Man, I'm definitely on the side that's getting tired of Arin. He's ruining new playthroughs. Not just because of his bad "no game should ever tell me what to do ever, or have any text for me to read at all" attitude that he thinks is both funny and justified (it's not). It's also the fact that he plays ahead and ruins a big reason why people would even watch the show in the first place. Him playing ahead in Zelda is one of the worst things he could do. Him knowing exactly what to to do and exactly who every character is at all times ruins the fun and the purpose of watching them play through the game for the first time. I'm sure I'm not the only one who was excited to see their first interaction with the Yiga clan, but nope! He doesn't have any surprise, and basically makes it impossible for Danny to have any, which ruins the moment and brings the whole show down. The show isn't just about listening to Arin recycle jokes.
The least he could do if he's going to play ahead is not explain to Danny every single thing he's going to do, where every character is, how every quest plays out before they finish it. At least then we could get something out of the series. But even then I don't think he should be playing ahead at all. This is his job. And sometimes you've gotta make sacrifices for your job. I understand that he might like the game and want to play it more in his off time, but really, he just shouldn't. His job is to play video games for an audience, so he needs to start taking that job more seriously like they (seemed to) back in the day. I understand that they're also supposed to be funny, but even comedians need to take the more routine bits of their job seriously like showing up on time, etc. Arin needs to respect his audience and not ruin the show for them because of his own personal desire to play ahead.