Street Fighter II is a particularly good example for showing why direct comparison of two entirely different versions of the game on the SNES and Genesis is such a poor measurement, because we have two versions on the genesis which demonstrates how different the exact same composition can be depending on driver and programmer.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
SNES vs Genesis Sound
- Thread starter Beerman462
- Start date
Street Fighter II is a particularly good example for showing why direct comparison of two entirely different versions of the game on the SNES and Genesis is such a poor measurement, because we have two versions on the genesis which demonstrates how different the exact same composition can be depending on driver and programmer.
ienjoyrawfish
Member
It's not a good benchmark though, because it's akin to a musician not tuning their shit properly before attempting to play it. Example.
You could just as easily argue that when used well, the Genesis is actually pretty flexible in regards to outputting all the varied sounds required for something like Street Fighter 2, whereas the SNES can't really begin to approximate the sort of output the Genesis (and arcade) had. The SNES is significantly better at handling samples than the Genesis... but it isn't doing FM synthesis, period.
Journey
Banned
It's the same argument people made of PS2/PS3 coding, they were a nightmare, but people defended them because some were able to do well with them, but in reality they weren't ideal setups for what they were intended to do.
the megadrive wasnt a complex architecture like the ps2 and ps3 are though.
No it isn't. The better sounding version of Street Fighter II on the Genesis is the beta. The final version sounds worse than the version that had less work put into it.
And the Genesis is plenty capable of sample based playback.
And your comparison ignores (or you somehow aren't even aware) that the SNES version of Street Fighter II has an entirely different soundtrack from the Arcade and Genesis version -- precisely because the SNES wasn't well suited to reproducing that kind of soundtrack.
No lies detected.
Journey
Banned
The only thing I know is what my ears tell me, and the Genesis did a great job at twangy piano-like music, but overall the SNES games did a better job at more complex soundtracks
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5OkfWy-Rqzk
Producing organ sounds is another strength
https://youtu.be/-X1-uqDYa7w?list=PL21BAA7C6EDEB63A3
But was also capable of good twangy sounds:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tcf_FBbIRpM&index=51
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5OkfWy-Rqzk
Producing organ sounds is another strength
https://youtu.be/-X1-uqDYa7w?list=PL21BAA7C6EDEB63A3
But was also capable of good twangy sounds:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tcf_FBbIRpM&index=51
Soltype
Member
Actually organs are one of FM synths known strong points.The biggest problem with the SNES is the sample size, it's hard to keep good timbre in such a small sample.
And you can hear pretty clearly in soundtracks like Chrono Trigger how they sequence/program the music with methods to cover up the limitations, like by making very liberal use of repeating echo notes on stuff like pianos and mallet instruments since they can't retain their natural decay, as you can hear in Corridors of Time. Contrast that with the sitar(?) melody which doesn't use this technique, which has these very noticeable looping artifacts as the sound lingers.
Journey
Banned
Was great at pumping out heavy bass too. I just really liked the sound of Genesis, this track from Casey Jone's stage in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Tournament Fighters has just about everything I liked about the sound of the console. Still love listening to this shit.
The SPC has an emotional and symphonic edge to it that the megadrive cannot match. I wil always put Chrono Trigger, SD3 et al above anything on the MD.....
...but then again, the sound of the mega drive's yamaha chip is absolutely beautiful, pure, raw sound. I can play any mega drive game, pump the volume up to deafening levels, and have a hell of a time. It's amazing.
...but then again, the sound of the mega drive's yamaha chip is absolutely beautiful, pure, raw sound. I can play any mega drive game, pump the volume up to deafening levels, and have a hell of a time. It's amazing.
Never played much Genesis as a kid so I've dismissed its chips my entire life until a couple of years ago when I started exploring its library and with the time gained a new taste for the music that damn thing could produce, it's really mind blowing.
Overall I think I prefer the SNES if only because most of my favorite soundtrack are there and its music tends to sound more "videogamey" (and yeah I realize the Genesis not being like this is a pro for many people). Also it's weird how when handled wrong the Genny can produce some really awful stuff, especially SFX, I've played some games with wonderful music where the effects felt like they were actually physically hurting my ears lol, but at the same time it has the potential to produce stuff that might as well be its own genre of music.
I'm not very informed in technicalities yet, so I'll keep reading the thread but I'm loving the talk here and the examples of great Genny music. I've been getting into Etrian Odyssey recently too and I've noticed Koshiro uses something for the soundtracks that sounds extremely similar to Genesis sound, is that FM synth? Loved his work on SOR1 and 2 and it's part of the reason I became a fan of the chip.
^btw lazygecko I'm loving your covers. Great stuff.
Overall I think I prefer the SNES if only because most of my favorite soundtrack are there and its music tends to sound more "videogamey" (and yeah I realize the Genesis not being like this is a pro for many people). Also it's weird how when handled wrong the Genny can produce some really awful stuff, especially SFX, I've played some games with wonderful music where the effects felt like they were actually physically hurting my ears lol, but at the same time it has the potential to produce stuff that might as well be its own genre of music.
I'm not very informed in technicalities yet, so I'll keep reading the thread but I'm loving the talk here and the examples of great Genny music. I've been getting into Etrian Odyssey recently too and I've noticed Koshiro uses something for the soundtracks that sounds extremely similar to Genesis sound, is that FM synth? Loved his work on SOR1 and 2 and it's part of the reason I became a fan of the chip.
^btw lazygecko I'm loving your covers. Great stuff.
I composed music for the SPC (SNES).
I translated the midi notes into hex and inputted them into the rom along with corresponding channel effects and loops. I did end up writing music for a rom hack called Zelda: Parallel Worlds on the SNES and in that case I used the Hyrule Magic editor - but I still had to transpose the notes I played on my keyboard into the game's hex logic and attribute SPC channel effects and instruments to it thereforth
The only tracks that ended up in the game were recompositions of the Zelda 1 dungeon theme, but I composed many others that work on real SNES hardware.
Journey
Banned
Dies Irae on SNES.
Dies Irae on Neo-Geo.
Dies Irae on Genesis.
It's not Neo-Geo, but the bass and drum really helps it be unique and stand on its own. I know the SNES could produce faithful classical music though (given a full cart of space). To me, as complaints, Genny always had the tinniness and brown note thing going on, while SNES had a tendency to sound like flimsy, warbling midi trumpets and weak drums. But it would most often get better multi-plat music.
Fun fact: Genny had the best version of Fatal Fury 2 by far.
Dies Irae on Neo-Geo.
Dies Irae on Genesis.
It's not Neo-Geo, but the bass and drum really helps it be unique and stand on its own. I know the SNES could produce faithful classical music though (given a full cart of space). To me, as complaints, Genny always had the tinniness and brown note thing going on, while SNES had a tendency to sound like flimsy, warbling midi trumpets and weak drums. But it would most often get better multi-plat music.
Fun fact: Genny had the best version of Fatal Fury 2 by far.
Soltype
Member
Star Cruiser-Church
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6Jee2rXV9Q
Castlevania Bloodlines - Theme of Simon
https://youtu.be/qxb7Zfay0dY?t=1379
The Genesis version is just lazy, they should have had a better driver and sound designer.
These are the same compositions and instrumentations. There are in fine cases different midi files for different sound cards/libraries.
I don't think European fm tracks pale compared to Japanese.
I have a pretty good example, the version of Simon's Theme in Castlevania Bloodlines. Has a really nice organ'y sound that for some reason isn't used anywhere else in the game.
Edit: Way too slow, forgot to refresh :lol
I managed to get some really good sounds out of the SPC. even within 64kb of streaming space, as long as you had good enough samples available via the rom (and enough clever know-how to switch between banks and effects at will), you could get some really awesome sounds.
I made an SPC once that was a near-exact replica of John Barry's We Have All The Time In the World - but sadly, I don't have it anymore. I used to have it linked on an angelfire host via acmlm, but it's gone.
I made an SPC once that was a near-exact replica of John Barry's We Have All The Time In the World - but sadly, I don't have it anymore. I used to have it linked on an angelfire host via acmlm, but it's gone.
Yes, that's part of my point. Games that were otherwise mostly equal got the shaft on the Genny. They seemed to be barebones GEMS conversions.
Discomurf
Member
First time hearing the music and sound in Super Turrican on SNES was magical.
