-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
What happens when a black trans woman 'stands her ground'
- Thread starter lexi
- Start date
- Status
MilesWebber
Member
It's a shame but kudos for the girl for pleading guilty. Even in self defense, she still killed someone.
Very brave of her.
Very brave of her.
Funky Papa
FUNK-Y-PPA-4
Jesus, can we just get along?
PackerinMN
Member
No. It is not a stand your ground state, yet.
A hurled bottle struck her cheek requiring 11 stitches.
I have no doubts she was intimidated into taking the plea. What choice did she have btw? Just roll over and die? Because that's what happens most of the time in cases like this, their deaths aren't investigated, authorities don't give a single fuck.
Plenty eager to prosecute them if they live though.
Indrid Cold1
Member
3 years in prison is hardly "the full weight of the law" for 2nd degree manslaughter. Be out in 18 months.
Oh well I guess it's okay then. Carry on, no injustice here. Maybe if we're lucky she'll get raped and killed in the mens' prison she's sent to.
marathonfool
Member
Without knowing the details of the incident. Can't form much of an opinion. If it was only a glass and taunts hurled stated in the article, hard to imagine her life was in danger. Terrible outcome either way.
ChocolateCupcakes
Member
The article really doesn't give much to go on....
Manos: The Hans of Fate
Banned
I'm pretty sure stand your ground doesn't apply to anyone not white. Realistically speaking
Not in PA. DA's have been pretty across the board in not charging due to Mobile Castle Doctrine.
polyh3dron
Banned
FTFYI'm pretty sure stand your ground doesn't apply to anyone not in Florida. Realistically speaking
The DA probably offered her a deal if she pleaded guilty and she chose that rather than risk the full sentence.
I'm just guessing here
Manos: The Hans of Fate
Banned
You've obviously never seen PA's self defense statute.
MWS Natural
Member
One less bigot on the planet.
It's hard to base an opinion with such few details. If the bottle was thrown while she was walking away and she came back that would be different than them surrounding her.
Yeah I can't say I feel there has been any loss to civilization that this guy is gone.
Yeah I can't say I feel there has been any loss to civilization that this guy is gone.
Manos: The Hans of Fate
Banned
Not in PA.
If she's placed in a women's prison I bet a whole bunch of dumbfucks will be saying she should be moved :/
polyh3dron
Banned
You're correct I haven't, I just know that Florida's Stand Your Ground legislation doesn't apply.
I have been brained with a rock, 23 stitches and stabbed with a carpet knife, 30-something stitches. In neither occasion did I actually feel like my life was threatened. Both times I was hurt and scared, but didn't actually fear for my life. I wasn't in her circumstance, so I can't speak for her, I'm just pointing out that neither violence nor injury are in themselves things that make you afraid for your life, necessarily.
Pathetic Basement Virgin
Banned
I thought this type of thing only happened in the south.
Manos: The Hans of Fate
Banned
I think being brained with a rock and stabbed are perfectly good reasons to fear for your life and use lethal force.
polyh3dron
Banned
Regardless of it being a Men's or Women's prison there will be arguments for her being moved to the other one. And even then, she wouldn't be there much longer, having already served about 11 months if she was jailed at the time of the altercation.
empty vessel
Member
Depending on other facts, this could justify lethal force in every state, notwithstanding so-called "stand your ground" laws. Self-defense laws in every state would permit lethal force to avoid grievous bodily injury. (You don't have to be in danger of losing your life or fear losing your life to justify using lethal force.) That said, there could be circumstances that would disallow the defense. (I'm talking in the abstract, I have no idea what all the circumstances in this case were.)
If she did have a solid claim of self-defense, she may well have still pleaded guilty to avoid the risk of conviction and a longer sentence. If so, this would be an example of how innocent people plead guilty simply to avoid the chance that they could be found guilty notwithstanding their innocence and be made to serve a long prison sentence. Unfortunately, these things get set in motion well before trial by the police investigation and charging decisions that are made by prosecutors. Overcharging is very common, and overcharging increases the likelihood that innocent people will plead guilty.
If someone threw a bottle at me, it struck, and they were coming toward me aggressively whilst screaming transphobic slurs, It's a fair bet I would fear for my life.
GrotesqueBeauty
Banned
I saw nothing in the post you're responding to that belittled her plight. I can empathize with why you are reacting emotionally, but it's hard to reconcile 3 years with "full weight of the law". Nonetheless, she has my condolences. I'd have to read more about the specifics of the case, but at a minimum it seems pretty cut and dry that she was thrust into a bad situation because of other people's ugly biases. Hard to say whether lethal force was justified without a more detailed account.
Unfortunately this type of shit happen everywhere all the time. Even here in San Francisco in the Castro district you hear about these hate crimes periodically. There's no true safe haven from bigotry.
Manos: The Hans of Fate
Banned
The problem is that a person would have to be charged in the first place, go to trial, and risk a jury convicting them.
Showing the value of having a law that would prevent a DA from doing that in the first place, since that's what often happens as you point out.
You're overreacting horribly. Getting a bottle thrown at you is usually not enough reason to stab someone to death with a pair of scissors.
Manos: The Hans of Fate
Banned
Depends on the person being attacked, health and other factors could make it more dangerous for one person than another.
Hobbestetrician
Member
Yeah, 'dicks' is the word that should be censored in that article...
That's roughly what happened to me. I chose to make an exit on one of those occasions. But as I said, I wasn't in her shoes. She maybe never felt she had that option.
Devolution
Member
When people are killed for being trans and the violence has already escalated to the point of slurs and throwing bottles? She should fear for her life.
See above.
Femmeworth
Banned
The guy got off easy, she on the other hand won't. :\
Either way, it's not going to be a pleasant time for her.
Let's get out of this state, possibly this country.
I didn't even notice that, gay slur no problem, racial slur no problem, but we draw the line at dicks!
Gentleman Jack
Member
What was the reason for refusing to plead not guilty?
And I'm confused about whether or not the OP is advocating for more 'stand your ground' laws in this country.
And I'm confused about whether or not the OP is advocating for more 'stand your ground' laws in this country.
I wholeheartedly agree with you but the problem is our system is so sclerotic as it is there is essentially no practical alternative without massive reforms that are badly needed but politicians of both parties are unwilling to even DISCUSS. Drug cases and other victim-less crimes are such a massive part of our criminal justice system (hurt further by mandatory minimums for sentences which gives people a greater incentive to fight) that there is almost not time for everything else. Cases that should be heard in days are scheduled weeks or months in advance. Our system is so sclerotic if every defendant opted to fight the charges everything would be backed up several years longer still. Justice is supposed to be swift and fair, it's more slow and based on pushing people through as fast as possible with plea deals.
mercenar1e
Member
so the guy throws glass at her face and she retaliates by stabbing the person.. if she gets sent to a male prison the treatment will be similar or much much worse! good luck lol
People are killed for being many things. That doesn't mean we should assume that a discriminated person who pleads guilty to murder by scissors should be given a full pardon because a glass was thrown.
Gentleman Jack
Member
Video mentions she was some kind of fashion student. Class materials?
they probably promised her less time if she just pleading not guilty. is she using a public defender? then they probably just told her to take the deal as public defenders don't really fight for you.
ChocolateCupcakes
Member
I'm confused is there actually a possibility that she would be sent to a male prison or are people just speculating?
Gentleman Jack
Member
That's pretty awful. Never plead guilty. Ever.
Not a lot of data but yes, LGBT prisoners do get sent to prisons based on their biology instead of identity. Even if she did land at a women's prison she'd be subject to harassment.
- Status