-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Animal Crossing Mafia |OT| - Making Animal Friends Is Awesome!
- Thread starter Karkador
- Start date
RobotNinjaHornets
Banned
Damnit Kark I'm dying here hurry up
DAY 6 ENDS
Total Votes for this Round (8 needed for majority)
(a
The Top 2 voted will be evicted today
Ourobolus (5)
Haly
RetroGamer42
Darryl
RobotNinjaHornets
kingkitty
Haly (0)
RobotNinjaHornets (0)
kingkitty (6)
EzekelRAGE
squidyj
franconp
Razmos
ultron87
nin1000
No Evict (3)
Timeaisis
tomakasatnav
Ourobolus
Karkador said:
Karkador said:
NIGHT 6 BEGINS
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
He was one of the good ones.
Yeah I figured they'd get haly because they wouldnt be able to get him next night. I for one am glad to be alive.
I was hoping everyone could give me their top 2 town and top 2 mafia then I'll give mine.
Additionally
Franconp, I'd really like the list of people you investigated each night with a short justification for why you chose to investigate them.
Nin.... what was with those votes? please explain.
I was hoping everyone could give me their top 2 town and top 2 mafia then I'll give mine.
Additionally
Franconp, I'd really like the list of people you investigated each night with a short justification for why you chose to investigate them.
Nin.... what was with those votes? please explain.
R.I.P Haly Even though i thought you were Town i now know for sure that you were town alligned.
I just was not sure who to vote for since both of them seemed like a good choice.
Well i know for sure that i stirred up the pittpull aka you
I just was not sure who to vote for since both of them seemed like a good choice.
Well i know for sure that i stirred up the pittpull aka you
R.I.P Haly Even though i thought you were Town i now know for sure that you were town alligned.
I just was not sure who to vote for since both of them seemed like a good choice.
Well i know for sure that i stirred up the pittpull aka you
you voted no evict, ouro, and kitty, you were whirling all over the place.
I'd still like to hear your top town and mafia.
Since there are just only 10 players left including me i will have to go for those
Top Town
Retrogamer42 - I Doubt that there would be 2 Mafia players in one gossip chat, since Ouro is now dead this puts Retro high up in my list as he being Town alligned.
Timeasis - Only because he was confirmed by Franconp
Top Mafia
Ultron87 . Pretty much the obvious choice even though we would lose Franconp
Tomakasatnav - Too quiet for my sake . thats why i call HHA on him
how can you have someone who is confirmed by franconp as a top town without putting franconp in your top town?
Since i dont know that he is town , he could be mafia aswell but i dont mind that since he is helping us.
you think timeaisis has been a particularly helpful town member? moreso than Razmos or RNH?
EzekelRAGE
Member
My bad King :-(
Think we can all agree Ult is Timmy? So we on the lookout for the lost partner. As far as who today. Maybe Nin with his flip flopping from yesterday, but not sure. Only note I made about nin in relation to our/hobo was they all voted on one day within ten minutes of each other.
Looking at the map, maybe darryl, unless there are no HHA in top row.
I'm suspicious of Nin for obvious reasons, but I can't tell if he is trying to block us on purpose or if he really is just playing badly.
But then again, I was having the same dilemma with Ourobolus and his claim about having a useful ability that he never used to help the town. He was either mafia or a bad town player, and we all know how that turned out.
Nin posted a lot of flavour-text at the beginning about coffee and stuff, he got "in character" more than anyone else did, and now we obviously know that the HHA are Animal Crossing characters.
But then again, I was having the same dilemma with Ourobolus and his claim about having a useful ability that he never used to help the town. He was either mafia or a bad town player, and we all know how that turned out.
Nin posted a lot of flavour-text at the beginning about coffee and stuff, he got "in character" more than anyone else did, and now we obviously know that the HHA are Animal Crossing characters.
Top Town:
EzekielRAGE: I think he's been very useful so far, and I have no real suspicion towards him at all.
RobotNinjaHornet: Pretty much the same.
Top Mafia:
Nin1000: his actions speak pretty loudly, and his position on the map is also pretty suspect in my opinion.
Ultron: for much the same reason as everybody else.
Unsure:
Tomas: He barely posts and I can't get a read on him at all, which is frustrating this late into the game. I don't like having him "there" and knowing nothing about him.
I might have misread this post the first time around, You're saying you think Franconp might be HHA but is helping town by giving investigation checks? if you think he might be hha why would you trust his checks so much? and why Timeaisis out of all of the checks that he's done?
I think me and franconp are a two for one deal at this point. Why would he clear me if he was mafia? Unless he was trying to gain the towns trust (which doesn't really make sense since none of you know whether or not I'm town to begin with)?
That being said, I think fran is town.
I guess for me, top town would be:
Fran - I was hesitant at first, but he's been consistent.
RNH - No reason to suspect. Helpful this game.
Razmos - I have no reason to suspect him
Don't really have any top mafia, but I'm suspect of toma and Ultron.
That being said, I think fran is town.
I guess for me, top town would be:
Fran - I was hesitant at first, but he's been consistent.
RNH - No reason to suspect. Helpful this game.
Razmos - I have no reason to suspect him
Don't really have any top mafia, but I'm suspect of toma and Ultron.
I like you.
I don't think it's a leap to say he was trying to gain town's trust, even though we don't know if you're town you can say "yes that's my role" and confirm his ability and lend credence to his story, I absolutely believe that he has the power he says he has but I don't find your argument for being a package deal compelling.
I don't like you.
I think you're scum but I still like you :3
Hmmmm that's true, I will have to overthink my list that I made up in less than 5 minutes.
.jpg/220px-Pitbull_the_rapper_in_Sydney,_Australia_(2012).jpg)
I guess you're not going to like the part where I point out that its weird that you only came up with your thoughts about this in the last five minutes.
It's pretty consistent with how he has been playing at least.
The hate is real with both of you , could you be mafia ?
Fair enough. Knowing, myself that I am not mafia leads me more readily to accept fran is not as well, since he is helping me out by clearing me. Of course, it all could be a ruse, as you said, but I don't exactly see what he'd gain from that. "Proving" I'm town doesn't necessarily prove he's town either, as we are demonstrating right here right now.
Lets put it like this, if he's mafia and he decides he wants to claim investigator as town, he might not ever be able to prove his alignment but he needs to prove his role and he can't out other mafia one after the other because that would be suicide, It should be expected that a mafia sided investigator will come out with accurate investigations of town members and then maybe throw a mafia teammate in there as a town check.
Ultron ability looks blatantly like a Nook sibling tbh. Kill two people at once. We don't even know if he's being honest about activating it himself. It could've triggered automatically after we evicted Hobohodo.
RobotNinjaHornets
Banned
Ok so first I WARNED YOU ALL! I TOLD YOU ALL THE ARGUMENT WAS WEAK, BUT DID YOU LISTEN? NO!
Also, losing Haly's rough. We can do this though. We're two down, I feel like there would only be 4 (last game there were 4, slightly less players this game but no apparent roleblockers and one of them wasn't grouped in with them so it seems balanced)
In terms of top HHA, I'm still thinking Timeaisis and franconp, for the reasons I've stated before.
Top town...dunno, everyone else I'm varying levels of OK with. Except nin. Seems sketchy. For example:
Why Timeaisis over me, for people who have been confirmed by franconp? Why not trust tom, when he's been confirmed as a light sleeper (which, to get into metagaming, seems like a useless role for HHA)? Why believe franconp's telling the truth about all the roles when last game I did basically the opposite?
Also, losing Haly's rough. We can do this though. We're two down, I feel like there would only be 4 (last game there were 4, slightly less players this game but no apparent roleblockers and one of them wasn't grouped in with them so it seems balanced)
In terms of top HHA, I'm still thinking Timeaisis and franconp, for the reasons I've stated before.
Top town...dunno, everyone else I'm varying levels of OK with. Except nin. Seems sketchy. For example:
Why Timeaisis over me, for people who have been confirmed by franconp? Why not trust tom, when he's been confirmed as a light sleeper (which, to get into metagaming, seems like a useless role for HHA)? Why believe franconp's telling the truth about all the roles when last game I did basically the opposite?
I apologise for any incoherency, I'm drunk and knackered. Nearly fell asleep when watching Terminator 2 in the cinema. Feel free to evict me for that because that is a goddamned awful thing to do
RobotNinjaHornets
Banned
Also, it would've been fucking hilarious if we'd all actually gone with Ouro at the beginning instead of no evicting
how do you feel about Darryl? He's been really erratic and basically just lashing out at people without much substance, he posted here today but the only thing he addressed was nin's ultron read which is a little weird to me. I used to think he was confused town but I'm wondering if that's just a smokescreen, I said something about mafia within the circle of himself, ouro and hobohodo and he blew up and just completely refused to address the premise of my statement, instead trying to push it back on me and call me mafia. At the time we didn't know that 2 out of those 3 were mafia but looking back on it the interaction seems strange to me, like he was just being evasive.
RobotNinjaHornets
Banned
Honestly, I've been writing him off because of the aggression, but he is pretty high up on the list. You got a link to that post?
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=166942257&postcount=1691
I might be overselling it as 'blowing up' but he was incredibly hostile to the idea. He follows up on the next page.
That's pretty much the gist of the conversation, I also find the ironing of that last quote to be quite delicious.
I'm hot on the case. I blew up because your initial half-assed posts were absolutely not cutting it. Yea, we know Ouro is HHA now. But we didn't then. And your argument against him was like literally 7 words, something about feels. At that point it looked like you were HHA since you photo copied Haly's reads and didn't appear to have read the thread yourself. I let it all go once it looked like you were paying attention, even if I had to force it onto you.