• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt |OT2| Wanted to find Ciri, but everything Gwent wrong

Status
Not open for further replies.

SDCowboy

Member
Hmm, maybe you didn't listen closely enough? I think in that ending Geralt continues to Witcher and then eventually settles down with your LI. For me, Ciri became Empress and Geralt immediately after settled down with Yen for a nice and quiet life.

Hmm...I like you ending better. Though, Ciri becoming a witcher with Geralt isn't bad either.
 
Later endgame-ish spoiler:

Even though I didn't want to, I went ahead and gave it to Radovid because I had already sent Triss on.

Then, I was scared it would burn me with Phillipa later, but it didn't.

If one of them is the item from Redania's Most Wanted then yes. Not sure about the other item.

I need to have Triss look at some magical items for two sidequests but she's not available SPOILER
I sent her to Kaer Mohren
. Can I ask Yennefer about the items?

Good to hear, I have one of those items right now.
 
So I'm super surprised at the strength of the writing and voice acting in this game, specifically the Bloody Baron.

I must be going soft in my old age or something because
I couldn't help but feel sympathetic for the poor wife beater. My stomach turned at that revelation but everything about his miscarried child and Tamara and being cheated on and blaming himself and taking responsibility for it all just kinda made me feel for him.

Kinda hate that the game made me feel that way bout someone who does that. Oy, that's strong writin it is.
 

Khasim

Member
Damn Roach, always sticking his nose in my business. I was just done talking to this innkeeper when I noticed something strange on the wall. Won't leave me alone even on my second playthrough.

hUqmejph.jpg
 

NeonBlack

Member
Romance Spoliers

I'm trying to play through the game on one of my old saves and I wanna know if I fucked up my chance with Triss. She left with the other mages.
 

BraXzy

Member
So I'm actually starting the game properly now, I've only hopped into it for a few minutes till now.

I'm on the quest for this Griffin, helping people along the way, getting to grips with the plethora of game systems to wrap my head around.

Question though, my inventory is starting to get really full, what should I sell? I am at 49/60 weight. I know there is a mod to make weight irrelevant but I want a clean vanilla experience. I have a bunch of swords that I should probably sell but all the different stat differences confuse me. Like my default Witcher sword has lower damage but +25 armour piercing. How much of a damage increase would I need to sacrifice the piercing? I also heard the Witcher weapons are worth keeping? I don't have a clue what to do with all this in my inventory D:
 
Just happened across the entire Griffin set of diagrams. No doubt won't be able to use them for god knows how long though.

No wait just looked and they are lv 8! I'm level 8! HALLELUJAH!!!

gonna get the hell out of here and build me a set of armor
 
question - does anyone on PC play with chromatic aberration on?

kept switching back and forth yesterday and it was becoming distracting.

it seems to blur the edges of everything which kind of hides the game's imperfections - but it almost gives me a subtle subtle headache when on...
 
Anyone else not use Roach at all? I go everywhere on foot.

Also can we please gey a quicksave button for PS4? Autosave is terrible.

Nope, use Roach all the time, and while I'd also enjoy a quicksave button, to be fair it only takes three seconds to do a manual save so it's not exactly a big hassle.

Does it make a difference if do the Baron or the Witch Quest first?

I don't want to spoil anything, but the answer is no, not at all. I'd do the "Baron" quest first though.
 

Allforce

Member
I feel like I've already hit a wall in this game and I only just got to Velen.

I'm Level 4, did every side quest I could find and "?" icon on the map in White Orchard. Now I'm in Velen and have met Keira. After that it seems every single ? I run into or Witcher Contract is recommended for Level 10 and up.

Do I just shoot for main quest stuff now? The next one is recommended Level 6 but I'm still at 4 with almost half the bar to go to get to 5.

And I still have SO MUCH SHIT in my inventory that I'm constantly having to find a guy to sell off stuff to. Game is fun but absolutely daunting, there's so many potions and decoctions and parchments and notes and alchemy crafts that I have no idea where to even start with some of this stuff. I don't think I've made a single potion outside of "Swallow" for some lady in White Orchard for a quest.
 

Korezo

Member
Why did they have to add that combat phase where if any enemy gets close the camera gets retarded and attacks who ever. Is there anyway to remove that? This is making me hate the game... witcher 2 didn't have that junk.
 
Need some help beating the wild hunt
any tips to kill the guy with the ice staff? I weakened him with Ciri but the ice balls he shoots are destroying geralt
 

Philtastic

Member
Get that shit out of here. No, this games does not "require more tactics" than most games. You can beat any fight in the game by spamming quen and dodging. Wow, such tactics.
...
so no, I don't dislike it because I "don't like to think" or because I'm bad. The combat is slow, dull, and thoughtless. It doesn't fit with the world contextually or thematically. Geralt should be fast and deadly, a glass cannon in a world of first-mistake-losses. And yet combat feels like hitting a guy or monster with a wooden sword until their body spontaneously tears itself apart. This is a great game CDPR has built here but pretending as if detractors have nothing to say is just damned disingenuous.
I'm going to preface this by stating that I have only put 22 hours into the game (a relatively small amount for this game, ha) and have only gotten to level 7 while playing on Death March.

Your Quen objection is exactly my point: you succeed at the game but in the most boring and one of the least efficient ways possible. It's like playing Batman and saying "I'm going to ignore using my gadgets and combo meter abilities and just jab and counter all the time". That mostly gets the job done but makes for a really boring game. Great, you put Quen up, you do 2-3 swings, get hit, shield breaks, then dodge around until Quen is back up. Or, if you've upgraded it, you go on a swinging spree as your stamina drains and, when you run out, you just dodge around while you wait for your stamina to regen. Waiting for Quen means that you have a significant amount of downtime which is boring. And if your Quen isn't going down because you're dodging, well, you're not actually using it. Successful use of Quen requires you to be hit. Let me repeat that: you need to get hit for Quen to do anything. Quen has its place mostly against slow opponents with large, sweeping attacks that are difficult to dodge but have large recovery times, thus Quen eats the one attack it can do and lets you go on the offensive. Against faster enemies, you're better off using signs that actually let you go on the offensive for longer while dodging incoming attacks which you can see coming due to your superior positioning. It does, in fact, boil down to you being bad at the game since Quen requires you to get hit. The real trick for someone who is good at the game is to have no downtime whatsoever: you are either dodging/parrying an actual attack, repositioning, swinging your sword at them, using a sign, or throwing a bomb, never waiting for stamina to use Quen.

And if you aren't waiting for stamina for Quen, well, then you are playing well enough that you don't need it, so use something else that let's you go on the offensive for longer!

Obviously I can't tell you what you personally find rewarding. But I can say the game itself provides little incentive to do much beyond what I've described.

I think they should redesign the combat from the ground up. Put a much greater focus on animation control - get rid of the randomness it currently has - and make it so both Geralt and his foes have a more grounded damage model. The light/heavy button pairing is also a mistake, I'd change it to single/group attacks. Witcher 1's combat system, while really boring, actually had a nice representation of this. It was a good idea and one I was sad they let go. AI also needs a massive overhaul, its really poor as is.
The incentive is to kill things more efficiently. In this wraith example, sure, you could throw up Quen and do your 2-3 swings until the wraith counters and breaks your Quen then dodge around OR you could use Yrden and do 5-7 swings since the wraith is too slow to break your combo. With Yrden and no other wraiths around, you can do one long combo and kill it whereas, with Quen, you might have to set that up more than once if you're not horribly outleveling the wraith. Or you're not actually using Quen since you're dodging its attacks, in which case, Quen is a waste. And the animations aren't actually random: they trigger based on how far away you are from the enemy. If you are right in close, he does a quick slash which may involve a turn but it has similar timing to the simple slash. If you are a couple of feet away or more, he does the longer leap and slash. The only one that I haven't quite figured out how to do consistently is the roll and stab. There is also a group attack style in the sword tree: whirl. Here's a gif that someone posted in OT1:
 

VE3TRO

Formerly Gizmowned
Morkvarg is cursed to be reborn every time he dies. You have to find a way to lift that curse.

What do I need to do to lift the curse? I've done all objectives. I called out Einar being a liar and killed him now all I have left is a repeat of "Get rid of the werewolf in the garden"
 

AngryMoth

Member
Finally made it to Novigrad. Playtime is bugged, I think due to ps4s rest mode, but I'm guessing I've played about 20 hours.

Some of my initial astoundment at the game's quality is starting to wear off. Been finishing up all the level appropriate side quests in Velen and I'm starting to get sick of wandering around in detective vision pixel hunting for red.

Nethertheless I'm still loving it. I continue to be amazing by the quality of the writing and presentation considering how much of it there is, and the combat while not the best I've played is still pretty good and engaging. And like countless people have said, I think this is the most well realised open world I have experienced.

Few quick questions.
- When I run out of a potion and go to craft another one, it says 'you already have this item' even though I'm on 0/3 or whatever. What's up with that?
- I assume there's no way to stop yourself overleveling? I'm feeling pressured to ignore some sidequests else I'll be to overpowered when I get back to the main story.
- I'm at level 11, about how far in is that?
 

M.D

Member
What tree skills are you guys putting points into? I have 4 points in signs and 3 to spend

I did an alch/signs build in TW2, but have not messed a lot with alch so far

Also, what are alt mode signs? How are you supposed to activate them?
 
What do I need to do to lift the curse? I've done all objectives. I called out Einar being a liar and killed him now all I have left is a repeat of "Get rid of the werewolf in the garden"

Wolf in Sheep's Clothing spoiler:
I convinced Einar to give me a fang that could lift the curse on Morkvarg. Sounds like there is a second way to lift it. Have you tried feeding him his own flesh?
 
For the folks that beat it, about how long did it take you?

I'm not quite finished yet, but I am nearly there I'd say. I've got 65 hours clocked, maybe 5-10 left to finish it all off. And I've still got 12 or so side quests and 12+ Witcher contracts. 100 hours is fast approaching.
 

Maximo

Member
I feel like I'm going to catch an accent by time I finish this game.
The female Master Armourer at Crows Perch makes me laugh everytime she says Geralt! In her accent. Also every keeps saying Whoreson, afraid I'm going to start using that as a insult to someone haah
 

KHlover

Banned
What tree skills are you guys putting points into? I have 4 points in signs and 3 to spend

I did an alch/signs build in TW2, but have not messed a lot with alch so far

Also, what are alt mode signs? How are you supposed to activate them?

Hold the button used to activate signs instead of pressing it. Alt mode signs are modified versions of your signs, ingame explanation should give you a pretty good impression of what they do.

The female Master Armourer at Crows Perch makes me laugh everytime she says Geralt! In her accent. Also every keeps saying Whoreson, afraid I'm going to start using that as a insult to someone haah

Fun fact: In Germany those guys are called "Hurensohn". This is an actual insult over here (suprise suprise, it means "son of a whore"), so seeing them gives me a nice giggle every time :D
 
Finally made it to Novigrad. Playtime is bugged, I think due to ps4s rest mode, but I'm guessing I've played about 20 hours.

Some of my initial astoundment at the game's quality is starting to wear off. Been finishing up all the level appropriate side quests in Velen and I'm starting to get sick of wandering around in detective vision pixel hunting for red.

Nethertheless I'm still loving it. I continue to be amazing by the quality of the writing and presentation considering how much of it there is, and the combat while not the best I've played is still pretty good and engaging. And like countless people have said, I think this is the most well realised open world I have experienced.

Few quick questions.
- When I run out of a potion and go to craft another one, it says 'you already have this item' even though I'm on 0/3 or whatever. What's up with that?
- I assume there's no way to stop yourself overleveling? I'm feeling pressured to ignore some sidequests else I'll be to overpowered when I get back to the main story.
- I'm at level 11, about how far in is that?

For potions they get automatically replenished when you meditate if you have alcohol.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom