TrojanBlade
Member
Have we even seen any XB1 MP videos? Is it due to issues with XB1 Live that was discussed in other threads?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
Have we even seen any XB1 MP videos? Is it due to issues with XB1 Live that was discussed in other threads?
See You Next Wednesday
Banned
That is not zoomed in, just a direct proportional .gif of the full screen 1080p Youtube video. There are artifacts from youtube compression though.
Hahaha, I love that you ask this question then immediately make a thread on the scaler being the secret sauce. Bravo!
But pertaining to your original question, I think you can get the jist just reading 10 random pages as it has all been covered over and over.
Sword Of Doom
Member
How beautiful is this game? IW/activision should be ashamed of themselves
RamzaIsCool
The Amiga Brotherhood
Is BF4 the only sub 1080p game on the ps4?
No that was PS4 version
This is from Xbone version. God help your eyes:
Sweet Jesus O_O
At the moment, yes.
mullet2000
Member
I'll throw one together if no one else is.
Goodacre0081
Member
LittleIdeaSLT
Member
I agree. When you take youtube compression, possible capture issues, youtube compression, color space quirks, lower frame rate, and wait for it... youtube compression I don't see how these videos really show what the actual experience will be like. The only solid thing I have to go on from these videos is the aliasing which already looks really bad on XB1 I can only imagine how much worse it would look on my 60 inch tv.
That is what you get when you are doing 720p with FXAA.
FXAA as someone said doesn't work on subpixel lines so resolution is very important to quality of FXAA.
Amentallica
Unconfirmed Member
No that was PS4 version
This is from Xbone version. God help your eyes:
This looks like shit.
Shit.
The jaggies are so bad I feel like my eyes are being torn apart. Fuck this footage. Fuck this shit right here.
You have to be a fucking idiot to prefer this to the circulating PS4 gifs.
IGN has video of XBO BF4 MP (haha).
cormack12
Gold Member
Put the vid on. Saw insane colour bleeding on the steering wheel and then heard the reviewer talk about the capture cards giving washed out colours and blacks. Completely pointless video for determining proper quality, although the transcript of the rest of it is interesting.
Good captures and he can actually play. Subscribed!
Yeah even if you take awesome BlimBlim 1080p 1GB videos from Gamersyde there is still noticeable compression artifacts.
Youtube 1080p is actually worse than native 720p...
Native 1080p should take 2-3GB for few seconds
Colonel Nasty
Member
Question: How often is the PS4 framerate outperforming the XboxOne?
Came across this image, can't watch the video at the moment.
Both have frame drops but the play station version recovers a little quicker.
Reminds me of PS2 era jaggies.
The One Who Knocks
Member
Would you like a summary of the thread, the article's conclusions, the pictures, or something else? I ask because the discussions that have been occuring thus far in the thread are quite broad.
Regarding the conclusion in Digital Foundry:
The Playstation 4 version is running at 900p while the Xbox One version is 720p. The Xbox One version analysed was lacking Ambient Occlusion which we have learnt will be added (but this may have a hit on the Xbox One version's performance). The framerate of the Playstation 4 version, despite running at a higher resolution and having Ambient Occlusion, is more stable overall; this has led to discussions in the thread as to how large the gap is in performance between the two.
Now, at this point you may be wondering "how has the thread reached 50 pages (or 120)" and it is because of a very peculiar issue. Digital Foundry's images contain crushed blacks (to some users this appears to be 'better' and has resulted in a large amount of discussion about why this isn't really the case/that this can be replicated by adjusting TV settings and does not factor in). On top of this, we had an initial claim that Digital Foundry botched their comparison, a later claim (by them) that they did not botch it, but it was an issue with the Xbox One itself (http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-battlefield-4-face-off-qa#comments),
The primary discussion within the thread has revolved around the Xbox One's images appearing 'sharper', and the blacks being crushed, the Playstation 4 version appearing blurred to some users, and why exactly this is happening (that is, the source of the difference).
EDIT: I hope this is a decent summary, I've been trying to keep it as brief as possible but the reality is that there have been so many different topics relating to thsi footage that it's hard to keep it both very succinct and very comprehensive.
Question: How often is the PS4 framerate outperforming the XboxOne?
Came across this image, can't watch the video at the moment.
Literally in like 2 places. But we don't know cause of this. Could be that effects on PS4 that are not in Xbone version can pile up in some situations and give worse framerate.
AO is yet to be implemented in Xbone version and if DICE didn't improve performance should eat a lot frametime meaning even worse framerate.
The Last One
Member
Oh God, look all the news of this site...
Sword Of Doom
Member
If you watch actual MP gameplay on ign of the xb1. The entire map is just full of jaggies everywhere.
Thanks to God the differences between 960p & 720p should be barely notable...
Yeah - in context neither of them can do straight lines.
yes but PS4 version doesn't look THAT bad. Xbone version due to low res is blurry AND has terrible aliasing. And because of how FXAA works and how it is dependant on resolution its AA is even worse in xbone version not working at all on distant detail where in PS4 version you can tell how it switches on/off
mullet2000
Member
I made a Jackfrags thread
bigboss370
Member
can we stop with the same shitty powerlines gif and post awesome ones instead? my eyes seriously can't take anymore of that xo aliasing crap....
Thanks to God the differences between 900p & 720p should be barely notable... it reminds me to BLOPS2 ps3 compared to 360 version...
I can tell which is what version pretty quickly tbh. Day and Night for me but ya know if it doesn't bother you much then that's cool.
phosphor112
Banned
plagiarize
Banned
yeah, I clicked on the frontpage too, and boy, did I laugh.
TheRealTalker
Banned
can we stop with the same shitty powerlines gif and post awesome ones instead? my eyes seriously can't take anymore of that xo aliasing crap....
hey bigboss I posted your gifs in the new JackFrags thread
you should post your rest there as well for it to have the glory it deserves
.... awesome gifs thank you
Can we stop talking about how bad the Xbox One looks and only show images that look good?
Killer .gif, though. dat jet!
can we stop with the same shitty powerlines gif and post awesome ones instead? my eyes seriously can't take anymore of that xo aliasing crap....
hrnngh, brb I made a mess
KaptinKeezey
Banned
That is the PS4 version. You can tell by the menu at the bottom. PS4 D-Pad has gaps between keys. Xbone does not. PC shows key bindings to keyboard.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Just fishing for hits / pandering to his audience. No one with 20 years of video editing experience could seriously believe in the BS spouted there.
Honey Bunny
Member
No that was PS4 version
This is from Xbone version. God help your eyes:
next gen is here you guys
yeah i have been wondering about that, perhaps it is a new effect for cover fire or whatever it is called.
Glorified G
Member
Thanks to God the differences between 900p & 720p should be barely notable... it reminds me to BLOPS2 ps3 compared to 360 version...
I can't be the only one wondering if you are being sarcastic
I believe someone created one and it got closed last night.
TheFLYINGManga_Ka
Member
I might be crazy but why does the XBone look better? Am I in another dimension?
look who is fragged by Jack at 2:50 on this map LOL. Watch in HD.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=81RJAoZJVEI&feature=youtu.be&t=2m50s
Can someone please make a gif of this in nice resolution?
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Not ported yet to PS4 by Dice with low enough performance penalty probably. I do think Sony's studios have a working version of their own SMAA called TMAA, and I think that's what KZ:SF is using on the latest released screens, as well as probably The Order 1886 latest screens and Resogun (I know Housemarque devs have said they use their own custom post-proc AA, and it does look far better than FXAA). My guess is it was just not made quickly enough to be shared with 3rd parties in a timely manner for launch games.
Read the thread and the answers will present themselves.
Already exists.
Thanks, this thread is huge.
bigboss370
Member
another jet gif
