• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Did Microsoft do a better job turning around the Xbox One than Sony with the PS3?

Did Microsoft do better turning around Xbox One than Sony with PS3?


  • Total voters
    172

AndrewRyan

Member
PS3 had the ground breaking best ever multiplayer game to ever grace this fine Earth which released just a year after launch.

warhawk-ps3-playstation-3.original.jpg


Nobody could have ever dreamed just how good Warhawk was going to be.

warhawk-ds1-1340x1340.jpg


Men wanted to play Warhawk and Women wanted to do Warhawk.

maxresdefault.jpg


Warhawk was the game on everyones tongues last gen, it really pushed the barriers.

warhawk-20070423070250551-1970871.jpg


If you never played Warhawk, you haven't lived.

53106_0_org2.jpg


I remember playing Warhawk and thinking, this, this is the future of gaming.

maxresdefault.jpg


All hail our Warhawk overlords.

warhawkdual.jpg

For the first few years of PS3 I mostly just played BC PS2 games and Warhawk. The beautiful thing about Warhawk is how well balanced it is and how there were so many ways to play depending on your mood.
 

egocrata

Banned
PS3 had a better turnaround. By the end of gen7, múltiplats even performed better on it. See GTA5, for instance.
 
Last edited:

Codes 208

Member
To those who are confused about why you’re being called out: you’re not actually being called out, it’s just a prank. A couple months ago gaf added the ability for us to create a blank reference that shows up as your name.

So for example in Redneckerz’s post it says Omeggos (me) is a prime candidate.
 
Last edited:

bitbydeath

Member
For the first few years of PS3 I mostly just played BC PS2 games and Warhawk. The beautiful thing about Warhawk is how well balanced it is and how there were so many ways to play depending on your mood.

I played mostly Warhawk for the entirety of last gen. It’s really ruined MP for me.

Nothing comes close.
 

ethomaz

Banned
PS3 from the mid until PS4 release received game after game.

So PS3 did a way better job (that reflected in sales too) than XB1.
 

ethomaz

Banned
Because its Afro Republican. Dude posts a dozen or so polls a week with the same basic template in them.

I mean, i have seen worse ways to boost post count. [vis_name][/vis_name] is a prime candidate of this. ;)
?

My post count is pretty low.

Edit - You got me lol
 
Last edited:

Elios83

Member
Of course not.
PS3 started from a disaster and in the end outsold the 360 worldwide ending in the 85-90m range. It was also the console where Sony built their WW studios success with great exclusives and where they built their online services starting from zero.
The Xbox One situation can't even be properly called a comeback with their low worldwide sales although they still did a lot to try to improve their situation.
 
Last edited:
Excuse me , but what has exactly XBOX ONE turned around? It's been the widest gap between competitors in the industry. If any, the XBOX X has helped Microsoft recover some of their reputation, ONE is pretty much in abandonment at this moment.
 

Optimus Lime

(L3) + (R3) | Spartan rage activated
Idk I'd word it like that, but the amount of spam he gets away with is making NeoGAF look like GameFAQs
It's incredible that he is being allowed to shit up the entire site with these idiotic polls. They are the absolute definition of content-free nonsense. And, as evidenced by his behaviour in some of the threads, the dude's a bit unhinged.
 

AnotherOne

Member
Idk I'd word it like that, but the amount of spam he gets away with is making NeoGAF look like GameFAQs

It's incredible that he is being allowed to shit up the entire site with these idiotic polls. They are the absolute definition of content-free nonsense. And, as evidenced by his behaviour in some of the threads, the dude's a bit unhinged.

Don't you guys think you're acting a bit harsh on the guy... I mean it's not like gaf is booming with traffic. I'd just not participate if these threads bother me pretty simple.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Optimus Lime

(L3) + (R3) | Spartan rage activated
Don't you guys think you're acting a bit harsh on the guy... I mean it's not like gaf is booming with traffic. I'd just not participate if these threads bother me pretty simple.
If he was just some dumbass who was creating terrible content without knowing any better, that would be one thing. But his behaviour in said threads has proved that in addition to making egregiously pointless threads, he's also a nasty piece of work.
 
I mean, as far as sales are concerned, the PS3 ultimately overtook the 360, even if by a slight margin. So PS3's turnaround was much more impressive.
 

SonGoku

Member
It's incredible that he is being allowed to shit up the entire site with these idiotic polls. They are the absolute definition of content-free nonsense. And, as evidenced by his behaviour in some of the threads, the dude's a bit unhinged.
Comon guys, his polls need to be more simple and objective but this level of thread shitting ain't alright either
Besides the site needs all the activity it can get.
 

Optimus Lime

(L3) + (R3) | Spartan rage activated
Comon guys, his polls need to be more simple and objective but this level of thread shitting ain't alright either
Besides the site needs all the activity it can get.
Have you seen his behaviour in the Atari/Amstrad poll thread that he created?
 
Heck no. The PS3 went from being a complete laughing stock that sat on the shelves for months due to the stupidly high price tag and the famous "PS3 HAS NO GAMES!" meme, to a console with a halfway decent library that Sony managed to turn around by the end of the generation. While Microsoft has undoubtedly shed their image of being anti-consumer as the generation has gone on, it still hasn't done enough to entice people and is getting handily outsold by the PS4, and even the Nintendo Switch slowly but surely. Whichever console is better is a matter of debate, but the PS3 had without a shadow of a doubt made a MUCH bigger turn around then Microsoft's Xbox One.

Also, due to all the polls you create, I might as well dub you "Afro-Pollster", LOL!
 

Fox Mulder

Member
PS3 came back and beat the 360 worldwide with MS at their peak. Even the Kinect bump couldn't stop it.

The xb1 is way back behind the PS4's dust. MS hasn't even introduced lots of new franchises like Sony did on the PS3.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
I wouldn't call it a comeback this gen from MS if they literally didn't come back. They have made improvements, but this gen was far out of reach.
 

Pimpbaa

Member
Hell no. Xbox One still has a huge problem of not enough exclusives. Japanese developer support is also hugely lacking. PS3 had neither of those problems later in it's life.
 

Halo0629

Member
Sony was able to turn the tide and eventually sold as much if not more ps3 than 360 at the end. Xbox one is an improvement now but they're still doing everything to catch up or even compete with the ps4 or even switch. Still this gen isn't over yet.
 
Sony’s Blu-Ray CELL 600$ Trojan Horse with a 1 year late start is a turn around.

Formerly always online weaker but more expensive than a PS4 with half the sales Kinect-Box isn’t a turn around.

3DS = turn around
Wii U = not a turn around
 

SynTha1

Member
Because its Afro Republican. Dude posts a dozen or so polls a week with the same basic template in them.

I mean, i have seen worse ways to boost post count. [vis_name][/vis_name] is a prime candidate of this. ;)
Hey don't pick on the new guy I'm just here to read the threads its just entertainment for me and sometimes I get some good information on the industry. I know I don't post much but most times its not worth getting involved with some of the discussions people don't want to have constructive conversations and definitely can't admit when they are wrong but I will be more proactive in the future
 

-Xenokai-

Neo Member
PS3 turnaround was not better. That system was nearly as bad as it was at the end of its life as it was at launch. I owned the thing from day 1 for $600 even and i'm not gonna blindly defend it. It begin a failure and ended as one.
 
Because its Afro Republican. Dude posts a dozen or so polls a week with the same basic template in them.

I mean, i have seen worse ways to boost post count. [vis_name][/vis_name] is a prime candidate of this. ;)
If you've got a bone to pick with me, than say it to my face.

edit: you got me there lol.
 
Last edited:

Redneckerz

Those long posts don't cover that red neck boy
Uh, what exactly have I done wrong thus far? Just wondering because I have not even posted much at all and I have pretty much stayed out of any and all major conflicts that go around on this site.
The only thing you have done wrong is not reading my post correctly. ;)

Hey don't pick on the new guy I'm just here to read the threads its just entertainment for me and sometimes I get some good information on the industry. I know I don't post much but most times its not worth getting involved with some of the discussions people don't want to have constructive conversations and definitely can't admit when they are wrong but I will be more proactive in the future
Read the quote, find the tag. :)

Also you dont have to commit to anything. Your post just makes me feel guilty :)
If you've got a bone to pick with me, than say it to my face.

edit: you got me there lol.
Well, i did say it to your face, no? ;)
 

Toe-Knee

Member
They've done a good job turning it around but when the PS3 dc it around it was done with masses of games so no the Xbox still doesn't have enough of the thing that people buy a games console for
 
Because its Afro Republican. Dude posts a dozen or so polls a week with the same basic template in them.

I mean, i have seen worse ways to boost post count. [vis_name][/vis_name] is a prime candidate of this. ;)

I hope this comes out right... [vis_name][/vis_name] has a habit of doing that. You get used to it though. Honestly, if [vis_name][/vis_name] wants to inflate their post count then more power to [vis_name][/vis_name]. I'm not gonna hate on [vis_name][/vis_name].

OT: No PS3 sold 80M+ and Xbox One won't even sniff that.
 
The only thing you have done wrong is not reading my post correctly. ;)


Read the quote, find the tag. :)

Also you dont have to commit to anything. Your post just makes me feel guilty :)

Well, i did say it to your face, no? ;)

Ah okay, I see now. I also logged out and saw that my username disappeared from your post when I did, so now I get the joke, LOL!
 

CatCouch

Member
I think the PS3 came out quite well in the end. I am happy that Microsoft is turning things around and I am playing my Xbox One a lot now. There is a noticeable bump in Japanese games getting Xbox releases in the last year so I assume Microsoft did something and I'm grateful for that!

I think Microsoft has set themselves up for the next gen quite well and may be able to win me over due to some of Sony's new issues. Nintendo completely fixed all the issues I had with them so I have faith that Microsoft can too.

I hated the PS3 around 2006-07 but ended up loving it by 2013. The 360 had wonderful Japanese support at first but it dried up and moved to the PS3, PSP and Vita. I kind of suspect that next gen Japanese support will move to the Switch and more games will be multi-plat. If that's the case and I can buy most if not all Japanese games between my Switch and next gen Xbox I'll drop Sony.

It's a toss up for me. Sony did a great job turning the PS3 around while Microsoft has set themselves up to turn around next gen. I'm happy with Microsoft now and very unhappy with Sony. I was very unhappy with the 360 and loved the PS3 by the end of the last gen. Hmm, pretty much a role reversal, ha ha~
 

DiscoJer

Member
The problem with the PS3 was basically just price. Yes, it was hard to program for, but realistically, that just made a headache for programmers, not gamers. And part of the reason it was expensive was Blu-Ray, to push for the adoption of it (over HD-DVD)

The Xbone suffered from price, from lack of games, and from being much weaker. It still suffers from all 3.

This Black Friday, I watched at work (Walmart) while our 100+ PS4s for $199 with Spiderman sold out in 5 minutes. We didn't even have a special for the Xbone, even though MS had dropped the price somewhat (to $229 for their bundles), we didn't even bother to change the price tags.

The Xbox X is much more powerful. But it's only owned by a small fraction of Xbone owners.
 

SaucyJack

Member
Don't you guys think you're acting a bit harsh on the guy... I mean it's not like gaf is booming with traffic. I'd just not participate if these threads bother me pretty simple.

Not really. It’s shitposting and there shouldn’t be anything wrong with calling it out.

If someone puts up an obnoxious poll then I’m more than capable of ignoring it. However, in the case of this dude he's spamming the board with his loaded polls. The conversation goes to shit in everyone one of them, it’s exactly the opposite of what GAF needs.
 

ANIMAL1975

Member
Because its Afro Republican. Dude posts a dozen or so polls a week with the same basic template in them.

I mean, i have seen worse ways to boost post count. [vis_name][/vis_name] is a prime candidate of this. ;)
Why do you think that? Not coming at you or anything, just really want to know. Sorry for the derail on the topic, and not voting because as many have said, the options are not objective.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Because its Afro Republican. Dude posts a dozen or so polls a week with the same basic template in them.

I mean, i have seen worse ways to boost post count. [vis_name][/vis_name] is a prime candidate of this. ;)

It's funny that my post trigger people so much, especially the fanboys.
 

mejin

Member
ms efforts are only going to show on the next gen. sony really did their best to turn around in the same gen. That's a critical difference.

And MS lost huge this gen. xbox brand was burned big when we see the results worldwide, ps3 never really went downhill this much.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom