• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF Reads Stephen King's It

I've just started this for the first time, always been interested in the book and haven't seen the miniseries. Also my first Stephen King novel, lol.

Up to Chapter 3, it's very creepy. I also like the idea of starting in 1957, it shows just how that first murder affected the entire town of Derry. Slightly confused as to the learning the characters names so far, but I'm sure I'll get used to it lol.
Cool, hope it interests you enough to check out his other books
 
My first Stephen King Novel was Dreamcatcher. I enjoyed it alot.

If I recall... the order I went in was something like

Dreamcatcher
The Stand (top 3 book for me)
The Gunslinger
Drawing of the Three
Wastelands
Wizard and Glass
IT
Tommyknockers
Wolves of the calla
Song of Susannah
The dark tower

Been a while. What else should I read?
 

JaseMath

Member
Just finished. Kinda of overrated if you ask me. Very bloated in parts as well. The
gang bang at the end
was literally the most cringe-worthy thing I've ever read in my life.
 
My first Stephen King Novel was Dreamcatcher. I enjoyed it alot.

If I recall... the order I went in was something like

Dreamcatcher
The Stand (top 3 book for me)
The Gunslinger
Drawing of the Three
Wastelands
Wizard and Glass
IT
Tommyknockers
Wolves of the calla
Song of Susannah
The dark tower

Been a while. What else should I read?
Misery
The Long Walk
Salem's Lot
Night Shift
Skeleton Crew
Carrie
 
Re: Your spoilers.
I think it's more one girl taking turns with boys, the power dynamic is definitely with Beverley. From memory she is the one who encourages some of the boys who are not sure about it.
But it's been about 20 years since I read it, so I'm off to grab my copy and start now.

That's actually an interesting distinction - I'll have to pay attention to how it's framed when I get there again.
 

GhaleonEB

Member
I was introduced to King via his short stories. Skeleton Crew and Night Shift in particular. I still go back and read those stories now and then. Those were followed by:

It
Salem's Lot
The Stand
Pet Sematary
Dreamcatcher
Insomnia

I read a few others after, but not many. I might pick up more of his work after getting through IT again.

Confession: when I was a kid I skipped the Interludes. Read a few pages, got bored, skipped'em as optional world building. Something I was curious about now that I'm reading it at age 40 was whether I'd appreciate them more.

Having gone through the first Interlude last night, the answer is a resounding "yes". They're fantastic world building, but also much more tightly tied into the narrative fabric of the story than I thought they were, when I read the story 20+ years ago. This first one did double duty as Mike's introductory chapter, weaving in a great deal of his character and personality through the voice used, which is distinctive from the first three chapters.

Living in a small town now for 13 years has just made all the small town history that much more interesting.
 
I'm reading It right now and I don't know.. It's reallyyy slow for me during the child sections. About 1/4 through and the boys just built a dam recently and I'm like, ok?

Ya.
 
I'm reading It right now and I don't know.. It's reallyyy slow for me during the child sections. About 1/4 through and the boys just built a dam recently and I'm like, ok?

Ya.
The story, the pay off, and sense of danger doesn't work if you don't see the bond develop and the friendship form between the group. It's like the most important and critical element of the narrative
 

Garlador

Member
I only just got my copy in the mail, so I'm just up to Bev's introductory chapter. Each character introduction is wonderfully unique how the "call" affects them in different ways. For some, it's the worst thing ever, while for others it puts their current problems back into perspective. For Stan, it's something he just refuses to deal with, while for Beverly, it's something that has her fight back against the overbearing abuse that defines her life.

Very interesting, and human, way to show them reacting to the news.
 

Jarmel

Banned
Finally finished the audiobook last night. God damn that was long. My initial reaction is that I hope they heavily rewrite the adult segments for the second movie. There's a lot of good stuff in there but anything involving Bev besides Tom Rogan was awful. Bev doesn't really serve a purpose at the end other than for
Bill to fuck her in some sort of weird self-insert writing
. It's not just her though, Ben doesn't really do much other than
egg stomp.
I also think the adult sections aren't as scary and kind of flat. There are some great moments such as the library fight and the Kersh visit but it's not enough and pales in comparison to the childhood scenes.

