I would like to point everyone back to this post. I was concerned about exmachina's use of the term "bus" as that exact slip up is what got TheExodu5 lynched and he flipped scum. I just didn't think it was a solid enough argument, there were too many holes in it so I chose not to consider switching my vote.
I would like to call special attention to this post. Everyone was lined up on BlackBuzzard then the instant there was a different possible target both Style and BlackBuzzard converged on him. BlackBuzzard was so frantic to do so he kept miscasting votes. Star was such a team player in trying to get exmachina lynched she drew special attention to BlackBuzzard's voting issues trying to make sure exmachina got pushed ahead in voting.
This claim does nothing to make me believe you. If you were going to have to lie about tracking anyone I'm one of the easiest choices because I'm not hiding in the background or disappearing frequently like some of the other players who may be trying to deflect suspicion from themselves for various reasons (whether that be a PR or because they're scum).
Special shout out to plop. A post like this after the votes have been cast seems a little convenient. You're not on my list currently but you're just below it.
That sure is a good question.
Well now that that's out of the way lets get down to the nitty gritty.
Player List:
???
Septimus Prime - Who are you?! Just kidding, welcome to the game. You replaced a player that didn't contribute much so I'm not even going to try and get a read here.
Town
II-Vanguard-II - Confirmed town.
Matt Attack - It feels like this is an example of someone who is town, but simply cannot devote a ton of time to the game. When he does post he generally shares more thoughts than a lot of others do for the entire day phase.
flatearthpandas - Has been questioning a lot of people in ways that I feel are productive. I don't see any reason to suspect fep and I haven't suspected in the past day phases either that I recall. He seems genuine in his thoughts (and his concern about either plop or myself being scum looks more valid now with plop seeming questionable)
Leaning Town
Verelios - I don't always agree with your opinions but it seems like you are town from your votes. You didn't vote yesterday which was odd, but your votes the first two days seem to be well placed and you stuck by your opinion in each one.
Null
WhereAreMahDragonz - Really not sure what to think here. I would put you lower but you've used the reasoning of having some personal issues to take care of so I'm going to let it by. Definitely closer to scum than town for me currently though.
11037 - Seems like a player that just doesn't have time to participate much. Hard to get much of a read beyond that. If he's scum then he's decided to just not influence the game in any way and hope it works out.
Leaning Scum
plop - I may have pointed out the odd term usage by exmachina but you really ran with it, pushed hard for it at the end, and then as soon as you knew votes couldn't be moved tried to backpedal and express remorse. Seems a bit too calculated to me. Star's claim of tracking me over for instance you (leaning scum) or BlackBuzzard (scum) also creates an odd link that concerns me. The only thing holding you back is I can't imagine all three scum would pile on exmachina. That would be so incredibly dumb on scum's part that I think they instead used you as a patsy. They saw town pushing to lynch town and jumped on board hoping you would be the one that gets lynched for it.
PK Gaming - If you want to keep defending Star I'm going to put you lower and lower on the list. You have barely contributed any thoughts to the game as of late besides "nuh uh can't be Star I refuse". The only thing I can think is you cannot separate Star, the person you are friends with, and Star, the player of mafia who based on a random distribution of roles could very well be scum.
Scum
BlackBuzzard - Has been defended by TheExodu5, confirmed scum. Was extremely quick to try and pile on exmachina to save his own skin. Has felt scummy for awhile and generally has not been helpful to town. Has also been defended repeatedly by Hyper. Feels like scum is just trying to delay the death of some of them while working through town members.
Hyperactivity - Where did you go for almost all of the last day phase? I know you said you were busy with applications but it does seem oddly convenient. If we take a look at the people that have been night killed they have all been part of the top posters. We only have a few people left at the top of the list that are even alive. I'm one and I know I'm town. You're another and I'm only just barely ahead of you in posts now. Verelios is the third and he's a bit behind you still despite you not posting at all really last day phase. I think while there is surely some truth in why you were busy, there was calculation behind it. You wanted to be quiet and give the rest of us time to catch up to you in posts. You realize that if the high activity players keep getting offed but you coast through town will turn your direction for a lynch, and that's the last thing you want as scum. You pushed all the conversation day two towards franconp who has now been cleared and when I pushed you to give in-depth reasoning you said you would then never did so. I doubt anyone is going to go with me on this but when Hyper keeps surviving through the night do not forget this.
StarSketch - I don't believe you're a tracker. You chose me to make your fake tracking claim about because I'm the safest target. If you were going to target someone based on the voting yesterday you could have picked plop, BlackBuzzard, etc. but you chose me even though I didn't even vote for exmachina. Seems far too suspect. This not to mention you lived another night without being targeted by scum which is still suspicious despite your claim of just conveniently slipping by as a revealed power role in one game prior. Just because it happened then doesn't mean I will just assume it'll happen now.
VOTE: StarSketch
