• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Shooting at GOP baseball practice, multiple injured incl/ Maj. Whip Scalise

Nepenthe

Member
This country violently broke away from Britain over some damn taxes, and those people are hailed by the right as heroes fighting for freedom. Guy shoots and wounds a self-described white supremacist who is part of a party that has not only been threatening political warfare against anyone not a straight white male, but defends the second amendment on the grounds that it well help in the rise of a tyrannical government like they're trying to create, and the GOP wants me to suddenly give a damn?
 

guggnichso

Banned
hey look, he got around to blaming minorities. time is a wheel.

Well, as far as I am informed (please correct me if I'm wrong) the midterms haven't happened yet. So I could hardly blame anyone for their result, because, you know, time and stuff, they didn't happen yet.

This time around, however, it would be cool if liberals would actually go out and vote in their own interest.

I get that there's machinations in place in the US that make it hard for some parts of the population to vote. And that make it easy for their vote to be marginalized. I get that. But for heavens sake, you guys managed to get Obama into office, so you at least have SOME power with your vote. USE it. Go out and vote. Don't just complain on the internet after the fact. Republicans consistently vote in the midterms, based on polling data, just fucking do the same.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
This country violently broke away from Britain over some damn taxes, and those people are hailed by the right as heroes fighting for freedom. Guy shoots and wounds a self-described white supremacist who is part of a party that has not only been threatening political warfare against anyone not a straight white male, but defends the second amendment on the grounds that it well help in the rise of a tyrannical government like they're trying to create, and the GOP wants me to suddenly give a damn?

Destruction of private property is cool when its about the Boston Tea Party but anything else? Unpatriotic! Thuggish! Etc etc etc blah blah blah
 

Drkirby

Corporate Apologist
Yeah totally bro

GOP: Healthcare is a service, can't pay for it fuck you and die. Funding tax cuts for 1% is more important

Democrats: Healthcare is a right, lets try and get as many people covered as possible
In what world are Bernie Sanders' and the GOP's values "similar".
The fact that you consider the former far left in any way is already ridiculous enough as it is and speaks volumes about the political context of the USA.


Ok, I had to actually go back and make sure I didn't confuse something.

Lets go through the chain
I've always maintained that extremists on the Left (my "side", I guess) bother me far more than extremists on the Right, mostly because they muddy our waters more than extremists on the other side do.
congrats, your brain is broken
No, its actually very normal. The Sunni and Shia situation is a similar parallel, where because they are so similar, the differences between them become much more decisive causing huge strifes between the groups.

No, I am in fact commenting about a person who is bothered by "their side's" extremists, and saying that its normal to bothered more by dissenters closer in their own ideologies that dissenters from different ideologies, and that is due to the fact you are able to connect with them on a more personal level. While it may be a awful parallel to draw due to going to the extreme, an example of this is the Sunni/Shia conflict, where the groups are more antagonistic towards each other for being heretics, than they are for followers of completely different beliefs.

I think I am awful at explaining my position, and it does not help that I can't think of the correct terms to find research on the physiological phenomena that I am trying to argue.

The position I am trying to argue is that groups with similar beliefs doing something "wrong" in relation to their belief set, will often bother people more than groups with different beliefs doing something "wrong".
 

jay

Member
you only feel it's a marginalization because I compared the effects of american white nationalism by bureaucrats to another bureaucrat who was responsible for the death of millions of people. My grandmother was the child of a slave, I have family members in jail because of the drug war, get outta here thinking you're the only one with proximity to tragedy.

I have an idea of the full range of scope of damage done by white nationalism in American govt (at the local, state, and national level) as well as the scope of damage done by the holocaust. Can you say the same?

The posts between you two is almost a case study of how people react to violent crime versus white collar crime that hurts and kills people indirectly (perhaps I should say institutionalized crime, since slavery was not indirect). Well, also this entire thread.
 

vonStirlitz

Unconfirmed Member
Woah at that Sanders thing.

I dont think there has been serious (possible) left wing violence aince the early 70s. Terrorists these days seem to be fundamentalists of the right and islamic varients (not that the right in the US get labelled as such frequently).

Aside from suggesting possible dark paths ahead, Trump will use this for maximum leverage.
 

Oni Jazar

Member
Healthcare is an extremely anxiety loaded issue. I'm 39 years old and I've just been notified that my job will be ending early next year. Now republicans are trying to pass a bill that the CBO (a trusted, non-partisan organization) reports will leave 20+ millions more uninsured & could cause premiums for those 50-60 of age to be 5-8 times the cost of Obamacare with possibly less essential benefits. I'm scared shitless. I don't advocate violence but I've been calling/faxing congressmen and I feel it's falling on deaf ears. When people's life and family are on the line and they aren't being heard they get desperate.

That's not democratic rhetoric it's the friken Congressional Budge Office!
 

jstripes

Banned
Yeah GOP operatives are already going with the democratic rhetoric mantra and blaming Dems in general.

I can see them using this to distract and deflect from the Russia probe.

I dont think there has been serious (possible) left wing violence aince the early 70s. Terrorists these days seem to be fundamentalists of the right and islamic varients (not that the right in the US get labelled as such frequently).

Black Lives Matter.

Edit: Before anyone else rushes to click reply, I later clarified that I was pointing out that the right wing views Black Lives Matter in that way.
 

Deepwater

Member
Well, as far as I am informed (please correct me if I'm wrong) the midterms haven't happened yet. So I could hardly blame anyone for their result, because, you know, time and stuff, they didn't happen yet.

This time around, however, it would be cool if liberals would actually go out and vote in their own interest.

I get that there's machinations in place in the US that make it hard for some parts of the population to vote. And that make it easy for their vote to be marginalized. I get that. But for heavens sake, you guys managed to get Obama into office, so you at least have SOME power with your vote. USE it. Go out and vote. Don't just complain on the internet after the fact. Republicans consistently vote in the midterms, based on polling data, just fucking do the same.

and some of the people responsible for voting in Obama voted for Trump so I don't think your posturing means anything
 

Mahonay

Banned
When is violence justified in your opinion?

It's easy to take a stance against future violence while reaping the spoils from past violence. But it is also dishonest to an extent.
For someone who's calling people out left and right for being high and mighty....this is well...high and mighty.
 

Mahonay

Banned
Woah at that Sanders thing.

I dont think there has been serious (possible) left wing violence aince the early 70s. Terrorists these days seem to be fundamentalists of the right and islamic varients (not that the right in the US get labelled as such frequently).

Aside from suggesting possible dark paths ahead, Trump will use this for maximum leverage.
It's not surprising considering the current extreme climate. A Trump presidency is an extreme reality to live in.
 
Shooter identified:

22913362-mmmain.jpg


AKA Walter from Big Lewbowski:

latest


w-sob-2.jpg

Please tell me I'm not seeing things here....
 

Bakercat

Member
Just went to the shooters Facebook page and tried to learn a little about the man. It seems he was very upset about many republican ideas and how things were changing. It's sad to see that he felt that this was the only way to change things. I also looked at the comments people made and it's sad to see such hate for each other just because of political parties. This is being spun into the idea that democrates are the enemy and how horrible they are. It feels like this story is gonna really tear the country further apart.
 

Ernest

Banned
King on the shooting of Giffords...
Washington D.C.- Congressman Steve King (R-IA) released the following statement after United States Representative Gabrielle Giffords was shot during a public event in Tuscon, Arizona today.

“My prayers continue to be for Gabrielle Giffords, her family, her staff, and all those that are in agony today,” said King. “We serve together and she is outgoing, personable and widely respected. It is inconceivable that anyone could harbor a vile, vindictive or malicious attitude towards her. I will continue to pray for her swift recovery and for the recovery of all those injured in this tragedy.”

Interesting that he didn't see all the division & rhetoric back then, and was able to narrow it to a single vile person instead of a "side" like he does now.
 

Ekai

Member
Just as I expected when I heard the news about him being a Bernie supporter. Hot Takes from Centrists about how evil and unhinged the left wing is.

: /
 

Mahonay

Banned
they've already blamed minorities for the reason why dems lose elections so everything here is fair game I suppose
Those damn minorities not pulling their weight!

Fucking never ends.

Dumb white people are the only reason we are here. And Russia. Definitely Russia.
 

Clefargle

Member
This isn't good whoever the perpetrator is. I hope it's just a line idiot and not politically motivated. Violence won't fix any of the issues the GOP has. They're not gonna call guns evil.
 

Dyle

Member
Black Lives Matter.
Name one instance in which BLM has advocated or incited violence... There are none. BLM protests have turned violent, either due to police action or people specifically there just to cause trouble, but never in a way that the organizations themselves promoted. Disinformation is dishonest dude
 

Swiggins

Member
This isn't good whoever the perpetrator is. I hope it's just a line idiot and not politically motivated. Violence won't fix any of the issues the GOP has. They're not gonna call guns evil.

Unfortunately it seems to be politically motivated, the shooter was an outspoken Berniecrat and very critical of Trump and the GOP in general. This is gonna cause a shitstorm.
 

tbm24

Member
Yeesh Pelosi's speech worse than Paul Ryan's so far
Different types of speakers, Ryan says simpler things, bluster no substance. Pelosi tried to be substance too much sometimes. Either way her point stands, despite partisan divides, they are one family and a threat to one is a threat to all.
 

kirblar

Member
Just as I expected when I heard the news about him being a Bernie supporter. Hot Takes from Centrists about how evil and unhinged the left wing is.

: /
Right wing partisan republicans are not centrists. You do realize the word "centrist" derives from Center, right?
 
When is violence justified in your opinion?

That's a complicated discussion not really fit for this thread because bottom line there here and now is not justified to start shooting politicians. If it were the other way around you wouldn't be saying that. Shit on republicans all day. Don't start insinuating it's time to start bucking shot because that's not a fight you'd win.

It's easy to take a stance against future violence while reaping the spoils from past violence. But it is also dishonest to an extent.

Man, maybe you don't know who you're talking to but I'm all about violence. At the right time and place and under the right situations where it's absolutely required. As far as benefitting from violence you can say that about anyone in any first world country.

Minorities are partly to blame yes.

Depends. Some minorities went for Trump. But others have been the bedrock of the democratic party for a hot minute.
 

paskowitz

Member
I do see any scenario where this goes well. Even if Trump bites his tongue, Fox and Breitbart will be on this for months.

As fucked up as it is, I would not be surprised if Trump's approval ratings rise.
 

RPGCrazied

Member
Donald Trump Jr.‏Verified account
@DonaldJTrumpJr

THIS

Donald Trump Jr. Retweeted Harlan Z. Hill
ThisDonald Trump Jr. added,
Harlan Z. HillVerified account @Harlan
Events like today are EXACTLY why we took issue with NY elites glorifying the assassination of our President

His son is worse then him sometimes, jesus christ.
 
Minorities are partly to blame yes.
You're going to need to explain. Minorities are the only demographic group that have voted against politicians that love oppression and standing in the way of progress. Even when the ones voted for are still far from ideal and problematic.

They are also heavily targeted so that their vote is suppressed.
 

Chozoman

Banned
stuff like this is amazing. Like what are they going to say when people call them out on it and the other memes like "the founding fathers didnt limit magazine size cause the moose were coming at them" or some shit. What are they going to say? Uh well, its just uh rhetoric.

"I have no recollection of saying that. It's possible I mentioned something similar to a friend at a small party one time, but no...no, I don't recall ever saying that."
 

kess

Member
This country violently broke away from Britain over some damn taxes, and those people are hailed by the right as heroes fighting for freedom. Guy shoots and wounds a self-described white supremacist who is part of a party that has not only been threatening political warfare against anyone not a straight white male, but defends the second amendment on the grounds that it well help in the rise of a tyrannical government like they're trying to create, and the GOP wants me to suddenly give a damn?

An organized movement with clear political goals is worlds away from a lone wolf doing something that the greater part of his movement would not sanction in the first place. The guy literally brought piss to a shit fight, and it's going to be raining diarrhea on liberals.

In the absense of rule of law, Trump will be president. Why don't you think about that.
 

tbm24

Member
I do see any scenario where this goes well. Even if Trump bites his tongue, Fox and Breitbart will be on this for months.

As fucked up as it is, I would not be surprised if Trump's approval ratings rise.
Honestly, Trump's approval rising because he gave a measured response to a tragedy isn't a problem or something you should dread. As shit as Trump is, this is what he should do in this situation. If Republican supporters want to take this and turn it into a partisan issue and belittle the tragedy and lives of these individuals as bullet points, that's their problem and you go after them for it.
 
Top Bottom