The Ritual of Chud itself was great in both eras. It has a sort of cosmic wonder to it and should look insane if filmed properly. I hope they nail it visually as I always love these sort of mind fights.
 
I started too! Gonna be slow going because I have a lot of stuff going on, but I'll get through it eventually. Pretty good so far, although I'm just past the intro chapters. First Stephen King in a while. He's so easy to read.
 
Finally finished the audiobook last night. God damn that was long. My initial reaction is that I hope they heavily rewrite the adult segments for the second movie. There's a lot of good stuff in there but anything involving Bev besides Tom Rogan was awful. Bev doesn't really serve a purpose at the end other than for
Bill to fuck her in some sort of weird self-insert writing
. It's not just her though, Ben doesn't really do much other than
egg stomp.
I also think the adult sections aren't as scary and kind of flat. There are some great moments such as the library fight and the Kersh visit but it's not enough and pales in comparison to the childhood scenes.

The Ritual of Chud itself was great in both eras. It has a sort of cosmic wonder to it and should look insane if filmed properly. I hope they nail it visually as I always love these sort of mind fights.
I think the adult movie could work more as a psychological thriller/drama that has horror elements gradually bleed into it, rather than a straight horror movie
 

Jarmel

Banned
I think the adult movie could work more as a psychological thriller/drama that has horror elements gradually bleed into it, rather than a straight horror movie
I could see that working but they need to rewrite Bev completely once she arrives in Derry. Both Ben and Bill could do with one too. That's the thing I liked the least about the adult segments in that certain characters didn't feel as useful or needed (Bev and Ben). The childhood segments had everybody serving a clear purpose.

Also there weren't what I would deem as necessary emotional confrontations. Bev needed to meet Rogan one last time and overcome him. Similarly I felt Ben needed to do the same with Henry. It does give Eddie a good moment but he gets one later during the second Ritual.

I'm not sure how they're going to handle Mike as a lot of his characterization comes in the Interludes, which are damn great.
 
Just finished chapter 17. This was the most chilling chapter for me since the opening with Georgie.
Reading the descriptions of the dog being slowly suffocated were enough to have me turning away at a few spots. Also, despite Patrick being an absolute psycho, his vision of Leeches was terrifying. Especially the one that exploded blood and pus in his mouth, it'll make for an insane visual if the movie follows suit. His death was the most disturbing thus far.
 

SteveMeister

Hang out with Steve.
My wife and I have been listening to the Audible version, narrated amazingly well be Steven Weber. We're well into the book -
the adults are all in Derry, and they've had their lunch at the Chinese restaurant and I think we just finished the last of their individual encounters but they haven't yet made it back to the library for their planned evening meeting.

It has been many years since I first read the book, which was right about the time it came out, so I was 22 or 23. Listening to it now at 52, I'm definitely getting a lot more out of the book as a whole, and I identify more with the adults' stories than I did back then. Such an amazing story.

I highly recommend the Audible book. It's fantastic.
 

Garlador

Member
Slow going, but I just finished Bev's chapter with the sink...

You can really see how the main cast is being pushed together, heading towards that inevitable confrontation.
 

bgbball31

Member
I am going to have to speed read this if I'm going to get it done by the time the movie comes out. Just finished up the phone calls. Really like it so far though.
 

Garlador

Member
Finished up the interlude with the bank robber shoot out.

Feels like all the pieces are in place now. The cast is all assembled and there's nothing left but the death-march towards the inevitable confrontation.
 

Kopite

Member
Reading this after watching the movie. First piece of fiction I've read in almost a year. About 3-4 chapters in, it's unreal
how angry Beverly's chapter with her abusive husband made me feel. I'd forgotten how much books can affect you like that.
 

Dead Man

Member
Finished up the interlude with the bank robber shoot out.

Feels like all the pieces are in place now. The cast is all assembled and there's nothing left but the death-march towards the inevitable confrontation.
Forgot about that interlude. They really make the book for me.
 

Takyon

Member
Finished the book.
I haven't watched the new movie yet, but I caught the Georgie scene and it seems to lack this little technique King uses in the novel.

So, the moments in the novel that spooked me the most was Stanley's wife finding his body, Pennywise grabbing Georgie from the drain and Pennywise's face becoming the moon. In all three of those moments there is a moment where time slows to a crawl and King details the response of the character in some abstract way, prior to the reader discovering what they're terrified/horrified of. Henry screams or rage morph into wild, unthinking fear, Stanley's wife stares in shock and then screams in horror and georgie, in that small moment between Pennywise grabbing his arm and his death, see's something so terrible his sanity is destroyed.I found this really effective, as in that moment, my imagination came up with something worse than the book could ever describe.

The Georgie scene seems to lack that moment, which is seems like a shame.
 

Shadybiz

Member
Just started a re-read after not having read it for like 20 years (yeah...I'm old). It will be slow-going, since the wife and I are sharing the book, but I'm definitely looking forward to getting into it again. Saw the movie yesterday (which I thought was excellent), so it will be cool to compare the two, since I've forgotten quite a bit about the book in 2 decades.
 
Finished the book.
I haven't watched the new movie yet, but I caught the Georgie scene and it seems to lack this little technique King uses in the novel.

So, the moments in the novel that spooked me the most was Stanley's wife finding his body, Pennywise grabbing Georgie from the drain and Pennywise's face becoming the moon. In all three of those moments there is a moment where time slows to a crawl and King details the response of the character in some abstract way, prior to the reader discovering what they're terrified/horrified of. Henry screams or rage morph into wild, unthinking fear, Stanley's wife stares in shock and then screams in horror and georgie, in that small moment between Pennywise grabbing his arm and his death, see's something so terrible his sanity is destroyed.I found this really effective, as in that moment, my imagination came up with something worse than the book could ever describe.

The Georgie scene seems to lack that moment, which is seems like a shame.
That's something that you can do that in books that you can't do in film
 

Laieon

Member
Just started reading it. Only about 150 pages in so far. I've seen both movies and know most of the major things that weren't in them, but I'm enjoying it none the less. This will be my first King book, thinking about checking out Carrie after this.
 

GhaleonEB

Member
Why does IT just take small bites kff its victims if it wants to feed?

Remember there are a lot of missing kids as well.
For everyone It maims or takes bites out of, even more are largely devoured. You'll see more of this as you go.
 

bloodydrake

Cool Smoke Luke
My first Stephen King Novel was Dreamcatcher. I enjoyed it alot.

If I recall... the order I went in was something like

Dreamcatcher
The Stand (top 3 book for me)
The Gunslinger
Drawing of the Three
Wastelands
Wizard and Glass
IT
Tommyknockers
Wolves of the calla
Song of Susannah
The dark tower

Been a while. What else should I read?

Your Missing Duma Key, and 11 22 63, as stand out recent King stories
 
I decided to join everyone as i havnt read it in about 8 years. Went to pull my og hardback from the shelf and the dust jacket is in pieces!!

A few kids got some splainin to do.
 

bgbball31

Member
Haven't been able to get near the amount of reading in I had wanted to, but I just finished The Black Spot interlude and woof, that was rough to read.
 

Wollan

Member
Had two reading sessions so far and I'm currently on page ~150. Very intriguing so far.
My first Stephen King book I will finish (tried the first Dark Tower but it became a bore).
 
I'm halfway into this now around the point where they all have gross fortune cookies. I'm not loving it. I don't read a lot of Stephen King but his writing style annoys me, I don't know. Like sometimes there's a section which seems super phoned in and other sections are obviously much better.
 

lunchtoast

Member
Switched over the mostly audio this week because it'll take too long to read. Steven Weber does a great job with all the voices. Must have been a challenge with all that stuttering dialogue. Never read it before, but whenever a scary scene happens I just think back to the miniseries and the mood is ruined.
 

Boem

Member
I'm halfway into this now around the point where they all have gross fortune cookies. I'm not loving it. I don't read a lot of Stephen King but his writing style annoys me, I don't know. Like sometimes there's a section which seems super phoned in and other sections are obviously much better.

I'm not sure what his situation was while he was writing this book, but he has talked about this himself. Part of it is just that he's a writing machine - this comes from the fact that he started out very poor and with a family to feed, and really had to pump out short stories for a couple of hundred bucks a pop to survive. He's well off now of course, but that drive is still there. His output is pretty insane - with some years even having 3 or 4 books, along with other stuff.

Also, he has had periods where he was heavily addicted to alcohol/cocaine etc, which he admitted affected his writing in places.

Overall, the end result is that the quality of his work can vary pretty wildly depending on where his life was at, but that it's all very easy/quick to read at the same time. It's not a surprise that a lot of people get into his writing in their teens as he can be a master at carrying you to the next page while sticking to fairly approachable language.

It's been 15 years or so since I read It myself so I can't remember exactly what I thought of the book, although it does stick out as one of my personal favorites in my memory. I also hope this doesn't read as a condemnation of King - I'm really a fan and very impressed by his career. But he did have some inevitable moments where he slipped a bit.
 
My first Stephen King Novel was Dreamcatcher. I enjoyed it alot.

If I recall... the order I went in was something like

Dreamcatcher
The Stand (top 3 book for me)
The Gunslinger
Drawing of the Three
Wastelands
Wizard and Glass
IT
Tommyknockers
Wolves of the calla
Song of Susannah
The dark tower

Been a while. What else should I read?

I noticed you're banned now but felt I would add in The Shining and Salems Lot. I am not big on vampires but still loved Salems Lot.
 

bgbball31

Member
Just finished up the third interlude, with Al Bradley, and am going to be happy to be back with the kids. Some of the adult portions got really slow, and I'm really unsure how it is going to work in the movie. It literally seemed like aimless walking at some points, and obviously (to those that have read it)
they are all on their own for this whole section after the scene with the fortune cookies, with some of their interactions with It out in public. I can see Bev's scene being effective, and Ben's in the library, but Eddie's at the baseball field and Richie's with Paul Bunyon I don't see translating to the screen very well.

I'm probably just not imaginative enough, but I have a hard time seeing how to make effective horror scenes out of those, without the narrative and flow of the film feeling exceedingly broken up.
 

hampig

Member
Question from somebody who much prefers audiobooks. Where can I find this? On amazon it says the audible version is no longer available. Do I have to buy the CDs? I don't want to subscribe to any service if possible and I'd prefer a version on my phone so I can listen on the bus.
 

Elandyll

Banned
I'm about to re read the book (haven't done so in probably 15+ years), but something said in the film thread as comparison vs the miniseries makes me hesitate...

Someone basically said that in the book
Adult Bev fucks Bill because of the crush they had in their childhood, which in my memory -allegedly tinted by the miniseries- doesn't make sense, because of the whole Bill/ Audra plot, and the Bev/ Ben setup
. I don't remember that happening at all in fact.

If that actually does happen in the book, I might pass I think.
 

Leeness

Member
I'm about to re read the book (haven't done so in probably 15+ years), but something said in the film thread as comparison vs the miniseries makes me hesitate...

Someone basically said that in the book
Adult Bev fucks Bill because of the crush they had in their childhood, which in my memory -allegedly tinted by the miniseries- doesn't make sense, because of the whole Bill/ Audra plot, and the Bev/ Ben setup
. I don't remember that happening at all in fact.

If that actually does happen in the book, I might pass I think.

Yep... it's a fairly passing thing though and is pretty much never mentioned again.

Question from somebody who much prefers audiobooks. Where can I find this? On amazon it says the audible version is no longer available. Do I have to buy the CDs? I don't want to subscribe to any service if possible and I'd prefer a version on my phone so I can listen on the bus.

Should be fine on audible?

https://mobile.audible.com/pd/Fiction/It-Audiobook/B019WPM4ZM/?ref=msw_search_c1_0_1_AL

Maybe you just clicked on a weird version :)
 

Dec

Member
My opinion on the book was good until the end. The final 10% was an absolute shit show. Paced like shit as well.

Soured the entire thing.
 

bgbball31

Member
I didn't think Bowers could be topped, but then I met
Patrick
.
Patrick
is a whole other level. That dude is just all kinds of messed up. Just about done with the part 4.
 
Top Bottom