• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

IGN's Peer Schneider: "the NX is a complete reboot for Nintendo"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Couldn't help but notice that subreddit's thread on a tweet Nintendo of Europe posted today:



Attached footage then shows Link going inside said house to retrieve...an axe.

N X.

I don't think this means anything but I love the notion of some intern having fun with us.

I REALLY don't think it means anything, besides, it's a repost. That clip was already shown at least a month ago when they started showing clips.
 

MuchoMalo

Banned
Yeah NateDrake afaik is not an insider, his sources are our sources, and then the rumor of customization is a speculation upon a speculation. (Though a logical one because all Nintendo's previous chips were customized.) All we 'know' is the dev kit has a tegra x1. After that I don't know why you jump to 14nm FinFET. I would like it to be Pascal based, I think it makes sense, because you need something passively cooled for a handheld, but this is still Nintendo we're talking about, so don't assume anything.

I pointed this out before, but on the console side the Wii U was the only time Nintendo was ever behind a node at a console's launch. It's a bit more complicated with handhelds, but still I don't think you should take Wii U as the absolute norm here.
 

Plinko

Wildcard berths that can't beat teams without a winning record should have homefield advantage
Just seems that if it doesn't happen in the Sept/Oct time frame, it would be best to wait until January.

Although a Xmas day Direct would be kind of cool.

It won't be past October. Plenty of time to fit it in that month.
 

Vena

Member
Is sboat the s-rank version of cboat?

I just really want his leak to be true, but as a Nintendo fanboy of thirty years, there's too much history to believe in dreams.

What history? You need only look to the 3DS for a device that came out with tech that was on the bleeding edge, it just wasn't the processor or the GPU. It was the screen.

WiiU was a huge investment in lossless, frame-perfect streaming. It didn't pan out.

Nintendo applies technology as they see fit, but not everything is lateral thinking with withered tech (this has always been true, but people are blinded by bullshit buzzwords like "supercharged PC architecture" or, more recently, "4K" oozing from Sony and Microsoft). The NX is based on a concept of mobility and home, in such a scenario they'd put a lot of emphasis on tech that can do both and do them well (hence Pascal making a lot of sense). It leads to a handheld/tablet-thing that blows everything out of the water and a fairly muted console but it is what it is.
 
It won't be past October. Plenty of time to fit it in that month.

I agree. "Very soon" as the Nintendo exec said at the GameStop meeting isn't Christmas or January if this thing is releasing in March. That's not "soon," that's "later."

Kind of genius to reveal it later this month or October though. People are getting all excited for the PS4 Pro which is releasing in November, and just a few weeks to a month can get that hype down a little to slap everyone in the face with the NX, and people can just get the NES Classic to hold off.

Assuming third party support actually happens to succeed. Looking a little better than WiiU with RE7's trademark getting out involving "Video Game Cartridges", just like BoTW.

Sep. 20th definitely isn't happening though.
 

jmizzal

Member
Not really. Nintendo specifically said they'll talk about it more in the fall season. Not even fall yet.

Sept 22nd is the first day of Fall, I do believe the Oct reveal rumor, but I hope they give us a few weeks notice before the reveal, which we should get notice in Sept
 
If only there was a Neo/Scorpio level leak >.<

This wait is just ugh.

That would make the reveal boring. Not knowing much is what makes this so exciting. Compare a Pro thread to a NX thread and they're wide apart in terms of suspense and excitement.

The Pro threads were boring because we already knew almost everything about it. The NX is much more interesting because its still a mystery.
 

udivision

Member
That would make the reveal boring. Not knowing much is what makes this so exciting. Compare a Pro thread to a NX thread and they're wide apart in terms of suspense and excitement.

The Pro threads were boring because we already knew almost everything about it. The NX is much more interesting because its still a mystery.

On some levels that's true, but if the NX was just supposed to be an updated Wii U form factor without the promise of new games, I'd assume the hype would be a lot lower.
 

marmoka

Banned
GAF tomorrow:

tumblr_mwng1139rM1qk4psso1_500.png
 

Malus

Member
Did eurogamer go back on the sept 20 date?

Eurogamer never mentioned a specifc day of september, that was Nicowav.

They haven't changed their stance as far as I know, but they haven't exactly said "we're adamant it's coming in september guys." Just that they haven't gotten new info.
 

2+2=5

The Amiga Brotherhood
NSMB, Mario Kart and Smash could all be played with just a circle pad and several buttons. So could most platformers, racers and fighters, you don't need dual analogs and 12 buttons for most games really.
That's a really small subset of games, basically only some games from nintendo, some indie games and few others, big third parties wouldn't use that feature it in their big games if not in minigames, it would just make the things confusing.

Also take into account a 2d/2.5d game playable with just an analog doesn't mean it could be played in multiplayer, some games are meant to be single player only like most of metroidvanias, adventure games, horror and others.

In my idea if you want multiplayer you use the nx on the dock plugged to the tv and 2 or more gamepads, while on handheld mode you are limited to single player and online multiplayer, simple and clear, it doesn't sound bad at all to me.

Thoughts exactly, but I understand the majority of players may like that feature.
I understand that too :)
 

marmoka

Banned
At this point, best case scenario for the 20th is a press release saying

"Join us on October 4th/11th/18th for a special announcement."

I would be happy with that. I only need to know the official NX presentation date. If Nintendo announces tomorrow that event for October 4th, that would be enough for me.

And the following 2 weeks will be really long.
 

Plinko

Wildcard berths that can't beat teams without a winning record should have homefield advantage
Wouldn't be shocked at all if they don't even announce a reveal date until October.
 
Just seems that if it doesn't happen in the Sept/Oct time frame, it would be best to wait until January.

Although a Xmas day Direct would be kind of cool.

For a while I thought they might start their preorder campaign in the fall and maybe offer some sort of package to put under the Christmas tree. It would be just like they did with Star Wars toys back in the day.

Now I think they will wait until January.
 

Thraktor

Member
Ok memory card doesn't equal cartridge which means I'm still expecting load times (look at Vita). I want cartridge confirmation and zero load times

It's worth clarifying the difference between old-style cartridges, modern 3DS-style game cards, and memory cards (i.e. SD cards).

Cartridges - Used in NES, SNES, N64, etc - ROM - Directly addressable via the memory bus, meaning data doesn't need to be loaded into memory when starting up the game, giving close to zero load times. Impractical on a modern system for a variety of reasons.

Game Cards - Used in DS, 3DS, NX - ROM - Accessed via its own bus, assets must be loaded into memory before use. Modern cards should be comfortably faster than optical media, and potentially faster than HDDs for contiguous reads, and orders of magnitude faster than both in terms of latency. Not zero load times but potentially faster loading than systems with disc-based media.

Memory Cards - SD Cards, etc. - NAND Flash - Not used in games consoles. Slower than game cards due to the need to run everything through a flash controller chip.

NX will be using game cards, not cartridges or flash memory cards. The load times are going to depend on the interface Nintendo uses for the cards. The DS and 3DS use an 8-bit parallel interface, but this was chosen back in 2004 for a handheld with limited 3D capabilities, and had to accommodate writing saves to the card. If they're designing a new game card interface for a modern system it would make sense for them to switch to a serial interface and drop support for on-card saves. Hopefully they adopt a variable-speed serial interface, potentially allowing games that need it as much as 250MB/s or even 500MB/s (or higher for NX2) without increasing costs for games that don't.

Maybe they really did postpone the release to get a custom Tegra X2, and there's no update because they are in fact only getting built now.

The design of the SoC would have been pretty well finalised by the time they announced the March 2017 release date. It's possible they made a switch from TSMC's 16FF+ to their new 16FFC process, which would potentially allow them to bring down power consumption and reduce costs a little, but there wouldn't have been any major redesigns possible at that stage.

I am going to draw out some scenarios so that people understand what could happen with NX's GPU.

We currently have dev-kits which are not finalised and contain a Tegra X1. It is rumoured from NateDrake that the NX will have a Pascal-based Tegra GPU.

Nvidia license out their GPUs, they don't do Semi-Custom designs like AMD which has been mentioned by other posters.

I will show what scenarios could happen. This ignores customisation.

- The GPU is unchanged and Nintendo have a stock Tegra X1 as the GPU for the NX. Keep in mind that 20nm chips do not have much manufacturing lines because it was a die size most companies passed on or stopped early because the performance benefits weren't significant.

- The Tegra X1 GPU has a die-shrink to 14nmFF, this gives a performance boost to save on energy but keeps the Maxwell Architecture.

- The GPU is Parker which is a 14nmFF design and has Pascal architecture.

Nvidia's GPUs are licensed, asking to have a Tegra X1 stay 20nm while changing to a Pascal architecture means designing a whole new chip. It is cheaper to pick Parker because it is already a GPU design with Pascal architecture.

If Nintendo decided to stick with some random 28nm chips, they would still have to do a die-shrink later on because it becomes expensive to manufacture 28nm over time when smaller nodes become cheaper to manufacture. 28nm has been around for a few years, things have finally picked up with 16nmFF/14nmFF that 7nm is expected by 2019.

Those are the scenarios I have drawn out.

There's really no reason to frame Nintendo's options in relation to existing Tegra chips. The NX will almost certainly be the biggest selling Tegra-powered device ever made by a substantial margin, and the chip that powers it will be made in far larger quantities, perhaps by an order of magnitude or more, than either TX1 or Parker. If anything, it would make far more sense for Nintendo and Nvidia to design NX's SoC from scratch and then use a variant of that for Parker, rather than vice versa.

Maxwell and Pascal are near-identical graphics architectures, and are both inherently modular and scalable, based around 128 ALU "Shader Modules" or SMs. Really there are only three questions when it comes to NX's GPU hardware:


  1. What manufacturing process will it be made on (ie 28nm, 20nm or 16/14nm)?
  2. How many of each functional unit will it have (ie how many SMs, ROPs, etc)?
  3. What clock speed will it operate at?
Nintendo's decisions on each of these are pretty much completely independent of the decisions Nvidia made for TX1 and Parker, and will depend on their own preferences when it comes to cost, performance and power draw. Both Nvidia and Nintendo have ample experience designing mobile SoCs, and in the grand scheme of SoC design this is definitely a case where the expected production run is so large the designers can do whatever they like without feeling constrained to simply modify an existing design.

(Also, while Nvidia haven't operated on a semi-custom business model recently, there's no reason to believe they wouldn't if it were profitable for them, just as AMD operate both semi-custom and licensing models depending on the client).
 
It already feels like cabin fever in these threads, but if the lack of information keeps up much longer, I don't know how bad it will get.
But anyway late October is good for a reveal because that's wen my birthday is
 

MuchoMalo

Banned
Wouldn't be shocked at all if they don't even announce a reveal date until October.

IMO, if nothing is known by October 4th at the latest a delay is very likely. I don't think they'd want to announce in the second half of October, so I think the actual reveal won't be later than October 14th. I think we'll get a date next Tuesday or October 4th.
 

Flare

Member
I feel that we'll get our announcement of the announcement next week. With the official reveal in the second week of October.
Or not and NX will be revealed in April
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom