You asked why he posted his argument and I told you the context. Not my problem if you can't handle that. Other points he raised can be argued as desired, but his main point was related to mine from earlier. Also, you are quite pathetic to resort to quoting someone and then deliberately attacking them in the same quote by changing the username of the person you are supposedly quoting. Grow the fuck up.
And a world war is NOT what we are engaged in. Our soldiers were either killing Nazis or dying by their hand as their lives were in imminent danger. Your life is not in imminent danger as a result of these Nazis wannabes today. How stupid are you to conflate a genocidal world war with a tiny fringe group rallying at a fucking statue?! Pull yourself together. You've lost all semblance of perspective.
Further, we just had a guy from the town I teach in shoot up a ball game in Washington, DC. We have also had violent riots in Ferguson, MO (which I drive through 4 days a week on my way to the other schools I teach at) not long ago that were successfully anchored to the BLM movement. Folks like Malcolm X advocated to violent reactions to injustice and to this day the general populace hates him and refuses to acknowledge any of his ideas, even the great ones. Do you understand why Bush and Obama refused to label international terrorism with the Muslim moniker? Do you understand why ISIS loves the fact that Trump tries to label them as representing Islam? Do you understand how much harm came from the events at places like Gitmo, or Bagram air base? In a battle of ideas as important as this one you cannot afford to give into the baiting of the other side. You cannot afford to do their work for them and give them their propaganda ready-made on a silver platter. You cannot afford to throw away demographics that could easily stand with you and turn the tide towards burying these fringe assholes. Something feeling good momentarily does not do a thing towards solving the problem. It only escalates things and loses you allies.
The point is that the left does itself harm by advocating violence just for the sake of being violent. It sets the ideas we are trying to convey back a decade or more time and again. Assaulting people for what they believe in is NOT ok. It isn't ok when Nazis do it. It isn't ok when ppl on the left do it (see: various clips of Richard Spencer and his ilk getting sucker punched, check your favorites list if need be). It isn't ok when Trump supporters at a rally do it. It isn't ok when the victim of that violence is perceived to be a broader threat to our way of life like how right wing nuts frame things as they attack abortion clinics. It is NOT ok under ANY circumstances unless you are helping protect someone from imminent harm. Unless you are in such a scenario, there are better, smarter, more effective measures to be taken that do not require you to totally abandon your principles. Might does NOT make right.
I'm sorry a few main things stuck out to me
1) If someone is posting dumb conspiracies and blaming the left for the rise in violent nazis and refuses to back them up for months I'm going to call them dumb
2) I think I explained his post more eloquently because not only did he condemn violence, he also insinuated this happened because of Richard Spencer getting punched along with a healthy dose of alt-right talking points
3) imminent danger? No maybe not for me personally right at this moment. Danger if left unchecked like we saw yesterday? Yes. A white supremacist is the president, armed neo nazis are roaming the streets and you say our lives aren't in danger. Cute
4) punching nazis is always ok, it's not in my favorites but I do watch the gif with glee
5) do you realize how dumb it is to conflate Obama not wanting to call isis and the like radical Islamic terrorists with neo-nazis where the entire dogma is already radicalized genocide. There is no good neo-nazi.
6) riots after a police execution and the National Guard acting militant towards protestors against a racist police department being labeled as violent blm fringes which "lost allies" is just more proof that the white moderate in America is dumb as fuck
7) I'm sorry I still can't take you seriously after you said we need anti-nazi hate speech laws