I said Uncharted 4, outside of Federation Force, was the worst I played this year. So I enjoyed everything else I played more: DOOM, Overwatch, Inside, Kirby: Planet Robobot, Dishonored 2, Tokyo Mirage Sessions, Last Guardian, Star Fox Zero, Pocket Card Jockey, XCOM 2...and anything I may be forgetting.
I just found Uncharted 4 to be, besides totally dull, almost insulting in a way. Dull in that the gameplay and narrative completely failed to engage me intellectually, emotionally...whatever. Insulting in the way that ND presumed that the story they were telling was so interesting and engaging they they could remove any sort of ability for meaningful interaction from the player. There was nothing to figure out, nothing to explore. There was nothing to play with, nothing to learn, no surprising moments on a gameplay level. No intriguing use of mechanics, no impactful level design. And most damaging, VERY little fun outside the set piece from E3.
It was almost as if the gameplay was allowed only begrudgingly with suffocating insistence on story telling first. And OK, you see other narrative focused games that I enjoyed (Inside, Last Guardian) and my opinion is that their stories were worth experiencing and that their gameplay actually heightened the experience. ND completely failed to do this with U4.
Bluntly, they need to get their heads out of their asses, realize they aren't great novelists or film makers and that by purporting to be, they made one incredibly tiresome game.