• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Polygon: Xbox Scorpio will be a ~6 TFLOP system (v PS4K's 4.14), unveil soon, Fall 17

timlot

Banned
Who is going to buy an Xbox One this year if next year they can buy one that's four times as powerful for $100 more? At least if Sony announces the Neo at E3, the Neo will be coming out this year and will probably be framed as a second tier of PlayStation. Microsoft would have to significantly mark down the Xbox One *this year* to not have a negative impact on current sales.

Hmmm, why would I buy a PS4 now if I know Neo is coming out "this year"? Given that the price difference between the two is probably no more than $100-$150 I would just forego purchase a PS4.

The price difference between XB1 and Scorpio will be substantial. 6TF in 2017? I'm guessing $599. A slim XB1 will be coveted item in and of itself. Especially at around a $249 price point.
 

Bsigg12

Member
Isn't the rumor that PS4.5/X1.5 are fall 2017?

The PS4 Neo is rumored for this year.

I don't believe polygon at all when it comes to Xbox. They have a reputation

It's being corroborated by Jason over at Kotaku and Brad Sams (Microsoft insider) said he had some more information he hadn't completely pinned down regarding the new console that he didn't want to share yet, which I'm guessing has to do with what Microsoft is aiming for with the power of the box.
 

Chronos24

Member
One thing is for sure...

For all the people that say 'Power doesn't matter!'
a) It's clear that the smart decision-making people at Sony and Microsoft have come to the opposite conclusion, and
b) The most powerful console of this gen has utterly dominated it.

That old 'Power doesn't matter' argument looking mighty weak right now. The new truth is 'Exclusives don't matter.' That's one I can get behind.

I gotta say, I was basically crucified in another thread about the whole power argument meaning more now than ever and the ps4 is a perfect example. Looks like more and more people are seeing my point here.
 

Striek

Member
Hmmm, why would I buy a PS4 now if I know Neo is coming out "this year"? Given that the price difference between the two is probably no more than $100-$150 I would just forego purchase a PS4.

The price difference between XB1 and Scorpio will be substantial. 6TF in 2017? I'm guessing $599. A slim XB1 will be coveted item in and of itself. Especially at around a $249 price point.

Do you predict a really dumb high price just so you can feign surprise when its way cheaper than that?
 

xaosslug

Member
wait, so they're gonna pull a PS3 era Sony (launch late + more expensive), only with none of the WW mindshare and no proverbial 'lead' due to their previous iteration? Talk about sent to die. SMH
 
Oh man I shouldn't have gotten excited it's Arthur Gies. I'm amazed he limited it to 6. Should have gone with 12 and the headline - "Devs abandon PS4 due to the overwhelming majesty and power of the next Xbox"
 

Jagernaut

Member
Hmmm, why would I buy a PS4 now if I know Neo is coming out "this year"? Given that the price difference between the two is probably no more than $100-$150 I would just forego purchase a PS4.

The price difference between XB1 and Scorpio will be substantial. 6TF in 2017? I'm guessing $599. A slim XB1 will be coveted item in and of itself. Especially at around a $249 price point.

A $599 console is not going to sell well. It would be a big mistake.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
Oh man I shouldn't have gotten excited it's Arthur Gies. I'm amazed he limited it to 6. Should have gone with 12 and the headline - "Devs abandon PS4 due to the overwhelming majesty and power of the next Xbox"

Well supposedly it was 5 to 6, so naturally the highest end will be clung to.
 
The PS4 Neo is rumored for this year.



It's being corroborated by Jason over at Kotaku and Brad Sams (Microsoft insider) said he had some more information he hadn't completely pinned down regarding the new console that he didn't want to share yet, which I'm guessing has to do with what Microsoft is aiming for with the power of the box.

Oh, then my interest is raised. Got to wait for E3.
 

Striek

Member
One thing is for sure...

For all the people that say 'Power doesn't matter!'
a) It's clear that the smart decision-making people at Sony and Microsoft have come to the opposite conclusion, and
b) The most powerful console of this gen has utterly dominated it.

That old 'Power doesn't matter' argument looking mighty weak right now. The new truth is 'Exclusives don't matter.' That's one I can get behind.

Couldn't be more wrong. The PS4 and XBOne themselves indicate that power isn't important to these companies. They are both really puny upgrades from last-generation.

They had the smallest generational power gap by far with by far the most time between generations. How does that indicate a focus on power?

Likewise, these iterative upgrades would be even more weak given we're talking 4+ years.

The age of powerful consoles has finished. The growth in hardware power is getting smaller and smaller as time goes by.
 

MuchoMalo

Banned
traded in my ps4 today... waiting for e3

714195_cbc8_625x1000.jpg


I don't understand why you would do this.
 
Well supposedly it was 5 to 6, so naturally the highest end will be clung to.
Two publications/people have corroborated the target range (which at this stage is subject to change and likely meaningless). We have clarification from one of those that it was a single source. What are the odds they both had the same source?
 

