• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The secret to making your Xbox One snappier and quicker!

Ran this last night after seeing it on r/xboxone and surprisingly my Charter DNS is the fastest.

Unsure if it's because my router is awesome, but I'm pleasantly pleased.

It's also interesting to learn that changing DNS settings is what resolves many people's issues with the OS being sluggish. I never experienced that, and now understand why.

Same here -- Charter DNS has always been reliably faster for me. The only time I've changed my DNS settings have been for debugging a network connection for work, and Charter kept serving it's own custom error page and not the one I wanted.
 
You're missing the main point that by redirecting the request to another server further away from your ISP, you're increasing the round trip time. If your ISP is 10 miles away and Google's nearest DNS server is 1000 miles away, the quickest lookup would be to use the ISP.

There are variables other than location at play - server load, server performance, faulty hardware, bad configuration, others.

Charter's DNS servers went down a month or two back over the weekend and left thousands without internet service, sort of. As I found out, it was the DNS servers that were down, nothing else. I changed my DNS to Google's and it fixed the issue. Once Charter fixed the DNS servers, I switched them back. I even tweeted out the temporary fix for others and helped quite a few people with the same issue.

Your request is not forwarded from your ISP's DNS to the DNS you've selected. It's direct (routed). If it was forwarded, then you would be completely SOL if the ISP's DNS went down, which is not the case.
 

OraleeWey

Member
What featured tab? Just go on the link I provided and download the tool and don't worry about messing around with the options.
There's a featured section there with downloads. Anyway, I'm on windows 8, so I just download this: namebench-1.3.1-Windows.exe right?
 

Anion

Member
I'll have to try this technique this weekend. I have FiOS and it did make my mac load Internet pages faster a while back. I hope the same happens with the X1
 

DJ_Lae

Member
I read the same thing was supposed to improve the awful download speeds I get on my Vita - made no difference at all, still stuck with about 20kbps where everything else I have is in the multiple megabytes over wifi.

Will test it out when my One arrives anyway, just out of curiousity.
 
I haven't messed with the XB1's interface since release. Any multiconsole owners care to fill me in on how it compares speed-wise to UI navigation on PS4?
 

artsi

Member
There are variables other than location at play - server load, server performance, faulty hardware, bad configuration, others.

Charter's DNS servers went down a month or two back over the weekend and left thousands without internet service, sort of. As I found out, it was the DNS servers that were down, nothing else. I changed my DNS to Google's and it fixed the issue. Once Charter fixed the DNS servers, I switched them back. I even tweeted out the temporary fix for others and helped quite a few people with the same issue.

Your request is not forwarded from your ISP's DNS to the DNS you've selected. It's direct (routed). If it was forwarded, then you would be completely SOL if the ISP's DNS went down, which is not the case.

Maybe he meant the ISP gateway <-> DNS distance, but either way it shouldn't matter as Google most likely uses some anycast voodoo with DNS servers all over the world.
 

RedAssedApe

Banned
you may or may not see a increase...depending on what those other dns servers are resolving to. and like someone just mentioned above...what CDNs you get routed to when trying to access content.

its not uncommon to see no difference or sometimes even slower performance or improved performance...and then back to normal. personally i just stick with my ISPs DNS servers. changing to Google or OpenDNS never did anything for me.
 
I tested the best DNS setting for my connection and found out that Google's would be 80% faster so I changed my settings. Re-ran the test after changing and was told that my connection would be 197% faster if I went back to my old settings.


I tried to make my connection better and failed miserably. The lesson is: never try.
 
Maybe he meant the ISP gateway <-> DNS distance, but either way it shouldn't matter as Google most likely uses some anycast voodoo with DNS servers all over the world.

Probably so. It's definitely a YMMV situation, and worth a look for anyone who feels their console/device's responses are slow. It's not a bandwidth issue, it's a latency issue dependent upon the speed with which the DNS server responds to each request. For example, when you open up your Xbox 360 friends list, if you have quite a few friends and it loads instantaneously, then it's highly unlikely you have an issue or will notice improvement - you might even notice a decrease in responsiveness. If it's slow to load, however, then you may have an issue of DNS responsiveness, and changing to another DNS may fix it.
 

Anion

Member
Wow. So it helped speed my xbox up a lot. I honestly did not expect it to be that helpful. Somehow my NAT is open now...
 

danielcw

Member
You're missing the main point that by redirecting the request to another server further away from your ISP, you're increasing the round trip time. If your ISP is 10 miles away and Google's nearest DNS server is 1000 miles away, the quickest lookup would be to use the ISP.

I am not missing the point, you are, because we were not talking about the part I quoted, we were talking about this:
Quote from you:
If you use Google's, the DNS lookup goes to your ISP anyway it'd is then forwarded to Google's DNS server.
And that is wrong. You doubled down on it later.



The number one reason isps don't want you to do that is support calls. If their dns goes down, they know about it and can quickly route those affected to a voice message explaining the outage. If somebody else's dns goes down, they don't know and they end up having you take up a tech's time for something that was out of their control.

I don't know about the One but the 360 didn't cache anything in terms of dns and each one of those boxes ends up in a dns call.

Ah, that makes sense.
Never had to deal with that during my support days.

Not surprised, that the 360 doesn't cache it longtime, but I don't expect it to make a lookup for the same domain everytime I scroll down a list for example.
I would assume, that the lookup result is at least cached per session.



Note that using DNS servers other than your ISP can mess with what CDNs you download stuff from.

Yeah, it should be rare, but one should keep that in mind.
 

Genio88

Member
I did the test and i got these results, does it mean that i've to put 62.101.93.101 as DNS?
Cattura.png
 

Mihos

Gold Member
My ISP DNS is always fastest, but I do use the google DNS on my laptop for when I travel or go into the office.
 

M3d10n

Member
Streaming wouldn't be improved by DNS

It can be. There's a thing called geolocated DNS, in which different DNS servers match the address to different server IP addresses, usually based on location. This is used mainly by CDN servers to perform a sort of load balancing at DNS level and (in theory) redirect users to nearer servers, but sometimes things don't go as planned and your ISP DNS redirects you to a CDN server that has a bad or saturated route.

Note that using DNS servers other than your ISP can mess with what CDNs you download stuff from.

Sometimes it's the other way around.
 

aaaaaa

Member
I don't think multiplayer games are significantly affected by DNS speeds. Once player connections are established, they shouldn't be using domain names.
 

UraMallas

Member
I downloaded the namebench program and it is running slower than Hell. Like, it is barely doing anything and constantly "Not Responding". I'm on Windows 8. Is there anything I can do?
 
Top Bottom