Funny that what you listed as advantages in XB's favor are actually working against image quality.
That's why I put them under question mark. Not all people like that look. If anyone has followed my posts on here or on AVS/AV forums they know I'm pretty in to my videophile stuff. Rocking a Pioneer Kuro fully calibrated, and run it with sharpness and all other post processing off. Also have all my mobiles, such as my S4, set to the mode which gives me closest to D65 colour temp (which happens to be Movie mode).
Can't stand edge enhancements, edge halo'ing and all that dynamic bollocks. It's part of the reason I went plasma over LCD, and also partly why I have my set calibrated.
I would not say that bad AA that cause fuzzy blurry image is better then slightly jagged edges
You can always add sharpness on your TV if you want to bring out the details. You can see in the comparison shots on previous pages, sharpness and a bit of contrast is all that is needed to give it that look. But the source image should not have these artificial enhancements applied. The PS4 version essentially looks the same as the PC version minus some minute detailing, the Xbox One version on the other hand looks completely different. It's obvious the XO version is the outlier, and not how the game was intended to look. Rather the result of enhancements done to improve upon the 720p resolution.