Markoman

Member
I gotta say, I was basically crucified in another thread about the whole power argument meaning more now than ever and the ps4 is a perfect example. Looks like more and more people are seeing my point here.

Ok, power may have meant something this gen. But have you heard the news? There are no gens anymore in the future. Power will become irrelevant in the grand scheme of things especially in fanboy wars, because we could end up with 2 year cycles down the road and Sony and MS won't release their consoles head to head again. This would mean that a proud Xbox2 owner only has one year and a handful of games to brag about until the next more powerful Playstation is upon us. Oh, the irony...
 

jeffc919

Member
6 TFlops!

Daaaamn MS you have my attention

I was on the fence about upgrading to the Neo if it releases this fall but depending on when the respective releases happen, maybe I just wait for this new xbox. Very interested to hear something official about release dates and specs.
 

KampferZeon

Neo Member
Cant't compare TFlops of NVidia to AMD. Dont scale the same.

Will get an Xbox again when this launches again. I take it the inevitable PC versions of Gears 4 and Scalebound will play like shit so a more powerful console would be nice to get them running well.

Dont spoil the fun.

Why couldn't xbox 2017 comes with Nvidia GPU if we are in the "anything is believable territory"

gflops is a universal definition for all gpus hardware from nvidia, amd or intel.
AMD is very poor converting power to actual performance for some unknown reason.

The liquid cooled R9 is at 7tflops yet its real life performance is only comparable to the 5.5K GTX980.

I used the 1070 what is physically needed to achieve 6T.

i wasn't talking about the theoretical performance and actual reallife performance differences between AMD and nvidia.
 
All of this is stupid. I'm sticking to upgrading my pc. Ms seems to want to port everything to pc anyway so what's the point of a $600 box that's so powerful.
 
From who? Gamestop? Sony sure as hell wouldn't it themselves.

I doubt your ps4 will ever be worth more than it is now to anyone.

I'm hoping MS will prior to the release of this rumored console, assuming it's true. Perhaps it's wishful thinking.

Edit: I realize he had a PS4. I suppose he probably is better off trading in prior to E3 if he doesn't use it much.
 

WadeitOut

Member
The console performance is probably not relevant to the PS4 overwhelming success.


This gets a 0% accuracy rating. There is no way in hell the PS4 would be doing so much better than the Xbox One had it not had the "it's more powerful" argument from day one.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
Two publications/people have corroborated the target range (which at this stage is subject to change and likely meaningless). We have clarification from one of those that it was a single source. What are the odds they both had the same source?

I am not arguing a source, I am just musing how 6 is the number paraded, when 5 is every bit as relevant. And judging by the story breaker, it is not too surprising a happy medium wasn't even chosen. Is all.
 
XBox could be hamstrung by its ESRAM, Unless they do magic they need to keep putting the ESRAM in to maintain backwards compatibility. Which could get expensive, meaning less profits or a more expensive console. Dropping backwards compatibility isn't an option, since that would defeat the whole purpose of iterative hardware.
They don't need esram for backwards compatibility even if they weren't already moving towards a platform agnostic development platform before the xbone even launched.

Esram is just a faster memory pool than the main memory and the system has dedicated hardware for moving data around both memory pools without stalling the rendering.

Even if the OS wasn't virtualized in the new system it would be very easy for them to intercept the calls that directly manage the esram and act accordingly to the new archictecture.
 

mjp2417

Banned
All of this is stupid. I'm sticking to upgrading my pc. Ms seems to want to port everything to pc anyway so what's the point of a $600 box that's so powerful.

If you have a gaming PC, there is no reason to be considering a new Xbox at this point. This isn't pitched at you or me.
 

ZeroCDR

Member
714195_cbc8_625x1000.jpg


I don't understand why you would do this.

I sold my PS4 last week for more than I paid for it, a no brainier for me before the value plummets. I can put it towards whichever sounds best, or rebuy a better PS4 bundle this fall if they're too far away/a bust.

I played what I wanted to for now on PS4 and I still have an insane backlog for what I've still got.
 

bobbytkc

ADD New Gen Gamer
Well, if they are indeed launching later than the PS4, it makes sense that they should have the more powerful hardware.

This is an interesting turn of events. I wonder how the market will react to it.
 

Striek

Member
This gets a 0% accuracy rating. There is no way in hell the PS4 would be doing so much better than the Xbox One had it not had the "it's more powerful" argument from day one.

Uhhh, did you forget that the Xbox One had, and indeed still has, the shackles of god awful policy (DRM, DRM, DRM) and hardware decisions (Kinect, $499) that MS made dragging it down? Marketing blunder after marketing blunder?

PS4 would be the same because most people didn't want an Xbox One when it launched. It was $100 more expensive and had one of the worst pre-launch hype periods of all time. Now it might be the same price/cheaper, but momentum doesn't work that way. You screw the pooch early, you're playing catchup the rest of the gen. Simple. Power is a realllllllllllly small factor in why the XBOne is failing.
 
Top Bottom