I think you're missing the point a little bit... being something special compared to current gen games is sort of a different concern- and while I would say it does beat out some current gen games in terms of art design, my point is that it
compares to current gen games despite being 6 years old. That's what impresses me.
Second, the game you chose to compare it to came out three months ago, and whether it's considered to be one or not, it
is a graphical powerhouse- it pushes the 360 and PS3 to their limits, coupled with some of the best art design in this generation. It's laughable that you're even making the comparison, but since you have... no, it doesn't make it look like an SNES game, it makes it look like a PS2 game, which is of course what it is. Compare it to a game with muddier textures and no anti-aliasing- let's say Darksiders (on PS3) for example- and the generational gap does not seem so massive.
edit: Nier, also a good example
I won't DP in such an unimportant thread, but here's some goodies:
Shit just got real storywise too, I'm digging it.