• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

New Jersey Teacher Tells Students To Speak American Not Spanish

http://www.ibtimes.com/watch-new-jersey-teacher-tells-students-speak-american-not-spanish-2601661

A 25-second video clip recorded inside a classroom at Cliffside Park High School in New Jersey went viral this week on social media and has caused a debate. The video which surfaced on the internet on Thursday showed a teacher at the school dictating a student in a class not speak another language other than English.

"Men and women are fighting. They are not fighting for your right to speak Spanish. They are fighting for your right to speak American," a teacher can be heard saying to her class in the video. A student can be seen leaving his seat at the end of the video.

The video has sparked outrage and ignited controversy among former students in Cliffside Park, New Jersey, a diverse community with a large number of Spanish-speaking students.

The student who walks out of the class in the video can be heard saying "You're being racist, I know how to speak English."

Maria Reyes, a 2014 graduate of Cliffside Park High School, spoke about the teacher's remarks: "This is a teacher in Cliffside Park High School; she isn’t allowing the student to express his constitutional right."

"Going to this school, and now my sister does, I really do not want a teacher like this," Reyes added, according to USA Today affiliate, NorthJersey.com.

Others have defended the teacher, who has been referred to on social media by some, as a "great person" and a "wonderful teacher," according to Fox59 news.

Some people commented saying English must be spoken in a class, which is being taught in English, out of respect for the teacher.

"This school is not a negative school," said Carmen Benitez, a senior at Cliffside Park High School. "You know there are a lot of different cultures in our school. There’s a lot of teachers who respect us."

Some have called for the teacher's resignation.

"It's really disrespectful," said Alana Lopez, a freshman. "That's not right. You don't do that."

Students told Pix 11 news that the principal had called an assembly to discuss the matter on Friday, when some of them brought flags to represent their culture.

Some have also planned to walk out from classrooms for Monday morning.

"You go to school to learn, you don't go to feel attacked by someone you believe is an educator," said Marvin Moreno, an alumnus, whose younger sister still goes to the school.

Link to video:
Cliffside Park High School incident


Teacher.
Tells class to "Speak American."

I was really hoping it wasn't an English teacher, but it is. >_>
 

The Kree

Banned
Men and women are fighting for your right to have a military that occupies foreign countries. The members of that military, ironically enough, get to speak English in those foreign countries with impunity.
 

yuoke

Banned
GLUgGc.gif
 

molnizzle

Member
Infantry vet here.

I fought for their right to speak whatever language they want*, because this is the United States of America.



*any real language. I'm afraid "American" doesn't qualify.
 

Volimar

Member
While I understand the reasons for wanting students to speak English in class, no they're not fucking fighting for you to have to speak American. What an idiotic thing to say.
 

zeemumu

Member
Infantry vet here.

I fought for their right to speak whatever language they want*, because this is the United States of America.



*any real language. I'm afraid "American" doesn't qualify.

Think her resume says she's bilingual because she understands English in the UK?
 

Draxal

Member
Is New Jersey above or below the Mason-Dixon line?

Asking for a friend that's a teacher

I mean Trump's from NYC.

Chicken and egg. Bad teachers -> bad education system -> more bad teachers

NJ's high schools are one of the best in the country. I don't like this video in that its an attack on the high school teacher unions which is really not good for Democrats civil infighting at this moment, (not that the blatant xenophobia here should be excused at all).
 
Infantry vet here.

I fought for their right to speak whatever language they want*, because this is the United States of America.



*any real language. I'm afraid "American" doesn't qualify.
Also people should probably know that there's some military folks who didn't even speak English and still joined.
 
To the people defending her by saying to speak English out of respect, she clearly said speak "American".

Why does that even mean? How the heck do you speak American?!

Why wouldn't you be in a place where lots of people speak multiple languages? It's one of the best things ever to hear! There's so much variety and culture behind a language! Why would you silence that?
 

entremet

Member
"Speak American" is a well-known BS line thrown by Rush Limbaugh and crew.

That's where it's from. It's intentionally mocking. They obviously know American is not a language. Makes the insult worse actually.
 

shiyrley

Banned
First of all: How do you speak a continent?
Second of all: That teacher is an asshole, and good on the student for leaving
 
"Speak American" is a well-known BS line thrown by Rush Limbaugh and crew.

That's where it's from. It's intentionally mocking. They obviously know American is not a language. Makes the insult worse actually.

Do they realise how stupid this sounds to normal people?
 
Top Bottom