Phat Michael
Banned
I've taken some. No idea how to get them from xb1 to here.
Goro is so fun Btw just bought him
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Mortal Kombat X Performace Analysis
- Thread starter Jigolo
- Start date
Goro is so fun Btw just bought him
Chobel
Member
I would like to post the screenshots in B3D forums, where they have actual pixel counters.
Backfoggen
Banned
https://xboxdvr.com/
You can check with your Gamertag here. I'd be interested if they showed up for you. For me it doesn't upload them. I think it has to do with the game not being out yet.
Muchi Muchi Pink
Member
『Inaba Resident』;159953830 said:
Oh is that true? Weird.
I think most X1 owners have come to grips knowing most of their games will be 900p.
Shao Kahn Brewing a Stew
Banned
If I had a penny every time I've read this post, I'd have tree fiddy.
List of trash:
FTL
Chivalry
Shovel Knight
Divinity Original Sin
Broken Age
Kentucky Route Zero
MKX particles
I also dislike graphic novels, bus stops, maps, reading for kids, classical music, board games, opera, art, and geiger counters.
(Today, 06:54 PM)
I'm surprised peaple really care that much about that instead, i mean 900p upscaled to 1080p is really hardly noticeable than native 1080p, proved by the fact that peaple who have the game already can't tell for sure if it's 900p or 1080p...60fps is what real matters just have fun and enjoy the game wherever you'll play it.
Phat Michael
Banned
Yep doesn't show up for me.
Keep telling yourself that.
Phat Michael
Banned
I agree with you. I think those of us who got the game early have been having fun playing it rather than counting pixels and getting angry for no reason.
xenorevlis
Member
While some can't tell, if you have an average or better HDTV, or play on a monitor, it's almost instantly noticeable if you play 1080p games (especially if its next to a 1080p version) due to the softness of the image. However, as you inferred, it's not really a big deal.
Due to the ESRAM size, I doubt we'll see games with engines like this that require a larger buffer for post effects and frame-composites to exceed 900p. Several developers have stated this and more have made this true (Ryse, Sniper Elite, etc.) This limit on the resolution will also help with performance, and it's still better than 720p which we saw happening to the XBO titles on FOX engine.
shadowsdarknes
Member
900p to 1080p is a noticeable difference.
However, if I'm playing the game on a show floor, it might not be as obvious.
But when I hook my consoles up to my PC monitor, I sure do notice.
Didn't know screenshots were available without uploading them....thanks for the advice (even not being for me, lol)
How are most people supposed to notice when they don't have the game yet? Twitch streams?
The difference between 900p and 1080p is instantly noticeable to me.
Liquidsnake
Banned
I really thought 1080p was a last gen thing,
I cant believe that MS couldn't secure a machine that would do it on a regular basis this current gen.
As a owner of both machines, I am very disappointed in MS, because I think the One is pretty sweet in every other way, just man being outclassed on this every time is crazy. Who spearheaded this machine?
I cant believe that MS couldn't secure a machine that would do it on a regular basis this current gen.
As a owner of both machines, I am very disappointed in MS, because I think the One is pretty sweet in every other way, just man being outclassed on this every time is crazy. Who spearheaded this machine?
OmegaDL50
Member
EDIT - Here is my settings in MK9 by the way just for confirmation
This is a screen capture I took directly from MK9 in Steam in training mode (This is downsampled from 3200x1800 to 1080p by GeDoSato by the way)
And this is MKX on PS4
Even not factoring my downsampled image of MK9. even I can notice the improved character models and background detail in MKX over MK9.
Yes...MKX clearly looks identical to MK9...clearly.
/s
This is a screen capture I took directly from MK9 in Steam in training mode (This is downsampled from 3200x1800 to 1080p by GeDoSato by the way)
BTW I'm not sure if your PC is actually downsampling MK9, lotsa jaggies there.
Anyway, MKX does look great and is a sizable graphical upgrade.
OmegaDL50
Member
BTW I'm not sure if your PC is actually downsampling MK9, lotsa jaggies there.
Anyway, MKX does look great and is a sizable graphical upgrade.
It's probably because of jpg compression in the image.
I can try a fraps capture and grab a uncompressed bmp or save a png
The fact I'm using jpg with a downsampled capture is pointless in itself.
lowhighkang_LHK
Member
NXgamer does a much better job than digital foundry. Kudos on making a thread about their work.
Shpeshal Nick
aka Collingwood
Um...why presumably?
Wait, he doesn't ACTUALLY know it's 900p? He's effectively going by eye? Good lord.
Wait, he doesn't ACTUALLY know it's 900p? He's effectively going by eye? Good lord.
xDUMPWEEDx
Banned
People act like it only being 900p matters so much.
It doesn't.
Jigolo
Member
So he wasn't wrong? The game is running a weird reso?
Corpsepyre
Banned
The Steam reviews for this are hilarious. Apparently it's just moving past the main menu??
Well yeah I don't think he's exactly right either.
I don't have the game though. I just looked at some pics in the screenshot thread. Maybe pixel distribution is different with cut scenes.
If its like Far cry 4 on XB1, it might be fair pixel counters might get confused by the upscaling, assuming its 900p, but then its like 1400 something by 1080
Of course that's pure speculation from me. NI don't know shit about the wizardry that goes into pixel counting directly from screengrabs to determine res. All i know is if its more blurry
Of course that's pure speculation from me. NI don't know shit about the wizardry that goes into pixel counting directly from screengrabs to determine res. All i know is if its more blurry
biglittleps
Member
I expect this.
biglittleps
Member
They matched everything with PS4 in IQ except resolution which is because PS4 has 30-40% more hardware resources so its not native Full HD.
A vertical resolution of 1080p does make it harder to tell that the image is upscaled. I think that's what is going on here.
Fuck that I'd take this guys word for It over digital foundrys any day. You should actually check out his stuff, he found things that digital foundry did not in many cases and in some opposite. Watch the unity one.
You realize you will see every game in 1080p as your output right?
Xbone version is technically inferior? For a game like this that is actually a surprise for once tbh. Would have thought full parity was a lock here :/
So... are we taking bets yet on whether the proper DF face off will now be using a "but the Xbox One version doesn't have region locked multiplayer, so they're both pretty much on par" narrative yet? ;P
So... are we taking bets yet on whether the proper DF face off will now be using a "but the Xbox One version doesn't have region locked multiplayer, so they're both pretty much on par" narrative yet? ;P
Yup, it's somewhere around 1344 or 1360 x 1080.
Backfoggen
Banned
Here is how MKX looks on XB1:
Similar artifacts to Dying Light which also was upscaled in one direction. Pretty good anti-aliasing for this lower resolution though. I expected a lot of shimmering because that's what 60 fps titles meant last-gen.
Similar artifacts to Dying Light which also was upscaled in one direction. Pretty good anti-aliasing for this lower resolution though. I expected a lot of shimmering because that's what 60 fps titles meant last-gen.
qa_engineer
Member
paragonpro
Banned
So good.
Haha it's like when I kid sticks his finger in his ears and goes LALALALA I can't hear you so you're wrong.