GIFs and the video comparison.
Orochinagis
Member
So much Xbox one hate these days.
chickdigger802
Banned
people in the beta, about what kind of pc is comparable to next gen versions?
It's as easy as that.
SEGAvangelist
Member
There are times when the PS4 dips lower, though. Easy for people to cherry pick photos.
Nah different resolution and better framerate don't make them close at all.
My god its like ps3 vs 360 all over again.
- PS4 has less jaggies
- X1 has better texture detail (check out the hair on the black guys head, his hair is clealy more detailed in the x1 version)
- More vibrant colours on the X1 (not and advantage, becuase everyone will have there tv's calibrated properly)
Neuromancer
Member
Because we're comparing next gen consoles. If you're not interested in discussing it, you don't have to be here.
Bam Bam Baklava
Member
So basically any point in the game where the black level hits a certain point you literally see no detail at all.
How is this happening?
https://twitter.com/jackfrags/status/395046482266447872
The guy who captured the footage
Thats why.
You too -_-
Hawk269
Member
You are right, but my eyes tell me that the Xbox One version looks better. There are some instances, power lines do look better, but textures look better on the one. I am more of PC gamer these days and am getting the PC version, but watching the video and some of the screen grabs, the 44% more pixels is not translating to the game on PS4 looking 44% better.
I am with many that thinks the Xbox One version looks better. I am still fucking head spinning though. That image where the show the side by side with the chopper, if you look under the pilot, you can actually almost read the txt on the warning arrow that is on the copper, but the PS4 version looks blurry and not readable. It is opposite of having a higher resolution should do. The only think I can think of is that the PS4 up scalling is causing this.
SolidSnakex
Member
That still doesn't make sense because they really aren't that close to each other. The DF comparison even says as much.
Eyes vs reading. I get all of that, but the bone looks "better" to me still. Would pick that version if I didn't hate aliasing.
AuthenticM
Member
Why is the PS4 image washed out ?
Don't do this to yourself.
The aliasing in the X1 is immediately apparent whenever any object or character is directly silhouetted. The part of the demo where they were driving away from the helicopter with all the scaffolds and rigging was markedly more jaggy and shimmery on the X1.
Edit: XB1 is crushing black levels like no tomorrow, trying to hide the lack of AO?
Edit: XB1 is crushing black levels like no tomorrow, trying to hide the lack of AO?
jhmtehgamr20xx
Banned
Actually there's one shot in this thread where the XBO is using a completely different texture to the PS4 (and I assume PC) versions, looks like a sniper w/ an older-fashioned army sheet over them aiming at a helicopter. I found the difference,...pretty laughable tbh.
They would tell me that it looks like imax 3d in their home.
ostrichKing
Member
It looks like XBONE is using an "unsharp mask" type effect to make the textures look crisper, but it's adding odd noise...As others have said...an adjustment of contrast I am pretty certain will make PS4 the clear clear clear winner...People seem to be just reacting to the higher contrast of the XBONE images...
Pseudo judo
Member
It's not his ignorance but yours. Read the Eurogamer article. Sony's resolution is higher but the scaler they used to get to 1080P sucks huge balls causing the image to look blurred. MS scaler is fantastic. It can't hide jaggies, which are abundantly apparent, but it doesn't blur textures like Sony's does and the colors pop and they crush the blacks making it look more cinematic.
Sony wins on resolution and effects rendering. MS wins on texture detail. Stuff like color and black levels are subjective.
Textures are same... You know that right?
My god its like ps3 vs 360 all over again.
PS4 has less jaggies
X1 has better texture detail (check out the hair on the black guys head, his hair is clealy more detailed in the x1 version)
More vibrant colours on the X1 (not and advantage, becuase everyone will have there tv's calibrated properly)
I think the PS4 is the victor here because jaggies were one of my biggest woes this gen.Though when you take into account the better looking textures of the X1, the PS4 advantage is even less of an advantage the 360 had over some PS3 games, such as fallout 3 and RDR.
Scottish Sin
Member
Yup, couldn't agree with you more. Will be happily playing this on Xbox One come November 22nd.
IchigoSharingan
Member
Probably coz they can't understand it.
For me......xbox 1 destroys black levels. Don't even bother gaming on a plasma.
What? Are we seeing the same pictures?
Subjective my ass!
Or the marginal differences in the quality of Battlefield 4 aren't the deciding factor for some people. If I were to ask any of the dozens of people I know in real life who play games if they even care about the difference seen here they'd say no.
I'm not buying either console at launch, and will buy a PS4 as soon as I'm in the financial position to do so, but this sure as hell doesn't influence my decision.
You keep telling yourself that. Use your eyes. They are close.