I enjoyed the new two TRs to an extent, but I don't think the formula has many legs. It has way too many shortcomings: faux platforming, trivial puzzles, joke 'tombs', pretentious narrative, bad writing, bloated skill tree, detective mode, meaningless exploration, fake 'survival' elements, and a complete disregard for core franchise elements. The gunplay is better than the originals (understandable, since it was never a selling point) and it has decent production values, but that's about it.
When you add to the mix some aggressive and user-hostile publishing issues (Microsoft deal, short cut-out content sold as day one DLC, season pass, microtransactions) it's hard to be exited about TR.