digitalrelic
Banned
This thread
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Snake Pass, and how a bad home menu icon drags down my enjoyment of a game
- Thread starter Neiteio
- Start date
- Status
Well context is everything, this thread is just a small sample size of their user base. This kinda reminds me of my work when we design new icons/logos for our games and the small minority of our fans complain, some developers kinda panic at first since it seems like nobody likes the design, but in the end the metrics show that the new icon works better (higher clickthrough rates) and you just have to live with the feedback.
petran79
Banned
On PC it looks gorgeous but surprisingly it is very demanding. Α GTX1080 is required to play the game in Ultrawide screen at 60fps. Probably bad optimization by Sumo
I know, I don't know why Sumo would change a perfectly good icon to the current abomination, either!This thread
This icon only shows up once you buy the game, though. The people who clicked through, clicked through on the old icon.zoukka said:
Don't see any in my library, but there probably is a case somewhere. Either way, in Steam you can choose not to view the icons or even change the icon.
This thread
It's a thread that isn't for us.
I don't understand why anyone would be bothered by an icon, or a logo or a cover art. But clearly people are.
constantstatic
Member
On PC it looks gorgeous but surprisingly it is very demanding. Α GTX1080 is required to play the game in Ultrawide screen at 60fps. Probably bad optimization by Sumo
It's sub 720p undocked and looks pretty bad. I'm on vacation so I haven't tried it docked. The games fun though its just disappointing how low resolution it is. I still think it was worth the 12$ but man is it ugly undocked.
This thread
Same
It's a piece of entertainment. Different people will be affected differently.
I don't understand the appeal of Japanese VA with English subs instead of an English dub, but I don't criticize people who feel differently.
Bottom line here, is people seem to either hate the change, or not care. So why not change it back for the people who -do- care?
I did not criticise.
Trigonometrize.
Member
I'm with you OP. There are a lot of ugly icons out there, even for good games, and something that is constantly just sitting there whenever you turn on your system should be addressed.
Although, while an improvement, the original icon doesn't fix much; it's still the same ugly character with that dumb look on his face.
Although, while an improvement, the original icon doesn't fix much; it's still the same ugly character with that dumb look on his face.
Eh, I guess I can understand. When Final Fantasy Brave Exvius' icon changed into a picture of Ariana Grande for a month, I let out an exasperated sigh every time I launched it.
Honestly I deleted the game when they changed it to that icon. No regrets.
Weird, she could be a main character design in FFXV for example.
metsallica
Member
Tumbleseed did this too, but they went in the opposite direction. It was, very briefly, an image of a stylized eye. Then it became the game's logo.
BouncyFrag
Member
Not getting a switch until this is addressed.
Something like a VA actually has an effect on the playing of the game.
The icon has absolutely zero.
Go ahead, hate the icon and beg for them to change it back all you want.
Saying it affects your enjoyment of the game though? Sorry, that's objectively crazy.
Weltall Zero
Member
Man, the pic with all the other icons sure makes it stick like a sore thumb. I don't own a Switch or Snake Pass yet (though I'm almost certainly getting both at some point), but I just contacted them at Info@Sumo-Digital.com about this thread. Hopefully they'll do something about it.
Damn. As a person prone to depression myself, now I want to protect your smile. :/
Damn. As a person prone to depression myself, now I want to protect your smile. :/
It doesn't affect enjoyment of the game. It affects enjoyment of the system and OS itself. So many of the posts in this thread boil down to "design doesn't matter to me so I don't get why it matters to others."
Lil'DigiOp
Member
This is why the industry doesn't take its customers and community seriously
ZombiePlatypus
Member
I have to disagree. The original icon looked like cheap, tacky, mobile shovelware.
The new one isn't anything amazing, but I feel like it's an improvement. It features Noodle's goofy smile more so that's a step up.
The new one isn't anything amazing, but I feel like it's an improvement. It features Noodle's goofy smile more so that's a step up.
Ugly things affect my enjoyment of using the Switch system. That's fact!
Also: The icon they had before was perfectly fine. Why change it?
I 100% understand how design matters and affects the system and OS.
But the thread title is literally "how a bad home menu icon drags down my enjoyment of a game".
And then you have posts like these:
bumpkin
Member
Saying it ruins the game is hyperbole but I do agree that the original icon was better. I feel like not having the title on it is some kind of bad UX pattern. I get that the OS displays the title above it, but nearly every other game has it in the icon. It's different for no apparent reason.
Playing the system is part of playing the game. All part of the experience. And not just this game, but when I'm playing Zelda or Mario Kart, taking screenshots, and I hit the home button to check the gallery, I have to look at the ugly Snake Pass icon then, as well.
As someone who tabs in and out of the home menu frequently while playing all kinds of games, the Snake Pass icon routinely annoys me. And it doesn't need to be this way: The previous icon was perfectly fine.
Send them an email linking to this post in particular if they want an at-a-glance summary of people's complaints.
stan423321
Member
Here's what I am getting from this. First party Switch icons feature titles, and there are no titles below the icons on Switch's welcome grid. Standard mobile menus inherited icon titles from desktop environments, under which simplified icons made certain amount of sense because they were very small and followed by a title. Switch Ui stretches them up, and the result is that people expect more from the icon, something closer to a box cover.
I don't know what does that mean in regards to Switch, but damn does that help me understand what irks me wrong about Wii U main menu. No universal icon titles (highlight only), simple iconography, and yet relatively high-res. 3DS at least got the whole title model thing.
I don't know what does that mean in regards to Switch, but damn does that help me understand what irks me wrong about Wii U main menu. No universal icon titles (highlight only), simple iconography, and yet relatively high-res. 3DS at least got the whole title model thing.
Wait. So not only is the Snake Pass icon dragging down your enjoyment of the game, but now the whole user experience of the system with it?
That was my point from the start. It was once an icon that everyone liked; now it's an icon that everyone hates. And every time I go to the home menu — which happens regularly, since I'm always taking screens while playing games, and tabbing over to check them — I have to look at it.
Now, in any other case, I'd just accept it and move on. But the key difference is, they already had a good icon for this game. It's not like they have to make a new one. They'd just have to change back to the old one. No extra work on their part. Just toggle it on for the next patch.
I really love their game. It's a great game. I'm hopeful they care enough about the fans to take into account this simple request. It's a small detail that goes a long ways.
JustAnotherOtaku
Member
This might be the most NeoGAF thread in the history of NeoGAF.
Yeah, I first noticed the change while starting a "linked together" playthrough of Zelda at a friend's house. (Where we each play with one of the joycons, controlling Link together.)
I was thinking about co-op like that recently in games. How is that going? I think IGN might've done a series like that. (I think it would make a very interesting thread if you want to do so.)
Yeah, I got the idea from IGN. I want to make a thread about my experience with it at some point in the near future, but I don't want to cannibalize the current thread, lol.
But in a word, it's awesome!
Nice! Looking forward to reading it. Reminds me of boost mode (especially videos of high level play, and especially challenges) in NSMBU.
Yeah, seeing what Square-Enix did, maybe I should just be thankful. Could be worse, lol.
zenspider
Member
This is the most interesting part of the story for me. Why be so adamant? Even the NeoGAF re-post blog Nintendo Life picked this up.
This is frustrating in a similar vein to how Sony won't let me turn off the distracting/battery-draining lightbar on the DS4 (except for on PC), or how Mario Kart 7 inexplicably left out single-player Versus mode so I couldn't do a quick race with items against the CPUs.
Design choices that don't make any sense, and that I find maddening. :-O
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked