• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.
And where did 64CUs suddenly come from? Is this the dual GPU rumor (72CUs, 36CUs each 4 CUs disabled each)?

People do realize that's gonna price the system well north of $500, right? Assuming it's even true (otherwise Sony would likely be looking at $200 loss per system if not more).
Lol that was about xsx and how hnmg said xsx retail is similar to dev kit spec. Someone did that and said 12.08 TF (64x1400)and Klee said bingo . He later clarified he meant the final number and not the cu and clock
 
Last edited:

hemo memo

Member
Glad I no longer work their then if that's the only prerequisite for not knowing something.

Also about the GS posted games sheet I can actually make a call and find out if that's legit but all of the games having the same release date is a company wide thing. They always have a placeholder date and tentative Price for all upcoming merchandise. The colors kind of throw me off but I will ask. Won't get a definitive answer until tomorrow.
Side note, if you think the price isn't concrete at this point with the reveal coming up soon and Pre-orders immediately to follow .... yea.

OsirisBlack

How soon? Have you heard something? Please tell us if you can?
 
Broken clock etc.

Yea, well, enough of that. I don't have as much fun whining over this stuff. I'll just quietly enjoy the speculation and watch everybody react to each new reddit and pastebin meanwhile everybody ignores the most obvious thing that has been staring them in the face for some time now. Night, night people. Matrix marathon here I come. I suddenly have a desire to see Neo in action. :)
 

Shmunter

Member
This generation it will be all about the games. I have no idea what has or has not changed but the last hard spec info I heard was that both were > 10 and X was 11.6 while the 5 was 12.4 (I am still standing on this hill)I was also told that the ray tracing on one was the same crap that was slapped onto the 1080ti (which I shared a long time ago) and that the performance of BOTH consoles was a bit better that of a 2080 super. Also for the millionth time they are supposedly so close in power that if you were to fart in a room while playing both systems the one you were closest to would have a slight frame rate advantage due to the excess gas helping absorb some of the heat. (I kid) Also I think that I just may get my Bloody Symphony, Thank you uncle Phil.
So this would point to RT being pretty ordinary on one of the consoles. Apart from RT setting them apart, regular operations should be like for like and off a high end caliber.

Your excitement is energizing.
 
Yea, well, enough of that. I don't have as much fun whining over this stuff. I'll just quietly enjoy the speculation and watch everybody react to each new reddit and pastebin meanwhile everybody ignores the most obvious thing that has been staring them in the face for some time now. Night, night people. Matrix marathon here I come. I suddenly have a desire to see Neo in action. :)

I assume you're referring to Github.

Github is real and PS5 is getting dual GPUs. I'm confident about this, but I can't share any information. Just trust me. I'll sit back and wait for your reactions. Also my other buddies think the same thing and may or may not be my source.
 
I assume you're referring to Github.

Github is real and PS5 is getting dual GPUs. I'm confident about this, but I can't share any information. Just trust me. I'll sit back and wait for your reactions. Also my other buddies think the same thing and may or may not be my source.

Thats stupid. It will cost sony a lot of money to make dual gpu for each ps5 unit .
 
Last edited:
I assume you're referring to Github.

Github is real and PS5 is getting dual GPUs. I'm confident about this, but I can't share any information. Just trust me. I'll sit back and wait for your reactions. Also my other buddies think the same thing and may or may not be my source.
Well, you are a new unverified member of Neogaf, so until proven otherwise, you are as reliable as an insider as any random pastebin.
 
Also for the millionth time they are supposedly so close in power that if you were to fart in a room while playing both systems the one you were closest to would have a slight frame rate advantage due to the excess gas helping absorb some of the heat. (I kid)

It's sad. As diplomatic as you're trying to be here, as soon as you say one has a higher tflop than the other....the obvious suspects from either side will start raising concern trolling esque statements e.g.... your input about raytracing capabilities

Regardless...your open candor is still appreciated.
 
Last edited:

Sosokrates

Report me if I continue to console war
Numbers were 64CUs and 1475 Mhz but I insist, everybody took klees comment as just confirming the teraflops number, not the cus and frequency.

I think 64cus is unlikely for XsX, its SoC is about 400mm2, I think 60cus with 4 disabled giving 56 active cu's is the most realistic, could be 56cus with 52 active.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
I was kidding. I am not an insider. I have no information. And neither does Senjetsu.
i thought senjestu said he heard it at xbox fanfest from people who designed the xbox consoles. i said this a few pages ago, but ive always wondered why these guys are so certain about their predictions and well there is our answer. they were told by ms execs and actual hardware designers, and tbh i would be inclined to believe them over journalists too.

that said, note to senjestu, if these xbox designers got the zen cpu leak wrong for the scorpio and made you a laughing stock on these boards for years over that leak, why believe them so blindly about the next xbox?

p.s i recall timdog here talking about how he met penello at e3. this is another xbox fan who seems a 100% sure. we know what penello believes since he came out and said that he thinks the ps5 is $399 and 8 tflops. its possible timdog is so sure because penello convinced him that they will have the more powerful console no matter what.

for the record, there is absolutely nothing wrong with speculation. but if you have sources, lets share them instead of passing off real info as speculation, prediction and doing avatar bets for them knowing you have inside info. its kinda lame.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
I think 64cus is unlikely for XsX, its SoC is about 400mm2, I think 60cus with 4 disabled giving 56 active cu's is the most realistic, could be 56cus with 52 active.
Proelite did some calculations and 350mm2 can get you 60 total with 56 active with a cut down zen 2. its possible that ms went wide and slow and thats why they have a much bigger apu.

i wouldnt be surprised if they have three shader engines and 72 cus, 64 active. they went with 44 cus, 8 more cus than the 580's 36 cus. its possible they once again went with an even bigger gpu than the 5800xt. it doesnt line up with the github leak but it is pretty much the only explanation for the unusually large apu unless they went with a full fat zen 2 which they likely didnt.

this will also help them push the clocks further in case sony came out ahead.
 
i thought senjestu said he heard it at xbox fanfest from people who designed the xbox consoles. i said this a few pages ago, but ive always wondered why these guys are so certain about their predictions and well there is our answer. they were told by ms execs and actual hardware designers, and tbh i would be inclined to believe them over journalists too.

that said, note to senjestu, if these xbox designers got the zen cpu leak wrong for the scorpio and made you a laughing stock on these boards for years over that leak, why believe them so blindly about the next xbox?

p.s i recall timdog here talking about how he met penello at e3. this is another xbox fan who seems a 100% sure. we know what penello believes since he came out and said that he thinks the ps5 is $399 and 8 tflops. its possible timdog is so sure because penello convinced him that they will have the more powerful console no matter what.

for the record, there is absolutely nothing wrong with speculation. but if you have sources, lets share them instead of passing off real info as speculation, prediction and doing avatar bets for them knowing you have inside info. its kinda lame.

The problem I have with that story is why an Xbox hardware designer would divulge any sort of confidential information at a fanfest.
I'm not saying Senjetsu is lying, he may well have spoken to someone with that sort of information. But there's no way anyone with an ounce of professionalism would share sensitive information in public, at an event.
Only Senjetsu has the full story on this interaction, but it doesn't make much sense to me.
 

Moses85

Member
The problem I have with that story is why an Xbox hardware designer would divulge any sort of confidential information at a fanfest.
I'm not saying Senjetsu is lying, he may well have spoken to someone with that sort of information. But there's no way anyone with an ounce of professionalism would share sensitive information in public, at an event.
Only Senjetsu has the full story on this interaction, but it doesn't make much sense to me.

A good friend of mine is working at Nintendo and I see and speak to him regularly. He knows a lot and tells me nothing.

This is called „professionalism“
 

farmerboy

Member
Until Cerny himself tells me otherwise, I think the PS5 will be a very powerful, capable machine.

I've long said that the PS4 is a conservative console, dictated by tech available, financial circumstances and the need to steady the ship. Free from those constraints, I feel Sony will seek to consolidate by innovating. Not more of the same x 10, but a whole new paradigm shift. What they've shown so far hints at that, but as Jim Ryan said, the more distinguishing features have not been shown yet.

This talk of power will carry through the whole gen, because one will indeed be more powerful than the other. But it's the total sum of the parts that will show how capable these machines are. Once we see games, I hope talk will shift to them, because I think we are going to see some amazing stuff.

Genuinely looking forward to it all. Its a new generation folks, buckle in.
 
yeah, im 50-50 on this whole github leak. its possible if sony is going with $399 but i just dont see it.

  • Schrier back in march said that both consoles were aiming to beat stadia's 10.7 tflops number. at that point, no one knew about navi not being gcn.
  • then colin and reiner came out at e3 and said the devs at e3 told them ps5 was more powerful. at this point, the 12 tflops rumors for the anaconda were already out.
  • then klee said both consoles were more powerful than the 5700xt and were aiming for double digit tflops. and ps5 was slightly more powerful.
  • then finally jason said both consoles were more powerful than the rtx 2080 which an 8 or even 9 tflops console simply cannot be. 12 definitely more powerful than the rtx 2080.
so you have the github leaks and penello pointing to 8-9 tflops, and on the other hands multiple devs in the industry saying something completely different to four different journalists.
When the PS5 being slightly more powerful first came out, MS hasn't even sent out dev kits. With consoles being x86 and using AMD GPUs, developers could code the game with out a XSX or PS5 dev it and have 80% of the work done.
Developers would only need 6-12 months to customize it for the consoles.
 

Reindeer

Member
Seriously? Why is that there are SO many claimed Xbox insiders. TimDog, Senjetsu, Klobrille, Colbert, Jez, Sams...
Could it be that 75% of the information is largely made up or spun together without concrete information, and then you all bounce off each other. "I heard this" "I know this", but realistically most of you know nothing?

Either way, your track record is awful.
I wouldn't pay too much attention to these fanboys, they always praise and defend everything Microsoft.
 
Last edited:

James Sawyer Ford

Gold Member
i thought senjestu said he heard it at xbox fanfest from people who designed the xbox consoles. i said this a few pages ago, but ive always wondered why these guys are so certain about their predictions and well there is our answer. they were told by ms execs and actual hardware designers, and tbh i would be inclined to believe them over journalists too.

that said, note to senjestu, if these xbox designers got the zen cpu leak wrong for the scorpio and made you a laughing stock on these boards for years over that leak, why believe them so blindly about the next xbox?

p.s i recall timdog here talking about how he met penello at e3. this is another xbox fan who seems a 100% sure. we know what penello believes since he came out and said that he thinks the ps5 is $399 and 8 tflops. its possible timdog is so sure because penello convinced him that they will have the more powerful console no matter what.

for the record, there is absolutely nothing wrong with speculation. but if you have sources, lets share them instead of passing off real info as speculation, prediction and doing avatar bets for them knowing you have inside info. its kinda lame.

thats precisely the problem with all these Microsoft insiders. Their sources are within Microsoft.

why would Microsoft insiders know anything definitive about PS5? They dont. And if Sony truly has some surprises, they won’t be revealed until after Sony announces them, just like the 8GB GDDR5 surprise, that much RAM wasn’t featured in dev kits yet
 
If Sony is aiming for $400, 8-9TF is a definitely possibility.

If Sony is going for $500, it'll be similar to SeX, which I think most people assume is $500 too.

One thing that seems unrealistic is ~12TF power at $400.
Sony might well be trying to give the best bang for the buck, and a lower CU, higher clock GPU will do that.
Get 10 tflops from a 40cu GPU at 2.0ghz, would be cheaper than getting 10tflops from a 48cu you clocked at 1700ghz.
Cant blame them for that if thats what they are doing.
Lets be honest, PS4 wasn't a beast when it was released, and neither was the PS4 Pro. They were middle of the road compared to what PC was at the time.
 

R600

Banned
Oberon has had stepping till E . The GitHub is Oberon B . Please shows us what changed in Oberon C D and E. U can’t ? Cause u don’t know ? Thanks that’s what I thought . Stop being so certain on things you wish to happen . Ofcourse 50 50 chance but still.

Also how did ur info about Durango being more powerful turn out ?come on man
Tbh that was Komachi mistake. He mixed PCI IDs and assumed 13F9 is Ariel. Its actually Oberon C0 (Ariel A0, B0, Oberon A0, B0 and C0). 5 steppings.

Makes sense since Oberon A0 in Github leak is only actual chip, B0 were just pre silicon numbers, so I guess that one was produced in coming months.
 

-kb-

Member
Sony might well be trying to give the best bang for the buck, and a lower CU, higher clock GPU will do that.
Get 10 tflops from a 40cu GPU at 2.0ghz, would be cheaper than getting 10tflops from a 48cu you clocked at 1700ghz.
Cant blame them for that if thats what they are doing.
Lets be honest, PS4 wasn't a beast when it was released, and neither was the PS4 Pro. They were middle of the road compared to what PC was at the time.

I don't see a 40cu @2.0Ghz part being substantially cheaper then a 48cu @1.7Ghz part, in fact I reckon it'd be more expensive.
 
i thought senjestu said he heard it at xbox fanfest from people who designed the xbox consoles. i said this a few pages ago, but ive always wondered why these guys are so certain about their predictions and well there is our answer. they were told by ms execs and actual hardware designers, and tbh i would be inclined to believe them over journalists too.

that said, note to senjestu, if these xbox designers got the zen cpu leak wrong for the scorpio and made you a laughing stock on these boards for years over that leak, why believe them so blindly about the next xbox?

p.s i recall timdog here talking about how he met penello at e3. this is another xbox fan who seems a 100% sure. we know what penello believes since he came out and said that he thinks the ps5 is $399 and 8 tflops. its possible timdog is so sure because penello convinced him that they will have the more powerful console no matter what.

for the record, there is absolutely nothing wrong with speculation. but if you have sources, lets share them instead of passing off real info as speculation, prediction and doing avatar bets for them knowing you have inside info. its kinda lame.

Ahh i decided to take a look at this one, didn't find it to be much of a troll so decided I'd give it an answer. Nobody from xbox ever told me that Zen would be in Xbox One X, and I've never said any such thing. I simply asked people who had a direct hand in designing xbox one x directly about the possibility of zen being in xbox one x, and based on the response I got and reading their reaction (basically trying to read between the lines) the strong impression I got was that they were clearly doing something with zen at the moment.

That said, remember as early as back then it was made clear that xbox was already working on the next thing after xbox one x, so perhaps the reaction I felt I got from the question on zen and xbox one x was one that I, on my own, in my excitement wrongly applied to xbox one x, when in reality the individuals I spoke to were likely hinting about projects much further out. It was always presented as my own speculation, and not some insider information guarantee that zen would be in xbox one x. I also regularly stressed where I got the belief from. This isn't the first time people have heard me mention that xbox fanfest story. What some of the usual suspects are looking to do to fit with their current agenda is pass it off as if I was stating I was some kind of insider and never made clear that where I got my suspicions on Zen in xbox one x from was from a convo with people who worked on the system at xbox fanfest at E3. It was never from some mysterious source with me stating i'm some insider. Me stating confidently that there was no xbox one gpu downclock, that was a different matter altogether. That was directly backed up information and not just me speculating in which I could prove with a first party xbox source telling me flat out it was a lie, something I believe I explained in full to a mod on here at the time. Can't remember who. And you're right, they would never divulge any such information about upcoming products to fans, but there are times when they correct the record. The GPU downclock thing that had caught fire was one such instance. So, yea, wanted to address that one.

Also saw another totally inaccurate statement where I said for sure that durango would be more powerful. I said no such thing outside of speculation (most thought xbox would be stronger) before facts were known, and if anyone can find otherwise please share it with me. I simply stated I believed strongly that when devs utilized the esram the system would benefit from it and not be as bandwidth starved or as weak compared to ps4 as some were suggesting. Many took it to mean I was saying that it was stronger than PS4 or would equal ps4. Nope, I only just said it would be competitive and be able to produce unbelievable looking games also, because people were really acting like the thing was weak. Weaker than ps4, yes, but not weak for a console releasing then. And with that, back to Neo and the Matrix.
 
Proelite did some calculations and 350mm2 can get you 60 total with 56 active with a cut down zen 2. its possible that ms went wide and slow and thats why they have a much bigger apu.

i wouldnt be surprised if they have three shader engines and 72 cus, 64 active. they went with 44 cus, 8 more cus than the 580's 36 cus. its possible they once again went with an even bigger gpu than the 5800xt. it doesnt line up with the github leak but it is pretty much the only explanation for the unusually large apu unless they went with a full fat zen 2 which they likely didnt.

this will also help them push the clocks further in case sony came out ahead.

I like that theory.

source.gif
 

SNPlayen

Member
My friends uncle who works at Nintendo told me an exact Tflop number will not be given at PS meeting in February and u will all be squabbling about decimal points of flops for many months to come.
 

Kenpachii

Member
My dad that has a friend that has a dad that has a uncle that has a son, that has a family member that is my dad's dad and his dad of that dad is also a dad that has inside knowledge about a dad that works for sony as mom has confirmed the new PS5 design box. This is 100% legit says the famous michael patcher.

1262026.png
 
Last edited:
This is how I knew Klee was wrong. He said bingo to 64CU rumor. 64*2*1475*64 = 12.08TF

But Arden is not 64CU chip, and 1475MHz is far below Navi efficiency sweet spot (especially at N7P). You are effectively wasting silicon creating chip so big but slow.
Bro he clarified in 2 pages later that bingo was to the 12.08 not the cu and clock .
 
Tbh that was Komachi mistake. He mixed PCI IDs and assumed 13F9 is Ariel. Its actually Oberon C0 (Ariel A0, B0, Oberon A0, B0 and C0). 5 steppings.

Makes sense since Oberon A0 in Github leak is only actual chip, B0 were just pre silicon numbers, so I guess that one was produced in coming months.
He said a custom made SOC with side stepping E has made drastical changes . Take that how u want .I m not continuing the discussion as I know ur stance .
 

sinnergy

Member
Still the TF is the measurement... what about having more CUs or bandwidth or better ray tracing seems that is more of a difference...
 

R600

Banned
He said a custom made SOC with side stepping E has made drastical changes . Take that how u want .I m not continuing the discussion as I know ur stance .
No, he said E0 stepping for custom SOC is "tremendous". As in, surprising. Which it is.

His only mistake was him mixing PCI IDs, as he was referring to Ariel. Here, his own spreadsheet.



Notice he ties AMD 00840F40 (so 5th stepping, from F00 to F40) with Ariel.

But AMD 00840F40 PCI ID is 13F9 and he even confirms it here.



And what is 13F9? Its Oberon.

EN4CPe_VAAAUhhl.jpg


So he assumed Ariel got 5 revisions, but in fact going by his own code, its lumped together - Ariel and Oberon (00840F00 being Ariel A0 13E9 to Oberon C0 13F9 and 00840F40)
 
Last edited:

Aceofspades

Banned
This is how I knew Klee was wrong. He said bingo to 64CU rumor. 64*2*1475*64 = 12.08TF

But Arden is not 64CU chip, and 1475MHz is far below Navi efficiency sweet spot (especially at N7P). You are effectively wasting silicon creating chip so big but slow.

Maybe he said Bingo to the exact TF number, how would he know the details for the chip?
 
Last edited:

hubertuss03

Neo Member
This generation it will be all about the games. I have no idea what has or has not changed but the last hard spec info I heard was that both were > 10 and X was 11.6 while the 5 was 12.4 (I am still standing on this hill)I was also told that the ray tracing on one was the same crap that was slapped onto the 1080ti (which I shared a long time ago) and that the performance of BOTH consoles was a bit better that of a 2080 super. Also for the millionth time they are supposedly so close in power that if you were to fart in a room while playing both systems the one you were closest to would have a slight frame rate advantage due to the excess gas helping absorb some of the heat. (I kid) Also I think that I just may get my Bloody Symphony, Thank you uncle Phil.
When you heard this last spec? This month? December?
 

R600

Banned
Bro he clarified in 2 pages later that bingo was to the 12.08 not the cu and clock .
Can you link me that? Because how does it make any sense, seriously?

You have people talking about 12TF for week back then (first WindowsCentral leak, then TGA) and then someone posts 12.08TF number ALONG with CU*CLK number and he says "Bingo". Later clarifies he only meant on 12TF number...Yea, people have been aware of 12TF for a week by then.

My guess from start is that he is making stuff up and some people did start to question logic behind 64CU so he backtracked. Its no wonder EVERYONE took his "bingo" as confirmation on hardware specs and not pure 12TF. Why? Because it has been talked about for week by then already..
 

R600

Banned
If Sony went to 7nm+ ?
I think its the only way to get above XSX number. It would bring 1.2x density and 15% lower TDP, therefore this is the only way I see Sony having 13TF to MS's 12TF.

Not because MS has some kind of magical designers, its because they clearly went to max with what 7nm can provide and they are now hittong the wall of huge chip, big TDP and expensive cooling.
 

eGb

Neo Member
I think its the only way to get above XSX number. It would bring 1.2x density and 15% lower TDP, therefore this is the only way I see Sony having 13TF to MS's 12TF.

Not because MS has some kind of magical designers, its because they clearly went to max with what 7nm can provide and they are now hittong the wall of huge chip, big TDP and expensive cooling.

The only concern is the amount of supply for the holiday and blackfriday.

But it's fairly a safe bet for Sony. They'v made a lot of extra money (They didnt expect it) this past year.
 

TheStruggler

Report me for trolling ND/TLoU2 threads
This generation it will be all about the games. I have no idea what has or has not changed but the last hard spec info I heard was that both were > 10 and X was 11.6 while the 5 was 12.4 (I am still standing on this hill)I was also told that the ray tracing on one was the same crap that was slapped onto the 1080ti (which I shared a long time ago) and that the performance of BOTH consoles was a bit better that of a 2080 super. Also for the millionth time they are supposedly so close in power that if you were to fart in a room while playing both systems the one you were closest to would have a slight frame rate advantage due to the excess gas helping absorb some of the heat. (I kid) Also I think that I just may get my Bloody Symphony, Thank you uncle Phil.
Question when was the last time you heard spec info about the consoles? Was it weeks ago, months ago etc that would give us insight of maybe things did change if it was long ago

edit: think someone asked the same question feel free to ignore
 
Last edited:

sinnergy

Member
I think its the only way to get above XSX number. It would bring 1.2x density and 15% lower TDP, therefore this is the only way I see Sony having 13TF to MS's 12TF.

Not because MS has some kind of magical designers, its because they clearly went to max with what 7nm can provide and they are now hittong the wall of huge chip, big TDP and expensive cooling.

Right because you would know ...
 

SgtCaffran

Member
My guess from start is that he is making stuff up and some people did start to question logic behind 64CU so he backtracked. Its no wonder EVERYONE took his "bingo" as confirmation on hardware specs and not pure 12TF. Why? Because it has been talked about for week by then already..

Klee was one of the first to "confirm" the 12TF even before the bingo. In fact, he said it's slightly above 12 Navi TF. He also correctly hinted that the XsX would be shown at the TGA's so please stop this nonsense.

His info actually matches a lot of what Osiris had been saying:
- both more powerful than 5700XT
- both more than 10TF
- XsX is slitghly above 12TF Navi (12.1)
- both are very very close
- PS5 has slight edge
- PS5 has the faster SSD
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom