• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

RTTP: The Pokemon. All 721 of them, and counting.

Macka

Member
Abomasnow is one of the most popular Pokemon of the 4th gen. It's like saying Lucario is a bad design or something.
I know, I removed the line about Abomasnow in the quote because I was commenting on the thread being depressing part. If it came across as condescending or mean-spirited, that wasn't my intent. I just find it funny that everyone here is so invested in their favourites that they can't tolerate other people disliking them. And I'm guilty of that too!
 

Azuran

Banned
You knock just as many Pokemon as you cry out in agony over when other people do the same. :p

I honestly like pretty much all of them except for Quagsire and Bidoof. Those two need to burn for all eternity.

I like Shinx, heck the moment I first saw him in a Corro Corro leak I said to myself, "That little guy is so going on my team."

And I made the right choice.

I love Shinx too and I use him throughout Gen IV but I was just so dissapointed in Luxray. Lions are define by their mane and Luxray had the worst one I ever seen on any fictional lion.

Gonna have to agree with you here. Gen IV designs just rub me the wrong way for the most part. Wouldn't call Spiritomb, Garchomp, or Lucario great either, and Drifblim is on the edge.

I assume it's easier for me to like things because I find all of those Pokemon amazing. Garchomp is in my top 5. It's a land shark aircraft monster. That's like the one coolest things ever.
 

StoneFox

Member
Luxray is a lynx, not a lion.

Although Shinx looking just like Kimba the White Lion is probably what makes people think the line is based off lions. :p
 

Boss Doggie

all my loli wolf companions are so moe
Luxray is a lynx, not a lion.

Although Shinx looking just like Kimba the White Lion is probably what makes people think the line is based off lions. :p

Pretty sure it is. In fact it even has a mane thing going on for gender even. Lynxes aren't "regal" like that. You also got Rivalry, Luxio (leo), and Shinx (sphinx, no it's not based on the name of lynx despite what many people say). Luxray has a mane, has a tail fluff, and its evolution relies on its mane growing.

Maybe when a lynx starts looking ilke a lion :p
 

PK Gaming

Member
I know, I removed the line about Abomasnow in the quote because I was commenting on the thread being depressing part. If it came across as condescending or mean-spirited, that wasn't my intent. I just find it funny that everyone here is so invested in their favourites that they can't tolerate other people disliking them. And I'm guilty of that too!

Truth

You are my sworn enemy because you despise Gen V, the perfect gen
 

Crayolan

Member
I assume it's easier for me to like things because I find all of those Pokemon amazing. Garchomp is in my top 5. It's a land shark aircraft monster. That's like the one coolest things ever.

Honestly the thing that really bothers me about Garchomp is that it always looks so angry. Dude needs to chill the fuck out.
 

Azuran

Banned
Honestly the thing that really bothers me about Garchomp is that it always looks so angry. Dude needs to chill the fuck out.

He's just tsundere that's all

garchomp_is_the_best_by_michi_chi-d7b9mp2.png
 
While I'm not the biggest fan of land shark how is he focus tested? Seems pretty original to me.

Hey kids, what animals are cool?

Sharks!
Dragons!

*scribbles*

What do you think of this?

Needs more spikes!
Put scythes on his arms!
Stick a star on his face!

*scribbles*

Yeah badass!
My Garchomp could beat up your Garchomp!
 

PK Gaming

Member
I'm pretty all sure these Garchomp haters are bitter Flygon fans.

It's been almost 10 years. It's time to let go guys.

I mean, people generally dislike people who are overly talented/popular and Garchomp is basically that person in Pokemon form

Garchomp's cool though, always been one of my more liked Dragon-types
 

GoldStarz

Member
Reasons to use Garchomp: It's Shiny Mega is PANK.

Also on the topic of Luxray vs. Pyroar, I personally think Pyroar looks too gaudy (in both male and female formes), it gives me a new appreciation of Luxray's more subtle mane because Pyroar's is too over-emphasized.

Gen IV and V have the best designs imo
 
I'm pretty all sure these Garchomp haters are bitter Flygon fans.

It's been almost 10 years. It's time to let go guys.
I don't mind Garchomp, but I would like Flygon to get some more attention. Every Hoenn Dragon type has a mega evolution except Flygon. Salamence, Altaria, Latios, Latias, and Rayquaza, but not Flygon...
 

Macka

Member
It's a toss up for me between Garchomp and Hydreigon as the worst looking pseudo. As others have said, Garchomp just looks so over-the-top EXTREME BADASS to the point of ridiculousness imo, and Hydreigon isn't much better in that regard, plus it has emotionless dead eyes. At the moment I'd rank them as...

Tyranitar > Noivern* > Dragonite > Metagross >>> Salamence >> Goodra >> Garchomp > Hydreigon

*
not really a pseudo, but looks so damn good it should be.
 

brinstar

Member
Hydreigon is the worst looking pseudo to me. If it gets a Mega I hope it becomes a full hydra instead of the weird puppet hands
 

ffdgh

Member
Pseudo ranks?

Metagross > dragonite> garchomp> salamence> goodra> tyranitar> Hidreigon

Metagross edges into first for not being dragon/dracoic.
 

PK Gaming

Member
They're all rather good in their own way

Hydreigon looks a bit silly (it really should have a fully formed lower half) but it definitely gives off the sense of violent, destructive monster that will kill anything that moves. I'm pretty fond of it.

Even if Garchomp is edgy, it undeniably nails the "intimidating aura" that most Pokemon don't have. I think the panel from the Pokemon Adventures manga does a good job of illustrating that:

200px-Cynthia_Garchomp_DPA.png


If I were to rate them, i'd probably order them like so:

Garchomp > Tyranitar > Metagross > Hydreigon > Dragonite > Goodra

Goodra is likeable I guess but sweet jesus does it not convey "pseudo-legendary" at all. It looks like an ordinary 3rd stage Pokemon.
 

Mr-Joker

Banned
Hey hey I will not hear any shit talk about Garchomp. >:O

tumblr_mu1huroRmP1r100j1o1_500.gif


Or I will set the queen after you.

To be fair, they did apparently try to give Flygon a Mega. It's just that they failed lol

How hard can it be? All they need to do is add spikes and shit and boom you have a mega.
 

Xenoboy

Member
People hatin' on Garchomp? It's incredibily cute, shame on you! It's not trying to be "edgy".
What's the problem with Hydregeon?
 
Top Bottom