-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
NeoGAF 2013 TV Show of the Year ~Results!~
- Thread starter RatskyWatsky
- Start date
- Status
FantasticMrFoxdie
Mumber
So long Breaking Bad.
*salute*
*salute*
Deadly Cyclone
Pride of Iowa State
Wow. No Doctor Who in the top 20... Sherlock would have made it had it aired in 2013. Only shows in the top 20 I watched were Game of Thrones & House of Cards, oh and a few episodes of Breaking Bad and Orange is the new Black.
Stumpokapow
listen to the mad man
Yep, that's correct. It's a shit show. This is Liberal NeoGAF's TV Show of the Year. Real NeoGAF had their own separate thread. Top 5 was Big Bang Theory, NCIS, NCIS LA, Dexter, and South Beach Tow.
Those shows are even worse though...
I'm just not sure what people saw in it. Certainly wasn't the writing. The first couple episodes were pretty fun but it took a rather remarkable nosedive after that.
second
He's making fun of you.
firehawk12
Subete no aware
I love that my one #2 vote put Yamato in the middle of the list. lol
Too bad none of my anime brethren voted.
Too bad none of my anime brethren voted.
I know I put Treme as my #1 anyway!
I didn't see your edit until after I changed my spreadsheet, oh well. I used 4 votes as the threshold instead of 8 and greyed out the low vote shows.
Sorted By "Enthusiasm" (score / votes)
Tabs on the bottom switch between the other spreadsheets.
Stop, you're embarrassing yourself.
I'm aware of that, I'm saying that his comment made no sense. He seemed to assume I don't like Orange because I'm in the Big Bang crowd. Unless I misread him.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Glad everyone likes the thread It ended up taking me a little longer than I expected, but better late then never eh?
From the looks of it, there are quite a few shows that I need to catch up on. The problem is that there are already so many great shows on the air right now, that the prospect of starting a 106 hour long episode series (Good Wife I'm looking at you!) is extremely daunting to say the least. Arrow is one of the more manageable ones out of the bunch, but 34 episodes is still quite a time commitment. Perhaps I can sneak in an episode or two every few weeks or so.
Cool stuff, guys! Thanks for putting all that together!
It ended up taking me a little longer than I expected, but better late then never eh?From the looks of it, there are quite a few shows that I need to catch up on. The problem is that there are already so many great shows on the air right now, that the prospect of starting a 106 hour long episode series (Good Wife I'm looking at you!) is extremely daunting to say the least. Arrow is one of the more manageable ones out of the bunch, but 34 episodes is still quite a time commitment. Perhaps I can sneak in an episode or two every few weeks or so.
Cool stuff, guys! Thanks for putting all that together!
Trent Strong
Banned
I can't believe Orange is the New Black is in the top ten at all.
RepairmanJack
Member
Surprised (in a good way) at Hannibal, surprised (in a bad way) about a couple others in the top ten.
Overall pretty great list. Good work Ratsky.
Overall pretty great list. Good work Ratsky.
I love that my one #2 vote put Yamato in the middle of the list. lol
Too bad none of my anime brethren voted.
I know I put Treme as my #1 anyway!
We stay in our own thread for voting. We cannot associate ourselves with people watching show that has 3D models. 2D all the way!
Very solid list, forgot to list mine but my major votes got into the top ten, Breaking Bad, Game of Thrones, Orange is the New Black, and House of Cards. This thread reminds me that I should watch the new season of Arrow, Hannibal, and Enlightened.
WarrenMax007
Member
Maybe we should create a voting thread for Neogaf All Time Best TV show? Or something like Neogaf TV reccomendation thread?
Nice job, Ratsky. There was so much good TV last year and many of them were from the freshman class. 10 of the top 30 are new shows.
Spartacus made the top ten in the Enthusiasm ranking!
I think it was done once, almost five years ago.
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=361760
Spartacus made the top ten in the Enthusiasm ranking!
I think it was done once, almost five years ago.
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=361760
Yeah, I'm still missing Breaking Bad. I'll have to watch the show some time. I stopped watching in the middle of the first season when it originally aired, but it's been hyped so much that I need to give it another shot.
And I kind of want to rewatch The Wire in its entirety.
No idea when I can fit those in. There are too many current shows to keep up with. I should probably cut some not-so-great shows from my list, but I'm somewhat bad at just stopping shows. They might get good at any time
SHIELD is more family friendly outside of a few truly shocking moments (burned alive, the brain scene). But I'd show a kid Arrow before SHIELD just because it's a way better comic book show.
That one.
Glad everyone likes the thread
From the looks of it, there are quite a few shows that I need to catch up on. The problem is that there are already so many great shows on the air right now, that the prospect of starting a 106 hour long episode series (Good Wife I'm looking at you!) is extremely daunting to say the least. Arrow is one of the more manageable ones out of the bunch, but 34 episodes is still quite a time commitment. Perhaps I can sneak in an episode or two every few weeks or so.
I watched the entire series of The Good Wife in 4 weeks. It's possible. Just watch two or three episodes a night, you'll be done by in no time. TOTALLY worth it.
dead souls
Member
Great work Ratsky.
I can't believe I've watched every episode of 26 out of the top 30 shows.
I can't believe I've watched every episode of 26 out of the top 30 shows.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
I should probably cut some not-so-great shows from my list, but I'm somewhat bad at just stopping shows. They might get good at any time
I'm really bad at this as well. I tend to only drop shows that I dislike in a really visceral way and, (un)fortunately, all of the "not bad" shows that I watch are just that - not bad enough for me to drop.
So, it was you! >:O
Damn, I've been watching Battlestar Galactica since the beginning of January (2 episodes a day) and I still have about one season left - that's only about half of The Good Wife! You must've just blown through it!
Stumpokapow
listen to the mad man
actual results if we did a 2014 Neogaf All Time Best TV show thread:
1. breaking bad
2. game of thrones
3. the wire
4. the shield
5. seinfeld
6. talking bad
7. breaking bad
8. breaking bad season 5 part 2
9. the episode of breaking bad where shit hits the fan
10. deadwood
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
Fixed for accuracy.
Someone on SomethingAwful actually listed Talking Dead as their #1 show of the year, but I'm sure it was a troll account. But still, got a lot of people riled up.
- Status