Gameplay:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y4TcWz0oHdU
At times the music sounds like a recording...once it kicks in:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?list=PLB0xooEkKbSbUlc0DMjvYRgKzDQ8pLOBO&v=qZUFWATfL9k
Gameplay:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=y4TcWz0oHdU
At times the music sounds like a recording...once it kicks in:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?list=PLB0xooEkKbSbUlc0DMjvYRgKzDQ8pLOBO&v=qZUFWATfL9k
So you had to know programming as well?
hex and spc loop logic at the very least
I know a good amount of ASM, but I never needed to touch it when composing for the SPC. Bear in mind I only worked with the N-SPC engine (Nintendo - Zelda, Mario World, SMK). Other devs had their own engines with likely completely different input methods and suites such as square's tech.
koji kondo, for example, would have had to program in his tunes in code.
I imagine there was some standardized software for audio in Nintendo's SNES devkit. There's hardly any information at all from interviews on how exactly people worked on SNES music compared to other systems, which is a shame. I read about one poor sod who had to physically mail the samples they created over to Nintendo in order for them to convert them into the proper SNES-compatible format and then wait for them to mail it back, because they lacked the tech to do it themselves. Other more fortunate devs could internally develop their own tools and drivers, like Ocean.
Today you can convert tracker modules to .spc, provided you stick within the format limitations. I think there's probably a tracker for directly composing in SPC format as well.
Today you can convert tracker modules to .spc, provided you stick within the format limitations. I think there's probably a tracker for directly composing in SPC format as well.
Ah, okay.
So you'd have your MIDI synthesizer, I'd imagine, and then do your composing and all that. And then you'd convert that to the proper SNES audio format?
Yep. With my experience, each note and octave had a corresponding hex value (values, actually) and the effects were separate.
Here's the Genny version, which has a flavor of its own.
Honestly, Super/Mega Turrican is one of the few examples where both versions sound good(but different). Personally, I prefer Mega Turrican. Sounds so clean and crisp. (And the SNES version is a missing a solo at around 2:40 for some reason)
Thanks for the info. Man, that sounds like a lot of work!
I never really enjoyed the Mega Drive synth at the time. I've grown to like some of the music on it more recently, but most of the stuff on the platform just doesn't do it for me.
Always preferred SNES's for the sheer variety of different sounds, even though the output was a bit muddy. At the time it was all coming out of shitty tube tv's speakers anyway.
Always preferred SNES's for the sheer variety of different sounds, even though the output was a bit muddy. At the time it was all coming out of shitty tube tv's speakers anyway.
many hours of slaving over a windows 98 (and later xp) PC before the concept of girlfriends ever entered my mind...
such a long time ago now.
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Of Course...
Crusade of Centy - Place of Peace
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-7k2QnBiLA&index=21&list=PLirSddeMOYZ4EFvn0BF07WogiCc3b8fnR
Scorpions Lair UMKombat 3
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hT7H4nVVW_g
Garfield - Count Scobula Castle
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9_7nCpaLe0&index=13&list=PLFSHdeZ6gP00agVcfBOj4JPmElINKGDID
More?
Oh man, the Genesis version is cool as hell, it's super energetic, I need to give Mega Turrican a play some time, some really great sounding drum samples for the Genesis hardware too.
This is sorta me. I didn't care much for Genny music at the time with a few exceptions but looking back a lot of it is probably down to the games that I played. A lot of them were games that were also on SNES and I just thought they sounded kind of shitty in comparison. Some Genny specific music is actually really good and though the overall sound of Genny music still isn't my favorite it did crank out some badass tunes. Plus hard synthy shit wasn't all that hot to me back then so the stuff coming out of a SNES was pleasant even if it was sometimes bland.
Ayy, I really like that Garfield track!
Dragon1893
Member
Dat Comix Zone.
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Thanks!
People don't understand how versatile FM synthesis can reach!
This is how an orchestra formed by only arab origin instruments would sound.
Monster World IV - Rapadagna Kingdom
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-vjgIaZv4c&list=PLirSddeMOYZ6c-OfCUYfnry3SZJXoQOwn&index=12
Monster World IV - Arab Court
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vFbvdGTCL-8&index=3&list=PLirSddeMOYZ6c-OfCUYfnry3SZJXoQOwn
The composer dared further and blended jazz with Arabic music, the Bass is f... awesome!
MrCunningham
Member
Mega Turrican has some incredible music:
Stage 1-2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tix0PV8_tbE&index=3&list=PLF3EE57659CD96551
Stage 2-1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atDWfoglyg4&list=PLF3EE57659CD96551&index=5
Stage 3-1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYHNvYSgEAA&list=PLF3EE57659CD96551&index=8
Stage 3-3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Br4w8KkMPw&list=PLF3EE57659CD96551&index=10
Stage 5-1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59TfMJfS5XY&index=15& list=PLF3EE57659CD96551 (one of the best tracks in the game)
Here is an example of a track from Toy Story, where I feel like the Genesis game sounds better than the SNES counterpart:
Genesis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPr4V1c2VqA&index=1&list=PL5DD08C64866A3712
SNES: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cFlZNrZ2mFg&index=1&list=PLSRvQoc-7SN1RZU70oRpiybUhE71OPt-y
Honestly, while the SNES track starts out strong, it kind of just degrades into hollow sounding instruments with a lot of reverb. The Geneis track goes an extra mile and tries its hardest to emulate the sound of saxophones, guitars, organs and a few other instruments. It does sound much "fuller" in comparison. Though the Genesis game uses some pretty crazy software mixing. Travelers Tales used to be crazy good with the Genesis hardware.
Meanwhile I could point to a track like this on the SNES here it just sounds much better than the Genesis to me:
SNES: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iT1pQkOadhg&list=PLSRvQoc-7SN1RZU70oRpiybUhE71OPt-y&index=19
Genesis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTmkvuXX8EQ&index=2&list=PL5DD08C64866A3712
Here is Moonlight Sonota from Earthworm Jim 2:
SNES: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBMUG2GnLb0
Genesis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRkHqw58PPk
The SNES track has a softer lullaby sound to it with a lot of reverb. The Genesis version has a harder and more solitary sound. I prefer the Genesis track here.
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
More Genesis stupendous soundtracks.
Steel Empire - stage 5-1
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=735495&page=23
Dangerous Seed - Stage 1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9jIaV79keA&list=PLEC60BA92514285CE&index=4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9G5QVHrqHe0&list=PLEC60BA92514285CE&index=9
Steel Empire - stage 5-1
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=735495&page=23
Dangerous Seed - Stage 1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9jIaV79keA&list=PLEC60BA92514285CE&index=4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9G5QVHrqHe0&list=PLEC60BA92514285CE&index=9
Soltype
Member
Dangerous Seed on the Genny sounded better than the arcade version.
EPSYLON EAGLE
Member
Yep Namco really transpose the arcade tracks for Genesis masterfully.
Another other criminally underrated soundtrack
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=210259266
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZURN13rk3w&index=17&list=PLFSHdeZ6gP00NpJp204p0dIP-Zlhr66bo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz8-_CAJneo&list=PLFSHdeZ6gP00NpJp204p0dIP-Zlhr66bo&index=2
I grew up with a SNES and for a very long time considered its sound to be better than the Mega Drive's. These days I have a hard time listening to the SNES and not being annoyed with how muddy it sounds. I don't think the Mega Drive got the breadth of quality soundtracks the SNES got, but it sounds real crisp.
Sewer Surfin' is still better on SNES though, for sure.
Sewer Surfin' is still better on SNES though, for sure.
To bring up a recent game from the Genesis/MD thread's game of the month, Bio-Hazard Battle has a really good sci-fi feel to it, that could only be brought by the system's brand of sound.
https://youtu.be/6lGhyde7r2g?t=2m47s
Just listen at how stage 1 branches into 2.
https://youtu.be/6lGhyde7r2g?t=2m47s
Just listen at how stage 1 branches into 2.
Cute Dragon Here
Member
I actually posted in the indie dev-GAF thread about trying to make music in the same vein as an SNES or Genesis, or at least something that sounds like it. If you were asking me, it's probably just me being exposed to SNES games first and stuff, but I've always thought that the SNES sounds are just... well, nicer in the long run.
I love myself a good FM synth, though I just get a bit of listener fatigue after a while.
Speaking of the SNES, am I weird for thinking the GBA renditions of the Final Fantasy V and VI to be sometimes superior to the originals? Sometimes the SNES/SFC versions felt a bit too soft.
I love myself a good FM synth, though
I just get a bit of listener fatigue after a while.Speaking of the SNES, am I weird for thinking the GBA renditions of the Final Fantasy V and VI to be sometimes superior to the originals? Sometimes the SNES/SFC versions felt a bit too soft.