Support NeoGAF

[omonimo]

I just love this useless speculation. Thanks for the laughs.

I'm just joking. But if it feels you better, I'm not referring to you when I'm so salty toward EG. It's just...a my little obsession to ...other things.

 

[Portugeezer]

Good grief,

1080p30 parity redeemed.

 

[EASTC0AST_GH05T]

Grass Gate reminds me of Mafia on PS3 when all the 360 guys mocked playstation users because mafia had several more blades of grass on the xbox. Now the tables have turned and the chickens have come home to roost!

 

[ekim]

Going to have to wait for the DF to see if that is true, if so not sure it is worth the double dip on Xbone

It is. Having solid 30 FPS is a huge plus coming from the last gen versions. And everything else also looks better.

 

[danowat]

Now the tables have turned and the chickens have come home to roost!

Hang on, hang on, the PS4 version has chickens in it too?, FFS R* where are my chickens at in the XBO version?

 

[cackhyena]

Only time I'll be noticing grass is as I'm plowing through it with a vehicle, so idgaf. Nothing to do out there of interest compared to the city.

 

[BigTnaples]

Fake. The ratio on map is all wrong. Left screen looks like it's from 360.

Who made this comparison?

I stand corrected. Difference is minuscule.

This has got to be the best thing I have read on GAF in so long....

 

[omonimo]

It is. Having solid 30 FPS is a huge plus coming from the last gen versions. And everything else also looks better.

The thing interesting in the article it's the disappointment for the use of the same polygonal model of the ps360. It seems not fit well in the overall improvement.

 

[Derpyduck]

Only time I'll be noticing grass is as I'm plowing through it with a vehicle, so idgaf. Nothing to do out there of interest compared to the city.

I notice the new grass all the time on PS4 because as I'm driving through it with my Zentorno, it's constantly poppin-in right in front of me. Actually I don't think it's the grass popping in, but the shadows from the grass. It's really distracting.

 

[iceatcs]

ouch xbox missing grass. Might be worst than image quality. Remind me of last gen, whereas some objects or textures are difference.

The gap is getting bigger.

 

[wachie]

All PS4 users on GAF? Yes, makes sense.

Wait, are you saying SonyGAF?

 

[mrklaw]

We can laugh about the lack of grass, but that shit was brought up non-stop when it was an issue in RDR PS3.

Pretty sure it was the verge of becoming a meme at one point too...

the grass was on the verge?

 

[Synless]

Grassgate, November 2014, the world was never the same........

You should have been there for the great grassgate for red dead redemption. It was made for one hell of a thread.

 

[digoutyoursoul]

Miles

 

[gamechanger87]

Gaming Bolt (I know) had some comparison shots. Not a definitive source but I'll post the link below.

http://gamingbolt.com/grand-theft-auto-5-ps4-vs-xbox-one-head-to-head-comparison-rockstar-have-crafted-an-impressive-port

I would post the photos but they are really large. PS4 looks washed out.

Here is one for good measure

 

[CambriaRising]

My bad, that was supposed to be another shot of the foliage.

Here's a webm instead,

http://a.pomf.se/rahkwc.webm

Could just be the capture software, but whats with the motion blur on the Xbox One version?

 

[Portugeezer]

Little things like these made me glad to have a 360 last gen, similarly I prefer having a PS4.

Maybe later I will own other consoles.

 

[RandyBobandy]

Well obviously the XB1 version has someone cutting the grass. It's all kempt and clean. PS4 gardener must be on holiday

 

[EASTC0AST_GH05T]

Hang on, hang on, the PS4 version has chickens in it too?, FFS R* where are my chickens at in the XBO version?

lost in the clouds

 

[danowat]

Well obviously the XB1 version has someone cutting the grass. It's all kempt and clean. PS4 gardener must be on holiday

Lawnmower confirmed?

 

[shandy706]

I love first person mode.

Also...GTA turns us nice people into jerks...LOL

 

[system11]

Oh. Motion blur? Is that a toggle? If not I'm out - I absolutely hate it.

 

[Caayn]

The version your friends play at. I love the DS4 functions, like the red and blue flashing LED when youre chased by the cops, touchscreen and speaker integration. But I would go where my friends are.

Thank god for duct tape and the ability to mute the speaker.

 

[Windom Earle]

ouch xbox missing grass. Might be worst than image quality. Remind me of last gen, whereas some objects or textures are difference.

The gap is getting bigger.

Mordor also had this issue, no? Or was that PC only? Maxed PC Mordor has the best foliage I have ever seen in a game.

edit: Also I really have the impression there is a problem with the gamma setting on PS4.

 

[Portugeezer]

Never mind misread

 

[Synless]

Mordor also had this issue, no? Or was that PC only? Maxed PC Mordor has the best foliage I have ever seen in a game.

PS4 Mordor had more foliage, you are correct.

 

[shandy706]

Enjoying the foliage and god-rays too. I spent time just walking around looking at things.

 

[ICPEE]

Grassgate, November 2014, the world was never the same........

AHahahahaha

 

[TheAdmiester]

Looks like the XB1 might have a lower quality motion blur as well?

The ghosting is from video resampling, it's in both but not as noticable on the PS4 side of that screenshot as it wasn't moving as much.

 

[biglittleps]

Gaming Bolt (I know) had some comparison shots. Not a definitive source but I'll post the link below.

http://gamingbolt.com/grand-theft-auto-5-ps4-vs-xbox-one-head-to-head-comparison-rockstar-have-crafted-an-impressive-port

I would post the photos but they are really large. PS4 looks washed out.

Here is one for good measure

Its not washed out, XB1 looks sharper because of their filter which is why we have crushed blacks in XB1.

 

[Caayn]

Its not washed out, XB1 looks sharper because of their filter which is why we have crushed blacks in XB1.

The filter that's not present when a game isn't using the internal upscaler.

 

[Miles Quaritch]

the grass was on the verge?

 

[Derpyduck]

Its not washed out, XB1 looks sharper because of their filter which is why we have crushed blacks in XB1.

The filter that is only used in non-native 1080p games? This is a native 1080p title.

 

[c0de]

Its not washed out, XB1 looks sharper because of their filter which is why we have crushed blacks in XB1.

But this is 1080p so there shouldn't be crushed blacks.

 

[T.O.P]

Enjoying the foliage and god-rays too. I spent time just walking around looking at things.

Fuck it, grabbing this on X1 tomorrow together with Inquisition on PS4

These couple of months have been awful to my wallet

 

[Chobel]

But this is 1080p so there shouldn't be crushed blacks.

The filter that is only used in non-native 1080p games? This is a native 1080p title.

The filter that's not present when a game isn't using the internal upscaler.

Some 1080p games have crushed blacks (Fifa and Madden)

Edit: Sleeping Dogs remastered also has it even though it's 1080p game

 

[Mr Moose]

But this is 1080p so there shouldn't be crushed blacks.

In the video from them (gamingbolt), there is crushed blacks. I don't see it in the DF video, though.

 

[Zombie James]

Good grief,

Dodged a bullet there, Rockstar.

 

[gamechanger87]

Its not washed out, XB1 looks sharper because of their filter which is why we have crushed blacks in XB1.

This game doesn't use the upscaler. One thing I have noticed is that games on the XBO are really focusing on having colors "pop".

 

[Metfanant]

the crushed blacks have nothing to do with the upscaling filter...its the FUBAR gamma curve MS uses...

 

[Derpyduck]

Some 1080p games have crushed blacks (Fifa and Madden)

That might be true, but it's not due to the upscaler filter.

 

[Hanmik]

This game doesn't use the upscaler. One thing I have noticed is that games on the XBO are really focusing on having colors "pop".

this site tells a different story..

http://gearnuke.com/gta-v-ps4-vs-xbo-1080p-direct-feed-image-comparison/

here the Xbox One looks foggy as hell ... wtf is up with this..?

 

[Chobel]

This game doesn't use the upscaler. One thing I have noticed is that games on the XBO are really focusing on having colors "pop".

It's because of the busted gamma curve used in Xbone.

 

[travisbickle]

There isn't such a thing as a "crushed black filter" for less than 1080p images!! It's dodgy gamma setting of the XB1 that have to be countermeasured by devs.

 

[BigTnaples]

Enjoying the foliage and god-rays too. I spent time just walking around looking at things.

The God Rays are nice. Not sure why they couldn't get them in Far Cry 4, but its still a great looking game none the less.



Was a pretty cool morning trying both GTAV and Far Cry 4 and both of them using fur shaders for all the animals, and having dense foliage instead of grass textures.


I feel like its a small thing, but something we have been wanting to be common place for over a generation.

 

[funkystudent]

Arguing about colours seems a little pointless when stuff like that is probably just down to gamma settings.

 

[shandy706]

this site tells a different story..




http://gearnuke.com/gta-v-ps4-vs-xbo-1080p-direct-feed-image-comparison/

here the Xbox One looks foggy as hell ... wtf is up with this..?

You just blew up a safe. Is there no smoke lingering in the scene on PS4?

If you just stand around, does it clear?

My X1 build isn't washed out like that...I do remember a lot of haze/smoke in that room though.

Edit**

Just checked and I recorded that scene. There's a ton of smoke in the room. My colors aren't as washed out, but the room is still smoldering on X1.



Maybe it's a good idea not to come to conclusions if one doesn't even know what is happening in a scene?

 

[NickFire]

No surprises in how the game looks or performs. Never expected a whole new engine. A little curious about how they got one version but not the other, but so many possible reasons not going to speculate.

 

[quetz67]

Good grief,

If this is true I take that over higher resolution or frame rate every day

 

[Glorified G]

Fake. The ratio on map is all wrong. Left screen looks like it's from 360.

Who made this comparison?

Still an obvious fake comparison. PS4 version is suffering from pop-in issue as well it's not a God-spec machine. The difference between the 2 systems hasn't been huge as Sony fans would've liked.

Theoretical performance doesn't mean jack when we have concrete evidence of real time performance on many cross platform games.

Sony fans are trying way too hard to make it look like PS4 is 2x better than X1 when it really isn't. Making fake comparisons to make that true doesn't really help either. Now that's just sad.

I stand corrected. Difference is minuscule.

You won't find four consecutive posts on GAF that's better than this.