-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
COD:Ghosts PS4/XBO Comparisons show the same resolution (720p)?
- Thread starter Oni Jazar
- Start date
If this is true, a LOT of people dropped the ball.
Windom Earle
Member
Ohoh, Quaz enters the picture...
Gemüsepizza
Member
Maybe because Battlefield 4 is 900p on PS4?
Chobel
Member
Shit!!! IW lied to us.
FasTriggeR
Banned
Would it be possible that the ps4 version uses the same texture resolution than xbox one, but outputs at 1080p anyways? In this case the upscaled 720p would look a lot like the ps4 1080p.
this would be hilarious
Dude, if I were you I'd refrain from making stupid comments like this. Gamers were lied to if this is official and that is NOT funny.
this post right here is everything that is wrong with GAF lol
its funny because it fits his agenda thats all...he doesnt really have a clue as to what he is talking about, just what he wants to be true
plagiarize
Banned
That is not what is going on.
Same Quaz51 from B3D?
It really isn't. What the fuck happened to this industry?
lol calm down buddy
I believe the 720p single player and the frame rate stutters on PS4. To me it seems like set pieces are very effects heavy and maybe the ESRam solution on Xbox One is better at that one thing, remember it does have a higher theoretical throughput so you could optimise it for known scripted events which seems to be a CoD special these days.
There is a clear color temperature difference in released shots and I am never sure why, Xbox is warmer and PS4 is cooler. PS4 is probably more realistic but not necessarily always better.
The multiplayer stuff we have looks much better on the PS4 even in shitty YouTube. My guess is without the Hollywood style effects the power advantage in the PS4 allows the higher resolution without tripping like a toddler because there are no scripted events.
Obviously we need to wait and see what real world testing says. Do reviewers have access to online play on PS4 right now?
There is a clear color temperature difference in released shots and I am never sure why, Xbox is warmer and PS4 is cooler. PS4 is probably more realistic but not necessarily always better.
The multiplayer stuff we have looks much better on the PS4 even in shitty YouTube. My guess is without the Hollywood style effects the power advantage in the PS4 allows the higher resolution without tripping like a toddler because there are no scripted events.
Obviously we need to wait and see what real world testing says. Do reviewers have access to online play on PS4 right now?
Did you have a look at the 1080p IGN comparison video? It features both MP and SP footage for both versions of the game.
Mr Moose
Member
It doesn't. You set the dropdown "profile" to HD 720 or HD 1080 then the slider from good to best.
The highest it will capture in 720p (set to best) is 15Mbps, 30 on 1080p.
maabus1999
Member
Souns good but honestly your first glance is the most probable theory by far of what is happening with the screenshots/videos.
It makes complete sense.
if that the case...after the resolutiongate...this would be seriously hilarious......i calling IW mediocre developer from the day one...im not the one who was going to take cod as proof of power....
if is a mistake..who did the mistake..should be ashamed...
i think we will know soon enough the truth
redwolflim
Neo Member
If this is the case, I bet the IW team were on crack while making this game
Metallix87
Member
This game as a whole is proof that something is seriously wrong over at IW.
Multi is graphically more light than Solo (FX, post-process) = more ressource aviable.
Probably not enough for upgrade resolution on Xone (just enough for stabilise framerate) but for PS4 yes. the good compromise probably was a 900p upgrade for preserve the framerate but 900p need upscale with bad ratio, is tantalizing to push until 1080p for avoid upscale and offer a perfectly sharp image
yeah all their talent went to Respawn.
maabus1999
Member
Destiny better sell 10 million copies or ATVI will be feeling it; because it is more and more looking like the COD brand has sustained some damage.
GribbleGrunger
Dreams in Digital
I just didn't word it right. That's what I meant.
Chobel
Member
J-P some people were ready to part with hard earned money to buy the PS4 version believing in a complete 1080p experience. £50 quid! 1/7th of the PS4's price. With Quaz51's temporary analysis, if it becomes official it means IW/Activision lied straight to our faces. That's not nice man and definitely not funny as insinuated by TheKayle.
yes
Man, oh fucking man! The epic evolution of this thread is proof of how great NeoGAF is.
I'm a PS4 fan, and actually have a copy of Call of Duty: Ghosts in my hand right now. But I still find this whole saga incredibly entertaining. Better than watching a movie.
At least the MP, which is the most important part, is still 1080p. But depending on the framerate analyses, and just how inconsistent the framerate is in MP, I may just return my copy of the game, and opt for BF4 instead.
J-P some people were ready to part with hard earned money to buy the PS4 version believing in a complete 1080p experience. £50 quid! 1/7th of the PS4's price. With Quaz51's temporary analysis, if it becomes official it means IW/Activision lied straight to out faces. That's not nice man and definitely not funny as insinuated by TheKayle.
listen close the browser....play the game forget about resolutions if u bought it for what it is...and not to count the pixels im sure you will get fun ...
that is the only way where u can get fun from videogaming....
yes but seem captured in 1080i. despite that it confirm
phosphor112
Banned
I don't know if this was pointed out, but older COD games don't downsample at lower resolutions, but in fact renders at the lower resolution itself. It was one of the few games that got better performance from decreasing the res down to 480p instead of 720p.
the problem here is there are just too many variables...and people are taking absolutely blind stabs in the dark at what is the cause of the issue because there is really no evidence to suggest WHAT is wrong, only that SOMETHING is wrong...
as of right now there is just nothing to go on...and wild speculation does nothing but cause the people who dont actually bother to READ an entire thread (so many people) to go bananas...
as of right now there is just nothing to go on...and wild speculation does nothing but cause the people who dont actually bother to READ an entire thread (so many people) to go bananas...
J-P some people were ready to part with hard earned money to buy the PS4 version believing in a complete 1080p experience. £50 quid! 1/7th of the PS4's price. With Quaz51's temporary analysis, if it becomes official it means IW/Activision lied straight to out faces. That's not nice man and definitely not funny as insinuated by TheKayle.
Trust me, I know. I cancelled my XB1 pre-order and will be hunting for a PS4 tomorrow because of the whole "resolutiongate". I'm just hoping there is a viable reason for all this.
Very interesting. Thanks for the insight.
Does that mean that the framerate is more inconsistent in single-player for the Xbox One than the PS4? If they both run at 720p, I would assume the more powerful PS4 can achieve a smoother framerate.
redwolflim
Neo Member
Until we have the games on our hand and analysis them, we wont know what's going on. I trust the neogaf members resolution analysis more than any of the journalists' news. But what I can tell is once the PS4 and Xbox release....
Chobel
Member
Can you analyse this? PS4 multiplayer gameplay video from the eurogamer Spain http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I89i0XxqmDs[/QUOTE]
Call of Duty lost its essence long ago. I was not going to buy it at launch, but now there's no chance.
Prime example of what I'm saying.
Sapphire Dreams
Member
One day we'll all look back at this and laugh.
I personally don't care about COD and none of us will care for Ghosts by the time the next one is announced.
I personally don't care about COD and none of us will care for Ghosts by the time the next one is announced.
phosphor112
Banned
Didn't realize that Quaz chimed in... that's really odd.
The scenario, not him posting, lol.
The scenario, not him posting, lol.
PdotMichael
Banned
Gratz you're colorblind (for real)
It matters insofar as having massive bragging rights on your console of choice about having the superior version of the biggest FPS of the year. There's still an advantage, but it's somewhat diminished now.
Oh well, at least there's always Battlefield 4 to brag about.
