So I bought a Pentel Graph Gear 1000, which is basically the gold standard as far as mechanical pencils go. It cost me nearly $20 with shipping (for one pencil..) but the thing writes like a charm. It has good weight to it, grips well, and has an overall great feel. I don't think I'll be able to go back to my BIC mechanical pencils after using this.
What other everyday items are worth spending more money on?