Outdoor Miner
Member
If Disintegration is at #72, then I would say The Head on the Door (1985) should be somewhere on the list too.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Spin's 300 Best Albums of the Past 30 Years (1985-2014)
- Thread starter kitchenmotors
- Start date
- Status
If Disintegration is at #72, then I would say The Head on the Door (1985) should be somewhere on the list too.
Manmademan
Member
I get the feeling a lot of the list is exactly this. A best of (insert genre) over the past three decades would probably have been a better call, because at least then you would have exclusively people familiar with the genre putting votes in, rather than say, 3 people REALLY into hip hop plus 9 people who bought a kanye album once.
The picks and omissions here are really, legitimately confusing as hell if you're a fan of most of this.
JadedWriter
Member
This list doesn't even have proper goth on here. There's no Lycia or Faith and the Muse or Dead Can Dance, which technically isn't goth, but they hit some moody ass tones. There's no trip hop on here either because Mono's LIfe in Mono or Massive Attack's Mezzanine would have to be on here. I saw a Garbage album on here, but I would've loved seeing something from Curve getting mentioned and well I would think Collide is too esoteric for them. Even if it's alt rock based they should've put 23 from Blonde Redhead on here.
TheBaldEmperor
Member
Not saying they should be swapped but Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness and Siamese Dream are both better albums than Nevermind. Nirvana continues to get way more recognition than is merited.
Dion Blaster
Member
Haha maybe. Just to be clear I don't think it's bad, just not my thing for whatever reason (mainly guest verses). I'm just surprised it's separated itself from all his other acclaimed albums, all of which I preferred to MBDTF besides 808.
Omitting the Sister's Floodland is a big shame. I would have liked to have seen Enigma's MCMXC a.D. on there too but that's more of a personal favorite I guess. I really used that album to break in some new headphones over the years though.
Manmademan
Member
To be fair, Spin covers VERY little of that- or at least they didn't when I was reading it.
This list is very, very mainstream in terms of what it singles out as "best."
JadedWriter
Member
There's not even any Clan of Xymox on here, which might be dark wave or something, but some of these omissions are pretty weird. Yeah I'm actually listening to some Sisters of Mercy from your recommendation and it's pretty good. I really do need to dive into my Sisters of Mercy play list some more.
But Mono and Massive Attack have both had mainstream hits.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Man this is the most vanilla paste, thirtysomething list ever.
Manmademan
Member
Plenty of niche acts have a song or two that breaks into the mainstream for a little while.
But we're talking about a list here that completely skips over critical and commercial blockbusters like Tool's Aenima, Metallica's self titled, Michael Jackson's Bad, and Alanis' Jagged Little Pill.
the odds are not great for niche artists here, unless they happen to be an editor's pet favorite here.
you're right, getting 16 year olds to vote on the most essential albums of 1988 is a much better call. Fuck Thirtysomethings.
Manmademan
Member
really? damn. List gets worse and worse.
JadedWriter
Member
Yeah don't worry I completely see your point with this one. I'm always just on that "fuck the mainstream" slant. And there are some really big glaring omissions from this one and yeah omitting Tool of all things is gross, that's almost as bad as the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ignoring Rush for all those years.
Mezzanine is on there
Goldenroad
Member
Ctrl-f "Spacemen 3". God dammit Spin. So the best album of the '80's (The Perfect Prescription) doesn't make the top 300. Ridiculous.
I do somewhat agree with Sign O the Times placement, though I adamantly disagree with Nevermind's placement.
I do somewhat agree with Sign O the Times placement, though I adamantly disagree with Nevermind's placement.
JadedWriter
Member
Oh it is? phew, I guess I got too carried away with some of the assumptions because the list is missing some good groups.
teruterubozu
Member
No Jane's Addiction either. I don't think any of these writers experienced the 90s. Nevermind is a ruse.
Manmademan
Member
Nevermind is the FF7 of Alt-Rock albums. There are plenty of better ones, but it was so many people's first that it's going to be in that spot for a good long while.
Rockstar Beaver
Banned
Appetite For Destruction should be in the top 5. That album is a rock and roll masterpiece. So many artists and bands were influenced by that album.
March of the Crabs
Member
This is a horrible, horrible list. Almost laughably bad. No punk except Against Me! (and they pick their worst album that the band themselves admits is their worst), no metal except Slayer and Master of Puppets yet they have Sleater-Kinney on there TWICE!? At least 36 Chambers is on there!
JadedWriter
Member
Filter's not even on the list. Short Bus was an experiment but Title of Record and The Amalgamut are legit good.
ElectricBlanketFire
Member
Another list that combines legacy/importance and critical reception.
Manmademan
Member
hey, they had to hold themselves back from putting Kanye on there more than 3 times!
One hand in the air, if you dont really care
Middle finger in air, if you dont really care
frankie_baby
Member
No KLF ??????? One (or preferably both) of these should have been on the list
Manmademan
Member
I myself am broken up over no "Humpty Dance" or "Black Box" but what can you do
Rockstar Beaver
Banned
Yet Pearl Jam is on there once, no AIC??? WTF??? Although Sleater-Kinney's The Woods album is on my top ten list. Great album! Every song on that album kicks ass.
Frank Serpico
Banned
You aren't seriously comparing the impact of BP to chronic. Hip hop before and after chronic dropped was a different landscape sonically
Please tell me how BP influenced the south, west and Midwest hip hop scene
Manmademan
Member
while true, it's also severely fucking up the rankings for Alt-rock, so...
Arthr2ShdsJcksn
Banned
Top 10 is very close to my personal list and there's tons of great albums on here throughout the list.
I'm sure everyone will have a bone or two to pick (personally Animal Collective deserves no spot on any 'best-of' list ever), but this is a great survey of the past thirty years.
I'm sure everyone will have a bone or two to pick (personally Animal Collective deserves no spot on any 'best-of' list ever), but this is a great survey of the past thirty years.
Nastrodamous
Member
Lol at blueprint over illmatic,
frankie_baby
Member
Right? DaFUQ
acheron_xl
Member
Seeing all the Nirvana hate makes me feel like an old man.
Manmademan
Member
Not hate, so much as realizing the album is consistently overrated. It's good, but "best album in the last 30 years" is very difficult to defend.
Jeffolation
Banned
No Faith No More?
No, I hate them.
Just about every popular grunge act that came after them were better, and Pearl Jam is about 10 orders of magnitude better.
Yeah, there's no denying how important it was. If the list were for most important rock album of the last 30 years, I'd get that. It completely changed the songwriting and production for so much popular rock that followed.
But (for me), it's hardly even really listenable, anymore. Honestly, I don't even like it, now. Maybe that's more about me than it...
Tool, and any music in general with heavy Progressive influences are always looked down upon by music press. Prog has been the "uncool" genre for a very long time.
Same reason you wont see Mars Volta on a list like this (not that they necessarily should be on there)
Interfectum
Member
Nice.
PsychoSoldier
Banned
Nevermind came out when I was a teenager but it's way way too high. Age has nothing to do with it.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll