All the games are pretty deep.
I mean, combat in almost all of the games in that list is subpar, and i'm being gentle.
Gta5 and rdr2 have shit aim and cover system and input lag (less on pc obviously) and you are almost forced to use the shitty autoaim becaude the game is balanced with that in mind, zelda melee combat is the most basic shit ever, combat in witcher 3 is mediocre at best and even if you have signs and potions and stuff, even at the hardest difficulty powered-up queen is almost all you need to fuck people up...and tlou at the end is a realistic tps without a huge deep combat...
They are not exactly the pinnacle of GAMEPLAY in VIDEOGAMES.
They are lucky because some other aspect are great in these games, gameplay tho? Nah...
P.s. and i love 3 games out 5 in that list, not really an hater of mainstream games.