• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Anonymous hackers detail PSN privacy concerns (when using CFW)

Status
Not open for further replies.

MThanded

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
androvsky said:
Nobody with cfw is connecting to PSN to buy anything anyway, so I might as well quote this again just for the hell of it. :)
Doubtful. Even then you are running some unauthed code and it could still manually open a connection and send your info out. Same issue with custom firmware on iphone or android. I could easily write code that farms your info locally and pipes it out. When you install custom firmware you are essentially trusting that code with your local information. It is almost as bad as someone watching you type every key on a a keyboard or having direct hardware access to your computer at all time.
 

gofreak

GAF's Bob Woodward
They say it's stored in plaintext, but it is a shame they don't elaborate on that.

I would have assumed your CC info would be sent once to their servers when you add your CC info, and they then store it on their end (?) How would they know how its stored on the other side?

Also if they're using SSL it's not entirely correct to say they transmit them 'in the clear', the SSL holes mentioned notwithstanding. They are encrypting them, but the PDF calls for encryption upon encryption. And given the...err..tone of the PDF, even if Sony did encrypt this info again people could probably claim it's not 100% secure anyway - given that we've seen apparently impenetrable encryption fail before.

edit - beaten anyway on that.
 

Archaix

Drunky McMurder
MThanded said:
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!




They still use https to transmit the data. The issue is if you have a CFW you can be snooped and your info can be stolen. Unless someone man in the middles your https handshake you are fine. Someone should fix the title.


Well, yeah, but aside from the security they're using, Sony isn't using any security at all! PANIC GO!
 

Rolf NB

Member
"SONY is only relying on
it's https connection. With all those CFWs spreading around, this is not secure anymore."


So basically, if I don't do CFW, and I don't, this doesn't affect me. Good to know.
 
MThanded said:
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!




They still use https to transmit the data. The issue is if you have a CFW you can be snooped and your info can be stolen. Unless someone man in the middles your https handshake you are fine. Someone should fix the title.
By Grabthar's Hammer, you shall be quoted.
 
MThanded said:
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!




They still use https to transmit the data. The issue is if you have a CFW you can be snooped and your info can be stolen. Unless someone man in the middles your https handshake you are fine. Someone should fix the title.
Quoted so we aren't running around like hens with out heads chopped off.
 

Carl

Member
MThanded said:
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!




They still use https to transmit the data. The issue is if you have a CFW you can be snooped and your info can be stolen. Unless someone man in the middles your https handshake you are fine. Someone should fix the title.

Needs quoting more.
 

MThanded

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
N.A said:
Yeah, my fault. Didn't read the full PDF.
Yeah you really jumped the gun on this one. I came in here about to setup some packet capturing and test this out myself. I would not put it past them or any other company. Security is an art not a science. Things are inherently insecure.
 

herod

Member
True or false, I could go and buy a second hand PS3 and if the previous owner didn't wipe it, I could dump his cleartext credit card info from the HDD?
 

LiquidMetal14

hide your water-based mammals
herod said:
True or false, I could go and buy a second hand PS3 and if the previous owner didn't wipe it, I could dump his cleartext credit card info from the HDD?
Read the thread :)
 

Clott

Member
MThanded said:
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!




They still use https to transmit the data. The issue is if you have a CFW you can be snooped and your info can be stolen. Unless someone man in the middles your https handshake you are fine. Someone should fix the title.




quotequotequotequotequotequote
 
Besides, soon there will be a custom firmware maker released, so you will no longer have to rely on downloading said shady firmwares (if they even exist). Make your own!
 

MThanded

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
herod said:
True or false, I could go and buy a second hand PS3 and if the previous owner didn't wipe it, I could dump his cleartext credit card info from the HDD?
Possibly. But you could just buy shit from their account anyway. If they did not wipe you have free reign on their psn account and associated credit card access.
 
N.A said:
Yeah, my fault. Didn't read the full PDF.
OP didn't read OP?

I guess this Sony PR another reason to say Custom firmware is bad. But it also goes to with custom firmware you put full trust into the person releasing it that they've release da working product and not some buggy piece of crap that will brick you just to be the first (didn't the latter already happen with the PS3).
 

N.A

Banned
Some other interesting privacy stuff in that pdf though. I'll edit the OP but can't fix the title.
 

LiquidMetal14

hide your water-based mammals
I NEED SCISSORS said:
Besides, soon there will be a custom firmware maker released, so you will no longer have to rely on said shady firmwares. Make your own!
I want that one guy who lives behind the 7-11's firmware. You know, the one who sells crack behind the dumpster at Burgler King at 2am. His is rock solid compared to Sony's!


For the record, I never store my CC info on these consoles. I will input it every time. Come on now folks, smarten up.
 

androvsky

Member
N.A said:
Yeah, my fault. Didn't read the full PDF.

The https connection was mentioned in what you originally quoted.

The credit card information should ALWAYS be encrypted. In ANY case. At least the security code. SONY is only relying on
it's https connection.
With all those CFWs spreading around, this is not secure anymore.

That said, Sony should use multiple layers of encryption. I get the impression that IBM's impressive security setup with the Cell made Sony incredibly lax on their side.
 

Rolf NB

Member
herod said:
True or false, I could go and buy a second hand PS3 and if the previous owner didn't wipe it, I could dump his cleartext credit card info from the HDD?
Pretty sure it's never stored on your HDD in the first place.
 

MThanded

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
Xater said:
"Junior Member"
Maybe someone can unjunior me. They rejuniored me like a year ago. He and I can trade places. LOL (i know its not going to happen)
 

LiK

Member
MThanded said:
Yeah you really jumped the gun on this one. I came in here about to setup some packet capturing and test this out myself. I would not put it past them or any other company. Security is an art not a science. Things are inherently insecure.
You should be a Member for this.
 

darkwing

Member
MThanded said:
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!
this thread title is incorrect!!!




They still use https to transmit the data. The issue is if you have a CFW you can be snooped and your info can be stolen. Unless someone man in the middles your https handshake you are fine. Someone should fix the title.

smh
 

Jinfash

needs 2 extra inches
captmcblack said:
Lock this thread, make a new one with correct/non-fud info or not at all.
Ugh, please. The info in that PDF is pretty interesting. Just edit the title, and we're good. Put down those, I SAID PUT DOWN THOSE TORCHES!
 

Foffy

Banned
MThanded said:
Doubtful. Even then you are running some unauthed code and it could still manually open a connection and send your info out. Same issue with custom firmware on iphone or android. I could easily write code that farms your info locally and pipes it out. When you install custom firmware you are essentially trusting that code with your local information. It is almost as bad as someone watching you type every key on a a keyboard or having direct hardware access to your computer at all time.

But couldn't disabling any connection the PS3 has to online connectivity nip this in the behind? I figure nothing but could be transferred if the system is prevented from connecting online.
 

MThanded

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
Foffy said:
But couldn't disabling any connection the PS3 has to online connectivity nip this in the behind? I figure nothing but could be transferred if the system is prevented from connecting online.
If you have a CFW then the firmware can fake you not being connected and still leak your info. Best to unplug from ethernet and remove all wifi passwords. If you use an OS written by me then all bets are off about what is going on behind the scenes.

Also i am fairly certain your CC info is on psn. Because you can link it online. I need to know more about the internals to be certain.
 

N.A

Banned
Updated the OP, the stuff in the PDF still raises some interesting points.

Sorry for jumping the gun :-\
 

LiquidMetal14

hide your water-based mammals
herod said:
I did, it's not clear. I'm not talking about the network transmission.
I'm not a high level expert but I was mainly concerning the misinformation in the title.

Is the short story basically that CFW is not good for security or what?
 
MThanded said:
Maybe someone can unjunior me. They rejuniored me like a year ago. He and I can trade places. LOL (i know its not going to happen)

kanyecry.gif
 
Dreamgazer said:
uh. a bit excessive considering N.A.'s overall contribution to this CFW thing.

Moral of the story. . .don't fuck up. If you are going to make a thread about something as big as this, do the research before posting it. Everyone knows GAF has lurking journos ready to pounce on anything for a story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom